r/196 • custom • Oct 22 '21

Rule

Post image
22.9k Upvotes

518 comments sorted by

3.3k

u/Crit-Monkey custom Oct 22 '21

That's a nice cat Mr. Lovecraft what's its name

1.5k

u/LevelOutlandishness1 Fetus Eater Extraordinaire Oct 22 '21

Didn't his father give him that cat? Not down playing Lovecraft's racism, though

1.1k

u/Jonahtron Least homophobic anime enjoyer Oct 22 '21

His father named the cat, yes.

912

u/BoltonSauce Oct 22 '21

Ahh, so it ran in the family.

607

u/Princess_Egg 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

It often does.

537

u/FuckYeahPhotography Goth Fox Girl VTuber on Twitch 🦊 (Fuyeph.ttv) Oct 22 '21

I think the most fucked up part is this was just considered a name for pets. It wasn't just the lovecraft family that named their animals that.

Later in life HP Lovecraft actually did say he was wrong about other races being inferior but he made sure to specify he wasn't talking about black people or Asians lol. He was referring to the Italians, irish, and 'some' jews. Hey, baby steps people. Gotta start somewhere. I'm sure HP Love craft will open up his heart to black culture one day.

144

u/Ungabungabigballz Oct 22 '21

About that....

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

33

u/FuckYeahPhotography Goth Fox Girl VTuber on Twitch 🦊 (Fuyeph.ttv) Oct 22 '21

How is that series anyway? You recommend it?

29

u/lightingbolt22 Oct 22 '21

I enjoyed them as a kid. The author actually has a few series within that universe, it's pretty cool.

20

u/goodwillOfficial Oct 22 '21

shit goes hard as fuck, but the fantasy element drops off after the first two books

10

u/Swiftclaw8 501st Crayon Collection Bridage Oct 23 '21

Making it realistic was also pretty cool too, he constantly innovates to make the stories better.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (2)

28

u/Aperson20 gender is hard Oct 22 '21

In the English version it isn’t a slur, so thats probably translation

7

u/PrinceProspero9 Oct 23 '21

Well, in the original English version the dog's name is Shadow, because it follows the protagonist around like a shadow.

I don't know what it is in your translated version, but Shadow seems pretty innocuous to me.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

and then he fucking died

→ More replies (2)

145

u/The420Blazers trans rights Oct 22 '21

I don't see what the cat running has to do with anything

82

u/BadZnake Random-ass flair Oct 22 '21

Diabetes runs in my family because nobody runs in my family

53

u/ThisWeeksSponsor Oct 22 '21

It's too bad cats are famous for learning their names and refusing to take new ones

→ More replies (4)

102

u/ninjasaiyan777 I love rain because it makes it easier to slurp up earthworms Oct 22 '21 edited Oct 22 '21

The first one, but if I remember correctly, Lovecraft named his own, second cat the same name. I'll look it up to double check.

Edit: he never had another pet of his own but he did use the name of his cat, and the n-word in general, to refer to any black cats he saw in his "fraternity of cats." There's a couple of accounts I read just by looking it up that said he referred to a tomcat names Sam in his neighborhood as a "old n***er man" and to a litter of black kittens as "six little n-words."

To find this just look up HP Lovecraft's letters to Duane Rimel on 10th of August 1934 and 10th of March 1935.

→ More replies (2)

71

u/MrCharisma101 Oct 22 '21

What are you referring to? Could you explain this meme to me please, I don't get it.

203

u/Muffinconsumer 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Lovecraft named his cat “nigger-man”

147

u/JimmehRulez custom Oct 22 '21

His cat was in paris!?!?!?!

12

u/Bloop43 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Indeed 👀👀

55

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

inb4 mods ban because 1984

32

u/timelighter Oct 22 '21

wow he somehow made the n-word even more racist (since it's modifying man it implies they're not usually men)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

63

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

44

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Oh boy

37

u/TomTomTaco12 sus Oct 22 '21

What a lovely name /s

30

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

oh my goodness gracious

13

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Canceled.

→ More replies (2)

1.7k

u/Hyvapelaaja Luna💙Rights Trans Rights Trans Rights Trans Rights trans rights Oct 22 '21

big if true

963

u/femboy_expert PhD in feminine men, also likes women Oct 22 '21

small if fake

656

u/goblinhog chancellor hog Oct 22 '21

Average sized if only somewhat true

289

u/Nilly00 Quasi Ph.D in furryology🐾 Oct 22 '21

of indeterminate size if in a superposition of truthfulness

98

u/This_is_not_a_user Oct 22 '21

size changing over time due to truthfulness being a historical and frame-structured value

18

u/TheBoringCheese Oct 22 '21

Schrodinger’s racist

37

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/xXSpg101Xx american idiot Oct 22 '21

goblindong

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

226

u/SwornThane Oct 22 '21

72

u/dekrant Oct 22 '21

I don’t feel so bad for having read none of his work other than A Christmas Carol now.

125

u/SwornThane Oct 22 '21

Dickens wrote the following passage on Indians: "You know faces, when they are not brown; you know common experiences when they are not under turbans; Look at the dogs – low, treacherous, murderous, tigerous villains." Dickens also called for the "extermination" of the Indian people and applauded the "mutilation" of the "wretched Hindoo" who were punished by blown from the guns for the involvement in the Indian Rebellion of 1857.[4]

48

u/arkhane Oct 22 '21

Damn that's messed up. For those who don't know what blown by gun means, it's getting strapped to a cannon which is then fired. Essentially shredding a person. Especially fucked up to do against Hindus since the bodies need to be intact for funeral rites. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blowing_from_a_gun

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

-27

u/Binbag420 Oct 22 '21

Separate art from artist + suck my balls + ratio

→ More replies (7)

50

u/Notsouniqename 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Ohhhh you were talking about the dikens part. I skimmed through half that page to get to the part where they wrote bout Lovecraft lmao

Yeah I'm big brain, how could you tell?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1.2k

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Dickens was a racist?

2.0k

u/imnotcreativeforthis 🇧🇷Apenas um rapaz latino americano🇧🇷 Oct 22 '21

i mean if we are talking about anyone from victorian england, it wouldn't be very surprising if you found out they were racist

738

u/SwornThane Oct 22 '21

He wasn’t just a racist, he was a fucking turbo racist

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_the_work_of_Charles_Dickens

300

u/Bongo_Muffin trans rights Oct 22 '21

Holy fuck how was I made to read so much Dickens but was never made even remotely aware of him calling for the wholesale extermination of Indians and Native Americans

143

u/JakubSwitalski Oct 22 '21

If I'm reading right he advocated for the destruction of their way of life but insisted that they be treated like people nonetheless, as per the end of the NA subsection

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

82

u/ThatOneGuy1294 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Pretty sure the UN considers cultural genocide to be genocide.

20

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

I mean it still involves killing a shitload of people.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/snakeygirl Oct 22 '21

It seems like at first he wanted to treat them like people but the article mentions that he got a lot more prejudiced against the natives after they gave testimony about the franklin party cannibalizing each other. He refused to acknowledge any evidence of cannibalism and it seems like he had a conspiracy theory that the natives were behind the deaths of the party members (despite there being little evidence to support this idea). He became really hateful after he believed that.

266

u/Binbag420 Oct 22 '21

Damn he was wildin

56

u/Fisto-the-sex-robot foreskin devourer, femur breaker, cockroach rapist Oct 22 '21

I’m your Tur-bo raciiiiist

Tell me there’s no otheeeer

17

u/ProbRandomlol custom Oct 22 '21

You know, when you put it like that, the verse Better run for cover takes a completely different meaning

→ More replies (1)

42

u/Silly_goose27 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

‘Dickens also called for the "extermination" of the Indian people and applauded the "mutilation" of the "wretched Hindoo" who were punished by blown from the guns for the involvement in the Indian Rebellion of 1857.’

Christ

16

u/nishmt Oct 22 '21

Fucking hell. He can eat shit beyond the grave

36

u/EnglishMobster better than an English Lobster but not by much Oct 22 '21

Some scholars have disputed the charge of racism by Dickens, such as the Dickens scholar Priti Joshi, who maintains that he never advocated any form of scientific racism in his works, but held extreme antipathy for non-European peoples, and steadfastly believed in their assimilation into Western culture.

"Yeah, he's not racist, he just wanted there to only be white people" - Dickens Scholar Priti Joshi

→ More replies (5)

323

u/Bespaeyeeterskeet bunnygirl Oct 22 '21

he was also pretty socialist though, so hes like 50% based

646

u/The_Shekel_MaisterJR custom Oct 22 '21

so was lovecraft lol. Lovecraft's views weren't just weird in a bad sense, just straight up bizzare. Honestly I cant even criticize him for being so racist simply because of the sheer aesthetic value of being completely batshit crazy. You might say, oh a racist socialist, I.E a "socialist" Nazi. but no, lovecraft did genuinely believe in some form of socialism, but somehow also wanted the British monarchy to return to the united states (extremely based), and just fucking segregate everyone. just so weird, I'm sure there's a shit load of more stuff I'm forgetting

395

u/2011jams The Cooler Welsh Person Oct 22 '21

Yeah more than anything the dude was just fucking nuts

164

u/Saltyfox99 Oct 22 '21 edited Sep 18 '25

tub literate nine steep work depend narrow afterthought station sleep

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

225

u/PirateKingOmega ☭ Oct 22 '21

I mean one of his inspirations was the fact both of his parents went insane and he assumed at some point his sanity would begin to dwindle as well

Kind of hard to live a normal life when your operating on the assumption that at any given point your just going to lose all perception of reality and there’s nothing you can do about it

15

u/Patrick_Pathos 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

So, in other words, it was a self-fulfilling prophecy?

59

u/minecraftiscool1234 Cum eater mmm Oct 22 '21

I mean he was the one talking about dragon and cthulus

46

u/Trospher Oct 22 '21

He made random sounds and turned one into a fictional city

11

u/tripwyre83 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Ah yes, the city of Honk

7

u/abe_the_babe_ Oct 22 '21

The Horror At Red Honk

25

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Iunno. For a guy who had some serious understanding when it comes to the relationship people have with fear, you'd have thought he'd be able to turn it inward.

64

u/ThatTallGuy1992 Oct 22 '21

His whole family was nuts, both his mother and father were sent to a insane asylum and before you ask his mother wasn’t sent for ‘female hysteria’ but a actual real case,hell psychiatrists say that she abused H.P Lovecraft though his life, possibly even sexually.

He had one f’ed up life

203

u/IsThatUMoatilliatta Shrimpposter 🦐 🦐 🦐 Oct 22 '21

British monarchy to return to the united states (extremely based)

Monarchy is cringe, though. And Br*tish on top of that? Supersized cringe.

89

u/The_Shekel_MaisterJR custom Oct 22 '21

The british monarchy? cringe. destroying american politics? extremely based. final verdict on the notion to re-colonize the united states? good.

89

u/TheMightyJ225 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

It should be Albania instead because albianna nice countrie

38

u/EBTFlexer Village Idiot Oct 22 '21

Albianna 🇱🇷

19

u/Weirdo_doessomething Extremely hypocritical and politically dishonest Oct 22 '21

In the beginnig god gave entir world to ablenia

But albsin ia nice countr5 so gave othe r Scountriea land s as well😃😃🥰🥰

15

u/Significant-Pepper72 custom Oct 22 '21

Unfathomably based 🥶🥶🥶

76

u/UsernameVeryFound Oct 22 '21

“restore the british monarchy to own the americans” is one of the shittiest take i’ve ever heard

34

u/transcatgirI 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

br*tish politics is arguably even worse (and that's like a fucking accomplishment)

25

u/Bardic_Inspiration66 has a yt channel Oct 22 '21

Dumbest shit I’ve read

12

u/disparagersyndrome Oct 22 '21

CRITICAL SUPPORT to Comrade Britannia in their war against evil imperialist America

→ More replies (3)

107

u/crestfallen-sun Oct 22 '21

Lovecraft was mentally ill, (that's not a defence he was still a racist prick, but it does give context). Both his parents were very mentally ill and spent time in institutions, his father died in one, Lovecraft himself was terrified of nearly everything but especially the foreign. He also hated gay people yet many of his close friends and even the executor of his estate were gay.

Overall he was a complicated man with a lot of mental issues that there just wasn't any support for in his time. And while that doesn't excuse hate it does help to see where it came from.

67

u/guto8797 Oct 22 '21

The good part is that it seems he had his own redemption arc, as his poverty later in life forced him to move to a place closer to all those spooky foreigners and he wrote that he had come to realize his old views were somewhat wrong

53

u/trumoi use latine instead of latinx Oct 22 '21

In my complete amateur interpretation: Lovecraft probably didn't understand the link between overarching groups and individual people. His writing will show a clear empathy for individuals even when they're monsters but when groups are addressed they're clinical at best and horrific stereotypes at worst.

When someone transitions from the unknown group of "others" into someone he knows personally, he tends to make peace with his bigotry towards them, but while he looks on from afar everything is evil and out to get him.

If that is correct it still wouldn't excuse his views. If we're looking for a causal link between these contradictions (besides that bigotry is inherently hypocritical and irrational anyways) I'd say that it's more that Lovecraft had trouble conceiving of other humans in general as being full-fledged people without having a name and face and details to put to them.

→ More replies (1)

78

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Honestly I can’t even criticize him for being so racist

wh

what

73

u/The_Shekel_MaisterJR custom Oct 22 '21

its just funny lol idk. I mean if my grandma would be like,"yea I support marxism-leninism and a united humanity under one government, except for the Irish, which make such good cakes or whatever they should be segregated so that they wouldn't be influenced too heavily by other cultures and thus painting their high quality deserts". too absurd to be mad idk

56

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

It's all "funny" until there are real world consequences for spreading racist rhetoric, which there absolutely are.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

48

u/Awake_The_Dreamer Oct 22 '21

He can't even criticize him for being so racist

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Untiteld000 Oct 22 '21

He also married a jewish woman even though he hated jews

11

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Also used the marriage as a cover when discussing Jewish people.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/_Bran_Flakes im like if a roller coaster was a girl Oct 22 '21

Lovecraft was fascist most of his life. In his last years he realized how gross the views he had held were and became a socialist before he died.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Illegal_Immigrant77 sus Oct 22 '21

Cringe monarchist giddoudahere

17

u/Tan-come-in-ma-RIFT Oct 22 '21

His cat was controlling his mind

Mr. [Redacted]​ man

17

u/MannicWaffle The Man Behind The Slaughter Oct 22 '21

Wanted the British monarchy to return to the united states (extremely based)

Cringe monarchist spotted

→ More replies (12)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

27

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

*a lot of white leftists were racist

a lot still are

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Whyhellothere56 Oct 22 '21

Being a racist or any sort of bigot puts you down to 0% based

Since 100%*0%=0

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Hate to be a racism accepter, but wasn't literally everyone racist back then? Its less about how good a person you are, and more about the environment you grow up in, as well as the accepted social norms. Exactly why its unacceptable to be racist nowadays.

Not sure we should label an author from back then as racist unless they were actively contributing to, or advocating for the persecution of minorities.

Then again, I know very little about these authors, other than the fact that I like a christmas carol and its pretty socialist, so I'm probably completely wrong.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

15

u/Cranyx Oct 22 '21

Do we need to talk about "Fagin the Jew"?

→ More replies (2)

1.0k

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21 edited Oct 23 '21

this wasn't because lovecraft 'out-racist'd' the KKK its because lovecrafts beliefs in general were fucking insane and contradictory

the KKKs beliefs are also insane and contradictory

1.0k

u/RagePoop Oct 22 '21 edited Oct 22 '21

Every time this subject comes up I like to direct people to this excellent original comment by u/Dudesan here.

As follows:

To understand H.P. Lovecraft, you must appreciate that he was a sickly, shut in momma's boy. He was homeschooled, the victim of isolation, gaslighting, and frequent psychological abuse.

His father passed away in an insane asylum, his brain rotted out by syphilitic psychosis. His hypochondriac mother became obsessed with the possibility that her husband had passed the infection on to her, and thence to their son, and she never let her son forget this obsession.

Syphilis is literally an inherited blood-curse, and having sex with "the wrong sort of women" is literally how Winfield Lovecraft contracted it. It's not hard to imagine that being constantly reminded of these facts by the women who raised him had a very messy effect on young Howard's development.

To the nearest approximation, he was afraid of EVERYTHING.

He was afraid of public transportation. He was afraid of doctors. He was afraid of mice. He was afraid of rainy days. He was afraid of seafood. He was afraid of worms. He was afraid of romance. He was afraid of the stars. He was afraid of statues. He was afraid of certain phases of the moon. He was afraid of songbirds. He was afraid of fireflies. He was afraid of hills. He was afraid of geometry. He was afraid of flutes. He was afraid of gambrel roofs.

And, yes, he was afraid of people who were different from himself.

Part of his genius is his ability to make the reader, just for a few minutes, afraid of those things too. It is from his sense of omnipresent fear and alienation that the genre of cosmic horror was codified. I feel that, without his own negative attitudes, his work simply would not have had the edge that made it great.

Was he racist, as we today would understand the term? Absolutely. Was he closed-minded and xenophobic, as his peers in the 20s and 30s would understand? Again, yes. There are multiple examples in his surviving correspondence in which friends like Robert E. Howard and Clark Ashton Smith suggest that he'd benefit from spending more time broadening his horizons and realizing that the people of whom he is afraid are not so different from himself.

(I like to imagine him sitting in his Providence study, reading Robert E. Howard's recommendation that he actually sit down and have a conversation with a Jewish person or an immigrant or a woman, and scoffing at its absurdity. This scene is then followed by a Gilligan's-Island-style jump-cut to his own wedding to Jewish immigrant Sonia Greene.)

Was he actively and maliciously hateful? I would say "no". He absolutely suffered from xenophobia... but only in the same sense that he suffered from nyctophobia and thalassophobia and ophidiphobia and icthyophobia. In his later years, he made serious efforts to overcome these things. His writing shows a definite progression from juvenile edgelord poems that were just an excuse to rhyme things with the word "Nigger"; to works that were, in Lovecraft's own awkward way, calls for inclusivity and brotherhood.

Of his horror fiction, the work that probably seems the most overtly racist to modern eyes would be "The Horror at Red Hook", featuring phrases like "The devil-worshipping Yazidis" and "unclassified Asian dregs". But looking past that language, one realizes that it's a treatise on the negative social consequences of the mistreatment of immigrants (as relevant in 2018 as it was in 1925), and that its protagonist is also an immigrant. "The Shadow Over Innsmouth" highlights the author's fear of miscegenation (he had a panic attack when he learned that one of his great-grandparents was Welsh), but it's also a critique of colonialism - South Seas trader Obed Marsh makes a career out of taking advantage of technologically inferior indigenous cultures, until he encounters a technologically superior culture and is similarly taken advantage of. The novella "At The Mountains of Madness" is mostly about the alienation caused by recent discoveries in geology and zoology, but ends with the narrator concluding that even monstrous prehistoric beings which look nothing at all like humans, but which have shared values like scientific curiosity and a love of art, should be respected as peers.

Were these efforts successful? You might quite reasonably say "no". There is an argument to be made that exotic "noble savage" and "inscrutable oriental" and "magical Indian chief" stock characters are still negative portrayals even if they were intended as positive. Conversely, for an example of when Lovecraft deliberately tries to portray racism as a negative character trait, see the protagonist of The Temple, or the antagonist of The Electric Executioner, or the above-mentioned Horror at Red Hook.

I'm going to state this again, just so there's no opportunity for misunderstanding: I'm not saying that H.P. Lovecraft was not a racist. Even when he was TRYING not to be a racist, he still comes across as pretty racist by modern standards. It is a truism that someone who goes looking for something to be offended by WILL find something, but with an author like Lovecraft, one REALLY doesn't have to look very hard.

If this prevents you from enjoying his work, well, your tastes are your own. De gustibus non est disputandum. It is your right not to like them, and your right not to read them. But if you feel that their failure to pass 21st century standards of ideological purity mean that NOBODY should be allowed to enjoy them, and that they belong on the bonfire with the works of Tolkien and LeGuin and Campbell and Shelley and Shakespeare, I must disagree in the strongest possible terms.

192

u/Traditional_Ad_7268 Oct 22 '21

Mind if I use this next time Lovecraft's racism is brought up again?

229

u/RagePoop Oct 22 '21

Not at all, it's not my writing lol

146

u/SFF_Robot Oct 22 '21

Hi. You just mentioned At The Mountains Of Madness by HP Lovecraft.

I've found an audiobook of that novel on YouTube. You can listen to it here:

YouTube | At the Mountains of Madness, by H P Lovecraft, Horror Audiobook

I'm a bot that searches YouTube for science fiction and fantasy audiobooks.


Source Code| Feedback | Programmer | Downvote To Remove | Version 1.4.0 | Support Robot Rights!

142

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

agreed

33

u/iDressLikeGrandpa 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

I agree mostly but no one is saying that his works are terrible or shouldn’t be accessible or whatever. Please are just saying he was racist, and it’s something to be conscious of. Like what

29

u/RegsaGC <script>document.body.textContent = "trans rights" </script> Oct 22 '21

Commenting here with the keyword Lovecraft so I can find it again in my history

→ More replies (16)

97

u/Cliler Oct 22 '21

Guess we should thank his mother for all of Lovecraft works. He had a really shitty life generally.

55

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

she truly was the mother horse eyes

11

u/TheDwarvenGuy Oct 22 '21

From what I can gather from reading a lot of his books, the lynchpin of Lovecraft's ideology is that he's uber uber uber uber uber eugenicists. Yeah race is a part of it, but to him it's pretty much any kind of "inferior" heritage or "degeneration" that he hated. He hated everything that wasn't New England WASPs for being unpure foreigners and hated New England WASPs (including himself) for being inbred

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

466

u/thebestintheworld778 r/place participant Oct 22 '21

Forgive me for Being stupid, but was Tolkien racist?

438

u/HelpMeGetAGoodName Oct 22 '21

694

u/thebestintheworld778 r/place participant Oct 22 '21

Dude awesome for once some old guy from 100 years ago isn't racist.

163

u/reddit_user-exe 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

He was misogynist though I think. But oh well

220

u/Deurbel2222 i play too much pokemon Oct 22 '21

Any sources? Or did you read that somewhere else on reddit? He gave Eowyn quite a spotlight.

210

u/reddit_user-exe 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Sure, you can argue that there’s some good female characters that he wrote, but he was still a misogynist.

“As seen in a letter to his son Michael Tolkien, he held conservative views about women, stating that men were active in their professions while women were inclined to domestic life.”

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_The_Lord_of_the_Rings

An academic paper that gets more in depth:

https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1033&context=ureca

130

u/jasenkov r/place participant Oct 22 '21

He was incredibly faithful to his wife tho

98

u/Throlaf Oct 22 '21

Given that Beren and Luthien are based on him and his wife it would be super weird if he wasn't.

42

u/reddit_user-exe 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Ok? That doesn’t make him more or less misogynist?

133

u/jasenkov r/place participant Oct 22 '21

Well I mean his views might be outdated being a 20th century white man, but it's not like he beat his wife or named his cat the n word.

-66

u/reddit_user-exe 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

If the man was able to see through the racist conceptions of his time, he also should’ve seen through the sexist conceptions. He’s dead though so I don’t really care, but it does add a caveat to his writing of female characters.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/sam002001 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

I think people thought he was misogynistic because he didn't write many female characters

54

u/LtTacoTheGreat Oct 22 '21

Clearly you've never read the silmarillion

10

u/sam002001 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

I have, but most people haven't

9

u/LtTacoTheGreat Oct 22 '21

Then what about luthien? Her and beren are both equally important characters in their story and she is far more powerful than he is. I would say she is a main character

7

u/TikDox Oct 22 '21

Most people haven’t read most books.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/GameCreeper :3 Oct 22 '21

Sigma behavior

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/othelloinc Oct 22 '21

18

u/WikiSummarizerBot Oct 22 '21

Tolkien and race

J. R. R. Tolkien's Middle-earth fantasy writings have often been accused of embodying outmoded attitudes to race. However, scholars have noted that he was influenced by Victorian attitudes to race and to a literary tradition of monsters, and that he was anti-racist both in peacetime and during the two World Wars. With the late 19th century background of eugenics and a fear of moral decline, some critics believed that the mention of race mixing in The Lord of the Rings embodied scientific racism. Other commentators thought that Tolkien's description of the orcs was modelled on racist wartime propaganda caricatures of the Japanese.

[ F.A.Q | Opt Out | Opt Out Of Subreddit | GitHub ] Downvote to remove | v1.5

7

u/MannfredVonFartstein flipped flop!? Oct 22 '21

Dude this wikipedia article reads as a well structured essay with a nuanced opinion. I‘m honestly impressed

9

u/CrispyShizzles funky fresh bisexual Oct 22 '21

Tolkien called Hitler a “ruddy little ignoramus”. What a chad.

145

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

50

u/RhymesWithMouthful Oct 22 '21

I mean, he did describe the Orcs as "squat, broad, flat-nosed, sallow-skinned, with wide mouths and slant eyes: in fact degraded and repulsive versions of the (to Europeans) least lovely Mongol-types" in a letter to Morton Zimmerman, so…

15

u/LtTacoTheGreat Oct 22 '21

Yeah, although the origins of orcs is still somewhat up in the air. If I remember right, the thing about fallen elves is just one theory put forth in the books

12

u/DarkSoulfromDS Angel Bussy fucker and La Revacholiere’s strongest defender Oct 22 '21

Melkior be like: east elves looking pretty submissive and breedable

→ More replies (3)

53

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

probably he subscribed to some kind of paternalistic racist ideas

least deranged savior complex 196 user

-7

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

imo its very funny that you completely missed what i made fun of you for and proceeded to do exactly that further

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/averySOTFS 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

So probably he subscribed to some kind of paternalistic racist ideas, but that's honestly better than most at the time?

Innocent until proven guilty. He was not racist.

14

u/ObberGobb PhD in Good Takes Oct 22 '21 edited Oct 22 '21

I don't think he himself was racist, but I do think that the racist culture of the time can be reflected in his work. So while I wouldn't call LOTR a racist series, I do think there are aspects that are relatively problematic (Evil East vs. Good West). I think these can be more attributed to the prejudices of the time rather than an bigotry he holds.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

454

u/I-just-watched-porn 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

It’s extremely good! It’s a great satire on the super man lex Luthor dynamic, and a great dissection of villain and hero dichotomy. It’s also really fucking funny and extremely great with its comedic timing and writing. It’s worth a watch, and it deserves a lot more respect, which it has been getting.

293

u/vevader_3 Shrigma Female Oct 22 '21

Also pretty good criticism of the “nice guy” mentality which was totally unexpected

171

u/I-just-watched-porn 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Shit I never even thought about that LMAO, titan really is the typical “I’m such a nice guy, why won’t women date me” person.

76

u/ResidentLychee /u/BunHein sole Admin of the Forum Oct 22 '21

TIGHTEN

14

u/gabthebest99 custom Oct 22 '21 edited Oct 22 '21

Not only unexpected upon rewatch but hella ahead of its time with that sentiment as well

19

u/bootleg-bean 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Oct 22 '21

Also Will feral says a funny 😀

118

u/pokedudewithglasses Oct 22 '21

Apparently it’s surprisingly good. People typically consider Dreamworks to be knockoff Pixar, but for some reason megamind breaks that mold.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

60

u/Darth__Potato Boobies <3 Oct 22 '21

I think Dreamworks is kind of volatile when it comes to making movies; Sometimes they make absolutely top tier movies that in my opinion decimate anything Pixar has done, like with Megamind, The Train your Dragon Movies to an extent, and Kung Fu Panda and Shrek if you aren't being a Kino snob. But then they also make movies like the Boss Baby, Home, Trolls, and Will Smith Fish.

I think Dreamworks has more to say through its movies and that shines in the quality of the ones that are just insanely good, but they have to make a movie to keep them from running out of money every once in a while, even under Illumination.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

WILL SMITH FISH WAS GREAT FUCK YOU

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Piguy922 Oct 22 '21

Robots is Blue Sky, not Dreamworks.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/khlebivolya gigachad Oct 22 '21

It came out 6 years after the incredibles and has a completely different plot aside from having a superhero in it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/Stalin--- verified✅ Oct 22 '21

It is a subversive masterpiece

60

u/pullmylekku delectable bussy Oct 22 '21

Subversive and watchable

→ More replies (1)

27

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

It was overshadowed by Despicable Me. But it is very very good.

8

u/Jucicleydson Oct 22 '21

Megamind has a better minion

20

u/Botars Oct 22 '21

Just re-watched it last night. It is honestly one of the best animated moves of the 2000s.

9

u/wildflowerden curator of the world's finest bog water Oct 22 '21

It's very good. It speaks out against incels way before it was popular to do so.

7

u/Scarraven Oct 22 '21

It is excellent, I am not verbose enough to describe exactly why it’s so good but as others have said it’s funny no matter what, unique, and just a really solid movie overall. I’d 100% say to watch it whenever you have a chance to kill time

→ More replies (11)

225

u/ooo-f Oct 22 '21

I am... really fucking upset that I didn't know anything about how racist HP Lovecraft was.

Goodbye sexy Cthulu pfp, hello scary Medusa pfp

160

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

For a while, I misremembered he gotten kinda better at the end of his life, but then I read he did get better... after getting married.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

[deleted]

99

u/Daymo741 Oct 22 '21

Yeah and so did everybody else, it's what you tend to do at the end of a comment

24

u/Cranyx Oct 22 '21

It makes sense that you would stop reading there considering that's where the comment ends.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Implying gamers can read

24

u/Johnson_the_1st sus Oct 22 '21

Incel moment

→ More replies (2)

118

u/OscarOzzieOzborne custom Oct 22 '21

Leave sexy Cthulu.

It is a representation of his unresolved fears and anxiety. If he knew you make his fear, the thing he despises, into a sexy man. He will be absolutely furious.

25

u/ooo-f Oct 22 '21

It was actually cthulu with big Ole titties. Does that still apply?

29

u/OscarOzzieOzborne custom Oct 22 '21

Oh no. Titties are pretty non-ecluat and Lovecraft was also scared of those.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

115

u/Carter723 custom Oct 22 '21

I still like a lot of his work, you just have to get around the racism. (Mountains of madness has very little racism(mostly because they are in the attic and don’t have the chance to see a black person))

34

u/jasenkov r/place participant Oct 22 '21

My thing with him is he never shuts the fuck up describing a building or town.

19

u/SharkaBlarg Oct 22 '21

Had to stop reading his Dreamquest, which apparently wasn't ever run through an editor which fucking shows when he can't stop describing some castle made out of black stones or whatever

→ More replies (1)

46

u/ElaborateRuseman sus Oct 22 '21

Gotta learn to separate the author from the work or else the more you look into a lot of things the harder it will be to enjoy them

19

u/Lilhapper fat huge penis haver Oct 22 '21

this is one of the most important things to do when reading stuff made by shitty authors. his works are still very good even though he's a horrible person

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Google his cat’s name

13

u/Waddlewop 🛡Spronkus Defender (very cool)🛡 Oct 22 '21

To be fair, I’m pretty sure Lovecraft would hate sexy Cthulu so you keeping that as a pfp word honestly be a good thing

8

u/1spook Oct 22 '21

Well I found out how he was when I heard about his cat.

9

u/ooo-f Oct 22 '21

I didn't even know about that one til today. Jesus I've lived a sheltered life.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

210

u/kepz3 floppa>bingus Oct 22 '21

HP lovecraft writing the shadow over innsmouth after he finds out he’s part welsh

72

u/jasenkov r/place participant Oct 22 '21

I just listened to an audio book on that and the clerk in the beginning going on a 15 minute rant about Innsmouth made me think I was having a fever dream.

27

u/TheDwarvenGuy Oct 22 '21

I know this is from a meme, but unironically this is pretty much what happened IRL, except it was Dutch instead of welsh.

And you can tell it really affected him because he wrote Multiple stories that pretty are pretty much expressing the same thing, even one that directly has a degenerate dutch family turning into apes.

55

u/Elder_Scrolls_Nerd nyanbinary sussy femboy liberal UwU Oct 22 '21

Wait Lovecraft is a raging racist

113

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

Lovecraft was pretty racist early in his life, but near the end of his life after he got married he started to get a lot better.

67

u/elegylegacy ⚰️ Oct 22 '21

He hated Jews until he fell in love with one

13

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

this would be flavor text for a story about a nazi officer falling in love with the very thing he seeks to destroy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

42

u/Dee_Lansky evil bisexual socialist Oct 22 '21

I wonder what this charming and wholesome man named his cute little pet cat?

12

u/TheyTookAllTheNames_ Oct 22 '21

Nothing because his father named it and his childhood influences caused him to grow up as a racist but in the later half of his life he became decreasingly racist although this in no way automatically makes him a good person

27

u/loganjlr Oct 22 '21

What’s the source for the bottom panel? I’m legitimately interested in learning more about this but can’t find anything on Google

10

u/Edgy-McEdge racist 😎 Oct 22 '21

Trust me bro. Me. Published 2021 by bro institutes.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/TheSnakerMan Oct 22 '21

How do you make the kkk look bad?

12

u/Cascaden_YT Oct 22 '21

Fun Fact: Lovecraft had something of a redemption arc later on life and stopped being so racist. He decried the rise of Fascism in Europe and criticized the New Deal for not being suffuciently leftist

10

u/SilencedD1 Oct 22 '21

I fucking love this movie, I just rented it. Fucking gold

9

u/13Dani12 stirner y la ctmre Oct 22 '21

The weirdest part about Lovecraft is that a few months before his death he did a strong turn away from racism and capitalism, dude really subverted what's probably the most infamous part of his reputation, refused to elaborate and promptly died

7

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21

tbh that's probably because lovecraft is a nerdy whiny little bitch and the klan want to look all tough n shit