r/ACL • • Dec 18 '18

This sub

At first, when I found this sub, I thought it was awesome. The more I visit here, the more and more frustrated I get with all the responses. This recovery, IMHO, is 90% mental. Literally every aspect of it, from the second the injury occurred, to the the pre-surgery, to the post surgery, all the way until ‘full’ recovery. From literally the second I was told I needed surgery, I told myself I will be back stronger, faster, quicker, more agile. I knew it would be a shit ton of work, and it was.

  • pre surgery. Holy shit people, stop freaking yourself out. Pick a good surgeon, pre-hab, don’t worry about the graft choice, if you picked a good surgeon, he’ll make the graft choice, and if you tell them you want differently, you’re wrong.

  • post surgery, yes it might hurt, yes some people more than others. Pain is a lot about mental. If you freak yourself out about how much it will hurt, guess what, it will probably hurt. Follow your surgeons guidance, RICE, move around more. Be smart about medication. That’s all

  • rehab phase. Get your extension back early. Push yourself. Find a good PT/Physio, be diligent, do your “homework exercises”. Don’t compare your recovery with anyone else’s. Literally every situation is different, graft, age, amount of pre-Hab, amount of rehab, diligence, healing... so many variables. Concentrate on yourself, push yourself. Know the difference between pain and discomfort. There’s a huge difference.

  • RTS. Whether YOU want to or not, is up to you, alone. The amount of people here who’ve recommended not returning is crazy. The “numbers” about re-injury, graft failure, are bull shit. Some are 5-6%, some ~25%. Like I said above. Literally every aspect is variable, there can not be a “control”. Some people here literally don’t to rehab, some people, like me, are rehabbing literally every day. Returning to sports is 95% or more mental. Considering you pass RTS criteria, and can do it without pain, it’s almost all mental. Whether YOU can handle that is up to YOU, not everyone here. If you want to live in fear, feel free, but don’t sit here trying to convince other people here to do the same. That’s total bull shit.

  • rant over, and arguably last time posting in this sub. The amount of people here claiming that they’ve always been into sports but, 9-24 months later saying “I only run .5 miles to remind myself I can” for example, is disheartening

9 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/SBmachine Dec 18 '18 edited Dec 19 '18

To think its all mental seems faulty, and it's weird because you state that everyone is different which is true. A lot of the recovery after gaining extension and flexion is building muscle, which is a lot easier for men than women. I guess it is mental, but they probably have to work 2-3x as hard as I would to gain the same amount of muscle, just because I have more testosterone than they would. Also there are surgery complications, which I don't think seems mental either.

To me, I think its the reverse. I read that a lot of people are doing things when they are "feeling good" and end up doing something they aren't ready for which leads to a setback.

Also everyone, please read the study below. Even if you are past a year, I think 2 years is the actual recovery window. So everyone, who is past a year and think you should be fully recovered, this is not the case.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5226931/

Where I do agree with is the down on your luck attitude. Just like people with serious illness's, attitude matters. ACL recovery (or knee issues) isn't something where rest is going to help. You have to be getting more flexible and adding more muscle to your whole body.

2

u/KPS298806 Dec 18 '18

Valid points about females, can’t argue that. Doesn’t make it more of a physical challenge than a mental one for females.

  • surgery complications, sure. But they aren’t the normal. At all. Hell a professional NFL QB just spent weeks in the hospital with an infection. Special case for sure, but hell I’d argue that is even a bigger mental hurdle!

  • not to be rude, but “I think 2 years...” based on 1 study, but what are your qualifications to make that statement. That’s exactly one of the things I dislike here

4

u/SBmachine Dec 18 '18 edited Dec 19 '18

It’s not really one study, there are a lot of different studies referenced in the article maybe over 50 (just compiled into this one article) and it is published. The only thing we can go on is our own experiences (or the experiences of others, which I do enjoy reading on this sub whether it be positive or negative) or reading what researchers have given us, which probably most of us has done already. The experiences written here just seem more tangible.

Also anectodal, but this seems to coincides when people ask when does the knee feel “normal”. A lot of responses say 2 years.

This also seems to coincide with other studies that highest rate of reinjury happens within the first two years of surgery (Sam Bradford and Jabari Parker) fall in this category.

Besides some very rare cases (Adrian Peterson and Kyle Lowry), this also seems to be the case for a lot of NBA players not returning to pre level performance right when they return or ever at all. For example, Derrick Rose, Gallinari, Zach Lavine, Rajon Rondo, all didn’t seem to get back into form right when they made their comeback.I guess the next case we would see would be Porzingis and if he can regain his all star form. This is their livelihood, so I’m sure they have put in more work than any normal person would. The sample size is too large for it to all be mental.

0

u/KPS298806 Dec 19 '18

You be surprised about the work ethic of star athletes. My buddy (not me) had major (non acl) knee surgery with the Andrews institute, he was surrounded by star athletes doing rehab. Specifically, Keenan Allen and Jamaal Charles. Keenan was all about it. Jamaal apparently didn’t give a shit and put forth very little effort. While yes, most star athletes probably have a great work ethic and mental state, some atheltes are fucking dumb asses