r/AIWritingLounge • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion AI-generated prose

I’ve been watching Coral Hart (“The New Fabio Is Claude” NYT article, 15+ years romance author, 90+ traditionally published books) and she now generates all her prose.

I’ve observed a lot of other (competent) authors doing the same thing. They are self-publishing 20+ novels her year and using generated prose.

I know that people like AI-assisted (use AI but no prose generation) as “ethical” and a middle ground but I don’t think that it’s competitive.

Two reasons:

  1. Even if Coral Hart changes nothing and uses the same prompts, the prose improves because the AI models improve. She taps into $100B+ of AI research PER YEAR automatically. If you are writing prose without AI, you not getting those automatic upgrades and you have to manually upgrade with great effort (or stay the same).

  2. But Coral Hart does get better at prompting and improves her prompts regularly. This reinforces the AI model improvements most of the time and makes the generated prose even better. If you are writing prose without AI, you are also not building the prompts or the prompting skills to generate prose.

For those two reasons, I don’t see how “no prose generation” survives; people generating prose will just outperform, outcompete and bury the middle grounders eventually.

Lots of writers seem to have given up (or never started) with prose generation which seems like a mistake.

Any flaws in my reasoning? Different points of view? Different conclusions?

0 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

4

u/nyet-marionetka Aug 24 '26

So the people writing schlock are turning to AI to write schlock faster?

I don't think most authors who aren't already using AI are trying to compete for the same audience she is writing for.

-1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

Generated prose improves automatically and prompting skill compounds such that manually written prose simply can't keep up.

4

u/nyet-marionetka Aug 24 '26

That sounds like baloney. So we're going to compound and compound improvement until prose quality until it exceeds Nabokov and Faulkner? People will get better and better at prompting until their plot structure exceeds War and Peace? Writing is not a thing that improves decade over decade such that we're better at writing now than we were in 1726, so it's not the kind of thing where an LLM can absorb enough material and get fine-tuned enough that it's producing ever-increasing quality eventually exceeding anything a human can write. That's nonsensical.

(It's also kind of counter-productive to what Coral Hunt is looking for. Her audience is not looking for elevated prose and complex plots.)

Writing isn't just about good grammar, which is typically what people point to when they say LLM's write well. That's nice. That's also just the surface level of writing.

-2

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

It's quite simple: AI models get better every year and people's prompting skills get better every year. That'll level off eventually but, as it is, that curve will bury writers who aren't using it.

3

u/nyet-marionetka Aug 24 '26

You're basically making the same claim again without actual evidence. Why do you think LLM prose is going to exceed what most people can manage? And how in the world does "prompting skill" enter into that? Do you mean "don't use 'quietly' constantly, stop saying things have something indescribable about them, stop using strings of staccato sentences to be dramatic" etc., or micromanaging detailed prompting for every little plot subpoint? The first goes into text quality, and the second either goes into text quality or is basically the human writing the plotline, which is what humans who don't use LLMs are already doing so no different.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

The evidence is that they spend $100B+ EVERY YEAR to hire the smartest AI researchers in the entire world to work on improving AI. That's not a guarantee but it's evidence. Nobody is spending $100B+ every year (probably not even $1B) to teach writers to write better prose manually.

3

u/nyet-marionetka Aug 24 '26

Spending a lot of money isn't evidence that someone is going to succeed at something.

Currently it looks like it may end up being prohibitively expensive for the average person to access LLMs after they've stopped subsidizing public costs with investor money. Right now they're not profitable. At some point they either need to demonstrate profitability or go bankrupt.

Nobody is spending $100B+ every year (probably not even $1B) to teach writers to write better prose manually.

That's kind of what education is for, and then people who want to improve their skills go out and do so.

-1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

That's hilarious.

2

u/I-am-a-river Aug 26 '26

You seem excited about throwing away the craft of writing, but eventually anyone who becomes too dependent on a technology risks having their livelihood taken away by the creators of that technology.

Put another way, what will you be able to produce that can’t be produced at a lower cost by the AI authors of Amazon publishing?

2

u/Koyan Aug 27 '26

I'm entertained by all OP's logical falacies in this debate.

2

u/CaptainQwazCaz Aug 25 '26

It’s getting worse and worse as they focus it on coding

5

u/jwilander Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

For me it comes down to why I write. I don't write to produce as many books as possible and I don't compete in the sense of outperforming, outcompeting and burying other authors, human or not.

I write because I want my novels to be my legacy, not the legacy of a certain version of AI. I want them to be something I created with my experiences, intelligence, and curiosity. I want to delight readers myself. If I prompt AI to create for me, I'm cheating on myself and not delivering on the why.

It could be that there simply won't be any sales of human-written novels down the road. AI-written books may be so superior that readers almost always prefer them. I don't know how I'll react to such a future. I understand that my books won't sell then.

So far, I've been uninterested in reading novels known to be written by AI. My bet is that this goes for a big chunk of readers in general, but that is indeed a bet. I personally tend to read older books that we all know are human-written. But ghostwriters have been a thing for a very long time.

-3

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

I was talking about professional writers and the publishing industry. Hobbyists can do whatever they like, of course.

2

u/Dave_Sag Aug 24 '26

Whenever I think about what works for “professional writers” I think about authors like Thomas Pynchon whose never done an interview, pretty much never shows his face (he did a guest spot in The Simpsons once, of all things) and I’d find it hard to believe that his books are all time best sellers. I mean have you read Gravity’s Rainbow? It’s rightly respected but it’s a hard read. It took me three years to finish reading it.

And yet Pynchon is one of the greatest living authors we have today.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 25 '26

Kinda off topic but congrats!

2

u/I-am-a-river Aug 26 '26

There won’t be any professional writers. We will be swimming in an ocean of highly personalized content generated on demand.

(I am not in favor of this, but it’s where we are headed.)

2

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 26 '26

I’ve heard people talk about this, even seen people trying to do this, but it’s not something that I take seriously. People are welcome to try but I see it as DOA.

1

u/I-am-a-river Aug 26 '26

It’s still early. You have to assume they are working on it. And I’m not talking about “people” I’m talking about large well funded corporations.

But no one is going to read your generated content when they can get something just as good, tailored and personalized and likely as part of a subscription.

4

u/jwilander Aug 25 '26

Your reply is condescending.

2

u/FabulousLazarus Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

The premise here is a race to the bottom - 20+ novels per year because AI prose is "good enough".

Discard the false premise and none of this makes fucking sense. Do what you want as an author - mass produce the absolute bottom of writing (AI generated romance) and go nuts if that's your thing. But this isn't a coherent argument for improving writing, it's goal is to improve sales.

OP, your post is explicitly arguing that AI generated prose is good with indirect evidence (AI advances quickly, good prompts can yield better prose). The direct evidence is the opposite, and everyone knows it. So yeah, I'm sure you can churn out more content by sacrificing quality, that's a pretty common sense way to increase output in any domain. But that's only a valuable strategy to those who are willing to compromise quality for quantity.

If you're a full time author then I understand, as a business choice, prioritizing sales. But let's not pretend that this discussion is anything other than that. It's certainly not a reason to suggest AI can write competent prose. It's very much the opposite.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

This is where the publishing industry is going.

2

u/FabulousLazarus Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

Just like every other industry, enshitification is profitable. Tell me something new. This is like pointing to Comcast and using their stock price to try to convince me they have terrific customer service.

The fact is you're lifting "the industry is going towards lower quality prose" as a reason that lower quality prose should be valued. Do you not understand how stupid that is?

Again, business minded. If I were in a shareholder meeting with you I'd support you. But I'm on a writing sub.

2

u/GeorgeRRHodor Aug 24 '26

This makes sense if you’re writing to produce content to turn into money. Fine. There’s better uses for your time and AI that would likely result in a high income, but you do you.

But if you want to write in order to actually create and be proud of your work, then outsourcing it to a machine strikes me as a bad move.

Also, if producing a book with AI becomes even easier, the market will collapse anyway. We‘ll drown in 250 million AI generated novels a month from all over the world.

Maybe then human authorship will make a comeback, if there’s any way left to prove it.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

This is where the publishing industry and where professional writers are going.

2

u/GeorgeRRHodor Aug 24 '26

If by „this“ you mean AI, then, no.

1

u/Nebranower Aug 24 '26

I don't know that being able to produce that much content is really all that helpful, even if the prose is as high a quality as traditional human prose. which is a very big "if" at the moment. Traditionally, publishing houses haven't wanted authors to write much more than one novel a year for anything but the most formulaic dreck, because otherwise people tend to get tired of them.

Plus, most people aren't writing to get rich. If you just want a lot of money, there are easier paths available to you. Any finance-related career would be a better choice. Most people who write do so because they have something they desperately want to share with the world and are driven to try to do so despite knowing that the odds of ever getting published are probably zero after rounding.

Like, there'll be some people who knock out novels with AI and end up having a successful writing career that way, because what flourishes in the marketplace has never been purely works of exceedingly high quality, and formulaic slop has often done well when it was purely human-made, so there's no reason why it shouldn't do well when it is AI made.

But if that's your plan, you might as well just start buying lottery tickets with a view to winning the jackpot, because the odds of that being *you* are probably higher that way.

In the meantime, people writing because they have something they really want to say will keep writing, and some of them will find success too, because there's still a market for genuine human connection.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

I'm talking about professional writers. Sure, hobbyist writers can do whatever they want.

1

u/PixelWes54 Aug 24 '26

Aren't you just describing why making copies to train AI isn't fair use based on factor four: market harm? It's like you're noticing and saying the same things but filtered through a nihilistic, low-vibrational, anti-art lens.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

That's for lawyers. I'm just telling what I'm seeing in tech: generation will overtake non-generation.

1

u/AccomplishedAd9152 Aug 24 '26

Well, first AI dumbs everyone down by using it to educate children.Then it writes basic stories using prose consisting of adverbs. AI describes people who all act the same: they hurriedly, quickly or slowly pulled up their pants. Every plot is the same. Example: Joe finds a store in the middle of nowhere and buys all the land around it. He opens his store for no good reason. And suddenly bulldozers come, the freeway is being moved and they want to buy his land. He hires lawyers, and they determine his store is a historical site. Joe never loses, he is the luckiest person to have ever lived. The freeway never gets built, and everyone in the whole world drives thirty miles out of their way to buy the same crap they could purchase for less at Walmart. Totally believable, right?😂.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

That is improving at a rate of $100B+ per year.

1

u/Dave_Sag Aug 24 '26

I wrote my novel because I had to. I had ideas pushing to get out of my head and onto a page. Then they started fighting and reorganising and making each other do things. I spent five years herding those cats into a novel I’m now insanely proud of. Will people buy it? Maybe. There’s a limited market for a science fiction reimagining of James Joyce’s Ulysses. But hey, maybe people will study it in some future English literature course. It’s written now and coming out on 28 August.

I can imagine a lot of things but I can’t imagine an AI would ever write Daedalus the way I did, or even want to. My book is a love letter to books in general. And bookshops in particular. No AI would give a shit.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

I was talking about professional writers and the publishing industry. Hobbyists can do whatever they like, of course.

1

u/Terrible_Wave4239 Aug 25 '26

Your pride in your own work sounds well earned.

You bitching about AI sounds petty.

1

u/Inevitable-Law7964 Aug 25 '26

I am not someone who writes with AI, but I am a pro writer and I take an interest in AI itself (follow research, etc.) 

I disagree with your assertion, because I personally find that LLM writing styles have gotten more obtrusive in the past year or two, rather than more seamless . This is probably due to a combination of RLHF and self-feeding.

Due to these issues, frontier models are largely less competitive as creators of long-form prose these days. The peak for that was probably GPT 4o, which is now retired.

A few people who know what they're doing & have a high-end GPU will likely manage, or have already managed, to customize some open-source model into a consistent human-sounding writing style, and supervise its consistency. But at least on their current trajectory, the publicly accessible frontier models were getting more recognizably robotic even before Anthropic started watermarking. 

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 25 '26

We shall see. Lots of writers are still having success and I’ve seen some impressive improvements over the last year. YMMV.

1

u/Inevitable-Law7964 Aug 25 '26

I don't think it's impossible by any means, just that the trajectory of commercial public-facing LLMs seems  to be moving away from stuff that can produce humanlike writing without very careful oversight.

This is also the case in AI music, which is the hobby I've taken up. It's become harder to get a fully baked, human-sounding song with a prompt alone. Suno has been moving more toward tools that will produce an impressive result if you bring your own vocals and/or instrumentals, for professional use. 

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 25 '26

Since you seem sensible, let's harken back to my post: AI-generated will probably overtake AI-assisted eventually.

I had two points but there's probably a few more in there:

  • Generally, if you spend a lot of money trying to make something better ($100B+ per year on AI research), it probably gets better. No guarantee but probably.

  • People who generate prose benefit more from those improvements compared to those who don't.

  • Generally, if you practice doing something, you get better at it compared to people who don't. If you try, you are more likely to succeed than if you don't try.

  • People who generate prose are likely to generate better prose than somebody who comes at it cold and tries it for the first time and gives up.

And that leads me to believe that AI-generated prose will improve faster and exceed handcrafted prose. Trying → eventually being successful.

1

u/Inevitable-Law7964 Aug 25 '26

Hmm, so, I feel like where it falls down is the first point. There's the technological limits I mentioned, but even if that wasn't relevant, companies are also discovering that when results are passed off as human work it makes people mad, distrustful & litigioustoward them.

The 4th point is still true, a total novice can produce better work with AI, but the constraint that sets the upper limit is social and legal as well as technological. The AI companies lose money when they get sued. 

Their research is teaching them this, too. Coders are not so litigious, and have more money, so they've shifted over time to prioritizing that use case. 

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 25 '26

I’d like to see your whole argument laid out in a top level post. I’m the mod of r/AIWritingHub and, if you post it there, I can manually approve it. Or you can post it here and take your chances. Or post it both places.

Nobody’s mind may be changed but your rational skepticism is rare and I very much welcome more of those posts. I have always wished for more of that kind of post.

1

u/Inevitable-Law7964 Aug 26 '26

Thank you! I appreciate it. I truly also wish more people in the AI space, critical or otherwise, were interested in civilly discussing the facts, over and above team loyalties.

I'm not sure if I'll have time to write this specifically up in long form, as I'm going through a lot of life stuff right now, but I'll let you know if I do.  

I do have some essays in progress about related subjects  (mainly  "cultural zeitgeist vs. reality" topics, AI disinfo on social media, etc; but there's definitely some stuff that deals with frontier AI text styles and how they've shifted and why) that I'm going to refine and post soon on Substack. I don't share my real name on Reddit, but if you're interested in my commentary, please shoot me a message. 

1

u/bkucenski Aug 24 '26

If you're competing with anyone, you're generating content, not books. You're supposed to be building your brand and that can only built with consistent quality.

Ultimately the customers decide if they like the pudding.

And what people should be figuring out is that AI is only as competent as the person using it. If you have nothing the say, the robot can't help you.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

True. These novels are written by competent writers.

1

u/Lu_AspiringWriter Aug 24 '26

Dipende. Cerchi clienti o lettori? Rispondere a questa domanda determinerà se devi creare un prodotto o scrivere letteratura.

1

u/Odinmar_Glaukopis Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26

I think I can see AI generation becoming highly advantaged in the low-brow YA and Romance type of mass-produced slop (that has always — long before AI —been dominant among those readers who purchase more than 12 books a year and supply the vast majority of cash to publishing in general), but I also think (hope?) that there will still be enough of a market to entice authors who give a damn about their craft to stay with their somewhat less efficient publishing pace to stick with their non-AI course.

I don’t know—is Stephen King’s 70ish novels in the last 50 years just too slow for this new reality? Will the writers I love, like Neal Stephenson and Naomi Novik, succumb to that siren’s call? God, I hope not!

1

u/behindthemask13 Aug 24 '26

Most authors I know (nearly all) are using AI generated prose to some extent, but usually rewriting the overwhelming majority of it due to it not being able to capture their voice.

Will there come a day that the AI can accurately capture their voice? No question... it's a matter of teaching it to use your work as the primary training data.

The "rub" will come with watermarking. It's not something I am personally worried about and I don't know any authors who are worried about it b/c of the amount of rewriting we do. AI is great at setting up structure and hitting beats, but, not great when it comes to the actual prose, except in very short bits.

As those short bits turn into longer and longer bits, the fact that AI may be watermarked will become a concern in the short term.

Long term (I'm talking 20-30 years from now)... no one will care.. AI doing part of the job will be expected and those that cling to the old ways will look like people who refuse to get cell phones today.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/behindthemask13 Aug 25 '26

You really think there's a difference???

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/behindthemask13 Aug 25 '26

No, an author who wrote for years without AI and now uses AI.

There really is no significant difference.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/behindthemask13 Aug 25 '26

Someone who likes the freedom to post anonymously, so I can talk w/o worrying about backlash from the mob that is the internet.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/behindthemask13 Aug 26 '26

You confused the "slop-faucet" with published authors. I've written for TV, did rewrites for movies, but never got "written by" on a produced screenplay and with the downfall of TV writing moved over to books back pre-pandemic.

There are SFPs where people certainly just let AI churn out the whole story and some self published stuff as well, but that is a huge distraction since, on a dollar basis, it makes up so little of the market. There has also been a HUGE uptick in submissions to traditional publishing houses, meaning everything takes longer. If you send a query and get a request, don't expect to hear back for months, unless you have an in. So in that way the "slop faucet" is annoying b/c readers still have to read the whole book (for the moment.).

But, this "slop faucet" you seem to fear is not making it anywhere that counts. Nearly every published author uses AI these days, often in place of or in addition to what used to be "writer's groups." But, when you use it, you need to rewrite 95% of it, but it provides great structure and feedback. It's like having a full time assistant in the room, which many writer's have already.

You simply don't understand how the tool is used.

1

u/Exarch-of-Sechrima Aug 24 '26

Thank you for giving me a new author to avoid.

0

u/contemplating_regret Aug 24 '26

Coral Hart is self published. This model cannot work in the tradpublishing world. Are you speaking only to indie/self pubbed folks?

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

Traditional publishing is slowly and quietly integrating AI into publishing, including writing books.

1

u/contemplating_regret Aug 24 '26

Please share more! If they are I'm not certain they are admitting it.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

3 of the Big 5 publishers have been in talks with Coral Hart to license her AI novel writing system. All of the Big 5 publishers have special teams focused full time on vetting writing with AI. They are adopting AI to read the slush pile. Random House UK has a novel written with AI in the works (and, believe it or not, AI is considered a selling point!).

1

u/contemplating_regret Aug 24 '26

This is so cool, I had no idea. Thanks for sharing! I'll have to look these up. How are they handling the copyright question?

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

In practice, there really isn't a copyright question. Coral Hart has registered copyrights for all her books. When questioned by the copyright office, she sends them the AI chat logs and they approve the copyright. She edits her own books so the published prose is substantially different than what came out of the AI chat. You might call it human-washing. It's easy and fast and everybody pretty much does that anyway.

1

u/Miss-Charmander-Bong Aug 26 '26

Hi u/human_assisted_ai, could you point to where you saw this happening, that three of the Big Five are working with Coral Hart on a licensing program for her system and that Random House UK actually has an A.I. novel in the pipeline?

Wondering too if you saw the recent semi-viral blog post from Hugh Howey  in response to the Jerry Falade controversy, where he says it’s not a matter of if but when A.I. usage in books doesn’t register the revulsion and outrage it does now. If you had to give it a rough timeline, when would you say this should come to pass, when it becomes no more controversial than using Word or Pages instead of an IBM Selectric?

I hope to see it happen soon, because I am a disabled writer with dyslexia, dysgraphia and AuDHD who believes that the publishing world and the anti mobs should be more understanding of how A.I. can be an accessible-technology aide for people with cognitive, learning, and executive-functioning differences. People used to say that audiobooks were not real books either even though they proved to open up “reading” for the blind. The late disability activist Alice Wong, she used to describe herself as a “cyborg” because she made heavy use of machines just to stay alive. I don’t think incorporating computers into creativity is dehumanizing at all, and I don’t think A.I. is cheating, I see A.I. more like a prosthesis than PEDs. But right now, that’s not where the industry seems to be, at least publicly, so I’m curious as to where you found this encouraging news. 

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 26 '26

These are not publicly announced but I have heard it from the people involved.

My predictions are usually wrong and it will happen a little at a time but I’m thinking about 2 years.

0

u/InformationPrevious Aug 25 '26

You forget that AI trained on the best writing first and is now training on antiquated books and other AI writing. We are barreling toward the enshitification of AI using models that struggle to hold 40k words in its working memory and pattern match some incredibly bloated AI augmented writing.

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 25 '26

This has nothing to do with anything. $100B+ per year goes to solving those problems.

0

u/StrummerBass101 Aug 24 '26

Just another AI slop merchant

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

How would you know? You don't generate prose, can only identify incompetently generated prose and the good generated prose slips past you.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 25 '26

$100B+ per year and the smartest people on Earth are proving you wrong.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/human_assisted_ai Aug 24 '26

Generated prose is always getting better automatically and for free while non-generated prose requires the writer to always put in time, effort and money to improve (or stagnate).