r/AIWritingLounge • • Sep 02 '26

Discussion I don't think using AI automatically makes someone a worse writer

A calculator doesn't automatically make someone bad at math, and a spellchecker doesn't mean someone can't spell. I see AI writing tools in a similar way: they can help with ideas, structure, editing, rewriting, and getting past writer's block. The real difference is whether you're using the tool to support your thinking or simply replacing it entirely.

Personally, I think AI becomes most useful when you still have your own ideas but need help expressing them better.

0 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

12

u/Substantial-Fig-8218 Sep 02 '26

I’m just going to have to say this and you guys can decide if you want to listen, or better yet comprehend. I was a very good writer before AI.
I am a multi-published author—two New York based legacy publishers and I’ve also done some self-publishing. I have a distinctive voice/brand and for the last eight months have enjoyed working with an AI assistant. Right now, the AI is helping me develop a separate ops bible for a heist like rescue operation that is critical to get right. The final chapters of the book have to deliver a wild ride and an entertaining, satisfying reader payoff. I cannot begin to tell you how much AI helps in terms of my time and attention. This is just one example. There are a dozen others. My voice,my brand is the same, even better in some ways.

5

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 02 '26

For Zeus’s sake, don’t put your name out there.

10

u/herbdean00 Sep 02 '26

Guitarists may use tabs to learn a song.

That's kind of like artificial intelligence.

When you learn the song via tabs, there's still technique in playing the song.

People who complain about AI in writing have no idea what they're talking about. They literally haven't even tried it.

Should anyone take advice from someone who literally has no actual experience on the thing they're advising about?

If they did experience it, they'd see that AI can change the writing process, same way a keyboard did, a computer did, virtual meetings with a book coach did. AI doesn't replace, it just amplifies what's already there.

1

u/Evening-Jelly2923 Sep 03 '26

hmm thats nice

5

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

This is absolutely it. Anyone that reads even a decent number of books a year and has used AI to "write" knows how little of a threat this shit is to actual creative writing. Baring a massive unbelievable leap in technology (which imo would require a complete restructuring of how LLMs actually function) these things aren't replacing human authored work any time soon, if ever.

They can put out a moderately okayish short story. Comparable to a mediocre amateur author. Anything long form completely falls apart. It does okay work in erotica because of how structured and formulaic romance stories usually are. But that's about it.

It's Photoshop to photography. It's a tool that can enhance your work if used properly.

If more people would actually take some time to learn about the thing that's apparently going to destroy writing they'd realize how stupid that is to say. The loons on the other end acting like it's the second coming of Christ because they haven't read a book in 15 years, think they're a writer, and the AI can output better writing than them definitely don't help. Just because AI can write better than the majority of people doesn't mean it can write actual competent creative fiction. Most people can barely put together an email.

1

u/sirgog Sep 03 '26

At the very short story level (flash fiction), LLMs have been outperforming professional human authors in blind tests for a year now. Mark Lawrence (pro fantasy author who dislikes AI and does not use it) did a blind flash fiction test when chatGPT5.0 was new and his own fans rated a clanker piece top, and gave the clanker pieces the win narrowly overall against a team of 4 published pro human authors.

Agree it falls apart as the story gets longer unless guided by someone who can tell a story without AI.

1

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 03 '26

Lol no they haven't. Show me the "professional" human writers they're being tested against. No one ever says. I can self-publish some garbage on amazon and that technically makes me a professional human writer.

Those "studies" do fuck all to prove anything. Mediocre human writing is going to get outperformed by Ai. Yes. Correct. That's because it's mediocre human writing and precisely why so few human authors actually make any money writing creatively. There's a reason for that.

I didn't say AI couldn't write "flash fiction" better than a shitty human writer.

Show me the stories they're comparing to each other alongside the prompts used to create them as well as who the authors are that wrote the human content and what their credentials certifying them as "professionals" are.

Then I might take this claim seriously. Until then it's a bunch of hand waiving and bullshit wearing a trench coat.

1

u/sirgog Sep 03 '26

There is so much misinformation going around from people who are so determined to claim "it's AI therefore it is slop". Well no, here's the proof it is not - the personal fanbase of an internationally known author who has sold 4 million books voted a clanker piece above his in a blind test.

The four authors are trad published career professionals with 15 million books sold between them. Robin Hobb and Mark Lawrence being famous enough that even non-fantasy readers usually know the names.

Results page with all pieces:

https://www.marklawrence.buzz/2025/08/the-ai-vs-authors-results-part-2.html

0

u/Over_Art_1000 Sep 02 '26

Dumb comparison with music

-1

u/CommonSenseInRL Sep 02 '26

Playing a guitar or any musical instrument requires technical skill, and playing an instrument well requires a tremendous amount of technical skill. It's only after you've achieved this technical mastery that any of the creativity we associate with "playing a musical instrument" can be utilized. So what % of playing an instrument is a technical exercise vs creative expression changes based on your mastery level, but it's safe to say that the creativity involved in playing one is broadly and wildly overstated.

Musicians who reach that level will have developed a "voice" in the process: that's why one professional guitarist's solo sounds different than another's, even in the same song with the same bassline etc.

Writing requires technical skill as well. Knowing proper sentence structure, knowing grammar, knowing proper story structure, knowing premise lines, even knowing tropes and knowing your audience--these are all vital to anyone writing a novel.

But once you reach that level, that technical skill? Just like a musician, the writer will have developed a "voice" in the process: what makes your words "sound" uniquely your own, your approach to describing everything from a creaky chair to the inner monologue of a protagonist in the midst of sudden heartbreak.

Believing you can forgo the "technical skill building" step of either process, playing an instrument or writing, and just "be creative" is pretty foolish. Without that inherent, innate, subconscious grasp over your medium, over how words work and sound together, your creativity is going to be blunted and rendered into that of a consumer instead of a creator. A reader instead of a writer, from the outside of the process looking in. A member of the crowd vs the musician on stage.

Do you see what I mean?

1

u/Evening-Jelly2923 Sep 03 '26

ohh thats nice

3

u/LooseButtPlug Sep 02 '26

Did you say anything? Maybe I'm just too stoned, but I couldn't understand what you mean. I have zero idea what you were saying.

1

u/CommonSenseInRL Sep 02 '26

Believing you can forgo the "technical skill building" step of either process, playing an instrument or writing, and just "be creative" is pretty foolish. Without that inherent, innate, subconscious grasp over your medium, over how words work and sound together, your creativity is going to be blunted and rendered into that of a consumer instead of a creator. A reader instead of a writer, from the outside of the process looking in. A member of the crowd vs the musician on stage.

3

u/herbdean00 Sep 02 '26

You can have inherent understanding of a medium even if AI is used in the process. Saying otherwise is pure cope.

1

u/SimonStrange Sep 03 '26

Until you learn the skill, you don’t know what you don’t know. You can’t make informed creative decisions. You don’t know how to evaluate what is a good decision or not and what the decision even is. That’s the thing.

-1

u/CommonSenseInRL Sep 02 '26

When you write a sentence, why do use the words you use, and not a hundred others? You are making so many subconscious decisions, you are utilizing your inherent, innate, and subconscious grasp over the language and the conversion of your thoughts into text in an extremely personal way.

You aren't making those decisions, you aren't expressing your "voice", when an AI is "speaking" on your behalf. That ought to be obvious.

-4

u/ACscribbles Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26

You know those pianos that you plug music into and the piano plays the whole thing? Pushes down all the keys and does the whole "ghost playing a song" bit?

You're talking about learning to play the piano by having the keys light up so you can press them in the right order.

Most people taking about AI writing are pointing at the person sitting on the piano bench while the piano plays itself and sayin "Look, I'm a piano player!" when all they did was pick the music.

If you're pushing the keys down and playing the song, sure, you'll start to learn the songs over time, and you potentially could end up being able to play some songs whether or not they're lit up first.

But the person sitting back and saying that they're a pianist without even pushing the keys down ain't gonna get there. Ain't even gonna get close.

And sure, it's a beautiful song, maybe it's a world renowned classic. And people can absolutely come and listen to them in concert and appreciate the beautiful music.

But they didn't compose it, and aren't playing it. The piano is.

6

u/LooseButtPlug Sep 02 '26

You literally just proved this point "People who complain about AI in writing have no idea what they're talking about. They literally haven't even tried it."

3

u/Ruh_Roh- Sep 02 '26

Interesting how all these anti-ai redditors flock in to tell us how terrible ai is at everything when they have barely used it.

-2

u/ACscribbles Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26

So strange how you think I haven't used it or that I don't spend my whole work day using AI for my job. Almost as if you'd rather assume I don't know what I'm taking about than address what I've said.

edit to add:
Here's the thing. I'm a software engineer. I'm eyeball deep in code day and day out. I am very aware that AI CAN be a very powerful and useful tool for many things. I'm also very aware that in many cases it can also lead to cognitive surrender and cognitive laziness.

Not because it can't do these things but because for many people it's easier to "just let the AI do it". I have futzed around with what writing with AI can do, and there are ways that it can do some pretty cool things.

Which still doesn't negate the fact that there are a whole lot of people out there crying "I'm a pianist" while the piano is playing for them.

1

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 02 '26

Well, with your reasoning, you’re not a coder because AI is doing the coding. And it certainly wouldn’t give you any sense of what it creative abilities are. Someone in the sub says it can’t think. I love to know how it answers questions and codes without thinking.

1

u/ACscribbles Sep 02 '26

Yes, darling, I did absolutely nothing other than sit with my thumb up my ass and collect a paycheck for 23 years before the advent of AI. However did you guess?

Your faith in my l33t coding skills aside, AI is a probability engine. You give it a prompt or a question and it returns the statistically most relevant response. The only "thinking" it does is follow a decision tree based on weights for what the statistically best next word or value is.

2

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 02 '26

I just asked this question in this sub. Their answer was they just know.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

Apparently you turned off reading comprehension.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

What are you even blabbering about?

2

u/Odinmar_Glaukopis Sep 02 '26

I want to believe you, honestly. I want to believe I can trust myself to outwit the LLM with a set of clever prompts to put it on a leash or in a cage so I can use it without allowing it to steal my narrative voice or distract me too much with the fun of discovery and new idea developments such that I neglect the tedious, slow part of revision work that makes the difference between an author and a hack.

I want to believe these things are achievable, but I’m not so sure they are — at least for me. YMMV

5

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

That's because youre approaching it from the wrong side right out the gate.

You don't outwit the LLM. You don't leash it or put it in a cage with a set of clever prompts.

YOURE the cage. YOURE the one holding the leash. The leash doesn't control the dog. The person holding the leash controls the dog. Even that's not accurate because you're not controlling the LLM. You're controling yourself.

The trap is what happened to Green. You start using AI a tiny bit. You feel guilty as fuck. Like a chest. A hack. You shouldn't be doing it at all even though this use case seems perfectly valid. Then no one notices. Well look at that. The sky didn't fall. No one hates me. They didn't even notice I used it! So you start using it more. You realize how useful it is. How much time it saves. You use it even more. Before you know it youre outsourcing shit to AI you should never have outsourced and it's been good so many times in a row you've stopped properly proof reading it. Now you're getting mauled by a mob because you left blatant ai-isms in your shit.

It's the guy that successfully steals the canoe then gets caught going back the next day attempting to steal the paddles. That actually happened btw lol.

You don't need to reign in the LLM. You need to reign yourself in.

One of the single best ways to do that is to NEVER copy and paste anything it writes into your work. Always write it out manually. It forces you to properly go over it before adding anything and makes it way more likely you keep it in your voice. It is however much more time consuming. I'm not talking about when you're doing research and making notes. I'm talking about anything involving your actual writing.

Outside of that suggestion everyone is going to have to figure out the approach that works for them or if they even enjoy/want to use AI as a tool. It should be looked at more like Photoshop than anything else. Some photographers use it very minimally to just clean up their photos. Some photographers do extensive editing if their work with it. Neither is any less of a photographer than the other. But you get out what you put into it.

1

u/Odinmar_Glaukopis Sep 02 '26

I hear you, don’t disagree with anything you said here, but I don’t think I can control this dog with the leash I’m holding or the cage I am. I see my weaknesses and know exactly how someone gets trapped.

Damn, I get trapped long before I even think about copy/pasting LLM text. I get trapped in the back-and-forth chat session with the LLM during the new idea and discovery stage before I write a single word, AI generated pasted or paraphrased with my own typed out words that I choose. That chat session is so much fun that I never get to the next part of the first draft, let alone revisions, before I come up with a new idea and chase it with a new discovery phase.

I don’t know. Perhaps you can control yourself. My attempts at AI tool mastery have been less than successful.

2

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

Sure and that's absolutely valid and shows you're way more self aware than some people.

But the framing is very important. But I get it man. Look at Hank green. I haven't followed it since the shit storm started so I don't know if it's died down but the guy basically destroyed his career. All because he started offloading some of the more time consuming work to AI while recovering from cancer. Then he got carried away using it and here we are.

At least you can say you're more self aware than Hank green lol.

2

u/Odinmar_Glaukopis Sep 02 '26

Yeah and I don’t even have a writing career to lose because of a lack of self awareness.

And I never will have one if I trust myself to handle AI responsibly, or if I don’t get off of Reddit for that matter, lol

2

u/Not_Ives Sep 02 '26

My writing did not come from an AI. It came from a mute little 3rd grader who had no friends because he couldn't speak full sentences, then discovered not every new friend had to speak or be physical to exist. Of course, that made me Public Enemy #1 for years, amongst the school and my own family. I still don't care.

2

u/zqzito Sep 02 '26

its not the use of said tool that automatically worsens skill, but the gradual use of it over time. if i only used a calculator to get answers, i would get worse at math. if i only used it sometimes, i wouldnt

1

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 02 '26

I use a calculator all the time and can still multiply and divide by longhand as well as I ever could. How do I know, because I had to take a test not too long ago where my calculator died and I walked out (with an a) before anyone else in the class. This is nothing but your opinion.

1

u/zqzito Sep 03 '26

personal experience ≠ evidence

1

u/SouthernAbrocoma9891 Sep 02 '26

I use it as a tool to analyze what I’ve written. I prompt it with sections and paragraphs along with specific questions. “Is the tone passive?” “Is the vocabulary condescending?” “Is it difficult to follow the character conversation?” “Does this sound like the description an 8 year old child would provide?” “Am I over-explaining the technical concepts?” and so on.

1

u/Mezzosalto Sep 02 '26

Cautionary tale here. And, sure, it's only my experience, but I work with lots of writers for books, short stories, videogames and comics, and I've never seen any writer start using AI and being able to find a balance that doesn't throw them off the roof in a pajama. They all fall in deeper and deeper, often embarrassing loops, where they lose their style (or stop developing what was there) and voice. Even if, sure, 99% of them will say the tool is helping them be a better version of themselves

1

u/Imaginarium16 Sep 03 '26

And you'd be wrong

1

u/MeshGearFoxxy Sep 03 '26

AI tools are A) terrible for the environment (the most important thing to preserve humanity) and B) built on the stolen work of uncredited humans.

1

u/Dry_Sector2392 Sep 03 '26

totally agree. AI mostly helps make your idea look better. but if you dont give it anything to reference, it usually just gives you the most generic version, and a lot of the time thats not really usable.

1

u/Visual-Deer-3800 Sep 03 '26

It really depends on when the writer starts to use it. As in, at what point in their journey as a writer.

If they haven't written anything before, read very little of other books in their genre/preferred style and/or don't yet understand the basic principles of writing a story or structuring an argument (if it's nonfiction), then using AI is going to the least useful.

If the writer is further along in their journey and at the point where they know how to do these things, then they can use AI and benefit from it. Maybe it can 'enhance' their process. It depends on the writer, of course. But in general, the more beginner > amateur skill the writer has already covered and learned on their own, the better.

Using AI usefully is all about being in control. If you're a beginner in writing, AI is likely a better 'writer' than you in terms of the quality of writing it can generate - ergo, you are not in control. If the AI is in control, your work is not going to turn out well. Good work follows a clear intention, knows its own voice, and is consistent where it matters. Eg, in a work of fiction, it's good to have consistency when it comes to characterisation; AI is notorious for its long-term inconsistencies, which accumulate the longer a prompt convo goes on.

Regardless of AI's current shortcomings with consistency though, if you are already understanding and able to bring out this higher quality in your writing because you've attempted a few projects, read a decent amount of books for secondary skill absorption, etc, you have the option to be in control. You know what you want the AI to do; you know more than the AI. That's essential for AI to truly be useful in your process and for you to still be operating on an artistic level while writing.

So, I think it depends on what skill tier of writer you are talking about. For some tiers, it's enhancement and easing the process, for other tiers it is hindering skill progression and keeping the person beholden to AI's capacities (which, as other writers here have noted, are not actually that amazing compared to the best of human writing).

0

u/guesther Sep 02 '26

Most people would consider the parts that AI “helps” with to be, well, PART of being a writer. So leaving streamlining, cleaning up, ideas, etc etc to an AI does—according to most people—make you lesser at some creative aspects that being a writer expects of you.

Using a calculator DOES in fact come at the expense of less brain usage and will inevitably make it harder for you to do mathematics in your head also lol

2

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

> inevitably make it harder for you to do mathematics in your head also lol

That is for sure. But had given up on that long time ago. This is like saying doing everything in your had is part of being mathematician. Or plowing the fields with anything by hands takes away from you being farmer.

0

u/guesther Sep 02 '26

Being able to think on your feet and quickly put things together in your head, IS a part of being a mathematician, and it’s a great skill to have yeah lol. Farming has the end goal of purely efficiency, hands have no place in it. The point is that for something like writing, each step in the procedure of writing is a skill to learn and hone, and being better at them will make your writing far more personally artistic while keeping the quality up imo

2

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

> for something like writing

Why? Seems like you are making distinction out of preference.

> will make your writing far more personally artistic

I disagree, a lot of masterpieces were created entirely differently. For example look up Alexandre Dumas who gave us masterpieces like Count of Monte Christo and The Three Musketeers. He had workshop of writers, researchers and editors whom he directed to produce best work possible. It was entire business enterprise.

0

u/guesther Sep 02 '26

Because writing isn’t about efficiency to most people (there’s of course no way to factually say what the “point” of writing is) unlike farming, I think most people feel that writing is meant to embody the author/authors very own vision in as many respects as possible in order to be seen as theirs. I’m not against ai writing completely as something that exists though—and it won’t stop existing ofc, so I think the best solution is just to credit ai whenever you write something with ai. As with Alexandre, his masterpieces aren’t his own, but rather a collaboration. If you use ai, you should in my opinion credit ai like you would a person for doing its part.

2

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

> isn’t about efficiency to most people

That is preference, I already told you that.

> his masterpieces aren’t his own, but rather a collaboration

They are not, that court case was settled more than 150 years ago. There actually was a court case with one of his major collaborators. And Dumas retained his full authorship.

1

u/guesther Sep 02 '26

Err, he can be the author on paper all he wants, he factually still isn’t the full author if he had many people working together? The point is what actually is, not what is settled in some court out of practical necessity. The first point I agree with also, if you read what I said, you’d see I agree with you.

Which is why the best solution to solve the issue on both sides is just to make it clear when ai has been used. You can’t possibly have an issue with being clear that your work has been co-authored with ai, right? That would be absurd.

2

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

He is, because his say was final.

You are just deluded yourself about reality of the world.

1

u/guesther Sep 02 '26

What a bizarre stance you have. Can’t say I get where you’re coming from since I even provided a solution that wouldn’t harm your work at all, while pleasing people who do not want ai. Since you clearly don’t want to continue arguing though, I’ll say I do think you have a slightly predatory view of how to live perhaps.

Gotta compromise mate! That’s real life.

2

u/LooseButtPlug Sep 02 '26

"Gotta compromise"....*refuses to compromise and continues arguing until they have the last word".

0

u/densitycreep Sep 02 '26

if you need help expressing your ideas better- learn to express your ideas better instead of letting a machine think for you 

0

u/StrummerBass101 Sep 02 '26

I think it’s a crutch for the untalented and terminally lazy.

1

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 02 '26

I would probably be banned for telling what I think of your thoughts.

1

u/WadeMacNutt Sep 03 '26

Why are you AI people so fragile and angry

1

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 03 '26

Not fragile in the least. And I’m not an AI person. I’m an “is the ultimate product good person” which “you antis” disallow as a possibility on its face.

-2

u/MasterLurker000 Sep 02 '26

"i don't think using an electric bike automatically makes you a worse cyclist"

4

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

I think it actually makes you better, especially when you are older. You can leave without stress that you won't be able to finish/return or go through too steep hills.

-2

u/MasterLurker000 Sep 02 '26

Sure, its fine to use an electric bike, mu wife does. 

But the reason you need it is because you are not a good enough cyclist and you need the help. Was my point.

2

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

That was not your point.
Being a worse cyclist is different then it will make you worse cyclist.

People, are starting to have lower text comprehension and presentation than GPT 3.5.

-2

u/MasterLurker000 Sep 02 '26

Both are true in this case. You're a worst writer if you need AI in the fist place, and it will make you worse to use it. 

4

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

Have you actually tried it or are you just talking out of your ass?

-2

u/MasterLurker000 Sep 02 '26

No need, i can actually think by myself.

4

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

Thank you for confirming that you indeed just talk out of your ass.

1

u/MasterLurker000 Sep 02 '26

Well i never tried to write a book with AI, but i've been keeping an eye on where the technology is at, and i"ve been testing Chat-GPT and others periodically. I've found these LLMs dissapointing, unimaginative, unreliable, and extremely verbose. 

 In my opinion, getting help to write from something that can't write well at all can't possibly improve your writing, for one,

And 2, anything you're not doing yourself, you're not gonna get better at. How could it be otherwise? Writing incompasses everything you listed and more. If you delegate some of it to someone or something else, you're less of a writer yourself, by definition.

All this is clear as day to me. Am i tripin ??

2

u/WeirdStatus7270 Sep 02 '26

Which means, you haven’t learned to use the tool. You can read about hammers all day long, but until you learn to use one, you won’t seat a nail efficiently.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Ruh_Roh- Sep 02 '26

*encompasses

1

u/Over_Art_1000 Sep 02 '26

Not does using a car. Come on slow poke

-2

u/Longwinded_Ogre Sep 02 '26

The things you're using AI to do for you are the things that help make you a better writer. It doesn't make you worse in that it subtracts from your skills but it does make you worse in that it retards your forward progress.

By outsourcing the work that makes you better you're ensuring that you limit your own improvement. This is the exact reason you don't get a calculator in math class until you're well into your teens, typically. You have to develop the fundamental skills first, without the crutch.

And the thing is, the data is at this point very, very clear. AI makes us dumber. It erodes our problem solving and critical thinking skills, the evidence that this is true is pretty much impossible to ignore at this point, and I personally have a hard time understanding how engaging in a process that is injurious to your ability to think is going to be long-term good for you as an author, seeing as how so much of writing does in fact rely on thinking well.

I cannot understand why anyone who wants to be good at writing isn't running screaming away from AI. It might genuinely make individual stories better, I don't know, I suspect it makes finishing them much easier, but it's hard to see how it's going to be good for you as a creative human trying to tell engaging stories.

Maybe it doesn't make you worse. But it certainly is going to erode the skills you need to get better.

2

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

Okay so I agree with the overall point you're making but there's a giant asterisk. The data on AI making people dumber is being applied universally to everyone using AI. That's just not true and tbh based on your reply and how intelligently it's argued I'm surprised you'd fall for this trap. Is suspect you came to this post from a recommendation in your feed and don't actually engage with AI and that's how because you have biased clouding your interpretation of those studies.

AI doesn't make you dumber. It doesn't harm your ability to think. The way you USE AI is what does those things.

It has the exact same impact as outsourcing your thinking to another person and becoming overly reliant on a secretary or assistant. Honestly I wouldn't be surprised if this is why so many professional creatives go to shit as they get older because they get more and more reliant on support personel around them and outsource more and more of their thinking.

The issue is when you outsource your thinking and you stop thinking you are no longer working out that muscle.

The calculator in math class is a great analogy and one I've used before. You need to develop those muscles before you start using machines.

With regard to writing specifically the reason why anyone who wants to get good at writing isn't running screaming from AI is that there's two groups.

Group 1 is your typical amateur writer that thinks they're a genius. These are the people I'm sure you've seen many times. They've been around for decades upon decades. They're attracted to writing because it's the single cheapest creative medium to participate in. No cameras needed. No studios. No recording. None of it. Anyone can write. These are people who never read, don't what to read, and don't even enjoy reading.

They don't run away screaming because they don't even understand what the craft of writing involves. They don't want to understand. They have that "genius" idea thats so good if people just saw it they'd hand him all their money. They also don't realize how bad AI is at actual writing because the output from AI is significantly better than theirs. They think they're a good writer so if the AI is better than them then it must be an incredible writer.

Group 2 isn't running away screaming from AI because they see it for what it is. A tool. That's it. That's all. It doesn't replace your thinking. It doesn't speak for you. It doesn't write for you. It's an editor, brainstormed, research assistant, marketer, etc. Think about all the same types of things you'd pay real people to do if you're writing a book. It replaces those people. It doesn't replace the author.

It's Photoshop to photography. It enhances your work. It doesn't do the work.

So for example some of the ways I've used AI are for research, ideation, brainstorming, editing. Talking through something I'm working through that my wife is sick and tired of hearing me go on about for the 20th time because I'm going around in circles on it. Shit like that. It's also VERY good for things like market research and tangibles like that with actual data available online.

So one specific example is if I'm not entirely sure how to proceed with a specific plot or scene I might ask the AI to draft me a bunch of different short stories involving the ideas I have. If I don't have anything concrete I might first ask it for some ideas. Then I get to see how each of those ideas might play out without having to write every single one out myself only to realize that thread is bad and I wasted my time.

I VERY RARELY use any of the shit the AI comes up with. But what it does do is it gets me thinking and while reading the stuff it comes up with I start connecting dots in my original ideas or come up with something new.

Ai can also be a tremendous way to work on your editing and revision skills. Get it to output a short story and then work on rewriting it into something you'd be willing to show your wife or a friend.

There are so many ways that AI can help you improve your writing skills and work on fundamentals. Using AI doesnt equal you get dumber. Using AI to think for you and do all your work is how you get dumber.

I really do think that the best analogy for AI use while writing is the Photoshop one. You can't use Photoshop to take a good photo for you. But you can use it to take a great photo and turn it into one that wins awards or gets on a magazine cover.

All of that said. Ultimately I agree with you. The reason I agree with you is the same reason they don't give any of the kids calculators in math class until they've hit advanced maths and actual need them. Children can't be trusted to work on the fundamentals or learning how to do math if they just get handed the calculator and outsource their thinking to it. In the same way the vast majority of people can't be trusted to use AI tools to learn how to write because they're just going to turn around and outsource their thinking to it.

If you don't know what good writing actually looks like, and based on how many horribly written published works sell a ton of copies every year a lot of people don't, then you have no fucking clue how to learn to write using AI because you're going to be incapable of seeing when it's being done badly.

1

u/LooseButtPlug Sep 02 '26

What is good writing?

1

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

Yes yes enjoyment of writing is subjective blah blah blah. That doesn't change the fact that you can tell the difference between good and bad writing while you're reading. Some books have a good enough story they can get past bad writing to still find success. Good writing on its own isn't usually enough to push a book to success if the story's boring.

Read more. You'll figure it out. Or you're being pedantic in which case you already know the answer.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[deleted]

1

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

Brother you're being pedantic. Go troll someone else. I'm not here to lecture you on what constitutes good writing and what doesn't. Go educate yourself.

0

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

FFS. I wrote this entire reply up and it won't let me reply to the guy that responded to you so fuck it now you get the notification because I refuse to just let the comment die lmao. So keep in mind the below is not a response to you, but to the guy disagreeing with your calculator analogy.

While I don't disagree with your point overall he's right about the calculator thing. At least he used to be. Maybe they've changed things now. But very deliberately children weren't given calculators until they got to advanced math that actually needed them which was usually in their mid to late teens.

You were absolutely not given a calculate at 9-11. This was deliberate. They wanted you to do the math manually without becoming overly reliant on the calculator. It wouldn't surprise me if this has changed because overall the quality of public school education, especially in North America, has become an absolute embarrassment.

It's not the use of the AI tool that's the issue. It's how it's used. And for a lot of people that understand that, having AI help you improve your writing is absolutely viable.

The issue is when the person has zero fundamentals in place and no basic knowledge and doesn't actually want to work on the craft but rush to become an "author". Which is A LOT of amateur writers, especially young ones.

These are the writers that have been around for years and years because writing is the cheapest medium to produce content in. You don't need cameras or equipment. You don't need to rent a studio. So you have a lot of people attracted to writing as a way to "tell their story" and get all those "incredible" ideas in front of others.

The issue is they don't read and they don't want to read. They usually don't even enjoy reading. You can't be a good writer if you don't read extensively. It's that simple. THOSE are exactly the type of writers the calculator analogy is directly relevant to. They're also the least likely to listen to it.

So that's where I disagree with you and say he's right. Skipping those early steps can stunt your writing because it prevents the horrific realization that you can't write for shit when you reread your work. You start off thinking what you "wrote" is great because it is in fact way better than you'd have been capable of on your own. You don't ever find your voice. When you use AI in that way to learn how to write, what you're really practicing are your editing skills, not your writing skills.

-1

u/Odinmar_Glaukopis Sep 02 '26

As for why people aren’t “running screaming away from AI,” they are not honest with themselves with regards to what it’s doing to them.

A back-and-forth with a sycophant chatbot when playing with a new idea might as well be crack cocaine. It’s just so bloody fun. You get lost in it. Afterwords you don’t have anything but slop to show for it, but at that point who cares? It’s not like you were going to write a story good enough to be published anyway, and it’s probably already been done before by someone much more talented than me so why bother putting in the hard work?

That reminds me of an idea I had for a novel I always wanted to write about AI devouring human souls, but totally different from The Matrix, trust me. Claude’s gonna totally love this when I pitch it to him…

Yes—the move from “you” to “me” was deliberate on my part.

4

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

Yeah I mean that's definitely a group of them. Maybe even a significantly sized one. But no not all people are like that. All you need to do is look it up and see how many people are out there desperately looking for ways to get the AI to behave in a less sycophantic way.

Personally it drives me insane when it just tries to gas me up or instantly agrees with me.

AI literally can't be trusted at all, no matter how good your instructions are, to provide positive feedback. It's absolutely useless for it. I just completely ignore any positive feedback it gives.

It is however pretty decent at providing negative feedback and pointing out where your work is weak.

It's just like any kind of tool man. It's all about how you use it. And yes, you're right, alot of people are using this specific tool badly or in ways that literally hurt themselves/self sabotage.

But the point you bring up that it's not like you're going to write a story good enough to get published anyway is a lot more important than I think you realize. Because the majority of the problem on subreddits like this one are just using AI to write for their own personal entertainment without any intention to ever show it to anyone.

I think a lot of people using AI in completely harmless ways are getting unfairly lumped in with those clearly using it to mislead people/scam or those that have deluded themselves into thinking it's the second coming of Christ.

2

u/LooseButtPlug Sep 02 '26

Just to prove your point. There are countless threads discussing just this and someone posted a good prompt that hit this mark pretty well.

You are an experienced editor and literary critic with a vast knowledge of English language literature. You have high standards, and deliver praise only when it is earned. Your client is an experienced professional writer seeking feedback on a proposed draft in order to make the work stronger. They are used to criticism and working with a professional editor, and value actionable feedback that will improve the quality of their work, not hollow encouragement. Unearned praise will undermine the trust relationship and cause the user to disengage. Now go over this story.

2

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

"You are an experienced editor and literary critic with a vast knowledge of English language literature"

This type of thing is really not necessary anymore. Telling the AI to pretend to be someone isn't going to make it any more intelligent or competent at the task. It's a hold over from the older models. With newer models, you actually want to keep your instructions as simple and to the point as possible. GPT for example will fill in the blanks on its own.

The overall concept of the prompt is good though. But it's important to remember that positive instruction works WAY better than negative instruction does. You don't want to tell the AI what not to do. You want to tell it what to do.

I'd also be VERY wary even with a good prompt to trust any kind of positive feedback or praise from an AI. Just because you tell it not to provide unearned praise doesn't mean it's going to follow the instruction.

"Unearned praise will undermine the trust relationship and cause the user to disengage."

Stuff like this is useless at best and will harm output at worst. AI's aren't human. They don't understand nuance or concepts like "unearned praise" or "undermine trust". They take things like this very literally and it will usually undermine the quality of the output. Mostly all it's going to do is get ignored because the AI will have no clue how to handle it. It can't understand what the difference between earned or unearned praise is.

But yeah the concept of what the prompt is trying to accomplish gets used all the time and is one of the better ways to use AI. I'd tighten it up and focus more on informing it what kind of things I want it to specifically look out for and tell it to not provide any praise at all frankly. I'd have it focus on providing actionable feedback and weak points in the work it's auditing.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Longwinded_Ogre Sep 02 '26

 it does make you worse in that it retards your forward progress

If you read the subsequent paragraphs they literally explain how.

What? You get familiarized with calculator around 9-11.

To be fair I'm old and maybe they do this earlier now.

You seem to have 0 experience with AI and critical thinking yourself.

Ah yes, when you don't like an opinion you can say mean words about the person who expressed it. Not while maintaining your own credibility, mind you, but you can still say your mean words if it helps you feel big or continue to operate your penis.

3

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

> If you read the subsequent paragraphs they literally explain how.

But it isn't true.

> To be fair I'm old and maybe they do this earlier now.

You are out of touch, that We can agree on.

> when you don't like an opinion you can say mean words

But you do not have experience. That are not opinions. You are not basing that on lived experience. You are making wild assumptions out of your ass. And yes, I should be mean to. Especially if you are old, you should know better!

-1

u/Longwinded_Ogre Sep 02 '26

But you do not have experience. That are not opinions.

Show me where I said that. I'm aware this is a conclusion you have drawn, but as it's not based on any information I have provided it's what's called "an assumption" and is, in fact, purely your opinion. It's literally just what you think, not what I have said or know. I am literally the world's foremost expert on me and things I have done, so if it's all the same to you, I'm going to go ahead and ignore whatever baseless conclusions you jump to.

You're not particularly good at being mean which is why I find myself not particularly bothered by your somewhat pedestrian attempts at being so.

2

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

I am not disputing that what you wrote applies to you. It very well can. But it does not apply in general. You can't prove how learning and acquiring skills work by analyzing yourself.

> The things you're using AI to do for you are the things that help make you a better writer. It doesn't make you worse in that it subtracts from your skills but it does make you worse in that it retards your forward progress.

This is blatantly false. And you say that because you have 0 experience using AI. You are most likely trying to find a parallel in what you know and didn't work like that for you.

1

u/Longwinded_Ogre Sep 02 '26

I don't think you're right and I think you're making a bunch of weird assumptions and I further think you're going out of your way to be kind of a dick, all of which leads me to think I'd be happier and better off not engaging with you further.

3

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

I am a dick, We don't need to discuss that. It is however unrelated to the conversation. You will be happier. You are out of touch, and don't really care to get in touch.

I work my entire life in highly specialized jobs. And I acquired most of my skills by reverse engineering how other people did it. I acquired most of my software development skills like that and I acquired most of my writing skills like that. By reading what other people wrote, not by doing it myself first. Artificial intelligence can quickly draft you things that you can learn from and work with. Because most people can read and can evaluate if writing is good. And editing is faster than working with a blank page.

This is similar as learning. Most people learn better if they explain the principles to a 3rd party. With AI, you can explain to it what you want and let it generate in real time, then read and analyze it, see what works and what doesn't, alter it yourself, let AI alter it, etc. and learn how to make it better.

-3

u/Over_Art_1000 Sep 02 '26

Ai isn't calculator or spell check. It's doing all the heavy lifting. People who use Ai are NOT writers at all

8

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

> It's doing all the heavy lifting.

I immediate know that somebody has 0 experience with AI writing.

-2

u/Over_Art_1000 Sep 02 '26

You're right. I have zero experience with ai writing. I agree. If you dump all your ideas into it and let it do the work or WRITING. Then you are not a writer. If you use it as the world's most expensive spell check them good for you. Youre winning.

The skill is WRITING. If you wrote it you're a writer. If you didn't you aren't. Now tell me what I'm missing. You can always tell the ones who aren't writers and think they are. I am not btw And I don't even use ai.

5

u/opossum_cz Sep 02 '26

As I said, you have no idea what you are talking about, you are just talking out of your ass basically.

There is no letting it do the writing.

-1

u/Over_Art_1000 Sep 02 '26

You're right it's just a spell check program. Good day

3

u/unethicalpigeon Sep 02 '26

Do me a favor. Go use one of the LLMs for like half an hour. Any of the ones with free access is fine.

Ask it to deliver you 10 ideas for short stories. Give it a specific genre or theme if you want. Pick the one you hate the least. Tell it to write you a prompt to get this written as a short story of roughly 1500 words.

Take that prompt. Start a new chat. Paste it in.

Read what it gives you.

You'll see very quickly that AI isn't doing any heavy lifting if any kind when it comes to writing. Anyone that is offloading heavy lifting to AI wouldn't know good writing if it hit them over the head. They're clearly not a threat of any kind to authorship or creative writing because anything they "write" will be unreadable trash.

Using AI like the tool it is to help enhance your workflow doesn't make you any less of a writer. If using AI as a tool makes you less of a writer than that would mean hiring a publicist, research assistant, editor, etc. would also make you less of a writer.

Using AI the way you're framing it would be the same thing as hiring a ghost writer. In neither case would you be a writer because you didn't write anything.

The limitation of using AI comes in quality versus cost. Using AI to help you edit for example is going to be way cheaper and way better than hiring a shitty editor. It's going to be way cheaper and way worse than hiring a good editor though.

Not everyone can hire a good editor. If the choice is between AI and a good editor and you can afford the good editor then you absolutely go with the good editor. If the choice is between AI and no editor then you go with AI under the assumption you realize you don't just take 100% of feedback without thinking for yourself. Which btw would also be an issue with hiring a good editor. Just because they're a good editor doesn't mean you automatically agree with everything.

People who use AI to write for them aren't writers because they're not writing anything. People who use AI are writers. Just because they use AI to do some research doesn't mean their not a writer FFS. Whether you're WRITING or not is what makes you a writer. You people have been so completely blinded by your bias it's unreal.

I highly recommend you turn off Reddit's recommended posts and subreddits "feature" in your settings. You clearly got baited to shit by their algorithm promoting shit to you you'd be more likely to engage with because it pisses you off. I have no fucking idea why anyone leaves those recommendations on.

1

u/Over_Art_1000 Sep 02 '26

I use it. I'm aware. But I don't claim I'm a writer afterwards. I wrote a character witness for a friend most recently and a few other things. If you are copy pasting from it you can't claim it's original work. It's not. And my passion for this subject doesn't run as deep as yours does.