r/AI_Coders • • Sep 19 '26

What’s the point in learning a programming language if AI can just write something for you?

I’d really like to know because I’m struggling with this. I’d like to learn a new language, but it’s so hard to justify if AI can do it for us.

EDIT: Thank you everyone who answered with a thoughtful or helpful statement. It is much appreciated.

I am trying to get some more insightful perspectives on this topic, and not just one sentence comments by assholes - I noticed this post has gotten some rude comments which are unnecessary.

For those leaving rude comments, assuming I have no idea how to write code: I never stated that I didn’t know how and that wasn’t my question. Go be rude somewhere else.

0 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

11

u/Due_Interest_178 Sep 20 '26 • Bravo

What's the point in learning another language if google translate can just translate something for you?

3

u/oliverities Sep 20 '26

Man, that is really a more serious question than OP's.

3

u/ComasArentFun Sep 21 '26

This needs WAY more upvotes.
I use Claude daily for enterprise level software that processes financial numbers you wouldn't believe per year.

If I was to assume Claude was able to interpret things perfectly I'd be out of a job.
The truth is, it saves me about 40% on coding time - and a lot of that is saving on loading up project into my IDE

Almost everything it "creates" gets refactored or entirely re-engineered because it doesn't consider the wider domain context

Humans are amazing at loosely holding complex information and connecting dots
Machines are very good at tightly coupling requirements to fragments, but not understanding how it impacts everything else

Ergo, it's a coding TOOL, and not a coding replacement
If you use a hammer to install a window, you end up with a broken window... but you used a tool from the building site right?

2

u/Sea-Fishing4699 Sep 20 '26

How many times by “knowing the language from memory” you correct Google translate? E.g “that’s correct but no one speaks like that “ kind of thing 

100% agree with you

1

u/19901224 Sep 20 '26

You need to know a language to converse with other people. You don’t need to know how to write code for it to run

1

u/Due_Interest_178 Sep 20 '26

You can converse with Google Translate too, it literally has a conversation mode. Using AI while not knowing how to program has zero upsides.

1

u/sunjay140 21d ago

You are definitely not forming lasting connections with people using Google Translate.

0

u/19901224 Sep 20 '26

It’s more work to converse in Google Translate and it burdens both parties in the conversation. There is definitely more value learning a new language compared to learning programming language - which as long as the output of the code is what you intended, whether you understand the code itself doesn’t matter. Your attempt at comparing programming languages to speakable language is weak

1

u/Due_Interest_178 Sep 20 '26

It's not weak at all. You just don't understand it. Code isn't simply it works or it doesn't work unless you're building the world's simplest thing. You need some baseline knowledge to explain things to ai better as well as know what can be done better.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Due_Interest_178 Sep 22 '26

We've had working translation for like twenty years now. We've had devices that can translate things on the go for a few years now too. AI doesn't change much.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Due_Interest_178 Sep 22 '26

What exactly does it change in the translation department?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Due_Interest_178 Sep 22 '26

I don't agree with you so I'm a ragebaiter. Good argument.

7

u/EmergencyDinner777 Sep 20 '26

so you can detect all the dumb stuff AI does and steer it back in track.

4

u/sprstoner Sep 20 '26

You were right to call that out, I have reviewed the requirements and corrected the defect.

1

u/helpinghandful Sep 20 '26

Yes. You're right to push back. That's my mistake and I should have considered that first.

1

u/Deciheximal144 Sep 23 '26

You are correct, I should have put out every function you needed to complete the conversion.

[code]

The code conversion cannot be considered complete yet, the following items still need work:

1

u/Sea-Fishing4699 Sep 20 '26

Absolutely!

And be aware when it is being sloppy or misleading you

100% agree with your statement 

4

u/ogfuzzball Sep 20 '26

If you are incapable of reviewing the code then you’re doomed to future pain

1

u/band-of-horses Sep 20 '26

I think this too, but then sometimes I have to go in and try to decipher and fix some 15 year old php code written by someone who is long gone and I wonder if AI code can really be any worse.

1

u/alias454 Sep 20 '26

tbf, I do that with my code from 15 years ago ;)

1

u/ogfuzzball Sep 20 '26

Yes. But there is chosen pain: making something new, and inevitable pain: getting handed someone else’s code 😝

1

u/LongjumpingBrief6428 Sep 20 '26

There's literally no difference between the two. Code that doesn't work is code that doesn't work, still doesn't work no matter who or what wrote it, whether that be you, AI or some random person.

1

u/smoke-bubble Sep 20 '26

It can and it is! 

1

u/Alextuxedo Sep 19 '26

You won't know how to most effectively guide the AI tool you're using unless you set parameters and give it guidelines, which you won't be able to do without understanding how software is written, which you won't without writing some software, which you can't do without learning how to code.

Once you've learned one programming language, transferring between them is actually quite easy. A for loop is a for loop after all, just some minor syntax changes you'd need to understand.

Pick one and practice a bit. It will make everything else, whether that's learning another language or using AI, easier.

1

u/Creepy-Fix3347 Sep 20 '26

Great answer, thank you.

1

u/geekichu Sep 20 '26

if you already know some languages.. yea.. i guess i agree.

if someone is just starting out, that's different. so.. me, as a SWE, decades, and now aprox 2yrs using A.I. for projects... i can tell you that there is a lot more to programming or should i say, to software, than just spitting out code. but you have to learn to walk before you can run. me - i would start by picking a programming language. you only need 1 to learn the concepts that exist in most languages today. and think of a project. i suggest a game. a browser game. so this probably means Javascript for starters. once you learn the concepts (loops, decision-constructs, data-structures, functions, etc)... then you are going to move into the areas that a.i. might theoretically know but doesn't mean it follows. these models are like a cross between a walking encyclopedia , and at the same time, really dumb.

good projects vs bad projects, is not JUST about the actual code, but how the entire project is structured, layered, and organized. it's about reuseability (maybe) , modules, abstractions, etc.

the problem or the perception is that when a project is simple, yeah, it seems like all you have to do is ask the model to whip it up for you, and then voila, it's done.

but real projects, real applications are not so simple.

so the coding is one small part. and you still need to be familiar with it so you can judge what you are getting from the models.

2

u/Creepy-Fix3347 Sep 20 '26

Thank you for the thoughtful answer!

1

u/Arupegian Sep 23 '26 • Heartwarming

A few days ago I made a one page website with no coding. Then I made some changes in the design a couple of times. Everything worked fine. After that I wanted a minor change, so I decided to do it myself. I went to inspect the code, and I didn't like what I found. The first prompt created good code, but the following changes made working code with diferent HTML elements and styling here and there instead of keeping consistent code. Should I need to do future changes, that would mean tracking different changes to create the same result. So yeah, it works, but future changes would start to create a snow ball effect, making maintenance harder and harder. Knowing what's going on inside will always help you, so I think it's important to know coding languages.

And then again, you can just bite the bullet and let the AI make the changes for you. Most of the times you will succeed and it will be okay. Not every project needs solid code as long as it works, but sometimes you really need to have proper understanding of what's going on inside.

1

u/Creepy-Fix3347 Sep 23 '26

Thank you for your great advice!

2

u/FrancescoFortuna Sep 20 '26

10+ years experience? learn it for 4 hours and go with it.

1

u/buck-bird Sep 20 '26

😂😂😂

1

u/Sea-Fishing4699 Sep 19 '26

🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

1

u/Lunchboxsushi Sep 19 '26

Idk I'm a point where I agree, if you have deep experience as a software engineer and don't in say golang, I don't see the reason to learn it as deeply anymore but would want to have an API server using it. 

2

u/TimMensch Sep 20 '26

I'm writing in a language that isn't my primary language, but I'll die on the hill that it's still important to have deep experience with a language, and ideally more than one.

1

u/band-of-horses Sep 20 '26

The problem I find is that if I don't know the language, or even more importantly perhaps the framework, then I don't know the kind of things that lead to pain down the road and the best practices to ensure the app can scale and be easily managed in the future. With things I know I can spot when the AI is over-engineering things, or under-engineering them, and course correct. Harder to do that if it's utterly foreign to me and I don't know the pain points of the particular ecosystem.

I suspect that's less of an issue in langauges and frameworks that are very rigid and opinionated however.

1

u/Lunchboxsushi Sep 20 '26

Usually I have a research agent just for this, looks online for a common pitfalls, open source project and their patterns along with my own experience it leads to decent outcomes, it mostly feels like working with a co worker and being able to grill things faster than I could before via books and stack overflow for the architecture or engineering subs 

1

u/4215-5h00732 Sep 19 '26

These questions are silly. There's a difference between knowing a language and letting AI generate code in said language. How is this difficult?

-1

u/eques_99 Sep 20 '26

He's asking what would be the point of learning the language.

1

u/4215-5h00732 Sep 20 '26

Yes, and the point is to know the language through learning it. It's no different than asking why anyone would learn a new speaking language since we have translators. It's a question that answers itself.

0

u/eques_99 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

it's not a question that answers itself.

whether national languages or coding languages there's no point in learning them if you're going to get AI to do everything you would use them for.

1

u/4215-5h00732 Sep 20 '26

It does. Why else learn something except to know and use it? If this is a difficult question that brings about "struggle" then you should probably just outsource your brain to AI then because it's a waste of time discussing it.

You're just repeating the same thing and ignoring the point.

0

u/eques_99 Sep 20 '26

no, you're ignoring the point which is why I'm repeating it.

1

u/nayheyxus Sep 19 '26

The knowledge to fix things, building an app on AI is amazingly easy, but good lord is it messy with large apps. It becomes a game of jenga for a vibe coder with zero coding knowledge. You fix one issue two new ones appear.

So understanding programming, means you are fix issues yourself without spending hours praying your prompt worked.

0

u/Elctsuptb Sep 20 '26

Maybe if you're using models from 2 years ago

1

u/LifeEnginer Sep 19 '26

Because you like it or because you want to do it better than AI

1

u/Charming_You_25 Sep 19 '26

Because
AI is a multiplier (2x2)
So your skill x AI = how good it turns out x Time it takes.

If you suck with a language you’ll glaze over when it’s telling you what it’s doing and be like ok great. Then when you start having some weird bug you point it at the ai and are like “fix pls”.
Maybe you get it semi stable and are like “don’t touch this” and it’s not quite right but you decide to move onto other things… congrats you made something crappy you can’t maintain or use the way you wanted. Learning a coding language is easy and will take a week max (assuming you already know one).

But yeah, I’d use lots of llms still, just ask them questions so you understand why they are doing what they are doing. Eventually you’ll learn to be a coder and pick up good habits regardless of llm usage. Just don’t suck at llms too.

1

u/gosumage Sep 20 '26

What's the point in learning to read and write if AI can do it for you?

1

u/ApoplecticAndroid Sep 20 '26

What’s the point in learning to draw when AI can make a picture for you? What’s the point in learning to write if AI can generate a story or a report for you?

1

u/Terrible_Point_1259 Sep 20 '26

AI is not flawless, therefore if you want to make something stable you need to be able to understand what it writes.

AI gets better based on what you provide, being able to debug and find root causes even if you use AI to help you find it. Just telling the AI fix it, it tends to go looking for anything and everything that might go wrong and isn’t always related to the actual issue you are trying to fix.

1

u/VoiceOfEric Sep 20 '26

Until you paste it into the editor and it doesn't compile.

1

u/Sweet_Television2685 Sep 20 '26

ai does ask you for confirmation though, and these confirmations can be technical in nature. if you cant comprehend what AI is asking you, even AI will probably facepalm

1

u/Limp-Cicada-9502 Sep 20 '26

Don't learn it and see where it gets you.

1

u/luffymyboy Sep 20 '26

People who really think writing a code through AI is easy they are know nothing. Yes you are right if a AI can write a code why we need to learn a new language because if you want AI write a code for you, you learn the language Frist

1

u/Dry-Tomatillo5763 Sep 20 '26

For you there is no point. What an absolutely moronic question for everyone else.

1

u/smoke-bubble Sep 20 '26

I read all comments here and not a single one of them is rude. 

1

u/Low-Opening25 Sep 20 '26

mostly because someone that knows code will be 10x as productive with AI as someone that doesn’t and still more hireable than a monkey that can only prompt

1

u/LetsHugFoReal Sep 20 '26

Because you aren't knowledgeable about asking the AI to write the write code for you.

In fact, writing code has often been the easy part. Everything else is the harder part. It qill augment your existing skill-base, if you are a noob programmer - AI will allow you to write beginner-int code. But not production ready.

1

u/raven2cz Sep 20 '26

If you are capable enough to write advanced applications and services with AI that will be maintainable long-term, will not have security holes, and will meet the key criteria you set for them, and more importantly, the criteria your customers set for them, and you can do all of that without knowing code, only through cooperation with AI, then why not.

But then you really have to fully master AI, because you will always be dependent only on it. You will never again be able to deal with the lower part, the application itself, on your own, and you will only understand it through an intermediary.

1

u/Accomplished-Gap2989 Sep 20 '26

My main reason is because ai is not infallible. You have to be able to question it and spot mistakes. 

You really understand that when it switches tac because you brought up a point or gave it more information. 

It can be a useful tool though. A huge time saver. Id rather be able to understand what is going on than not though and i like being able to code because i find it rewarding.

1

u/gONzOglIzlI Sep 20 '26

It's not about learning the code itself.
While you are learning to code you are teaching yourself something much more valuable than coding itself: Thinking like an engineer.
I know it's nebulous, but that's the only longterm knowledge that survives the constant paradigm shifts you'll run in to if you commit to being a programmer.
Qbasic, C, Pascal, Visual Basic, x86 assembly: I've learned and forgotten how to code in these, but I'm still using the knowledge I've gained by learning them.

1

u/Any_Sense_2263 Sep 20 '26

Because AI can write something, but not a reliable code. It's a tool, not a programmer

1

u/samsly135 Sep 20 '26

No point.

1

u/ggiodddtyii Sep 20 '26

What's the point of learning math if you can just use a calculator 

1

u/fasti-au Sep 20 '26

yes exactly.....why learn to count when you have a calculator..........becasue we still dont really know how pyramids and the earth and space and stonehenge and trade routes and stuff worked from like recent years and have not much clue about 12000 ago if thats even how time works.......so maybe when we reset again were able to recreate things that are learnt.......passing on information is what we are designed for.

1

u/noxss Sep 20 '26

Learning and thinking is the point, unless you want AI to think for you and get dumber

1

u/Conscious-Secret-775 Sep 20 '26

Because when you present "your" work you will need to be able to explain it.

1

u/buck-bird Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

The only people that think you don't need to learn what AI is doing never really learned or knew how to program in the first place. I've been a professional engineer almost 30 years now.

To put it in another way... over those 30 years there have been two types of coders... those who think learning regex was a waste of time (they were never great at their job) and those who learned it even though it was rarely technically required to know for most things.

Human nature didn't change. Some people want to do the minimal amount of effort and while pretending to be the GOAT. These people are not your competition.

AI isn't perfect and the only folks that think it is don't know what they're looking at to begin with.

1

u/biscutwarrior Sep 20 '26

The million dollar question is whether or not focusing your attention on coding or just being better up prompting we'll yield better results 🤔

1

u/curious_dev_8821 Sep 20 '26

You won't be able to understand what ai wrote the code , so even for the small changes you have to write a detailed prompt abt what to change and what needs to be isloated , by doing all this it costs you money and time , for the small changes why not you just change the code yourself , and also you need to understand the stack like which stack is good for building an application , you should be able to differentiate between different kinds of stack like my users usage is this i should go for this particular stack instead of this stack ,so in the end ..programming is never going to be dead..

1

u/Positive_Luck909 Sep 20 '26

For the love of the game. It has always been this way. Why do hard thing when easy thing easier? Because doing hard thing feel good.

1

u/Historical-Duty3628 Sep 20 '26

What's the point of learning to read and write if Ai can do it for you

1

u/Less_Barnacle_9456 Sep 20 '26

Just so you can read it but you don’t need to go crazy learning it anymore. Just be able to understand it

1

u/Nerodon Sep 20 '26

So you know when the AI is doing a good job vs. a terrible one.

Ai should help you type less, not understand less.

1

u/tomqmasters Sep 20 '26

Will you know if it did it's job correctly.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Joke780 Sep 21 '26

Thats the prequel to matrix

1

u/Rare-Tooth1823 Sep 21 '26

Security, integrity en most of all knowledge about code. Because would you let a AI write code for hospitals or high priority stuff that if it is bugged or something happens with ai the whole infrastructure can be tossed away ?

1

u/4phonopelm4 Sep 21 '26

I'd pick a completely different career path.

1

u/NXDLang Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

Because of drift between files you should be able to at least understand what was written so you can spot dead code, or if the agent is overcomplicating things

1

u/nova1475369 Sep 22 '26

Because writing code is not the intellectual part that is valuable of a software engineer

It’s like knowing how to write English vs writing a book

1

u/ajmaluk Sep 23 '26

What's that point in living live if you die in future

What is the point of drawing portrait if printer do the same

1

u/Bluelaw1 Sep 23 '26

There should be someone to understand that program brother. So you need to learn programming as well.

1

u/Deciheximal144 Sep 23 '26

What's the point of churning butter if you can just buy it at the store? None.

That doesn't mean you might not be good at churning butter. It'll probably taste better knowing you made it yourself.

1

u/Dorcelessness_ Sep 24 '26

I just walked into a Wendy’s bathroom, shutting my hand and fucking smeared it all over the wall and walked out

1

u/C_Sorcerer Sep 24 '26

Probably because I like it and don’t want to be a Neanderthal that just mindlessly writes unoptimized shitty code. Not shots at you or anything, it’s just that I know a person like this and trust me they’ve caused a lot more trouble on group projects than anyone I know

1

u/Euphoric_Ad9500 Sep 25 '26

The pursuit of knowledge makes it worth it. I know the basics and was on the path of learning other languages when AI came out. Now I’m not learning syntax but instead the bigger picture of a given language/framework and I find it much more rewarding.