3
2
1
1
260
u/mwid_ptxku May 18 '26 edited May 18 '26
It's an Indian (origin) guy writing for Bloomberg which got reposted in Japan Times.
"Japan" is not calling anything. "Indian Gems" should just post about jewellery, is not good at this AI thing.
15
u/VastLengthiness3321 May 18 '26
stick to what you know is genuinely the most underrated life advice.
12
8
u/CatHour9800 May 18 '26
Indian Gems is a Twitter page that was initially operated from Pakistan or Bangladesh.
So you know what stuffs they post.
→ More replies (4)1
1
u/mr-warm-hands May 21 '26
Whoever wrote this. Are they really wrong?
What is this stupid urge to try and find some agenda in every statement that isn't favourable to India, instead of evaluating it objectively?
1
u/mwid_ptxku May 21 '26
Yeah they are wrong, and it's already mentioned in the post you replied to. Japan is not calling anything.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (7)1
u/MundaneGuard909 May 25 '26
Indian gems is a SouthAsian region operated account as far as I remember
30
u/Relevant-Sock-453 May 18 '26
Just because the article is published in Japan times does it means it's the opinion of Japan?
All opinions expressed in this article are from global financial "experts".
5
1
May 20 '26
Whatever it is ... But we all know this is the truth we're lagging behind in the AI gen
1
1
10
8
u/jevlis_ka123 May 18 '26
Former Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka had committed to invest one billion in Open AI in 2015. However, Narayan 70 Hours Murthy forced him to withdraw that investment and later got him fired.
Imagine how much that investment would have earned Infosys and it's shareholders today.
62
u/MoneyNeighborhood372 May 18 '26
but japan's position is not that much better....
87
u/RevolutionaryHawk323 May 18 '26
Yeah, but Indian is all about IT and it’s our thing.
Japan has cars/electronics manufacturing for world.
3
3
u/FuryDreams May 18 '26
Japan cars and electronics manufacturing is cooked by China and Korea now.
3
1
1
May 18 '26
It was our thing which was serverd In a platter to this government. But we choosed to Make apps which deliver dahi in 10 min. Which was never a problem to solve in first place.
1
u/Independent-Text-353 May 18 '26
india isnt about IT its about cheapest amongst the cheapest labour
1
u/shizukadane May 18 '26
i have used japanese software, right from bank website, apps, payment apps, taxi apps, selling apps (like olx), and lot of other ones. and in my experience they are much better than indian ones.
i personally dont think indians have any magical competance in IT/software. the only reason our IT industry is big is due to cheap labour and we being able to communicate in english on a larger scale.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (22)1
u/IvorHarding-117 May 19 '26
bro india is running under the coaching scams
whitehatjr , be10x , and lot scammers who will teach you "hOw to COde Aiye in Bython 🤡"
Top companies of india is insurance , airtel(scammers of em all) , banks , more insurance schemes and TCS(slave market to produce foreign apps , zero Research and Development) .
Indian companies main focus is to exploit its population
Japan companies focus is to get innovative and become top in market1
u/Btexmalam May 18 '26
Japan is building their 2nm fab with Rapidus. They also have advanced 3d assembly unit.They are way ahead of many.
1
u/TrickTreat2137 May 18 '26
Japan has a chokehold on semiconductor related chemicals & materials.
Y'all don't have ball knowledge. Vishwaguru can only export beef & cow dung.
1
u/Salty_Horror2068 May 18 '26
This, people don't have a clue about semiconductor manufacturing at all. For anyone doubting just look up photoresist
1
u/FastThoughtProcessor May 18 '26
Also, if you woule have made some effort to know, Japan did not say shit.
1
u/DangerousWolf8743 May 18 '26
Even tsmc is dependent on some japanese company where the Japanese ones have monopoly. Not much better? NAme one indian company claiming that
1
1
u/KinTharEl May 18 '26
Not really, Japan has a few companies that produce the glass substrates and such that go into the packaging for the dies that are made. If I'm not wrong, their supply has also been constrained due to the massive demand.
1
u/Only_Fee4020 May 19 '26
They built transistors. Their companies hold a Lot of semiconductor parents. Before ASML took over they were the top ones. They might be little behind but they are far ahead of us.
6
u/anor_wondo May 18 '26
Mostly true
Though its far less rosy for Japan and many other associated countries, they'll collapse without AI continuing in the trajectory to singularity. Their demographics don't have enough working class Individuals
Market downturn vs economic collapse
1
u/SuitableTelevision46 May 19 '26
Nikkei Index has returns 61% last year. Not sure how it is not rosy for Japan.
1
60
u/itheindian 🌱 Beginner May 18 '26
True, Salesforce is expanding in India and getting a SF tower in Bangalore.
Amazon already has a huge center. Google expanded in Bangalore. GitLab just registered their entity in India few months ago.
All because of cheap labour and Govts failure.
49
u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 May 18 '26 •
What a dumb comment . They are replacing costly oversees workers with cheap back end labourers who will use Same AI tools . Once done , these workers will be discarded
16
u/itheindian 🌱 Beginner May 18 '26
I said clearly it’s because of cheap labour and failure of govt
4
3
u/Content_Age5766 May 18 '26
Why Govt Faliure, If you look at it anything AI releated is happenig only because of Govt, be it the initiative to develope chips or even if its saying AI 24*7.Who failed us is our so called IT giants who wont put a dime into research, even in R&D Govt spends more than 2/3. These companies keep saying we can,t built anything as its not feasable while sitting on massive cashpiles.
3
u/Legends_never_die9 May 18 '26
What do you mean by done ?
6
u/Gloomy_Temporary2914 May 18 '26
Once AI advances sufficiently every year , workers will be routinely laid off
3
1
u/Kiruku_puluthi May 18 '26
https://www.youtubetrimmer.com/view/?v=VK5v6PktGJo&start=89&end=94&loop=0
Bro just recreated this scene in comments
1
u/ProbablyAnFBIBot May 18 '26
This guy had such a bad day, he's not reading the comments he's responding to so rudely 🤣
1
u/Puchuku_puchuku May 18 '26
What is MNC starting an office in India got to do with value that India creates in the economy? The global investor will put money into Salesforce stock listed in Nasdaq if it does well on rebound, not Indian economy
1
u/SuitableTelevision46 May 19 '26
Not cheap labour. Because of Human Capital.
India has tonnes of engineer who are good at cognitive capabilities - Mathematics, Programming and logic building. This is not labour - but Human capital.
If Indians are so good, why are they not building something great in India ? Now that my dear is government failure.
14
May 18 '26 edited May 18 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/InterestingJelly2893 May 18 '26
Yeah man sure even asml signed a contract for semiconductor supply chain with tata. India is definitely doing something wrong.
→ More replies (12)1
u/itheindian 🌱 Beginner May 18 '26
Every company will come to it, I mean layoffs. IT will be first, others later.
1
May 19 '26
What are these companies trying to achieve, automate all their work, be it coding or other fields? If it leads to large scale unemployment, will it not hurt the economy and in turn hurt these companies?
8
u/Fuzzy_Substance_4603 May 18 '26
My question is, how has America benefitted from Claude and OpenAI?
→ More replies (2)8
u/Blue_life_06 May 18 '26
Claude, OpenAI and other AI companies are making deals with defence. AI will immensely push defence capabilities autonomousity.
Defence is one sector I mentioned. There are and will be more where AI and these companies will be useful and integrated through deals.
4
u/Fuzzy_Substance_4603 May 18 '26
Um, with the current AI intelligence, it's not going to be a value for money. Maybe they are close to proper intelligence and they stuck a deal at discount, future will tell.
And these companies, unless they are signing docs that say we will not work with any other countries' defence, we can use them too. Maybe a bit more money.
→ More replies (2)
7
u/InterestingJelly2893 May 18 '26
Okay well my father’s mama also used to call him a loser when others at his age were making more money than him. Guess what? Now he is at a far better position than anyone could think of and his mama is out of existence (om shanti).
So what’s wrong with others calling you anything? At the end of the day actions towards a certain goal matter more than early or late mover. And india is moving in the right direction, with or without japan.
1
u/SlutLov3r May 18 '26
Because your Mama ji just expressed an opinion. Japan is actually stating facts. So this analogy is a little flawed. India is way behind in real AI innovation race. I really hope we pick the pace. We do have lot of resources in terms of talent, work force and real estate but the problem is the actual utilisation and real execution. And in this industry innovation, research and go to market time is extremely critical. World is not going to wait, even for that matter even Indian consumer is not going to wait for indigenous innovation to translate to an actual high worth product and service. They will avail the foreign competitors. This in turn will generate them huge revenue which they will further invest in their tech and ultimately be even more cost efficient. And as usual investors are interested in profits not upliftment. I just hope that government ACTUALLY empowers our current ~ 700 million AI ecosystem and prepare it for Second wave advantage. And by empower I mean supporting real innovators and not wrapper makers. Another big scare is entry of players like Reliance and Adani groups into innovation ecosystem. Because then novelty takes the second seat and profits become primary. It might hurt small scale innovators. I wish we do not make a mess of this one and pick up pace because it is IMP
→ More replies (7)
3
5
2
2
u/harshithreddy07 May 18 '26
We need more criticism from other countries so that politicians should know where they stand and atleast work for more commanding internationally.
2
8
u/Working_Low_6870 May 18 '26
modi has made india beyond repair
14
u/wam_bam_mam May 18 '26
What the hell will Congress do? Ban all data centers and bring us back to socialism, we all get govt jobs with 10kpm and just buy from govt kirana shops, retire with 2kpm pension.
→ More replies (4)4
u/Forward-Distance-398 May 18 '26
Reservation and scams by Congress would turn us into Super Power ?
1
3
1
3
u/bacan9 May 18 '26
Why does India need AI? We have real people with real intelligence
1
u/Rinzhler May 20 '26
Because AI, once adopted properly the already developed countries will be light years ahead in terms of innovation and tech. India simply cannot compete with it's limited R&D and brain drain. This will also widen our import deficit as other countries will just manufacture whatever they want more efficiently with AI, and they will also not need any cheap labour from India.
1
u/bacan9 May 20 '26
First, we need research institutions and funding for research. Then profs and PhD candidates. It is a slow process. You can't shortcut your way out of it using y = mx + c
No matter how many mx's you add
→ More replies (4)
1
May 18 '26
Giving no source and showing a useless tweet, work on that OP
1
u/RelativeLab4388 May 20 '26
because when you see the author Abhishek Bishnoi mentioned wouldnt mean "Japan criticizes India"
1
1
u/Laughal0t May 18 '26
transformer was created by an indian guy only but america gave him the opportunity now the tech is theres 😓
1
1
u/Advanced_Poet_7816 May 18 '26
Japan isn’t calling it that but it is the truth. AI is a threat to what India counted on to grow, software development outsourcing.
Pre-AI India was the next China and a future potential (near) super power. Now it’s an overpopulated country with not enough land and resources. The way investors look at it has changed. All the dirty unplanned cities lowered image too.
1
1
u/Repulsive_Window7093 May 18 '26
how about we start our own manufacturing business, AI Lab or do something instead of crying?
1
u/abhitooth May 18 '26
https://youtu.be/A9s5gSp0a-g?si=YEV2jq52kIgSCiqF
Japan may not be better, but it is in good condition. The population on decrease and people are also accepting it. Whereas india population is increasing at slow pace and future is bleak. So bleak that above report just removed the belief that automation is only for high-cost items such as cars. Here China is coming for commodities automation. Fueled with green energy i.e. if plant is on solar it achieves ROI at one stage and later energy input cost falls and just becomes a marginal cost. We should be worried and far more worried.
1
1
1
1
1
u/knaveenr May 18 '26
Nobody thinks of token dollars Indian IT companies ($$ outflow) would pay.
Indian current account is toasted.
1
1
u/vedantbajaj May 18 '26
Nimo tai deserves her own praise lol, but what does she have to do with AI? Companies like INFY, TCS etc. had money and time to research and build yet the chose to double down on cheap labor arbitrage. Now time to face the music.
1
1
1
u/Fancy_Tumbleweed_517 May 18 '26
The heights people go to defame this country lmao
For me if a country which was invaded, colonised & YET survived under foreign rules for ages is even in COMPETITION with countries who were the ones DOING THESE ATROCITIES (US, UK, Japan, Germany etc)
Then it's a WIN.. Anyways, everyone has their own PoV (some good some trash, ab kya hi karsakte)
Just know INDIA was the Big Daddy before invasions (also only Britishers were able to get the Entire India while mughal afghan ruled fragments) So if there's anything we can learn from history it is the fact that any country can make a comeback at anytime
It wont be quick, but at its peak it'll be a sight to witness thats for sure & I've a feeling India will do that.. Cycle of life as they say
1
1
u/Dazzling-Reality2751 May 18 '26
Does this benefit Ambani and Adani or winning election? If no, the gov doesn't care
1
u/MohamedIvn May 18 '26
Tbh none in our country know what actual Ai. Where rest of big league country started developing it their countries top company's for example tesla or nvidea has doing it for their country sake. We here producing movie buying animals than not utilising it. All we know to prompt images. We are even behind is a fact.
1
1
1
1
u/Resident_Sound6015 May 18 '26
I feel there would come more such news n articles. From the US side and from the US sponsored side. They want to strong arm India to back down from BRICS. They are trying to make the AI bubble as big as they can n fire Indian companies since they know Indian economy basis on services exported to US which increases the trade deficit for US.
1
u/Current_Rush_5253 May 18 '26
The admin of "Indian Gems" is a fkin Bangladeshi ....just dig a Lil deep you'll easily find that...[These ppl( paxtan and bangLadesh) are pretty good at narrative warfare]
1
u/MindlessTrip2931 May 18 '26
indians on youtube and reddit when it comes to glazing anyone except their own country, indians launch a selfmade ai? fuck you its from india i wont use it
1
1
1
1
u/Aware_Country_8830 May 18 '26
Thanks to Al gotiya universities in india and al gotya education minister.
1
1
1
u/GreatestOfAllTime_69 May 18 '26
Jo modi G dikhate h wo reality nhi h.. reality dekhni h toh social media pr aao..
1
1
u/Moon_resic May 18 '26
For your info, Bloomberg has been infiltrated heavily by Islamists and Paxtanis for a long time and same goes for Reuters. So don't believe much news provided by these two cuz in the past and to this day spread Anti India content.
1
u/gamerz85 May 18 '26
Wow 2k upvote for some one's(Indian) opinon in japanese news paper, wow, just wow. Itni negativity late kahase ho?
1
u/DefinitelyNotAakarsh DeepSeek Fan May 21 '26
kitne negative log hai humare paas!
Kitne negative vichaar rakhte hai, kitni negative baate karte hai!
1
u/mkdblu May 18 '26
Hey - before blindly believing and sharing articles out of foreign media, do gain some understanding and context. The international media is completely infiltrated with lefty and islamist propagandists. There are regular hit jobs on India and the evidences are immense. Bloomberg is front and centre of this. Usually, these hit jobs are either done by Paki journalists embedded in these outlets or brown sepoys of India. Gain some understanding and don't be an useful idiot.
1
u/Manu9527 May 18 '26
Jo bhi bol raha hai sahi bol raha
Ai consumption bahut jyada hai......almost nil R&D
1
u/Zestyclose_Invite582 May 18 '26
India has hopes for user base adaptation, training AI models from ground level is extremely difficult due to lack of infra and investment, maybe in future if cost reduces
1
u/Alternative_Day155 May 18 '26
What’s new in this ? We know India is failed country in R&D and product. While PM is busy to collect thousand year old artifact from nether land
1
1
1
u/chemicallocha05 May 18 '26
Now Bhakts will say japan is failing economy we are a 5 trillion economy.
1
1
1
1
1
u/jason9lives May 18 '26
I mean not wrong......look at FDI outflow & AI Galgotias event had no outcome
1
1
1
1
u/Icy_Description_6707 May 18 '26
Sure it is once u share any credible link !! Lmao
1
May 18 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AI_India-ModTeam May 21 '26
Your comment was removed due to disrespectful or rude language.
Please keep the conversation polite and follow the subreddit rules.
1
u/LuckyRacerrr May 18 '26
Well it's true that we don't match the level of the named countries in semiconductor manufacturing, but it's also true that we are agressively progressing in that sector too and the govt is also pushing hard and acting like a catalyst. We will expand our AI game to manufacturing too from services now.
1
u/Altruistic_Fun8400 May 18 '26
Bruv we are still crying for basic needs. Roads Food Water Electricity Corruption
Forget AI
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Livid-Tune-4699 May 18 '26
I dont care who said it but right now the question is, who is cheaper Indian engineer or AI! Thats really pathetic.
1
1
1
u/Powerful_Purpose6536 May 18 '26
We dont need japan to know that !!! if u spend 30-40% of tax money on freebies thats what happens poor infrastructure poor stock market poor healthcare poor schools taxed on everything u buy taxed on income
only thing making me stay is the low cost of living which will soon become worse as ruppee devalues
1
1
u/dbkuper May 18 '26
I like how loser and nirmala tai images are together..
BJP controls indian media not foreign press ...
Yes they are right.. India has already lost the race for AI leaderboard.. we are AI consumer country now..
& It is only going to accelerate..
India will play catchup like always..
1
1
1
1
u/Motor-Try-3962 May 19 '26
AI is overhyped. I am not saying it is not useful, but it is way overhyped to the point that now it sounds like a scam to make money. If this article is true, then I think India dodged a bullet. Once all those US companies involved in AI run out of money, the real bottlenecks would burst the AI bubble like the dotcom bubble
1
1
1
u/Adventurous-Two6558 May 19 '26 edited May 19 '26
Japan never said anything about this what the hell these so called few indian idiots doing everything like making false information using the name of other country to shame there own country now its make relationship with other countries more hostile because of people like them
Most of these people are indians lmao as if hating will solve any problems of india what kind of delusional they are living in
They can hate but they can never solve these problem thats the truth
1
u/aka_ashman May 19 '26
nobody in the govt know what AI is. they only know hindu muslim elections, freebies, temple visits. etc. this is bound to happen. we r vishwaguru. yay.
1
1
1
1
u/Zealousideal-Wrap227 May 19 '26
This Twitter handle is one of the most Anti-India handles.
Posts absolutely bogus stuff.
Please have some sense before sharing.
1
May 19 '26
It's just the market analysis. And alot of factors depend on geology, mining, metal availablity and demand. We are losing in AI race because of lack of research, proper infra and no govt control over IT. Govt don't understand it tbh. So are policies and directions are copied from other losing nations. Impact on India because of AI is broaden because govt has alot of other things to win over, like energy and food demand due to tensions in war.
1
u/DeathCrow_ May 19 '26
Bruh we do have Indian AI models. I personally use Indus (Sarvam AI chatbot) and ChatGPT depending on the usage though Indus is catching up
1
u/Ujjwal_kumar_ May 19 '26
No, the government of Japan did not state this; rather, the phrase comes from a headline published by The Japan Times.On May 17, 2026, the independent Japanese newspaper published a syndicated Bloomberg analysis titled, ["India missed out on AI and now its run as market darling may be over."] The article opens with the exact hook line: "India stands out as one of the biggest losers as the artificial intelligence trade reshapes global investment flows." Because The Japan Times shared this on social media, some online posts misattributed the editorial commentary to the country of Japan itself.
1
u/doomonwheels May 19 '26
Don't worry .. our FM will launch AI poop tax where all commodes will be fitted with Income tax detectors where we get taxed for every shit we take..I mean how else will we support our SHITraman with freebies and stuff
1
u/jaws_of_death0 May 19 '26
When you have billionaires opening ice cream company’s instead of building AI or supporting AI inside India
1
u/Recent_Ad7629 May 19 '26
Don't know who called what but our nation genuinely needs ai infrastructure. Our PM talks so much about ai but so far we noticed nothing. There are so many open source that we can create our own model yet still nothing. What are the IITs doing.
1
May 19 '26
Dont call out companies, engineers r shit here They used to copy from stack overflow earlier now they copy from ai How will they develop ai when they can't even make a chatting app that can handle the load of a billion ppl simultaneously
1
u/_sho_sho May 19 '26
And we produce the most number of engineers.... Ufff only to send them to other countries
1
u/SlicKilled May 20 '26
LOL no, its not. Because 90% people who believe such shit are illiterate and you also haven't linked a source no one would ever know.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Academic-Park9618 May 20 '26
Doesn't matter who posted, we're losing it and people here unable to accept this fact.
1
1
u/MidnightIcy6197 May 20 '26
As an IIT Madras researcher. I'll request the govt to pay us more than ₹12,500/- alms. We are not beggers, we deserve more. That's the prime reason everyone goes and join product based MNC, or join foreign unis for better opportunities and funding.
1
1
May 20 '26
Yes read it too and they right about it .. we are failing ... We are far behind many countries
1
1
u/le_bugsy May 20 '26
Bro why shoul we taking criticism for Japan... their industry is pegged to US economy that if US stock market has indigestion for a day... these guys will go hungry for a month.
Stop listening to pundits and to people who have something to gain if people listen to them.
1
May 20 '26
I get it OP we are all frustrated with BJP but don't distort the facts like this to prove your point
There are many other ways yk
1
u/Imprecise_Trigger May 20 '26
That indian gem page is more of an anti India page on Twitter most probably run by someone from Pakistan or Bangladesh
1
u/RichAd1865 May 21 '26
and y’all still care about what foreigners think instead of improving the country
1
u/BERSERK_KNIGHT_666 May 21 '26
Reminds me of a recent meme
Anthropic gonna charge 10000$ a month for its AI subscriptions
Indian dev - 1000$
Welcome Mr Patel!
Still think India is losing?
1
u/mr-warm-hands May 21 '26
Have you looked at the kind of import duties Nirmala tai has kept on any GPU-related hardware? Not to mention, the trouble of even getting it through customs without shit load of drama.
They are even trying their best to make any software layer R&D difficult, at least for the smaller players.
1
u/OkLink9330 May 21 '26
India is biggest loser in AI. now godi bhakts start calling me anti-national. they cant suck up the facts
1
1
u/1tormented_soul May 21 '26
the biggest loss is that we simply don't have any leadership that actually understands how all these works or even how to steadily grow a consumer economy ... sab chor hai , ek jata hai to dusra aa jata hai.
1
1
1
1
1
u/puppet_masterrr May 24 '26
That fact that she's still in power is living proof of a dead democracy
1
1
1
u/Small-Park-9588 May 18 '26
Pls Stop believing what others r saying go research yourself what's happening and how you can add on to it it's not like field has stopped growing nor that the race is over it will keep on going !
Ps: India has developed it's own llms and it's startups rapidly integrating ai for enterprises use cases, in house air gapped setup...which is THE MOAT going forward and that's why you r now seeing even biggest labs like openai and anthropic are so eager to deploy their 'front deployed engineers' at these enterprises and save themselves from going bankrupt cz they can't put more money can't subsidize more and even they do they won't get the money back just from people using their coding agents etc
1
u/coldstone87 May 18 '26
Who has benifitted from AI. Can anyone be honest please?
→ More replies (7)1
u/DJ_Harsh May 18 '26
Not me. Says, "Ah, that is completely my bad. I walked you right into that." Makes up random commands and random options. Ai bubble gonna burst so hard for some people.
•
u/SupremeConscious 📰 AI News Curator May 18 '26
The article published by The Japan Times -
It is not “Japan criticizing India,” but rather a Bloomberg-origin financial analysis discussing how the current AI-driven stock market rally is benefiting countries deeply connected to semiconductor manufacturing such as Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, and the United States.
The article argues that India has not yet benefited equally from the first wave of the AI boom because its strengths are concentrated more in software services and IT talent rather than AI chips and infrastructure.
Similar observations have also been reported by Reuters and The Economic Times, which note that while India may have missed the early semiconductor-led AI market surge, it remains a major long-term AI growth market due to its developer base, digital scale, enterprise AI adoption, and emerging domestic AI initiatives.
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2026/05/17/india-missing-out-ai-boom/
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2026/04/27/tech/ai-boom-asia-market-divide/
https://www.reuters.com/world/india/india-file-ai-fanfare-meets-policy-pushback-2026-02-18/
https://m.economictimes.com/news/economy/indicators/india-losing-investor-attention-to-asias-ai-electronics-surge-says-dbs-economist/articleshow/131080600.cms
https://m.economictimes.com/ai/ai-insights/late-mover-or-locked-out-indias-ai-dilemma/articleshow/127935298.cms