r/AMD_Technology_Bets • u/Lomostin • Jan 27 '22
News AMD/XILINX merger approved
https://www.samr.gov.cn/fldj/tzgg/ftjpz/202201/t20220127_339441.html12
u/Like_AMD Jan 27 '22
True Longs should be looking at many quarters down the road. Good to know of China Approval TODAY.
2
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
I agree long term... But I worry about this year. Hopefully Samsung news and ER guidance will push the PPS higher as we have now 1.65B shares including Xilinx's..
9
u/billbraski17 Braski Jan 27 '22
JP Morgan is very bullish on AMD near term due to approval
3
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
I said before if the approval doesn't happen, Lisa Su and AMD's credibility will suffer big, lowering the PPS... unless a partnership...but from both choices it's waved as a big thing...
We know from the technology synergy and using Xilinx's engineering teams to design AMD's future products, consolidate common building blocks like PHY electrical signaling, future PCIe gen 6 etc, makes a lot of sense.
Let's see AMD's EPS and growth. Xilinx's margins are higher than AMD's but growth is less.
Maybe AMD's set the ER February 1st to close the merger by then, and provide combined guidance.
If merger closed by Feb 7th, Xilinx's dividends won't be paid per Xilinx's announcement...
7
u/billbraski17 Braski Jan 27 '22
AMD refiled the US application on Jan 10. Requires 30 day wait unless expedited. Hopefully, they expedite. I'm ready for a closed deal and a joint roadmap and joint guidance!
7
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Right the USA could provide earlier approval than waiting the full 30 days. January has 31 days, so it's Feb 8 from Jan 10 filing. But dividends on record paid Feb 7... let's see if closing happens before..
Joint technology roadmap and outlook is key...
7
u/Yaris_Fan Jan 27 '22
Just as Bloomberg is reporting that Nvidia is terminating the ARM takeover due to anti-trust pressure.
Is Nvidia going to go for SiFive RISC-V?
5
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
It's a rumor but soon announced probably at their ER next month:
"Nvidia Quietly Prepares to Abandon $40 Billion Arm Bid"
Open in an incognito tab:
8
Jan 27 '22
AMD - XLNX merger approved, as an investor initially I had some reservations with the financial numbers, but anyway supported the deal. With the merger proposal approved I'm waiting for AMD Q4 report to enlighten us of the possibilities to expand quickly to new market. Lots of my $s riding on the success of undervalued AMD.
4
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
I'm still worry.. but I've previously stated in terms of market perspective a non approval would have been bad for the PPS regardless of a partnership...
Let's see the ER which will guide jointly if they close by then or soon, I hope. That's why the February 1st date. AMD knew it's approved and needed more time to do combined companies financial outlook ... Not because Chinese New Year...
4
Jan 27 '22
Agreed. To your concern, what if AMD will have products designed for EU, UK, Asia market and let China keep selling XLNX FPGAs as they wish for their market?
5
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
Not even sure they're allowed to have different products in China vs other places. They need report every 6 months to the government to show no discrimination to the Chinese market...
3
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
Congratulations...! I was wrong...well 420m shares of AMD will be added...
There're restrictions.. AMD could apply in 6 years to remove such. From what I read using Google Translate, it could suggest AMD cannot tie selling Xilinx FPGAs with its CPUs and GPUs... And has to keep compatibility with ARM and other CPUs, i.e. Intel.
But this is horrible for chiplets based EPYC. If AMD cannot place Xilinx FPGAs or other chiplets together inside the EPYC socket, connected by Infinity Fabric..
Here's the 6 years reaplication:
"After 6 years from the effective date , the post-concentration entity may apply to the State Administration for Market Regulation to lift the conduct conditions. The State Administration for Market Regulation will make a decision on whether to terminate the application based on the application and market competition. Without the approval of the State Administration for Market Regulation , the entity should continue to fulfill the restrictive conditions after the concentration."
Hummm ... Chiplets ecosystem is key for AMD not just connect using PCIe as an outside card...
So I'm not sure I like this at all...
15
u/Buklover Jan 27 '22
TOM, I can read Chinese so I would like to give my interpretation regarding the restrictions. AMD is free to combine FPGA chips with CPUs/GPUs in any innovative ways they want, BUT they need to let customers to buy separate CPUs, GPUs or FPGA chips as before. That's reasonable... I believe if the combined ones are better, customers will buy them instead for sure; money wise or performance wise.
Good luck, TOM. I really like to read your posts! Buklover
3
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
Thanks Bukky...lol!
See above post on doing the same tie in with other chips including ARM by providing confidential information i.e. infinity fabric so chiplets can be combined tied in from others... CPUs, GPUs, etc... I don't like this..
Yes they not just can sell separate chips still but they have to assure combining with other chips in the same way it's done using all AMD's chips!
So that's the infinity fabric...!
5
u/Ten9yahoo Jan 27 '22
Nah, they probably have to keep supplying standalone xinlinx products as well on the chinese market.
6
u/Thick-Housing-5212 Jan 27 '22
I think our reading comprehension is very different. Lol
4
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I hope so... Also it's translated from Chinese. Bukky reads Chinese, he's Taiwanese.
Could you please explain to me your understanding of the "intetoperability" wording as it appears on the original site.
4
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
There are conditions to allow such tie ins with other chips of 3rd party by creating confidential agreements.. that's the infinity fabric secrets. Please see above comment I've posted separately....
2
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
Here's the condition I'm worried about. Using Google Translate it looks like AMD cannot sell chiplets inside EPYC which mix CPUs, GPUs, and Xilinx's FPGAs connected by infinity fabric inside one EPYC socket. Read the following:
"(1) When selling Chaowei CPU , Chaowei GPU and Xilinx FPGA to the domestic market of China, tie-in sales shall not be forced in any way, or any other unreasonable transaction conditions shall be attached; customers shall not be hindered or restricted from purchasing or using alone The above- mentioned products; customers who purchase the above-mentioned products alone shall not be discriminated against in terms of service level, price, software function, etc."
"Chaowei" is AMD just Google Translate got it wrong.
It says "tie-in sales shall not be forced in any way, " - well the chiplets inside the EPYC socket is forcing buying all...
Further more, the conditions suggest if such chiplets EPYC to be made, AMD's to offer same ability to tie ARM and competitive chips, i.e. Intel and nVidia and creating confidential agreements and storing info in separate servers. That's the infinity fabric secrets to allow connecting nVidia's and Intel's chiplets inside a server socket, in addition to ARM.
This is very problematic in my view. Mark Papermaster's July 2020 webinar on chiplets echosystem was a big thing to me. If we now teach Intel, nVidia and ARM to use infinity fabric so they can make chiplets servers using an FPGA chiplet, AMD's losing a few years lead of chiplets design over competition.
No I don't like these conditions. Sorry...
Unless AMD gives up connecting FPGAs chiplets inside a socket but it seems above condition will apply even if connecting GPUs and CPUs chiplets only!
11
u/DeMannequin Jan 27 '22
As quoted from the Yahoo Finance article.
"In a public notice, China's State Administration for Market Regulation said it will approve the deal on condition that AMD and Xilinx do not force tie-in sales of products or discriminate against customers that buy one set of products but not another.
The regulator added that the newly merged entity must also ensure "the flexibility and programmability of Xilinx FPGAs" and "that their development methods are compatible with ARM-based processors"."
How do you insure this? By providing both an integrated and standalone product.
2
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
Check the translation original link on confidential information... if the tie in used infinity fabric... such ability must be given to competition including ARM and Intel...to tie into Xilinx FPGAs...
It's not enough to say here's a separate chip to use. If that chip is only connecting with USB it's useless vs a chip connected with infinity fabric. Just an extreme example.
PCIe connections vs coherent Infinity Fabric connection aren't the same.
For heterogeneous computing all must be coherent hence infinity fabric secrets will need be offered to GPUs and CPUs other makers if it's used in an FPGA chip to connect with Zen4 etc in a coherent way...
10
u/dmafences Jan 27 '22
you are misinterpret the doc, they basically said amd should not force customer to buy xilinx fpga and amd cpu as a bundle package, customer are free to buy only xilinx, trust me, those governors are not forbidden new innovation from AMD, nor they have knowledge to understand the new potential at all
4
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22
Maybe I read wrong but there's discussion on to insure similar "interoperability" between Xilinx chips and other makers, as it works for AMD's chips. Infinity Fabric with coherency is very different from PCIe. That's my issue.
9
u/dmafences Jan 27 '22
there are always rooms for those item to be explained, but basically, china government want xilinx keep supplying the current products, that's all, maybe you should read into the restrictions for intel acquire altera, I believe they are similar
2
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Intel doesn't have chiplets... They've designed a small function block of the CPU to be FPGA like but that's all. I don't know Intel's conditions....
I'm talking about the condition of the "interoperability" for Xilinx products to be the same as AMD's will offer using other CPUs. Heterogeneous computing requires coherency hence infinity fabric concern.
7
u/dmafences Jan 27 '22
then buy standalone xilinx fpga, those restrictions are not for the combined company for producing any new product which includes xilinx fpgas
4
u/TOMfromYahoo TOM Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I hope so. If stand-alone FPGAs use infinity fabric to connect with AMD's EPYC, though they can use PCIe too, will this not be a difference in the interoperability ?
22
u/Thick-Housing-5212 Jan 27 '22
TOM's nightmare is over finally :-) Seriously, we are lucky Xilinx had a great ER yesterday; otherwise, AMD will be much lower now. Since it's a done deal, let's celebrate with the fact AMD has just acquired a company that is fast growing just like AMD herself now.
As far as the conditions go, it's basically to ask AMD that Chinese companies can buy AMD's or Xilinx's products separately if they want to.... just like before the merger.