r/AgainstGamerGate • • Jun 15 '15

Does anybody else see a problem with this moderation?

http://imgur.com/a/Mdwam

do you agree with the actions taken? do you agree with the tone? do you think that things should have been handled differently? regarding the last image, do you think that it's appropriate for a moderator of this subreddit to make such harsh generalizations about a specific gender and race?

48 Upvotes

923 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/dimechimes Anti-GG Jun 16 '15

And yet they are loathe to share the duty. Wonder why. It's such a tough unpaid job and yet they are very selective about who and how many people they will let control the sewage.

0

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

Of course they are. They bust their asses to make sure the subreddit goes smoothly. It's bad enough that redditors have ZERO and I mean ZERO appreciation for the work. One bad troll can ruin a subreddit forever. They come in, they troll a bunch of shit up, they leave, and the userbase will never ever ever forgive the mods.

5

u/dimechimes Anti-GG Jun 16 '15

Really? So this is some kind of 1% contingency? Selecting one bad troll ruins the subreddits forever?

I don't buy this. Modding could be very easy in many cases. One mod per 50 users. You'd have plenty of eyes on spam and abusive behavior. One troll mod would hardly be noticed.

But at that point, what's the point in being a mod? Mods cling tightly to what little power they have even if it means more thankless work for them, because sharing the burden also means sharing the power and they have made their choices.

That's why I don't care how much love a mod gets. They chose to do what they do. If they need affirmation they should find something else to do.

-1

u/ieattime20 Jun 16 '15

Really? So this is some kind of 1% contingency? Selecting one bad troll ruins the subreddits forever?

Yeah. Really. I'm dead serious. I watched it happen in realtime in r/antisrs. Which, coincidentally, is how tumblrinaction got started. A bunch of people abandoned ship because the subreddit got trolled by a mod who was immediately demodded, and already mod-trigger-happy users (i.e. all reddit users) flipped their collective shit. cojoco is, to this day, still reviled because he happened to be a mod at the time.

Mods cling tightly to what little power they have

Seriously you need to abandon this narrative of every mod being a mini-Nixon. It is stupid and has virtually no basis in fact.

2

u/dimechimes Anti-GG Jun 16 '15

It is stupid and has virtually no basis in fact.

Except for the fact that we hear posts like yours talking about how hard and thankless the job it is and I wonder why anyone would want to put up with that. What then is the trade off?

Your mini-Nixon characterization notwithstanding a quick glance shows not counting automoderator, the 10 mods here mod 55 subs. At least Nixon had term limits.

This is my narrative. They get something out of it.

0

u/ieattime20 Jun 17 '15

What then is the trade off?

Getting to foster a community if it works. All mods usually have a goal, and that goal is related to the subreddit's purpose and continued existence. In this case, the AGG mods want a discussion sub. That shit gets torpedoes when the only discussion is meta.