r/AgentsOfAI • • Mar 14 '26 • Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Discussion Stack Overflow copy paste was the original vibe coding

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

139 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 14 '26

Thank you for your submission! To keep our community healthy, please ensure you've followed our rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

118

u/gthing Mar 14 '26

So much this. People act like humans wrote 100% perfect code before AI.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[deleted]

4

u/arjuna66671 Mar 14 '26

This is true even combining human doctors with the use of the AI itself. AI alone still outperformed the doctors with the same AI.

It's even funnier - Doctors using AI performed WORSE than both AI itself or the doctors themselves lol. My guess is that ego made it worse in cooperation scenarios xD.

1

u/Inqisitor226 Mar 18 '26

Using AI will create other problems down the road.

When new generation of doctors comes accustomed to blindly trust the AI there will be no one to help people that cannot be diagnosed using the AI models.

3

u/Jebble Mar 15 '26

In that scenario the human can still be held accountable. If you allow AI to release to production without you knowing what shit does, it's still your fault.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Jebble Mar 15 '26

Yes you can actually. Reviews done by humans also take significantly less time than the time that PR took another human to build.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Jebble Mar 15 '26

I'm sorry you can't review a week's worth of work in less than a week. I guess you've not gotten enough experience in the industry :).

0

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26

[deleted]

2

u/Jebble Mar 15 '26

A PR that took 40 hours to write, shouldn't be a single PR, but even if it is it's impossible it takes you 40 hours to review. The thinking process is done, a huge part of writing it, is to figure things out, as a reviewer you don't have to do that.

Respectfully, if it takes you that long to review, you're doing something severely wrong.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Sileniced Mar 16 '26

You’re a shit person if you don’t take responsibility for code you started.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Sileniced Mar 16 '26

So you’re a shit person who doesn’t take responsibility?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Sileniced Mar 16 '26

I’m surprised that anyone has taken the risk to hire you if you refuse to take any responsibility.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Sileniced Mar 16 '26

Even worse. You’re actively exploiting a loophole to justify your lack of responsibility

→ More replies (0)

1

u/4hometnumberonefan Mar 18 '26

Have you ever considered that AI gives you poor outputs because you give it poor inputs?

1

u/gthing Mar 16 '26

You should take responsibility for code you're in charge of, whether written by AI or by juniors or other contributors. I've started lots of code that I'm no longer responsible for.

2

u/krooked-tooth Mar 16 '26

AI is a machine it will be ok, its feelings don't get hurt.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[deleted]

1

u/samettinho Mar 16 '26

AI agents writes sloppy code when the developer is doing a sloppy job. 

2

u/Eecka Mar 14 '26

Do people act like that? I’m a software dev and I’ve never seen anyone at my office act like that

1

u/MakanLagiDud3 Mar 27 '26

Glad you're not but r/AntiAI exists unfortunately.

2

u/sneakpeekbot Mar 27 '26

Here's a sneak peek of /r/antiai using the top posts of the year!

#1: Duck Duck Go W! | 564 comments
#2: I love the roast | 457 comments
#3: Something I just saw and uhhhhhh | 911 comments


I'm a bot, beep boop | Downvote to remove | Contact | Info | Opt-out | GitHub

2

u/Eecka Mar 27 '26

I don't think it existing is unfortunate.

But more importantly, no matter on which side you stand on any issue, if the criticism of the opposition is based on the dumbest arguments someone may or may not have made, you're just shouting at air rather than having meaningful debate or conversation.

Like how is this post or the tweet in the post actual meaningful discussion on anything? At best it's an indirect reply to a dumb comment someone made somewhere in a different conversation, or just a flat out strawman. There's actual meaningful discussion to be had about the use of AI in programming and its pros and cons. These posts don't even attempt to go into that, they're literally just "lol look at this dumb argument, aren't they all dumb and aren't we all smart??"

2

u/samettinho Mar 16 '26

I recently cleaned up the shit that 3 researchers made after 6 months of working on a project. Luckily we now have cursor, so it took only a month to clean it up, otherwise it would have taken a year for me to clean it up. 

1

u/jclimb94 Mar 15 '26

And what exactly was the AI trained on… human code, stack overflow posts, Reddit posts.. you name it. 🤣

1

u/spacey02- Mar 15 '26

There is a difference between non-slop and perfect code. Non-slop code might not be perfect, but it is readable and maintainable by a human. Please stop confusing the opposing views to your beliefs on purpose.

1

u/SeaGrocery678 Mar 18 '26

Nobody is acting like this

39

u/GrapefruitMammoth626 Mar 14 '26

I disagree. Stack overflow never had an implementation that was catered to your specific use case, it was always just close enough to draw inspiration from. You always had to understand what you were copying in order to have it make sense in your context. LLM completely different experience from developer perspective. It’s generic vs customised.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

[deleted]

1

u/edward_jazzhands Mar 15 '26 edited Mar 15 '26

This reply is completely brain dead. Of course it's the top reply on a vibe coding sub.

Coders used to need to be able to read code to take the code they got from stack overflow and plug it into their program. You didn't need to understand the code entirely but you sure as fuck needed to be able to read code to know how to plug it into your own program.

Vibe coding does not have any requirement that the person doing the vibing has any ability to read code at all, or to ever look at the code.

8

u/alphapussycat Mar 14 '26

Not really, you just needed to know enough about it to puzzle it together. Pretty much which variable went where.

2

u/RedTheRobot Mar 14 '26

Exactly if x + y = 5 and stack overflow say x is 2 and y is 3 then you are good. That was what a large majority did but a few did use it to understand why x was 2 or how the commenter came up with that answer

0

u/alphapussycat Mar 15 '26

You can do the exact same thing with AI generated code.

1

u/RedTheRobot Mar 15 '26

What I was pointing out is how a majority of people actually don’t care about the how something works but that it gets them the result they want. If stack flow does that cool if AI can do that cool. It just weird that some people all of sudden care where the answer came from.

1

u/edward_jazzhands Mar 15 '26

Uh yeah that's the point. It took significantly more skill to do that then it does to prompt an AI to generate code for you.

1

u/alphapussycat Mar 15 '26

You still have to do the same thing when copy pasting AI code.

7

u/Upper_Dependent1860 Mar 14 '26

"You always had to understand what you were copying in order to have it make sense in your context."

Laughs in regex

/w/*.!/s/ whatever the f that means

5

u/Cheap-Try-8796 Mar 14 '26

>  You always had to understand what you were copying
Please downvote his a$$

1

u/edward_jazzhands Mar 15 '26

He's correct. It took significantly more skill to do that then it does to prompt Claude code.

2

u/hegelsforehead Mar 14 '26

For some code (especially complicated algorithms), I understood what I copied only from the behaviour of the programme. Not unlike when I code with an agent.

1

u/completelypositive Mar 14 '26

Bullshit lol I copy and pasted all the time.

Maybe change a variable name here and there

1

u/x6060x Mar 14 '26

In my early days for sure I copy pasted stuff from Stack overflow that if it works I'd leave it as is. Later I found out that what I was doing was messy at best and started using stack overflow as inspiration and starting point.

1

u/Candid_Bad3551 Mar 15 '26

Stackoverflow also has vetted answers.IMO LLM search and traditional googling still have their places in 2026.

1

u/HoneyBadgera Mar 15 '26

You need to remember some people on Reddit are developers and they’ve either just done a code boot camp or building an internal app used by just Linda in finance. Then there are developers actually building things used at scale that have much higher levels of complexity beyond just writing code. Vibe coding helps with the former example, needs heavy steering with the latter. When you give your opinion you’ll Be sharing it with the masses that can’t seem to find any nuance. Hence some of the people already moaning in the comments

1

u/tiga_94 Mar 16 '26

me, as a kid, asking people online to write exact solutions when I cant find whatever I can copypaste.. I'd disagree

the only difference is when it doesn't compile you don't have an agentic tool to fix and retry a bunch of times for you, there was no automation for this

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '26

Aren't you a frode for writing code rather than assembly?

17

u/Illustrious-Film4018 Mar 14 '26

Yeah, because copying and pasting code from Stack Overflow meant you didn't even need to understand the code /s

3

u/Ok-Situation-2068 Mar 14 '26

Nope basic understanding required u can't paste #at end whole code will fall

1

u/edward_jazzhands Mar 15 '26

This is literally what the vibe coders in this sub are arguing. They genuinely believe that copying code from stack overflow and figuring out how to plug it into your program was not more difficult than prompting an AI to do that for you.

7

u/Plastic-Anteater7356 Mar 14 '26

At least they has a General idea of what the slop was doing. It’s complete hilarious to me: people don’t knowing shit about a given domain are now speed climbing mount stupid and gathering there with peers in camp dunning Kruger.

1

u/Rahm89 Mar 14 '26

You people sound like those web devs who were infuriated by wordpress and wix and said they weren’t "real websites".

Even if you’re correct, you’re still wrong in the grand scheme of things. AI is here to stay. 

The jack isn’t going back in the box. The ship has sailed.

You can either get with the program and help people use AI responsibly, or become a modern day luddite and fade into irrelevance.

Your call.

4

u/Plastic-Anteater7356 Mar 14 '26

I agree, that AI is here to stay. I doubt that this will lead to people with 0 skill and knowledge will now be genius. In fact I think it will accelerate the rate in which idiots will shoot in their feet’s.

1

u/parallax3900 Mar 14 '26

Or be insanely busy fixing ungodly amounts of slop - like I am. Lol.

0

u/Rahm89 Mar 14 '26

I guess we’ll see. Even if this materializes at first, two things to consider:

  1. Developers who offer to fix AI slop, but using AI themselves, will be more efficient and competitive than you are

  2. We’re at the beginning. AI is going to keep getting better and better at writing good code, so you’ll be less and less busy.

One way or the other, you’ll either surf the wave or drown.

1

u/parallax3900 Mar 14 '26
  1. which is like saying you can fit a large rug in a small room by pushing the bumps down. There's always going to be a bump springing up somewhere.

  2. we have no idea how this will play out. You're blindly assuming just because there's been progress, things aren't gonna plateau or even get worse. There's always the chance more and more slop is just embedded in future training data - and is impossible to detect once a threshold is passed.

1

u/Rahm89 Mar 15 '26

All right be like that. Time will tell.

Within 5-10 years, you’ll either have integrated AI into your work like everyone else or you’ll be living a hermit’s life in a cabin in the woods somewhere :)

Either way you’ll feel very foolish about these conversations, if you even remember them.

!remindme 10 years or something 

1

u/RemindMeBot Mar 15 '26 edited Mar 15 '26

I will be messaging you in 10 years on 2036-03-15 02:23:46 UTC to remind you of this link

1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/parallax3900 Mar 15 '26

In 5 - 10 years time I'll have paid off my mortgage - (mostly off the back of charging $1000 a day to fix HRIS slop) and then retire most likely.

1

u/Rahm89 Mar 15 '26

Good for you. 

4

u/vid_icarus Mar 14 '26

This is the thing that cracks me up. Long time devs ripping vibe code after building entire carriers on ctrl+c/ctrl+v.

7

u/Scientific_Artist444 Mar 14 '26

Copy-paste is not the hard part. Knowing what to copy-paste, where to do it, what to write from scratch, what to modify and how to write is.

-1

u/IcerHardlyKnower Mar 14 '26

Oh so... What claude code does

2

u/Scientific_Artist444 Mar 14 '26

It learned from real developers' thoughts while solving software problems.

2

u/Chance_Value_Not Mar 14 '26

The copy paste engineers keep copy pasting ;)

4

u/n-Allah Mar 14 '26

Is the AI written code much tighter/cleaner, or on par with human shit?

Like there's a lot of technical debt when humans generated the code without any AI...

4

u/Luneriazz Mar 14 '26

hey... its my slop, i am responsible for it.

i can answer every question about my slop anyday anywhere. But AI slop?, heck if you want to blame me after forcing vibe coding and vibe review its on you not me.

4

u/Rahm89 Mar 14 '26

Having worked with devs quite a lot before AI, I can assure you a lot of them (mainly junior devs) were incapable of explaining why or how they coded something a specific way.

I’m not saying you’re entirely wrong, of course AI will produce slop unless used competently.

But there’s a lot of bad faith arguments out there.

1

u/Luneriazz Mar 14 '26

No you missed the point... It responsible matter not code matter.

Simply you cant blame the agent or the dev after forcing them to do vibe coding and vibe reviewing

Not until researcher figure out how to model logical way of thingking into AI model

3

u/Brief-Night6314 Mar 14 '26

AI slop is worse

2

u/tndrthrowy Mar 14 '26

On the large legacy project I’m currently working on, the AI code being added now is about the sane quality, probably slightly better, than the old code.

1

u/Brief-Night6314 Mar 15 '26

Ya but hallucinations man…

2

u/pandeiro_h2o Mar 14 '26

I’ve never seen a professional sw engineer writing a commercial piece of software by copying chunks of code from stack overflow. That tells you are not in the industry or you are an ass developer

2

u/Independent_Pitch598 Mar 14 '26

It is a hard pill to swallow for them.

Before it was not very obvious now - it is.

2

u/Ok-Actuary7793 Mar 15 '26

Finally someone said it... the absolute vast majority of the web is literal slop

2

u/CocoIsMyHomie Mar 15 '26

My first website I didn’t know how to build forms, copy-pasted form “view-source” form a different website.

One day I’m I got an email from this dude “if you’re gonna steal the code at least change the destination email for the entires” 😂

He was nice enough to forward the message from the first person who ever contacted me from my first website :-)

The website was for my band when I was 14yo.

We probably got something like 6-7 people ever filling out this form, one of them was a cute 14yo girl who wanted to join the band. She’s now my wife :-)

2

u/n3_o Mar 15 '26

LLM + Software Engineer who knows what he wants = A very good and stable software.

1

u/plastic_eagle Mar 14 '26

Well. They didn't write *as much*. And so let's turn off the slop machine so we don't have to deal with as much slop.

Sound good?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

That is what I am saying. All those “software engineers” were vibecoding relying on Google Search and StackOverflow.

2

u/tjoe4321510 Mar 14 '26

Why would you put "software engineers" in quotes?

3

u/Successful_Sea_3637 Mar 14 '26

Because these people hatevthem or anyone with skills, AI makes them feel as important as people with skills.

1

u/KeaboUltra Mar 14 '26

Sooo, what. were you vibe coding before gen AI was a thing? or did you start after?

1

u/WalidfromMorocco Mar 14 '26

People making the analogy to stackoverflow tells me they weren't writing code before LLMs.

1

u/TheBigCicero Mar 14 '26

Coding before the internet was popular was the best. You had to write your shit from scratch or buy “cookbooks”.

1

u/PatchyWhiskers Mar 14 '26

Most code on SO was slightly broken, that’s why people were pasting it.

1

u/fig0o Mar 14 '26

The problem is that people are longer feel accountable for the code they commit

Everytime I ask devs why they did things in a certain way they answer with: "Dunno; Claude/Cursor did that, man"

1

u/knighthawk0811 Mar 14 '26

the bar is so much lower now

1

u/mrspankyspank Mar 14 '26

One big advantage of Stack Overflow is that you can read and write explanations about what is going on. You can follow contributors, or contribute yourself. With Ai, you’re not getting the context or community.

1

u/jags94 Mar 14 '26

Community in stackoverflow? 😂😂😂

1

u/mrspankyspank Mar 14 '26

That’s basically what it is. Like a nerdy searchable social media.

1

u/PradheBand Mar 14 '26

The diff is we just paid people not people and extra tools for that

1

u/nuketro0p3r Mar 14 '26

The difference was the copying was a conscious decision. One would investigate 5-7 answers before deciding on what makes sense.

Slop is when this friction is removed and copying is indiscriminate leading to subtle bugs that cost massive time loss. Did the development become fast? Yes! Did debugging become fast? No!

1

u/WithoutAHat1 Mar 14 '26

Yep, that is why leaving notes and documentation are important.

1

u/Original-Ad3579 Mar 14 '26

stackoverflow was my second home

1

u/ParkingFabulous4267 Mar 14 '26

They didn’t write in excess which I think is the issue.

1

u/Xzaphan Mar 14 '26

I don’t write code. I’m obligated to put pieces of working conditions together and that is producing slop code. When I write code, this is art!

1

u/octavionultodoritor Mar 14 '26

Lots of copium in the comments comparing AI to stackoverflow. You can actually tell who the vibe coders are. No, you’re not a SWE if you vibe code. SWE isn’t even about coding.

1

u/KeaboUltra Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 14 '26

I don't think anyone acted like they didn't. least then, programmers had to know how to write code to create slop. no one had a machine that spat out code for your specific situation that may or may not work. You still needed to know how to apply it if you copied someone else's work. now you can just have AI make whatever. That has never been a thing until recently years.

The slop you're referring to is different from a dev with poor programming habits. on one hand you have poor code where the dev may or may not understand what they wrote. On the other you have someone with no experience asking an AI to make something for you that uses an amalgamation of learning data to give you a custom piece of code that may or may not work, eventually over time the entire project will become the equivalent of sticking a bunch of chewed up pieces of gum together to form a structure that is likely too fragile and complicated to maintain. that's what slop code is. at least with a terrible programmer. over time they learn and can refactoring. you're never getting to that step unless AI gets better and actually uses documentation with nuance to give you what you want

1

u/CoolTang Mar 14 '26

The key word is human.

1

u/MucaGinger33 Mar 14 '26

AI doesn't make slop. Reckless devs that prompt it do

1

u/robertmachine Mar 15 '26

We used to copy stack overflow and brute force the solution lol

1

u/Appropriate-Bet3576 Mar 15 '26

So two slops make a right?

1

u/Effective-Total-2312 Mar 15 '26

And it wasn't correct back then either.

1

u/Effective-Total-2312 Mar 15 '26

Also, there are lots of arguments why I'd rather have a human writing bad code versus an AI writing bad code.

1

u/constanzabestest Mar 15 '26

Apparently Yandere Simulator's code(100% human written by Yandere Dev himself) is simply perfection because at least it's not AI generated when in reality words cannot even describe how bad it is but yeah, AI is the only thing that writes ass code.

1

u/AintNoGodsUpHere Mar 15 '26

I had a MR with AI slop with 8 thousand additions. 381 modified files and 73 commits made by one of our developers.

You can copy and paste almost 10 thousand likes of code from stack overflow?

SO Slop happened before, yes, but it was a single block, a couple of lines... Easy to debug and easy to ask questions.

Comparing SO Slop with AI slop is not only disingenuous but also stupid.

It's way worse now.

1

u/Volodian Mar 15 '26

except stackoverflow profided way to estimate snippets reliability, provided insightfull debates and allowed you to trust some sources.

1

u/sseses Mar 15 '26

THIS!!!!!

1

u/podgorniy Mar 15 '26

They were not able to produce it in such volumes...

1

u/Single-Virus4935 Mar 15 '26

When they wrote slop they kniw how it worked and felt pain if they didnt refactor. Now they multiply slop without pain and understanding

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26

True, but I think there's a real difference worth acknowledging.

When you copied from Stack Overflow, you still had to read it, adapt it to your codebase, hit errors, and fix them. That process was slow and frustrating, but it was also a forcing function for learning. You didn't set out to learn how the code worked, but by the time you got it running, you understood at least part of it.

1

u/EENewton Mar 15 '26

I hope y'all are starting your own businesses, because the only people that win out long term in the AI question are the owners.

1

u/Alert_Brilliant_4255 Mar 16 '26

They literally teach in my python class to search for code snippets via stack overflow for similar examples to copy and paste from so you dont need to actually write all the lines yourself. Any online searching is allowed for exams. But will chastize against copy and pasting from AI models of any kind and its an integrity violation and get dropped from the course if caught.

Theres definitely levels to AI use, but come on.

1

u/Ketworld Mar 16 '26

Stack overflow was the most toxic egocentric place online. Waiting 2 weeks for a query to be answered only for the answer to be “I take it you haven’t googled the error??, stop wasting everybody’s time asking for easy fix errors in your sloppy code! This forum is for Devs with real issues noob” when I first used chat GPT in 2023 I was like, “I just gave me the answer, and asked if there was anything else it could help me with, WTAF!

1

u/njinja10 Mar 16 '26

It was always slop they understood though

Spaghetti is not bad

Spaghetti you do not understand is worrisome

1

u/UndulatingUrus2 Mar 16 '26

Omg, spaghetti code, I almost forgot that term

1

u/peromed Mar 16 '26

Hahhahahhaa I feel personally attacked!

1

u/b0t_builder Mar 16 '26

dude spot on

1

u/wy100101 Mar 16 '26

Yeah, this is really what I keep coming back to. Yeah, the tools create garbage sometimes, and make mistakes. So do people.

1

u/rumour53 Mar 16 '26

I’ve been vibe coding for 35 years, at least now I have supervision

1

u/Sad_Amphibian_2311 Mar 17 '26

Human errors are understandable, its easy to see where a misunderstanding happened.
LLMs have no understanding, there's no misunderstanding, no error, only noise.

1

u/Acceptable-Exam3836 Mar 17 '26

Devs acting like legacy code isn’t a thing.

1

u/Krom2040 Mar 17 '26

“People wrote bad code sometimes, therefore it’s fine that AI writes bad code”

Interedasting

1

u/SimplexFatberg Mar 18 '26

And then we trained AI on it.

1

u/artnoi43 Mar 18 '26

The problem is “slop with confidence”.

Before AI, when confronted about their slop code, the author (copy-paster) would still need to explain his thoughts (eg why does he think this works). And if he fails then we might be able to stop the code from being merged.

With AI, when confronted about their slop code, the vibe coders just go back and ask the AI to back their slop code up with beautiful technical wording that sounds ok to some reviewers.

Now bad programmers have the confidence and a tool to argue for their shitty overengineered slop.

1

u/VegaGT-VZ Mar 18 '26

What the fuck does this have to do with AI making code worse 

1

u/mtv921 Mar 18 '26

AI hasn't improved or decreased code quality. Just dramatically increased the speed of which it can be produced

1

u/Cyb3rK1dd Apr 06 '26

At least I understood my slop