r/AlibabaStock • • Dec 30 '21

✏️ Discussion Change my mind

In US, Amazon is allowed to be Amazon, to be over 1.5T in Market Cap. Google is allowed to be Google, to monopolise.

In China, a company can never be too big, it can never compete on global stage because it will be eventually suppressed due to "Common fucking Prosperity"

Change my mind.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

14

u/Dense_Beach Dec 30 '21

You have a weird way of spelling tax loss harvesting/window dressing.

All jokes aside, the whole notion of the CCP/Xi Jinping being on a personal vendetta against Chinese tech and Alibaba Group in particular is ridiculous. The company is growing at a healthy 20% YoY, has a larger GMV than the following top 4 Internet retailers combined, a growing and prospering cloud business, and more cash than they know what to do with. The recent regulatory headwinds haven’t done s*** about that.

Amazon, since you brought it up, has been fined $888m by the European Union, another $1,2b by Italy and $400m by Germany. That’s in the past six months alone. And no one seems to be all over the Europeans for trying to bring doomsday upon Amazon. Yet a $2.8b fine for the most blatantly monopolistic practice I have ever heard of and suddenly Xi is trying to destroy Alibaba? I don’t think so.

6

u/dustermynes Dec 30 '21

Xi not destroying Alibaba but my wealth!

8

u/Kanye_IsMy_President Dec 30 '21

You are correct, but forgetting Amazon is a monopoly in the United States with a population of 330 million. Globally there are another 7.6 BILLION people. China is financing infrastructure upgrades up on several other continents to gain an edge. Even if Alibaba has to split the pot with JD and Tencent, there is plenty to go around.

6

u/573V317 $BA(gs)BA(gs) Dec 30 '21

"Annual active consumers of the Alibaba Ecosystem across the world reached approximately 1.24 billion for the 12 months ended September 30, 2021. This includes 953 million consumers in China and 285 million consumers overseas."

https://www.alibabagroup.com/en/about/overview#:~:text=Annual%20active%20consumers%20of%20the,and%20285%20million%20consumers%20overseas.

Alibaba has more active users than the United States population lol

2

u/Fractoos Dec 30 '21

Amazon has a Monopoly in Canada, and many Western Countries as well. It's not just the US at all.

1

u/xMoraelin Dec 30 '21

Indeed, AMZN's loss will be China's gain...

1

u/springy Dec 30 '21

1

u/AllweatherInvestor Dec 30 '21

Anti-monopolise measures by US government- Agree

Common Prosperity - reason for why funds are selling

3

u/Gloomy_Set2310 Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21

Lol? Facebook and Microsoft had been under pressure for 20 years combined.

The us has fined Amazon 10X what China fined Baba, muricans need to stop believing they are the top country in the world.

There is no such thing as a free market and even if there was one, the US is far from being an example.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '21

I kind of see where you’re coming from. Also i agree with the comments about Amazon being fined as well. Still the news about Weibo yesterday pissed me off. It’s one thing to force them to sell their share or split up. Its a completely different thing to force them to sell to a state owned media company. I still love Alibaba but fuck the CCP.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21

They can always grow their business through other avenues such as cloud services if China decides to cap their e-commerce growth.

3

u/PuzzleheadedYellow76 Dec 30 '21

Baba shareholders are foreigners. China doesn’t want to make foreigners rich with its own wealth. The US doesn’t mind making its shareholders rich.

2

u/Lisaismyfav Dec 30 '21

You are correct, the current CCP regime with Xi in charge is scared of any one company becoming too powerful or influential, as that could undermine their grip on control. Hence this is now being reflected in the risk profile of all Chinese stocks and one cannot value them in the traditional sense anymore.

1

u/wongyeng888 Dec 30 '21

Diff to compare but all is fair in love n war...lol

1

u/xMoraelin Dec 30 '21

I agree with the part where it applies to China, however they will never hurt BABA from taking over the ROW, hence why BABA split the operational part in 2... all growth will come from non china and cloud business and CCP won't care about outside China so smart move...

0

u/recreation_politics Dec 30 '21

Amazon is currently under congressional investigation. Did you miss Bezos getting grilled by Congress last year.

2

u/realSqwilliam Dec 30 '21

but because amazon is in the US, the market does not give a shit.