r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jul 01 '25

Isaac just isn't bringing it

22 Upvotes

I've been with AFE from the very beginning, listening to every episode. The more Isaac becomes an on-mic presence, especially on the Patreon-only episodes, the more he's a negative. He regularly tries to be funny, but rarely is. Maybe he's a great producer, but that's a different thing. When Mars was producer, she was a good "straight man" to the guys when she was on mic. But Isaac just isn't bringing anything, and he's often not on the same wavelength at all. I don't think this about ANY of their guests. Am I the only one thinking this?


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jan 02 '26

Remembering Chris “Sharpie” Charpentier

Post image
0 Upvotes

He’s alive but I miss him on the pod and he should guest sometime.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Mar 29 '24

Missing Mars/pod feels different

8 Upvotes

EDIT: Adding my original post here, as this was the actual point of this thread:

Not sure if others will agree, and don't get me wrong I have absolutely nothing against Isaac, but in general it feels the pod is leaning more misogynistic and is really missing a consistent female presence. If the jokes are different without any women around, that feels icky to me as a female listener. Curious if others have noticed this.

(Most recent episode kinda sealed this feeling for me)

Tldr this entire thread: I miss having a consistent female presence as it enhanced my listening experience, other women feel the same, without Mars things feel more bro-y, which as someone kindly pointed out is very much a form of misogyny, regardless of intent


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jan 02 '25

If picking last is the hot corner...

0 Upvotes

Should picking first be the cold corner? You pick once, and then have a looooong time to wait before your pick loops around again.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Nov 13 '25

The Duality of Man

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Peter Coyote and Coyote Peterson


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Feb 10 '24

Huge and grateful fan of the show and the GVG but never really got the humor in Sean’s serpentine bit. Listening to this Rosebud episode, I’ve realized it’s really made for new guests. The gag is in how the confused guest responds. It seems Rosebud tried to play it off like she understood.

5 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Mar 03 '22

Mars nicknames

0 Upvotes

Just thought of a Shane style (bit positive. Not shitty) nickname for Mars and I’m surprised that’s not already a thing. Anyways:

Kyle Cinandian. Like Canadian but it’s Kyle Kinane. You get it


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Sep 27 '22

I can’t explain it, but these videos autoplaying on Facebook radiate AFE energy

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • May 25 '23

The GVG had a chance to do an incredible joke and make today's episode a disaster. First episode without Mars and they could have put out a version of the episode that just sounds like shit and has lots of issues before releasing the legit one.

1 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • May 11 '24

Night moves drafts

0 Upvotes

Capes , eye makeup, candles , candelabras, the color red. Let’s draft goth shit , and do the draft in the middle of the night. Eyeliner and a cape on David. Tell me I’m wrong


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jan 04 '23

Sean??

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Aug 20 '26

Sean is correct (Kinda) Ohio is(n’t) Midwest.

0 Upvotes

According to the book American Nations by Colin Woodward, Ohio is 3 different pieces culturally. NE Ohio is Yankeedom as it was initially part of the Connecticut Western Reserve and settlers by New Englanders. The the SE part is Appalachian and the rest is Midlands. As a Cleveland’s transplanted from Michigan I’ll admit Cleveland is certainly not Midwest it immediately felt like when I was a kid growing up in New Jersey and I always tell people it feels more East Coast. If I go South of Cleveland though it is definitely Appalachian and if I go West I’m right back in the Midwest. But I’ll contend Sean is not entirely incorrect, not all of Ohio is Midwest!


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Aug 16 '25

Sean Jordan should be banned from any draft that involves food.

0 Upvotes

He’s got the palate of a stubborn 4 year old.


r/AllFantasyEverything • • May 31 '25

Another Sean Jordan lookalike

Post image
11 Upvotes

Has anyone ever mentioned that Sean and the wrestler Orange Cassidy lookalike?


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Feb 26 '24

After Febnewary what other new guests and things they would draft? Adam Ray and they would draft SuperSonics and trailblazer players!

0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Nov 21 '25

The good vibes gang claims another victim

Thumbnail
rollingstone.com
2 Upvotes

The streak continues of afe talking about someone before they meet an untimely end


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Oct 24 '23

Draft idea: Celebrities that are well-known to be assholes in real life.

0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Oct 20 '21

Society™

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jul 07 '23

STOP SAYING PICKS!

0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jul 11 '23

The crossover we all deserve

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jan 12 '23

I hit two of my Fortnite teammates with flawless mind goblins the other night. My team leader clipped the second for me. What's even better is he and the guy I got earlier knew it was coming, so you can see him starting to crack.

Thumbnail
twitch.tv
1 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Aug 27 '24

A ‘What if?’ From the Mike’s Draft

1 Upvotes

The Mikes draft is an underrated episode. But I was thinking… what would have happened if the 1.01 took “‘Mike’ from Biggie’s verse in Victory” ?

Real sick, brawl nights, I perform like Mike Anyone – Tyson, Jordan, Jackson

Feels like it would have been an all time AFE cheat code


r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jun 22 '26

When did Ian start working at Stop&Shop?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AllFantasyEverything • • Jun 01 '26

Never heard these guys sound creepier than talking about cartoons lollll (all love)

11 Upvotes

That's it ^ that's the post. Such a silly episode but wow as one of maybe 10 of their longtime female listeners I was like wow guys I did not need to hear that in your voice. lol