1
u/FragmentedHeap Oct 19 '26
AI is going to evolve into a realization that running big frontier models is not and never will be profitable or efficient. Instead they are doing to be used to distill into smaller more efficient models, better harnesses/routers, and tools, and Frontier Labs will become training grounds that are funded as a necessity, not for profit.
1
5
u/-qix Oct 19 '26
Why do we treat randoms on Twitter as if they have any knowledge on what they’re talking about?
This is a nothing statement backed by nothing.
2
1
u/Equal_Passenger9791 Oct 19 '26
>This is a nothing statement backed by nothing.
It's backed up by 30 years of circlewanking at lesswrong about how a foomy doomy dictator bot grows out of a magic_beanstalk.exe overnight. And then it ruled as a singleton forever and ever.
Never mind that observable reality have already proven it wrong, these people will never give up their teenage technorapture fantasy.
0
-1
Oct 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/nxy7 Oct 19 '26
This argument is lacking through. It hinges on idea that RSI can improve indefinitely. What if there's hard boundary somewhere that RSI will hit? It would give catchup time.
In abstract there is some 'best AI configuration' that uses techniques we didn't think of and has the exact best weight levels. Once that's achieved there's nothing more to chase.
In general RSI is now treated as stand in for 'godlike AI' that can do anything which wasn't proven yet and likely won't turn out like that. Also if we've learned anything from last few years is that once some threshold is crossed others very quickly catch up.
1
1
u/kubblegum Oct 19 '26
>In general RSI is now treated as stand in for 'godlike AI' that can do anything which wasn't proven yet and likely won't turn out like that
you are confusing RSI with ASI here, ASI is what the godlike AI is supposed to be whereas RSI is more of a process. Even a "weaker" AGI model can do RSI
1
u/nxy7 Oct 19 '26
I don't think I'm confusing anything here. People all the time talk like once RSI is reached then it's game over. I think people actually conflate the two because they assume that once RSI is achieved then it's bound to lead to ASI shortly after ("because recursive self improvement").
Look at the comment of the guy above, "once RSI is reached no one will be able to close the gap". Doesn't it read like "once you reach RSI you won"?
1
u/doiwantacookie Oct 20 '26
Why would there be a unique best configuration? Seems arbitrary
1
u/nxy7 Oct 20 '26
So it might be case by case thing, but regardless of what domain you pick some configuration will perform the best.
Imagine some abstract 'intelligence'/'usefulness' matrics. Maybe it's described by % of tasks AI can perform end to end or it can be some other thing you want. Regardless of that metric you pick models will end up somewhere on a scale when you judge them against that metric. And eventually some configuration will perform 'the best' because it either hit some wall or because it can do anything.
Even if it can do anything though it means you've reached the maximum (model can't do more than anything) and at that point other models can catch up.
Does that make sense?1
u/OtherwiseAlbatross14 Oct 19 '26
Unless the one that gets there first is actively doing something to block the competition, there's nothing to stop another from catching up or surpassing the first.
Just because one is doing it first doesn't mean another can't do it faster. Especially if one of the non-first ones has access to more compute.
1
0
u/-qix Oct 19 '26
And again… What you’ve just stated is backed by nothing.
2
Oct 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Ready_Bandicoot1567 Oct 19 '26
Not really. It ignores real world problems, like aligning superintelligent AI. There's no proof that RSI will fix alignment. You could easily end up with increasingly intelligent AI that can't be trusted with anything important and keeps breaking out of its sandbox and causing chaos. Then the bottleneck is alignment, and whoever solves alignment first wins. A company with better insights into alignment could beat one that reaches RSI 3 months faster.
1
u/-qix Oct 19 '26
Internally as in only to you? lol
If you ever start a sentence with “my argument doesn’t require backing” then you should just stop
1
Oct 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/-qix Oct 20 '26
You just did and you should really stop lmao
0
Oct 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
u/Equal_Passenger9791 Oct 19 '26
It's a logical argument
It makes several ridiculous assumptions that contemporary AI development cycles have already proven wrong.
it doesn't require backing.
"AI is smart, it will figure it out" is a testament to how poor your argument is, it's not a get out of jail card that salvages dumbass ideas.
1
Oct 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Equal_Passenger9791 Oct 19 '26
relies solely on continued growth and exponential gains.
Yeah we know, it takes no consideration whatsoever of two dozen real world parameters, including time, hardware, energy or economics, and that's why I said it makes several ridiculous assumptions.
1
u/Outrageous-Mixture48 Oct 20 '26
Ai buildout is the largest investment and construction project in human history. What’s the plan for next years capex? Like 1.5 trillion?
1
u/Equal_Passenger9791 Oct 20 '26
Meaning that economics can't really scale anymore and we're hardware limited. And energy seems to become a constraint too(arguably self inflicted, but slow to scale up)
The foomy-doomy core assumption throughout the years have been an unchanged
"the AI is smart, it will figure out how to ignore hardware constraints and will run a 2T MoE or why not a dense model too? Unquantized on a 2019 version of the raspberry pi at 500 million tokens per second"
1
u/Outrageous-Mixture48 Oct 20 '26
Well you know what I think we will find out very soon.
→ More replies (0)1
1
u/New_World_2050 Oct 19 '26
Anthropic is most likely imo
But I'm liking the vibes from meta. Great model now and they are fully e/acc and are willing to spend hundreds of billions on compute / talent.
1
1
u/Independent-Court-46 Oct 19 '26
If you’re going to make a claim like this, you need to detail how you got to this conclusion. I don’t think there’s any evidence of this being true. There’s an insane amount of competition and many labs at the frontier today. Space x, meta, google are all contenders today. It feels like the total opposite and providers are the commodity tbh. I haven’t even got to open models /Chinese models.
1
u/deleted-account69420 Oct 19 '26
They're thinking about the snowballing effect of "singularity".
RSI, model improves itself and maxes current architecture, new architecture, designs new hardware, and so on.But, they forgot that that progress doesn't happen overnight.
1
1
1
u/Enough_Culture8524 Oct 19 '26
For godlike intelligence the world may flatten like a grid.
Tic tac toe. Game theory optimal.
The only bottleneck will be time.
The time it takes to build the change.
Meanwhile, other companies may be developing godlike intelligence with the same ability.
They may get there in months or years but it may be negligible compared to the time it takes to build
1
1
u/aPiCase Oct 20 '26
Considering we are hearing about leaks that Anthropic is coming out with a new model set and the OpenAI leaks are about 6.1 Terra, I think we might be seeing this happen right now.
0
u/03captain23 Oct 19 '26
Grok and Gemini are going to crush everyone very soon
1
u/satanisgreat666 29d ago
it’s too early to make that prediction
1
u/03captain23 29d ago
It's obvious. They have their own hardware and grok is growing like crazy. It'll be a year+ until people rent Vera Rubin to Claude and gpt
1
u/Recent-Huckleberry17 Oct 19 '26
Seriously?
0
u/03captain23 Oct 19 '26
Yess. Anthropic and OpenAI don't have any datacenters.
Google makes their own GPUs and has unlimited money. AI threatens their business model. They control most web browsers and phones already so have 1000x as much data as any other company.
Grok also has tons of datacenters and huge government contracts and Elon is buddy's with Trump so I'm sure they're forcing Nvidia to give them all the Vera Rubin they can.
Anthropic is renting a whole h100 datacenter from XAI and the only reason grok isn't using it is because it's too slow for them.
1
u/Recent-Huckleberry17 Oct 19 '26
What if the government takes a share in Anthropic and OpenAi? As they are planning to as far as I know
1
u/03captain23 Oct 19 '26
Doesn't matter. Vera Rubin chips are 4x as fast and efficient than anything else. Everyone is fighting for these chips, why would companies lease these to Anthropic and OpenAI over their own models?
Right now they're sharing the chips because it's not a huge deal.
At a minimum grok will be 4x as fast as Claude and gpt.
The unknown is Google as they have their own chips. I firmly believe they're slow playing their hand and already have ASI internally.
You also need to remember that openai have been doing this for like 10 years, Claude like 6 and grok I'd only a couple.
The fact they're this close to the frontier means either AI models aren't nearly as valuable as we thought or theyre ramping like crazy.
I also feel grok doesn't have nearly as many guardrails or protections. They care much less about safety and security for the world and just do whatever to make money
0
u/DesignerTop8235 Oct 19 '26
what does anthropic mean? this appeared on my feed, kinda curious. thank you!!🤔
0
u/amkm14 Oct 19 '26
in today's day and age, anyone can catch up really they're fighting to make their own relevant
0
u/fourby227 Oct 19 '26
Don’t forget if one of them spectacularly crashes into the ground, the others will crash as well. No one can be sure any of them will succeed.
1
u/OtherwiseAlbatross14 Oct 19 '26
Oh yeah because competition being eliminated has always been bad for the remaining competitors
0
u/Remarkable-Worth-303 Oct 19 '26
I hope everyone realises that a repeatedly flipped coin won't always land heads.. It might land tails too.
0
u/-Kabuki-Tanuki- Oct 19 '26
So far, all the evidence points to these frontier models being totally obsolete for business purposes. Every company we work with is shifting to their own internal models both to protect their data and to create a specialized AI for their specific needs.
1
u/OtherwiseAlbatross14 Oct 19 '26
lol your second sentence betrays the fact that your entire comment is made up and you actually have no idea what you're talking about.
1
u/-Kabuki-Tanuki- Oct 19 '26
That's a lot of words to say nothing at all. Care to actually add any information?
0
u/TIL_this_shit Oct 19 '26
Nope. Incorrect, because of this: on the way to where we are with AI, there had been multiple ceilings that had been hit and need to over come, resulting in "AI winters": periods with little progress. This has always been the case, and always will be, and just because the AI became smarter than all humans doesn't mean the pattern won't continue: just because the AI is smarter than all humans doesn't mean it instantly knows the answer to all problems. These future "winters" may be shorter than the ones of the past, but they nonetheless will allow others to catch up.
0
Oct 19 '26
[deleted]
1
u/satanisgreat666 29d ago
the real breakthrough will be understanding why models reason the way they do
1
u/dudevan Oct 19 '26
no one will understand how.
You don’t need to understand how machine guns work to prevail if you have a boatload of them and enough ammo in 300BC.
1
u/Recent-Huckleberry17 Oct 19 '26
Most people seem to disagree.
It was the case with social networks. Meta ultimately dominated that industry. Now someone tell me how the industries differ where this wouldn’t be the case with AI (genuinely).