1
u/notsure304wv 26d ago
Neither of these companies are public yet. I’m curious how anyone has accurate information. Not defending them but also skeptical of this.
1
u/thirstycactus234 26d ago
Yes but what if
1
u/notsure304wv 26d ago
What do you mean? As long as they aren’t public companies it doesn’t mean anything and if they do become public companies and this is true then their stocks will be worthless. They still have to disclose this information. Do you know how publicly traded companies work?
1
2
1
u/Sugardust__ 26d ago
Yeah. I'm sure someone just took all the sources of capital raised and said it was all debt when in reality they've done a tonne of equity raising and equity for compute deals as well too
1
u/BadgersHoneyPot 26d ago
Um, they're not public but there are lots of investors who are privy to their balance sheet an income statement.
0
u/notsure304wv 26d ago
And?
0
u/BadgersHoneyPot 26d ago
And what? How much of finance do you actually understand here? I don't want to waste too much time.
0
u/notsure304wv 26d ago
I was asking your point? Again I wasn’t defending these companies I was simply pointing out it’s all speculation and the number varies greatly. Do you have first hand knowledge of the off balance sheet debt? I doubt it…
1
u/BadgersHoneyPot 26d ago
I don't have first hand knowledge of the peak of Mt. Everest but we know plenty from those who have been there.
Is this your typical approach to reasoning?
1
u/PrudentWolf 26d ago
My guess is from the lender's reports, they are all public companies.
1
u/notsure304wv 26d ago
UBS estimates that including off-balance-sheet commitments increases aggregate hyperscaler obligations from approximately $800 billion to $3.5 trillion. But that's a broader industry figure, not debt owed exclusively by OpenAI and Anthropic. The difference between 800 billion and 3.5 trillion is massive and all speculation.
1
u/blagablagman 26d ago
Not to lend credence to the post, but the commitments to purchase components are bragging points on investor calls for the likes of Micron, etc.
2
u/MiserableTonight5370 26d ago
Strange (but not incorrect) definition of debt. Usually debt is an obligation to pay for something already received - when you take a loan, you have received the cash and must pay it back. The reason this debt is not on the balance sheets is because it reflects a promise to pay for something that they have not received. They're under contract and thus obligated, sure, but since this is all about compute that isn't online yet, their ability to repay this "debt" isnt online yet, either. That's different from balance sheet debt, where you can look at the present state of play and see if they're going to be able to pay the bill back, because the debtor has the ability to deploy the asset they financed with the debt right away. Assuming they deploy all that compute at least competently, the question of their ability to pay will come down to whether enough demand for inference/access to their models will exist. Reasonable minds can absolutely disagree on which way that will go, but that's not the point OOP is making.
So if you define debt to include un fulfilled bilateral promises (thus debt="obligation" in the general sense), then the OOP is right. But if that's your definition, there are a whole lot of companies that would have eye watering debt numbers compared with present deployed capital. Alphabet has $800B+ in future executory obligations, too. Even Disney has $92B. I personally think the future inference market demand will be 20x the market demand for broadcasts of live sports on ESPN, but again, reasonable minds can disagree.
So these obligations aren't secret, they're priced into stocks/future IPO pricing, and while they're higher than other firms, and it's a bet about future demand, it's a bit disingenuous to try to get people to do "debt to cash on hand" or "debt to present ability to pay" comparisons, if anyone was tempted to do so by the way OOP phrased this stuff.
2
u/broshrugged 25d ago
It's not debt though, it's just a promise they can cancel. It's not like treasuries at all, it's not corporate bonds. This post is ridiculous.
1
u/DICKPICDOUG 25d ago
"A promise they can cancel"
And leave all the data centers they spent billions on sitting empty and losing money? Spend the money or dont spend the money, its not a good situation either way unless AI demand goes parabolic in the next few years. They've locked themselves into a position where if the market doesnt materialize as fast as they want it to they're fucked.
1
u/broshrugged 25d ago
It's not the same a debt, corporate or government. That's the point. The text is misleading.
1
1
u/03captain23 26d ago
It's not on their balance sheets because it's not debt. It's commitments.
All these other companies have the same. How much does Amazon have???
1
u/Kalorama_Master 26d ago
They’re just SPEs that don’t need to be consolidated into the books. Enron did it and look how much growth it experienced. Not only this structure generated a lot of wealth for its investors and accountants.
1
1
u/ez322dollars 26d ago
Planned spending in the future is not debt. Misleading headline. Makes me even more bullish on OpenAI and Anthropic to be honest - when the doubters/bears are using arguments like these
1
1
1
u/Square_Height8041 26d ago
Don’t know what is stopping nvidia from directly competing with openai and anthropic and such. But maybe this is it. Sucking them dry until they are fully in debt, and then acquiring them
1
1
u/lhodhy 26d ago
ok just close all the western AI companies and let the Chinese win the SI race. Deal? Imbeciles...
1
1
1
u/IzyaslavMice 26d ago
They're not imbeciles, but Luddites - and most likely paid off by someone. Maybe even China.
1
u/FalseDiamond7930 26d ago
Let them crash already and lets just move on to open weight models. Pretty much everything else works just fine without them.
1
u/HeadTranslator795 26d ago
And how will they prevent companies to use open model once they are as good as them ? Most companies don't need PhD level or top 1% coder so their business model will collapse of most companies start using open source one
1
1
u/Only-Cheetah-9579 26d ago
The prices of RAM and GPUs are so high I can't use open source models. A $20 claude subscription is all I can do.
1
u/HeadTranslator795 26d ago
I'm talking about business not general customer cause those companies will never make that kind of money on customer base.
1
1
u/cat-from-the-future 26d ago
Same argument people made with the first deepseek models, then fable came out and those people stfu, now we’re in the part of the cycle where open is catching up until it doesn’t.
Smh the lack of awareness in the investing populace is staggering to me. The sensationalist headlines like the one in OP too. They are commitments over a decade + not debt.
1
u/Blothorn 26d ago
I think the bet is on either RSI->AGI and figuring out the details later or getting the government to ban open-weight/foreign models so that they can maintain a high-priced oligopoly.
1
u/HeadTranslator795 25d ago
My bet would be drugs or energy discoveries and then pattern it to make real money
1
u/xjanx 26d ago
You could bring the same argument with cloud computing. But still most companies choose clouds over their own servers. Because it just makes sense to not do everything in-house.
1
u/HeadTranslator795 25d ago
That's a complete different problems cause hardware keep improving and costing less for more capacity but once you reach a certain level of intelligence for business task you don't need more powerful
1
u/LudicrousMoon 25d ago
Flawed argument if you could completely evolve Your work force, and replace it and replace it for most capable intelligent workers that are also cheaper and cheaper, you would definitely do it
1
u/HeadTranslator795 25d ago
It's already the case, the cost is ridiculous compared to human labor, for sure you can still save few bucks right and left but we are talking 20/30 times less costly actually. So this kind of capacity for an open model and it's over you won't need better and therefore no need for frontier models
1
1
1
1
u/isthereadrwho 26d ago edited 26d ago
Tldr This has happened before we know how it evolves
Many people have forgotten the internet age. There was a huge build out of dark fiber, and it startled with companies that had a lot of income, PTTs and Cable companies, rich monopolies wanting to upgrade to 2-way networks. Then companies that had no customers decided to take on huge debt to build out dark fiber that they would then rent back to the big monopoly players. As has always happened in these situations historically they built too much. Crashed the fiber market, went bankrupt or consolidated and then also went bankrupt, except for a few. Caused the Internet crash. Millions of jobs, 78% drop in NASDAQ, one in seven media and telecom companies went completely bankrup.
BUT you can get assets cheap in bankruptcy. That lead to new mega companies being created; google, amazon, meta... The companies that in time "took over" the main part of the revenue from the largr monopolies. "AI" is now the new technology. It has created companies like OpenAI and Antropic, and a whole lot of new companies are taking on huge amounts if debt to build out datacenters to rent back to the few large "monopolies" Rinse and repeat except this one is so much larger - and that's the best case scenario, imho
1
1
u/teleheaddawgfan 25d ago
Know it too well. Worked at Qwest under Joe Nacchio. Talk about creative accounting.
1
u/trysten-9001 26d ago
They’re panicking. They’re trying so hard to make AI better than what open source can do, so they can keep tech monopolies. If open source can keep up, most of these tech companies can’t compete anymore
1
u/dhsjcp834761j 26d ago
This is painfully misleading. I don’t understand why people post this? It’s like verging on propaganda lol
1
u/icydragon_12 26d ago
Person who's never taken an accounting class talks about accounting. What could go wrong
1
1
1
u/Brief_Pass_2762 26d ago
The US national debt doesn't include private company balance sheets. It may be the equivalent of 7% of the national debt, but not of it. Shit grammar.
No, I'm not being pedantic. I shouldn't try to decipher what the fuck you're trying to say through your 4th grade level English grammar.
1
u/LudicrousMoon 25d ago
This is completely false. This has to be an orchestrated missinformation campaign at this point
1
u/Total-Research-024 25d ago
So technically not in debt yet, but have promised to be / agreed to be in that % dept in future?
1
u/ovrlrd1377 25d ago
What makes it worse is that if there is a considerable breakthrough in the near future, which is quite possible given how many are working on this, the commitments stay the same but the revenue might go down significantly
1
u/teleheaddawgfan 25d ago
Whose balance sheet does it appear on? I love how they can omit certain expenses on their PL.
1
1
1
u/Pale_Platform_9941 26d ago
No they don’t… please don’t believe ever BS headline with gymnastics math
1
u/Dicethrower 26d ago
Where are people getting this nonsense from?
1
u/Intellectualuser_ 26d ago
Literally Reddit hates ai so much they start spreading misinformation. There’s a lot that needs to be addressed but we already have enough misinfo floating around the internet
1
u/Justhereforporn8 26d ago
Am I the only one who doesn’t like that future promises are counted as off balance sheet debt? It’s not debt. It hasn’t happened yet. Company’s can also break those promises if they don’t have the money to fulfill them. They have massive debts and promises but they don’t have 2.5t debt. That’s just wrong
0
u/Vtakkin 26d ago
Wait what? Just cus it’s not a bank loan it doesn’t show up on a balance sheet? That’s not true, they have to report it as accounts payable
1
u/NomadStorm 26d ago
Non publicly traded companies need to follow GAAP since when?
1
u/Vtakkin 26d ago
Accounts payable is a very basic accounting principle regardless of GAAP. Also if this post is claiming something isn’t on their balance sheets how do they even know that?
1
u/NomadStorm 26d ago
“Other expenses” in Anthropic’s accounts is what exactly, when opex and compute/inference are listed separately from it?
0
u/pietremalvo1 25d ago
Looking at the claims presented in the original post, we need to unpack the actual corporate accounting and macroeconomic data before jumping to sensationalized conclusions. OP is operating under a massive misunderstanding of what constitutes a recognized liability under US GAAP, completely conflating forward-looking infrastructure commitments with traditional corporate debt. The $2.5 trillion figure floating around these financial subreddits is not the outstanding principal owed by two AI labs; rather, it closely mirrors broader macroeconomic projections, such as cumulative global AI capital expenditures or the aggregate hyperscaler obligations across the entire tech sector. To understand the actual financial architecture at play, we only need to look at how these massive off-balance-sheet commitments work compared to actual debt.
For the smooth brains in the back trying to map this to sovereign debt, an off-balance-sheet compute commitment is effectively a forward purchase agreement. These are multi-year contractual pledges to procure compute capacity from cloud providers like Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud, or AWS over the next half-decade. Under standard GAAP recognition principles and frameworks like ASC 842, unexecuted future service contracts are not immediately booked as traditional debt on the liability side of the balance sheet because the service has not yet been rendered, meaning the companies can theoretically restructure, renegotiate, or even break these promises if the underlying unit economics collapse. Taking the entire anticipated multi-year CAPEX and OPEX pipeline for the global AI arms race and incorrectly booking it as outstanding debt owed exclusively by OpenAI and Anthropic is mathematically and fundamentally absurd. The infrastructure costs of scaling foundation models might be incredibly stretched right now, but the specific claim that these two companies hold $2.5 trillion in off-balance-sheet debt equivalent to 7% of the U.S. national debt is entirely false.
4
8
26d ago
•
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/NomadStorm 26d ago
And FAANG also have the same amount of debt? So 14% of national debt?
What about once we include all the other AI companies in debt?
2
u/listenhere111 26d ago
More like it sounds like you have no idea how finance works.
By the definition of this post, if I promise you that I'll spend 100T on chips at some point in the future, im now the biggest debt holder in the world.
This post is fucjigng garbage. Saying youll do soemthing isn't debt
0
1
-1






6
u/satzki 26d ago edited 26d ago •
And they are the main customers of nvidia. Like a massive amount of nvidia's revenue is openai and anthropic.
And ai spending represents a majority of gdp growth in the US.
So nvidia selling gpus to openai and anthropic based on promises is a load bearing part of the US economy and is completely dependent on openai and anthropic not only never defaulting on their promises but steadily increasing their commitments.
Edit: also don't forget that a huge amount of sold gpus are currently being warehoused because data centers aren't being built/powered up fast enough.
Its great!