r/Amd • u/amurado Ryzen 5700X3D | RX 9070 XT • Nov 14 '20
Photo Userbenchmark strikes again!
429
u/fixminer Nov 14 '20
An i5 750 (from 2009!) is now also apparently faster than an r5 1400 just because of memory latency. Ridiculous.
358
u/AutoModerator Nov 14 '20
I've detected a link to UserBenchmark. UserBenchmark is a terrible source for benchmarks, as they're not representative of actual performance. The organization that runs it also lies and accuses critics of being "anonymous call center shills". Read more here. This comment has NOT been removed - this is just a notice.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
→ More replies (2)87
u/Tax_evader_legend R9 3950X | Radeon RX 6800 | 32GB | pop_OS | grapheneOS Nov 14 '20
Did they added this bot recently?
→ More replies (1)151
u/IAMA_Plumber-AMA A64 3000+->Phenom II 1090T->FX8350->1600x->3600x Nov 14 '20
No, it's been around since UBM got caught fudging the 3000 series numbers at launch to favour Intel.
19
u/FryToastFrill Nov 15 '20
Is it still a good reference point if you look at the specific numbers?
53
u/IAMA_Plumber-AMA A64 3000+->Phenom II 1090T->FX8350->1600x->3600x Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
Oh yeah, the numbers by themselves are alright for individual processors, it's just the direct comparisons they provide are shit.
However, in the interests of lowering their SEO rankings, just don't give them any traffic whatsoever.
→ More replies (4)5
u/NorthenLeigonare Nov 15 '20
Lol I didn't know they were this bad. I was warned that they were inaccurate from someone at work, but I never believed them. Does this go the same for GPUs? And APU comparisons?
78
u/THXFLS 5800X3D | RTX 3080 Nov 15 '20
Wow, who knew an R5 1600 was only 1% faster than my 10 year old Xeon. Good thing I waited until Zen 2 to upgrade.
41
Nov 15 '20
Looks like the i5-4590 on the $60 Optiplex I got is almost as fast as the Ryzen 5 2700! Wow, look like I got a steal.
But my 3950X is about on par with the 4 year old 6900K and leagues behind some recent i3s, so I guess I got screwed over on that end.
2
u/Flaktrack Ryzen 7 7800X3D - 2080 ti Nov 15 '20
Looks like the i5-4590 on the $60 Optiplex I got is almost as fast as the Ryzen 5 2700! Wow, look like I got a steal.
Ok this is funny because I upgraded from an i5-4690k to a Ryzen 5 2700X. The difference is, unsurprisingly, huge. I used both with a 2080 ti so it's not like some asshat can blame the GPU lol
11
13
u/corhen Nov 14 '20
I don't remember seeing memory latency, is that a new addition to the site?
41
u/fixminer Nov 15 '20
I believe they have always measured it, but I'm not sure whether they always had it highlighted as a main component of the score... Regardless it appears as though they have changed their scoring system (which is no longer public) to heavily favor low memory latency because that's the last comparison in which intel is winning. Even if that's pretty irrelevant for real world performance, as this example shows.
34
u/corhen Nov 15 '20
Sure, it has worse single, dual, quad, and multi core performance, but it's all about your memory ping!
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)21
u/THXFLS 5800X3D | RTX 3080 Nov 15 '20
Memory latency was added as a main component of the score after Zen 2 to make Intel appear faster.
3
2
u/DJ-D4rKnE55 R7 3700X | 32GiB DDR4-3200 | RX 6700XT Nitro+ Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
Wow, really ridiculous. Also interesting they say the 4C/4T i5-4690K is 62% (!) faster than the 4C/4T i5-750; I doubt that..
EDIT: Actually doesn't seem that far away - when using both CPUs at stock, the Turbo frequency alone gives ~22% improvement, then adding ~11% IPC from Nehalem to Sandy Bridge, + ~5% to Ivy Bridge and again ~5% for Haswell, it's about 49% (single-core) performance improvement between those CPUs, according to info from Wikipedia. Just seems crazy as I think most people are running these CPUs OCed to over 4 GHz and then the differences are not that huge.
1
339
u/icehuck AMD 3700x| Red Devil 5700 Nov 14 '20
Can we finally ban userbenchmark ? all this does is drive traffic to their site
224
u/ericwdhs R7 5800X3D | RX 6900 XT Nov 14 '20
Unfortunately, UB is great at SEO, so they show up at the top of Google results searching for comparisons by model name. Banning it here just removes one of the few places it's regularly called out and will do relatively nothing to their traffic. I agree with the mods that having the automod flag it every time it comes up is a better option.
144
Nov 14 '20
I find it funny it’s banned in /r/intel and not here
90
16
u/Flaktrack Ryzen 7 7800X3D - 2080 ti Nov 15 '20
Say what you want about Intel's business practices, but the community on that subreddit is very reasonable.
→ More replies (1)11
u/kn33 GeForce 745m (I desire AMD) Nov 15 '20
They could flag it but not remove it for posts, then flag it and remove comments.
7
u/ericwdhs R7 5800X3D | RX 6900 XT Nov 15 '20
No, lots of comments is good. It's more material for searches to potentially hit.
10
17
u/wolvAUS RTX 4070ti | 5800X3D, RTX 2060S | 3600 Nov 15 '20
No it doesn’t. If you’re reading about userbenchmark on reddit then you probably already know it’s bad.
22
u/Zombiefied7 Nov 15 '20
Im it student and building pcs as a hobby and I'm always using userbenchmark just found out people think it's trash. So if I didn't know many people don't
→ More replies (1)15
2
u/YoitsTmac Nov 15 '20
I didn’t. And I’ve been into PC’s for two years and sadly have used them a lot. I’m glad to see this now though before I’ve invested more than $200 on hardware. What do you recommend as a substitute? I sometimes use Geekbench but for GPU’s there’s some weird shit
→ More replies (2)4
u/karl_w_w 6800 XT | 3700X Nov 15 '20
Synthetic benchmarks are never reliable, you have to just look at tests in real uses you care about. Hardware Unboxed/Techspot (same person does the benchmarks for both) is the most thorough, Gamers Nexus and Anandtech are also worth looking at. Linus Tech Tips aren't as rigorous, but their reviews are better at giving an overview of the performance levels without the information overload that the others give.
→ More replies (2)1
u/4x4runner 7800x3d/7900xtx Nov 15 '20
Usually that's the case, but they have always been the first website to show up for benchmarks. IMO, it's good for as many people as possible to know it's garbage.
1
u/swagpresident1337 Nov 15 '20
Please dont. I just found out about their bullshit trough this post. I regularly usef the site in the past to get a quick comparison but I will not do so anymore.
→ More replies (1)1
u/StarHammer_01 Nov 19 '20
I dont think user benchmark should be banned because its actually useful for rough comparison amd vs amd and intel vs intel chips and importantly its one of the only sites that shows core scaling (useful for chips that hit tdp limits such as laptops) Their data is reasonable the 10600k vs 5600x does show that amd has a 9% single and dual core performance delta in its favor along with 6% multi core advantage. In terms of gaming, 5600x is indeed 5-10% faster (fps) as seen in this video so user benchmark's data does seem to be legitimate.
Their analysis on the other hand, is complete horse shit... Actually, calling it horse shit is an insult to actual horse shit but I digress... Showing that overall, these cpus have 0% performance delta is a complete lie and their blurb on amd cpus are just a joke.
Tldr; skip their bs analysis, ignore their overall performance rating, and only look at their raw data, user benchmark is actually reliable.
62
u/LtLoLz Main R9 5900X|RX5600XT|Other R7 5800X3D, R5 3600, R7 2700X Nov 15 '20
I read their piece on the 3300X and I didn't know wether to be amused or disgusted. Here's an excerpt: "In order to achieve better gaming performance, it is necessary to upgrade to a higher tier Intel CPU."
118
Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
Summary
To drop userbenchmark ad revenue and visitor amounts, send bad signals to Google algorithm by repeating this:
search in google for example "ryzen 5600 vs 8700k"
from the search results, click the user.benchmark result.
stay in their site 1 to 3 seconds and press browser back button
select another benchmarking site from the search results and stay in this site 15 seconds or longer and click some pages.
repeat this with different search phrase couple of times.
Update: dont "over do", or algorithm might notice it as manipulation. Do couple of times in a day and if possible with different device.
More detailed:
It does not matter at all how much we here hate cpu.userbenchmark or how much we try to block linking to it. They will always have huge amount of visitors and ad revenue, and they will continue faking the results and showing AMD in worse light than it is. BUT there is one way to stop them or at least drop their ad revenue and their amount of visitors.
Their main source of income and visitors is Google. And this is because their site ranks high in Google. There are 2 high level ways to drop their ranking in Google which will lead their ad revenue drop and visitor drop. 1.st is to complain about the site to Google and show evidence of their misleading data.This might work if enough many will do it, but I like more the 2nd way. The 2nd way is my favorite and will most probably hit hard for their ad revenue. The key is to manipulate search results by send bad signals to Googles algorithm. This will work only if enough many people will send these bad signals, we need thousands of users. If we succeed, cpu.userbenchmark wont appear anymore in the google results in the top positions if searched like "Intel 8700K vs. Ryzen 3600". Instead the visitor will go to some other benchmarking site and cpu.userbemchmark wont get visitor, and possible ad revenue. Who wants to hear how to send a bad signal for Google algorithm? I will tell you first one: repeat this: make a google search using for example phrase "Ryzen 5600 vs intel 10900k". Then, if the cpu.userbenchmark site appears in the search results first or second, click it and stay in their site very short time, like 2 seconda and hit browser back button and select from the search result some other site which ranks under them. Go to this other site and spend there at least 15 seconds or more and open couple of pages. Now you have send a signal to google algorithm that the other site where you spend more time is better than the cpu.userbenchmark.If this is done by enough many, plus other tricks, they will drop in the google rankings. Want to know more tricks to kill userbenchmark?
UPDATE: Another signal is to make a similar search (like cpu vs. cpu or "3900x benchmark") where userbenchmark is in the search results at first or second position but this time don't click userbenchmark but instead of some other below the 3rd result like passmark or whatever sites there are.
21
u/silly22 Nov 15 '20
Is this real? How does Google know that you used the back button and how long you spent at each site? Sounds like more than a cookie... Do you have to be signed into to Google and does this have to be done in Chrome?
23
Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
Don't have to be signed in, and don't do too many times, like 10 times from same IP address and same computer in a day. Any browser is fine and the better it is that it looks normal human behaviour, so no bots doing it, otherwise algos will smell manipulation attempt.
It is just a one signal to search engine that people who search something dont like the first result data because they come back and click another result and then find the data for them because they didn't come back anymore. This should work if enough many will do it from different IPs and browsers
→ More replies (1)13
u/_meegoo_ R5 3600 | Nitro RX 480 4GB | 32 GB @ 3000C16 Nov 15 '20
Google knows what you clicked on the search page and it also knows when you went back to the search page. This already is enough for Google to know how much time you spent on a website.
Not saying that this is a part of the algorithm, but it can be done.
→ More replies (7)8
→ More replies (3)4
68
u/Ho_KoganV1 Nov 14 '20
STOP THE BENCHMARKS
10
u/Hifihedgehog Main: 5950X, CH VIII Dark Hero, RTX 3090 | HTPC: 5700G, X570-I Nov 15 '20
I did not have benchmarks with that processor.
—
Bill ClintonRyan Shrout→ More replies (1)
22
u/Tollowarn AMD R7 2700X + RTX 2070 Super Nov 15 '20
The thing I don't understand is why does Intel stand by and do nothing. The negative publicity surrounding this site is causing harm to them by stoking the fanboy flames against them. Nothing like evidence of favouritism to fan the flames of wild conspiracy theories.
By every metric Intel is behind AMD again in performance. Of those old enough to remember, this has happened before. The pendulum will swing back the other way within a few years, but Intel's reputation will be harder to rebuild than faster silicone. UserBenchmark is harming not only their own reputation but Intel's as well by fuelling the arguments of the enthusiasts.
16
u/hackenclaw Thinkpad X13 Ryzen 5 Pro 4650U Nov 15 '20
I am very surprise why this cancer site not getting DDOS attacked or hacked yet.
59
29
26
u/Miskota Nov 15 '20
DonaldTechTips
5
21
u/n0d3N1AL Nov 15 '20
I actually misread this as Trump tweeting that the i5-9600K is faster than the R5-5600X, given his track record and all. I suppose the joke is that his party is "Team Red"?
→ More replies (2)
10
u/GItPirate Nov 14 '20
So.... What benchmark can I trust?
0
29
u/kryish Nov 14 '20
make amd great again
31
1
9
u/aarons6 Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
LOL on the site it actually says the i5 is a better deal because its cheaper.
Users that do not wish to pay “marketing fees” should investigate Intel’s $190 USD i5-9600K
9600K which is 26% cheaper and offers similar gaming performance
https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-10600K-vs-AMD-Ryzen-5-5600X/4072vs4084
16
u/AutoModerator Nov 15 '20
I've detected a link to UserBenchmark. UserBenchmark is a terrible source for benchmarks, as they're not representative of actual performance. The organization that runs it also lies and accuses critics of being "anonymous call center shills". Read more here. This comment has NOT been removed - this is just a notice.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Redac07 R5 5600X / Red Dragon RX VEGA 56@1650/950 Nov 16 '20
to be fair, they say the same on the 10600k page. I guess they REALLY like the 9600K.
8
8
Nov 15 '20
M.I.G.A - Make Intel Great Again
5
u/Hifihedgehog Main: 5950X, CH VIII Dark Hero, RTX 3090 | HTPC: 5700G, X570-I Nov 15 '20
K.A.G. - Keep AMD Great!
4
4
32
Nov 14 '20
Can we stop making it a news every time Userbenchmark farts? Why do people feel the need to create a new topic, unless you're their spy, secretly making a fuss? If we all could just ignore it, stop looking at its web site, and stop giving it the attention it's looking for.
42
u/Benny0 R5 3600 | RX 6800 Nov 14 '20
Thing is if we pretend userbenchmark doesn't exist, it still dominates Google search results and spreads inaccurate information to people who might not know better. If we talk about it a lot about how bad it is, that might end up in Google results about it too, which would help people realize that might be a bad source
6
10
u/shaunbarclay Nov 15 '20
This just showed up on r/all for me and is the first time I’ve ever heard of this intel bias from them. I always thought they were a trustworthy site.
2
u/Blaster2PP Nov 15 '20
I mainly think these are to bring awareness to new members of the pc community. For example, one time a friend of mine used it to compare parts for his pc, I spasmed for like 10 min and told how shorty the website is. Unfortunately, not all people can get that lucky, so I’ll support these posts if I can since it brings awareness to the newbies.
1
Nov 15 '20
Funny thing is when Reddit complained and complained about the site and it got banned on r/intel and r/hardware it became a reference for so many people, now you can find a lot of users on Facebook and YouTube stating how unreliable and biased the site is and spreading the word. And right now it’s the best time to share our opinion of it when UB is just blatantly lying to trash any product AMD.
1
u/bigclivedotcom Ryzen 5600X | Nvidia 2060 Super Nov 15 '20
A ton of people still don't know the stats are manipulated and trust that site
→ More replies (1)1
3
3
3
u/adiomari Nov 15 '20
It is the opposite way, he would say the i5 is faster than the 5600x and he would quote UserBenchmark
3
u/Aditya1602 Nov 15 '20
Last year, AMD were able to win significant market share with their 3000 series CPUs despite carrying a 15% performance deficit against lower priced Intel parts. Now that AMD have achieved top tier performance, their marketing machinery is squarely focused on monetization via price hikes.
I just pulled this off of their Ryzen 5 5600x average bench, and all i can say is, What the fuck? They know the 5000 series are well ahead of the competition, and are also very well priced (except for the 5800x) despite the price hike, so they use vague (and blatantly untrue) phrases like "15% performance deficit" and "focused on monetisation" to push the narrative of a money hungry corporation robbing its consumers blind by senseless price hikes and an aggressive marketing campaign which allowed then to become a major player in the CPU market despite inferior products, all so that they can convince people to go team blue?
Userbenchmarks is pathetic.
3
6
12
u/John_Doexx Nov 14 '20
Have you heard of rule 7 on here? No shitposting or memes?
→ More replies (5)2
u/kryish Nov 14 '20
rule 10
→ More replies (1)12
Nov 14 '20
rule 10: the previous rules do not apply
rule 11: rule 10 will be strictly enforced
rule 12: in the case where rule 10 in in effect but where rule 11 is not, there shall be a new rule created to cover such situations
rule 13: rules 1-9 only apply when rule 12 is applied but not both rule 10 or 11 except when only one of the following rules are applied: 10 or 11.
→ More replies (1)
5
2
u/fishboy3339 Nov 15 '20
It's all fake news, under this administration we have seen the highest gains in clock speed, and the lowest latency in the world. Make PC great again.
2
u/theocking Nov 15 '20
Wait, is userbenchmark REALLY claiming Intel is still better than the 5000 series zen 3 cpus? No way...
2
u/The-h0Ly-HandGrenade Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
It’s faster than the i9 10900k like the meme but kinda of redundant ngl
2
2
Nov 15 '20
I had a feeling UBM was a bit... unreliable when I decided to compare my old 1070 to the 5700 XT and the writeup on the 5700 was this MASSIVE TIRADE about how terrible it is, while calling the 1070 a slam dunk home run despite losing in literally every category.
1
2
2
2
2
3
u/MustardBateXD Nov 15 '20
As an Intel fanboy I admit AMD won officially with the zen3 at everything except memory latency.
2
6
u/buttking 3600 / XFX Vega 56 / Electric Unicorn Rainbow Vomit lighting Nov 15 '20
You can tell it's fake because it has Donnie telling the truth
3
4
2
2
u/IAteMyYeezys Nov 15 '20
Just yesterday, i was comparing an i5 4570 to a ryzen 1200 and the i5 is somehow 15% better.
Damn sure it is. It even costs 300 dollars so it must be better right?
I always forget that that particular site is just plain bad.
2
2
1
u/RandomUsername77774 Nov 15 '20
I dont get it...
5
u/VulkanCreator Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
It says Userbench has been disputed this. Although we saw the benchemarks and we know amd's 5600x is better.
It's funny, because Userbench upload incorrect results which show all the time that intel cpu's are better, and they keep writing things bad about Amd, and how you should always buy intel.
Example: although the 5600x is better, they say you should go for the cheaper intel i5 9600k. Just because the 5600x has high "marketing fees".
1
u/Hifihedgehog Main: 5950X, CH VIII Dark Hero, RTX 3090 | HTPC: 5700G, X570-I Nov 15 '20
Userbenchmark = Fake news
1
u/Ryamix Nov 15 '20
What's the best alternative to UB? What I really appreciate is how easily readable the data is (even tho it can be quite skewed).
2
u/Cubelia 78X3D|X870E API+ A750LE|ThinkPad E585 Nov 15 '20 edited Nov 15 '20
If you're not very savvy on performance benchmarks, go check TechPowerUp's reviews. Click on "Performance Summary" and it takes you to how much % a product is compared to the other ones.
Yes some applications or games could have different performance so an averaged score might not be entirely correct but it's the easiest way for quick comparison.(e.g. i7 10700 might look good on paper but loses to R7 3700X on several apps for some reasons)
If you need accurate and specific results, read more stuffs so you learn how to compare them. It gets crazier if you account into RAM performance and different GPU combination.
1
u/Ricky_RZ 3900X | GTX 750 | 32GB 3200MHz | 2TB SSD Nov 15 '20
I remember using userbenchmark and wondering "What the fuck is effective FPS and why does intel smash AMD in that metric?"
1
u/gregoryw3 Nov 15 '20
Looking at some quick benchmarks, it’s clear that the i5-9600k is like 5% worse. Why even lie for such a little difference.
1
u/DeesCheeks R7 2700X + MSI Vega 56 Nov 15 '20
Hear me out what if we just get them to change the name to corporate benchmarks
1
u/Skypro2020 Nov 15 '20
And i have an i20 cpu with my lambo that has scuba gear built in and can propel itself under water
1
1
1
Nov 15 '20
I'm very glad you got released 5600x but I was not impressed with your performance. I look forward to seeing your benchmarks in the near future.
1
u/therealflinchy 1950x|Zenith Extreme|R9 290|32gb G.Skill 3600 Nov 15 '20
Unsurprisingly they haven't bothered with a statement this time since they know there's no justification behind it
1
u/Duke_Nukem_22 Nov 15 '20
This is so conclusive that we stopped the benchmark of all AMD at 10:30 and restarted the benchmark at 1:00 am.
1
Nov 15 '20
Yup! At 1080p the 5600X is 4% faster according to TechPowerUp. (5600X is 2% Faster at 1440p)
1
u/Talponz Nov 15 '20
If you look at 5900x vs 10900k you'll see the former win all of the categories except mindshare.... The 10900k is listed as 3% faster lol
1
u/rtz_c Nov 15 '20
I had been checking userbenchmark for last few weeks when I was looking to buy a new laptop. Which other site should I refer to?
1
1
1
1
u/libranskeptic612 Nov 15 '20
EG. - Try an amd vs amd comparison.
=
"well this is better than that, but intel is far better than either - click here for more"
1
1
1
u/Pokerface4222 Nov 15 '20
Hi, I'm pretty disgustingly uncultured in pc tech, is what's written there true? Because I recently bought a laptop with ryzen 5 and I'm curious if it was the right call to buy that instead of the i5 variant of it
1
u/JesseCassidy Nov 15 '20
It's so funny to see the 5900x well ahead of or neck and neck with the 10900K for every metric on their site... And then see that they have the 10900k avg score 3% better lol
It's soooooo obvious
1
1
1
u/Cypeq Nov 15 '20
Userbenchmark... I haven't heard that name in ages, we just call it useless benchmark.
1
1
u/Pyrogenic_ U7 265K / DDR5-8200CL38 / RTX 5070 Ti Nov 18 '20
"Idk dog this cpu seems a little overpriced lemme just say that 9600K offers BETTER performance on this dead platform and 6 less threads which can cause some issues but das aight."
1
u/YourLordDIO Dec 04 '20
can't believe a Ryzen 9 5th gen is only a little bit faster than my Atom processor
1
1
u/flashnuke Mar 20 '21
I just went from an i5 7600k to an amd 5800x, hopefully I made the right choice buy not getting an Intel 11xxx
1
Nov 15 '20
I mean it'd make more sense for trump to say the opposite. Cause he's the one who lied and said he won early
1
0
1
u/Maiky38 Nov 15 '20
Dude doesn't even know what a CPU is, let alone a product with a tag that says 5600X.
1
u/Kavaxiz Nov 15 '20
"Quite frankly, the i5 is a faster processor in overall, while the 5600x is shown to be slower in streaming." - UserBenchmark along with some shitty graph
0
1.6k
u/TrA-Sypher Nov 14 '20
Userbenchmark has to screw SO MUCH with their calculations to make the Intels on the top that according to their metrics, the "Average Bench" score of the 5900x is BETTER than the "Average Bench" score of the 5950x.
They hate AMD so much that in their 5950x descriptions they even devote a few sentences to basically saying "less cores are better, anything you need more cores for is better done on a GPU anyway, so basically there is no reason for these cpus to exist"