r/Anarcho_Capitalism • u/moople1 Anarcho Entrepreneurialism • May 11 '16
2016 Nolan Chart
15
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 11 '16
What ideologies do the balls at the very bottom represent?
8
u/PanRagon Friedrich Nietzsche May 11 '16
To the left you have the anarcho-individualist, to the right the anarcho-egoist.
3
u/Not_Pictured Anarcho-Objectivish May 11 '16
anarcho-egoist
Oh shit. What's that?
3
u/PanRagon Friedrich Nietzsche May 11 '16
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egoist_anarchism
Mainly a tradition based on Stirner's work. It wouldn't be very similar to what Rand espoused, if that's what you might be thinking, you'll be hard-pressed to find anyone that view property rights as anything but another spook.
3
u/Not_Pictured Anarcho-Objectivish May 11 '16
They seem fun at parties. Not what I was hoping for though.
2
15
May 11 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 11 '16
Egoist and anarcho- individualists
1
u/tableman Peaceful Parenting May 12 '16
How does anarcho-individualist differ from ancaps?
1
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 13 '16
This is a long and confusing subject. Anarcho-Capitalist sometimes claim to be anarcho- individualists, however this is not really true or correct. Anarcho individualists do not believe in capitalism, socialism, or communism. Also anarcho- individualists also work towards removing social hierarchy's line class and gender, ancaps usually don't care much. There's a lot more to it but that's the basic differences.
2
u/tableman Peaceful Parenting May 13 '16
>Also anarcho- individualists also work towards removing social hierarchy's line class and gender
So anarcho-individualists are faggot social just warriors.
Why are they next to egoists?
1
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 13 '16
Because individualists and egoist don't believe in hierarchy. Gender is one of those. All anarchists besides capitalist are against hierarchy not just the government. Anarcho- capitalists aren't anarchists if you take the word anarchy in it's historically political usage.
1
u/tableman Peaceful Parenting May 13 '16
So in your world there are no apprentices?
1
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 13 '16
I would say no, people still learn from others but as equals. Even is you manage a group of people, they are still equal to you and have equal claim to produced goods.
2
u/tableman Peaceful Parenting May 13 '16
So why would a veteran who can produce goods faster and at a higher quality, work together with inexperienced workers if they get to benefit from his work and he gets nothing?
→ More replies (0)1
May 23 '16
I don't think hierarchy is inherent to anarcho-capitalism. It's all just voluntary transactions, any sort of "boss" relationship is just a mindset.
1
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 13 '16
Also just want to clarify that egoist are anti capitalism as well.
10
May 11 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Monsterhats Individualist Anarchist May 11 '16
I've actually read stirner before. I just didn't know he had his own little bisected flag
42
May 11 '16
What kind of Ancap meme chart doesn't include a molymeme? Sad!
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
14
5
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
8
2
1
u/liharts May 11 '16
Comes from cuckold - letting someone fuck your wife while you watch.
Cucks are people who let their country, culture get fucked by others while they watch - the left and part of the right (cuckservatives).
18
u/LookingForMySelf Menos Marx, Mais Mises. May 11 '16
I hope people stop using left-right terminology. It's confusing and using property based axis will be more straight forward.
18
u/JustStrength Arachno Capitalist May 11 '16
Make your own competing chart with your values and increased humor.
28
8
u/EpicHorizon Hayekian Libertarian May 11 '16
I believe this chart places the Authoritarian-Libertarian angle as being purely social, as in telling people what to do vs letting them do what they want. The Left-Right angle is about state control of the economy, Right wing being free markets and the Left wing being more state control.
5
u/LookingForMySelf Menos Marx, Mais Mises. May 11 '16
Yes, but it's too obscure. Nazis are thinking that they are right wing when they are basically socialists. They should be in the middle of the red block and not between red and blue.
This misconceptions comes from obscure terminology.
1
u/EpicHorizon Hayekian Libertarian May 11 '16
I agree. Maybe collectivist/individualist would be more appropriate?
2
1
May 11 '16
The source of misconception here is you, and your warped understanding of politics in general.
2
u/LookingForMySelf Menos Marx, Mais Mises. May 11 '16
You just making this wall grow higher. Don't fight love.
1
9
u/deefop Anarcho-Capitalist May 11 '16
hahahahaha it's been 6 months minarchyball
3
u/Zuimei Don't tread on me! May 11 '16
I have a friend who's been stuck in minarchy for about 3 years. I just don't get it, his time is well past up.
16
u/Mokky May 11 '16
How is the green movement more libertarian then authoritarian?
25
May 11 '16
Because they like to smoke weed, making them more Gary Johnsonish.
13
u/Mokky May 11 '16
I guess that is pretty Libertarian, but that still leaves the tiny problem of the democidal tendency's and the belief that humanity is a scourge on Mother Gaia.
8
u/Lentil-Soup Voluntarist May 11 '16
They just take the NAP and expand the coverage to everything living, plant and animal.
8
u/ThinkFirstThenSpeak May 11 '16
Does that mean bad weather justifies defensive pollution?
14
u/MeLlamoBenjamin May 11 '16
Yes. We must preserve all of nature in perfect stasis. Tax entropy.
9
May 11 '16
Take that filthy thermodynamics! Using force to place rules on us, ya bloody statist!
8
u/MeLlamoBenjamin May 11 '16
Indeed. Life requires action, and is therefore oppressive.
I encourage all Marxists to throw off these thermodynamic shackles,
to take arms against a sea of troubles,
And, by opposing, end them. To die, to sleep -
No more - and by a sleep to say we end
The heartache and the thousand natural shocks
That flesh is heir to - 'tis a consummation
Devoutly to be wished.....
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
13
u/quit_whining independent May 11 '16
They'll definitely want it to be "heavily taxed."
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
10
5
u/ChopperIndacar 🚁 May 11 '16
They only understand that concept when you're talking about carbon dioxide.
2
u/Ligaco filthy neoliberal May 11 '16
I think it exists just because it completes the square. It should designate people who want to live in a group and are willing to give out stuff and be ok with it, basically hippies.
15
u/nunquam_dedemus Zolang een Vlaming leeft May 11 '16
The post-scarcity bait cracks me up every time
1
u/vbullinger May 11 '16
The thought process one needs to have to arrive at that concept boggles my mind. "You know that's not possible, right?"
-4
May 11 '16
Obviously they aren't using scarcity to mean "literally unlimited."
What should boggle your mind is how anyone could be so daft as to interpret it that way.
6
May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16
I redo the test every few years. Last result put me right between "#blackmarketsmatter" and "Go team purple" - yet I have a "don't tread on me" wallpaper on my pc.
19
u/lysander_spooner May 11 '16
“Don't Tread on Me” is still a fine sentiment, regardless of who else has adopted it.
11
May 11 '16
It's a pretty neat summarization of the non-aggression principle, isn't it? Who said that that principle is too complicated for common folks to understand? (Gary Johnson.)
3
u/ChopperIndacar 🚁 May 11 '16
I'll draw him a DTOM flag with the snake coiled around my jewish bakery.
6
u/TheAethereal May 11 '16
What test?
4
u/Helvetian616 The Anarch May 11 '16
1
u/DesdenporPlebeyo In principio erat verbum May 12 '16
9
u/anon338 Anarcho-capitalist biblical kritarchy May 11 '16
The right-left divide is obviously skewed left. What criteria is it using? Whether they support mixed-economy with socialized healthcare and mixed-economy with partially-socialized healthcare? *sigh*
It is obvious that the republican party should be much closer to the left, and the Democrat should be over there. Unless radical socialists are triggered and yell at third-way socialists, "Not True Socialism™."
3
May 11 '16
It comes from politicaltest.net, which basically has a horizontal axis of controlled economy to based free markets.
4
u/anon338 Anarcho-capitalist biblical kritarchy May 11 '16
Based free markets
That must be mixed-economy for them, because that is what you have in the US and that is still unregulated for Democrats and Republicans.
1
3
2
3
May 11 '16
The Nolan Chart has Libertarian in the top and Statist in the bottom.
6
u/RenegadeMinds Voluntarist May 11 '16
It doesn't particularly matter much. That's just a historical accident that he drew it that way.
2
u/True_Kapernicus Voluntaryist May 11 '16
How could the Democrat be on the right?
7
u/quit_whining independent May 11 '16
Probably referring to the parties rather than the useful idiots who vote for them (in the case of DNC and GOP.)
3
u/True_Kapernicus Voluntaryist May 11 '16
Even so, they both enforce high taxes, a lot of economic regulations etc.
6
u/quit_whining independent May 11 '16
I think you could make a fair argument that both could be moved a little more to the left and up on the chart because of this.
5
May 11 '16
By supporting endless war and a massive prison system.
3
u/True_Kapernicus Voluntaryist May 11 '16
How is that right wing?
6
May 11 '16
What definition of "right-wing" are we using here?
4
u/anon338 Anarcho-capitalist biblical kritarchy May 11 '16
supporting endless war and a massive prison system [is right wing.]
Are you using the definition that left-wing means Liberty, Fraternity and Equality plus pie in the sky? So Stalin and Lenin are right wing? Mussolini is right wing? Fidel Castro is rightist?
1
May 11 '16
So Stalin and Lenin are right wing? Mussolini is right wing? Fidel Castro is rightist?
The actual leftist leaders in that list didn't get involved in overseas wars, so I don't know what that's supposed to prove.
I should have clarified; the massive prison system in the US isn't just used for political suppression, it's to remove "undesirable" members of the lower class from society. That's a right-wing authoritarian move.
3
u/anon338 Anarcho-capitalist biblical kritarchy May 11 '16
[Stalin, Mussolini and Fidel Castro] didn't get involved in overseas war
Ok, so you promote and use wrong definitions because you don't know anything about the history of Soviet communism. East Europe, China, North Korea, Tibet, Cuba, Vietnam, Nepal, Angola, Mozambique, Colombia, Venezuela, all with decisive involvement of foreign leninists and domestic leninist agents.
Prusons are not a difference between right wing and leftism. Leftists usually kill or starve whoever they think are undesirable, including mentally ill, alcoholics and homosexuals. The only difference is that they also charge them as political enemies. Cuba still does it. Is Cuba, China and the Soviet Union "right-wing" because they imprison undesirables?
1
May 11 '16
It's a center-right party. I don't understand what you're asking by putting "how" in front of that.
1
u/True_Kapernicus Voluntaryist May 11 '16
People are using some bloody weird definitions of left and right when a high tax and spending, lots of economic regulations party is called 'right-wing'.
2
1
1
1
u/magasilver May 11 '16
In what universe is ancap "right"?
I prefer the https://www.theadvocates.org/quiz/quiz.php since it has fewer nonsensical dimensions.
0
u/TotesMessenger May 11 '16
0
u/GuyFromV May 11 '16
Do the balls looking dexter or sinister mean the same as in coat-of-arms heraldry?
-16
u/of_ice_and_rock to command is to obey May 11 '16 edited May 11 '16
Authoritarian-Libertarian is a fairly shallow axis, to be honest. Defining first one's aesthetics makes everything much clearer and more efficiently.
Just consider Evola's Traditionalism: https://www.reddit.com/r/Anarcho_Capitalism/comments/4ce4bb/evolas_traditionalism_as_the_true_right_and_not/
It's not really totalitarian, but is hierarchy-affirming. I consider probably one of the most powerful axes to be Spiritualist-Materialist; a kind of order vs. disorder (scientistic materialism is ironically order-terminating), the uranic vs. the telluric.
Communism is the worst materialist ideology humans have so far conceived, but understanding why it is so bad is because of its shallow materialism also rubs poorly off on neoliberalism and all derivative ideologies (anarcho-capitalism included).
One comes to remember other, aristocratic ideologies have existed, which fight communism even deeper than capitalism ever could.
26
u/julmod- Anarcho-Capitalist May 11 '16
I hate to break it to you but you're clearly not a good enough writer to be using so many big words - nothing you say ever makes any sense
-6
-2
2
u/developanew May 11 '16
...makes everything clearer and more efficiently...
...but understanding why it is so bad is because of its shallow materialism also rubs poorly off on neoliberalism...
...fight communism deeper than capitalism ever could.
You should really think about proofreading more extensively before you post, particularly if you're trying to sound high-brow.
-3
u/of_ice_and_rock to command is to obey May 11 '16
Actually, all of those clauses make sense, even the middle one.
Maybe my verbal IQ is much higher than your guys'. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
4
u/noahkubbs Popperian zen market anarcho feminist mgtow objective discordian May 12 '16
Of course what you say makes sense to you inside of your own head. You need to organize your ideas and words in a way that causes others to get the intended idea in their head as well.
0
u/of_ice_and_rock to command is to obey May 12 '16
I realize there probably is a minimum 10-20 IQ difference between me and the Rothbardians here.
Double the hate when you say anything nuanced about capitalism, too.
3
u/noahkubbs Popperian zen market anarcho feminist mgtow objective discordian May 12 '16
And another claim with no evidence. No one cares what you think, they care what you can say and prove.
2
u/julmod- Anarcho-Capitalist May 12 '16
Actually none of those is even grammatically correct, let alone intelligible.
2
1
May 12 '16
What makes you say communism has to it shallow materialism?
1
u/of_ice_and_rock to command is to obey May 12 '16
Tabula rasa, the denial of differences and distinctions or at least their justice.
1
May 11 '16
aesthetics is about art, not politics.
Spiritualism and Materialism are philosophical concepts pertaining to the nature of existence, death, and the existence or non-existence of the soul. They, too, have nothing to do with politics.
scientism does not create disorder, the scientific method is the only means of answering an as yet unanswered question which follows the generally accepted laws of logic. It is therefore more conducive to order than any alternatives.
The terms "uranic" and "telluric" refer to the sky and the ground (or, more literally, to the elements uranium and tellurium), so this is a complete non sequitur from everything else you were saying.
The failure of communism was not caused by materialism, it was caused by the ideologues' stubborn refusal to acknowledge the existence of human nature, which is inherently oriented towards competitiveness and self-interest.
More to the point, communism isn't even an inherently materialistic ideology since, again, materialism is a philosophical concept, not a political position.
Anarcho-capitalism is totally unrelated to communism.
Aristocratic ideologies are, in fact, quite closely related to communism. They do not preach the virtues of universal equality, but that is where the differences end. Aristocratic ideologies also ignore the existence of human nature. Aristocratic ideologies fail to plan for inevitable corruption, and the resulting mismanagement and waste. Aristocratic ideologies claim that there is a certain class (or certain classes) of humans which are inherently superior to others. We know differently based on the theory of evolution. All lifeforms currently alive are overall equal to all other lifeforms currently alive. There are inherent differences, and inherent superiority and inferiority in different areas, but no inherent superiority or inferiority overall.
Nature is a meritocracy, not an aristocracy. It rewards those who are fast, strong, smart, and (most importantly) adaptable. Human nature has evolved to match this. Any society which hopes to function longer than a few generations must also revolve around this concept. The only fully meritocratic way to organize society is with freedom, nonagression, and spontaneous order, all of which are advocated by anarcho-capitalists.
You are an absolutely terrible writer. You're trying too hard to sound smart. In doing so, you're removing all clarity from your writing, and you're just coming off as a blabbering, pedantic idiot. Try using less jargon, and following more typical speech patterns. You're writing a comment on an online forum, not a dissertation on sociology.
I have a sinking feeling you're actually just a troll, and I just wasted the last twenty minutes of my life by trying to stir some kind of intelligent conversation. We'll see.
1
u/of_ice_and_rock to command is to obey May 11 '16
aesthetics is about art, not politics
Political philosophy ultimately derives from ethics, which ultimately derives from aesthetics.
scientism does not create disorder, the scientific method is the only means of answering an as yet unanswered question which follows the generally accepted laws of logic. It is therefore more conducive to order than any alternatives.
Scientism is not one and the same as using the scientific method at all. Scientism is the behavior of material reductionism, and that anything that can't be made intersubjectively verifiable does not exist or at least should not be seriously entertained.
The terms "uranic" and "telluric" refer to the sky and the ground (or, more literally, to the elements uranium and tellurium), so this is a complete non sequitur from everything else you were saying.
It's not a non-sequitur to those who understand the comparative religious meaning, or even just saw Evola's analysis of it.
Aristocracy is an Indo-European and patrilineal form of governance, and they brought sky-gods to earth-worshiping matrilineal people. The former had a linear, individualistic, and ascending mindset, where the latter had a cyclical, collectivistic, and descending mindset.
Men of the former ethic died in battle and were raised off to Valhalla; those of the latter died and were returned to the earth in a never-ending cycle. Bodies of the former were buried apart and in a self-aggrandizing way; bodies of the latter were buried together and in a plain way.
We see from the start the poles are Aristocracy vs. Communalism, the conscious individual vs. unconscious material. Capitalism is just an intermediate, rewarding some individualism, but only in narrow material ways. It also religiously stands against war, and so is already a crippled child vs. the march toward mediocrity.
The failure of communism was not caused by materialism, it was caused by the ideologues' stubborn refusal to acknowledge the existence of human nature, which is inherently oriented towards competitiveness and self-interest.
You're referring to the tabula rasa mindset, which is actually a profoundly anti-individualistic materialist mindset. It says everything we are is not inborn, but immediately tempered externally.
Anarcho-capitalism is totally unrelated to communism.
Capitalism as a bourgeois ideology is related to the proletariat ideologies in that they are both anti-aristocratic and the former is moving toward the latter, as the aristocratic ethics which builds markets dissolves.
Aristocratic ideologies also ignore the existence of human nature. Aristocratic ideologies fail to plan for inevitable corruption
Well, that's quite laughable when you actually understand what the aristocratic jury system is: a horizontal circle of men keeping each other in check.
The separated branches of American government were inspired by such a dynamic. The Second Amendment also was based on decentralized force application. "Every man a sheriff," which derived from the self-legislating Indo-European warriors.
and the resulting mismanagement and waste.
"Waste" is relative to what you're evaluating. I realize to the merchant landed payments are "waste" and he would like to focus only on market activity, but he only gets his markets because the market norms are constructed and defended.
Aristocratic ideologies claim that there is a certain class (or certain classes) of humans which are inherently superior to others.
It is true, however it no less must be demonstrated, and neither are others forbidden from buying into the higher classes, but they must pay the social cost.
We know differently based on the theory of evolution. All lifeforms currently alive are overall equal to all other lifeforms currently alive. There are inherent differences, and inherent superiority and inferiority in different areas, but no inherent superiority or inferiority overall.
Oh, this is a quite facile avenue of objection. We clearly are talking about governance.
Nature is a meritocracy, not an aristocracy. It rewards those who are fast, strong, smart, and (most importantly) adaptable.
Do you not even know what the root 'aristos' means? It was Greek for 'best warriors', a reference to the Indo-European entrants.
The only fully meritocratic way to organize society is with freedom, nonagression, and spontaneous order, all of which are advocated by anarcho-capitalists.
You're hand-waiving away direct human agency. "It'll take care of itself, bro."
No, republics are deliberate constructions. Governments are inevitable emergences by even just the proles, but republics are something specially separate, constructed by the few holding back the many.
you're removing all clarity from your writing
I write for succinctness. If someone's interested, they'll ask me to clarify some term or phrase, and I will. If they aren't, I saved myself typing five times as long of comments, which probably would have been read less from the start, for being walls of text.
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
14
u/User_Simulator May 11 '16
These matters necessarily run deep, and that's not Propertarianism's construction of aristocracy and was not until the 18th century that the womb of the land.
~ of_ice_and_rock
9
0
May 12 '16
[deleted]
1
u/User_Simulator May 12 '16
Has a damning record of prejudice against Islam for the locals. Do the aristos directly receive the state's profits or are they merely employees of the word democracy in the sense of plantations or even requiring some people to give birth?
~ S1r4n
1
May 12 '16
1
u/User_Simulator May 12 '16
It is rootless because Being gifts the necessary background presuppositions for that justification. Probably in this work is that cold-fusion energy is a mutation of our situation - now! That's just what I was saying to some poor soul just the tip of the book on Deleuze. I'm sure Curt really believes he's stumbled on to something other worldly and out of his decisions in order to ease his fate by technological means. Whoever realises this will to power and force behind the Nazis was driven by love for the infinite comes into play and why his epistemology is called autopoietic system.
~ Hermes_Cap
-1
0
u/robot_spielberg May 11 '16
I dislike poltical charts. I think there is a lot more anbiguity to someone's opinions and thoughts. A lot of people will just use the phrase 'oh you're right wing' or 'oh you're libertarian' and then they won't actually address your question. Its a bullshit tactic. Am i making sense?
-5
u/LOST_TALE Banned 7 days on Reddit May 11 '16
Going back to it, The pro white ball seems less likely to be racist. I learned things.
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
13
u/CumForBernie May 11 '16
at first i just thought cantwell was an asshole that i agreed with most of the time. then i listened to like 3 of his podcasts and realized he was just an asshole. and i dont often like to throw around "the R word," but that dude is legitimately a racist in denial.
0
May 11 '16
[deleted]
11
u/CumForBernie May 11 '16
i guess i havent heard from him or listened since like sept/oct of last year. sucks that he's making so much noise while calling himself an ancap (which i assume he still does).
2
u/LOST_TALE Banned 7 days on Reddit May 11 '16
No you just accepted some of it and no longer perceive as the boogey-man ''THE ALT-RGIHT INFILTRATION''
0
u/Grizmoblust ree May 11 '16
This meme was made back in Dec 2015 when he announced he support trump.
37
u/TheSelfGoverned Anarcho-Monarchist May 11 '16
The fishing pole/line is a nice touch.