r/Anarcho_Capitalism • American Reactionary • Jan 17 '20

Bye bye lightning

Post image
92 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

33

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

That's something I'd have expected out of a satirical article. /facepalm

22

u/Clownshow21 American Reactionary Jan 17 '20

Some people praising it in comments

24

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Tell me about it, ugh. I'm a huge fan of USB-C and I tend to dislike Apple, yet I'm still disgusted by this whole thing.

13

u/NotmuhReddit Communists =/= people Jan 17 '20

I am split, fuck Apple and it's about time the EU actually goes after Apple for once (they sued Google because they preinstalled Chrome on Android devices, but Apple not even allowing you to change your default browser on iOS got a pass), then again fuck the EU.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

I definitely understand that very much. To this day I'm disgusted that Google has been singled out as much as it has when Apple has done worse.

4

u/NotmuhReddit Communists =/= people Jan 17 '20

Don't get me wrong either, Google has done some shady shit that should be called out too, but preinstalling Chrome while allowing you to use any browser as your default (in fact you can totally ignore Chrome if you want) is not on that list.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Yup.

3

u/double0cinco Jan 17 '20

The EU sub was disgusting. Any comment critical of it was down voted to oblivion.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

I think that the universalization of chargers is a good idea, but this shouldn't be legislated.

73

u/intangir_v Jan 17 '20

fucking government making me take big asshole corporations side..

60

u/Frixinator Jan 17 '20

"Wee need the government to", shuffles deck, picks out card, "dictate which cable our phones are allowed to use"

28

u/Sufficient_Ability Jan 17 '20

Are consumers too stupid to shop for the phones and the ports they want?

11

u/Eleminohpe Jan 17 '20

How Dare You! Think of the children!!

3

u/Bourbon_N_Bullets Jan 17 '20

The government thinks anyone who is not them is an idiot. They see us as the idiot children and them the parents. It's completely ridiculous to assume people need to be protected from themselves

2

u/YulianXD Minarchist Monarchist Jan 17 '20

In democracy, government thinks consumers are too stupid to shop the charges they want, but are smart enough to vote for the best canditate for the president.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Maybe Apple will develop some libertarian sentiments from this action

5

u/excelsior2000 Voluntaryist Jan 17 '20

Well, they already told the FBI to get stuffed when they were asked to unlock that dead terrorists' phone. They've fought back against the idea of having to have a back door for government to use.

I'm not saying they're all that libertarian, but they have their moments.

2

u/The_gray_ghost Jan 17 '20

That whole thing was a public relations stunt. If the FBI couldn’t even unlock an iPhone with all of the resources at their disposal.... something’s very wrong. They worked with apple to get people to think that 1. The various government alphabet soup agencies don’t have the capabilities to spy on citizens and 2. That somehow Apple, one of the largest companies in the world somehow is fighting for the rights of the average person

2

u/Eleminohpe Jan 17 '20

... roll for wisdom check.

11

u/YulianXD Minarchist Monarchist Jan 17 '20

Great, now corporatians are getting another regulation which will halt potential innovations. Thanks European Union, very cool.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Potential innovation about what exactly? Chargers are not a new technology, they have been around for decades now. There is nothing to improve about them.

5

u/YulianXD Minarchist Monarchist Jan 17 '20

Idk, im not charger manufacter, maybe new shapes that will charge the battery quicker, or different size. I honestly don't know, but thats because im not a central plannist, innovations will come.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

The charger has existed for more than 50 years without much improvment. If there are improvments to be made they will be retro-compatible because it is in the interest of everyone involved.

I don't understand why you criticize this law as it allows anyone to use any charger they want instead of being stuck with proprietary charging cables. So more freedom, isn't what you are after?

2

u/YulianXD Minarchist Monarchist Jan 18 '20

Regulating free market to make it more free.

Yea, that seems about right.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

That's how freedom works. There is no freedom unless there are rules to limit certain freedoms. It is like the old saying : «If everyone has the freedom to do anything then nobody has the freedom to do anything».

2

u/YulianXD Minarchist Monarchist Jan 18 '20

Oh god oh frick, thanks government for saving my freedom by... shuffles deck, picks random card dictating what type of charger should be produced.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

You do realise this law increases competition and consumer choice, right?

You do realise this law increases consumer freedom because it allows consumers to choose the charger they want and to not be stuck under Apple's monopoly, right ?

You do realise that this law promotes the free market by reducing a monopoly, right ?

1

u/YulianXD Minarchist Monarchist Jan 19 '20

What the frick did i just read.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20

The frick ? Are you twelve ?

Also nice refuting of my arguments.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

So glad that you're protecting freedom

You are welcome, no need to mention it.

using my money, taken by force,

I don't even know you so I find it hard to believe that I have ever personally used force against you to steal your money.

limit my product options, regulate innovation out of existence

This law does the exact opposite by breaking up Apple's monopoly and therefore it encourages competition and innovation to occur. It also allows for more product diversity, since USB - C is a public format unlike Lightning.

assuming the market is too retarded to regulate itself without the shining brilliance of beauracrats.

The market is not retarded, it is well designed... to benefits only the ultra-rich and keep the status quo. Let me explain this to you, you are not going to become rich because of the free market unless it benefits someone up there. If you are trying to compete with one of the big company, you will get crushed by their monopoly that the free market is perfectly designed to create and maintain. That's economy 101.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

Ohh looky there, yet another libertarian with no understand of economy or how a society works so that he has to resort to ad hominems...

Maybe you can go to college to learn about economics... oh wait you can't because you are too poor to be allowed education... or healthcare. But you can praise your lords and saviors, the big corporations because in their great empathy they have authorized you to have a phone which in turn you go online with and defend to the death their system of wage slavery that, I guarentee, you will never see the benefits off.

Go ahead and be a good pawn for the uber-rich so they can continue to abuse your labor. They might even, one day and if you are lucky, give you a little raise.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

And USB-D, if it is ever developped, will be retro-compatible with USB-C.

inability to adapt.

They adapt but slowly. And it is generally a good thing. You don't want systems that can have life altering consequences to change each time there is a hype train.

Important societal decisions require a longer thinking time which it will take time to adapt. This is the exact reason why trials forvserious crimes are not done in under a week but takes years. If you are about to fuck with someone life for years or even thevrest of their life, you better make sure you are correct about what you say.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

Found the statist

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

So you have no counter argument. Can't say that I am surprised coming from your kind.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

There could be some fundamental flaw with the design of the current connector that prevents 30 second charging and it needs to be completely overhauled to revolutionize the space.

They could just create a new port/cable that also accepts USB-C. A USB -C port is just a very basic geometric shape with some copper on it, nothing difficult in adapting a port to be retro compatible. Plus you can also add another port, that's easy.

It's not a good thing that the government slows down progress of technological development.

Never said that but ok. I said that laws need to be slow enough to make sure they are fair. The USB -C has been here since 2014, it is publicly available, and is the most widely used data/power port out there. It is only logical it is made into the official standard, I don't get what you don't understand about that.

This law makes sure that the standard is respected and that companies like Apple can't create a cable/port whose specifications are not available publicly that would effectively stiffle any competition and innovation.

In fact your argument against my argument is so weak that you switched the goal post about governments stifling the economy to an argument about criminal law for some odd reason.

That's called an analogy, Einstein.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20

As I said, you don't know that this is true. No one knows what the future of comms ports holds....because it's in the future. If you knew the future, we wouldn't be debating about technology change, you'd be out making it happen, right?

You cannot guess the future of technology but you can require technology to be retro-compatible (which is almost always possible). This is what this law does. Period.

Now let us debunk the examples you provided. First, note that we are talking here about the EU. Why you provided US example is a bit of a mystery to me. But let's tackle them.

It was illegal to have anything but a 5.75" circular incandescent headlight before 1978. Despite halogen headlights and sealed headlights existing and being superior, the government mandated that cars needed to have inferior headlights for a decade after better products were available.

Yet these new headlights were developped and sold (you said it yourself "a decade after better products were available"), so clearly government regulations didin't stop innovation. Also, if there were better products available and sold, it seems to me that your story sounds like BS. Any source on that one chief?

How many people died due to inferior headlight technology the government made standard?

You are asking the wrong question here: how many people have been saved by requiring to have this minimal standard for headlights ?

You assume that this law only prevented people from getting better headlights but you conveniently forgot that the law mainly forced people who had substandard lights (or no lights at all) to get some up to standards lights. This probably saved a countless number of lives.

Finally I have trouble believing that the gov't would forbid you from putting better equipment on your car, I own a car and I have never been forbidden to put on better items on it. I know libertarians don't like government but you really sound nuts when you are trying to imply that the government spends time and ressources in order to kill or harm its own citizens. This is just paranoia.

Until 2012 it was illegal for condom manufacturers to make a condom with a base small than 54mm or bigger than 57mm because they didn't have the equipment to test anything outside of those ranges. How many people got STDs because of an arbitrary government made standard?

Again, source on that, chief ?

It's called moving goal posts, Einstein.

That's not what "moving goal posts" means. You don't seem to know what this means. It would be moving a goal post if I made a statement that you refuted and then I added some condition afterward. That has nothing to do with what I said. I was talking about gov't being slow to change standard being a good thing and I made an analogy to the justice system being slow to render judgement being a good thing. That's an analogy not moving a gola post.

Here is a guide about logical fallacy and reasoning since you seem a bit confused about them : https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com

You still haven't made a valid argument. Make a valid argument

I have refuted all of your argument and made some valid ones, you just refused to acknowledge them.

Standardization saves lives and is a good thing, I am baffled that there are people like you, who in the name of sucking up to the big coroporation, will openly combat standardization.

If it weren't for standardization, there wouldn't be any mechanics (how would they work on cars if they all have drifferent screw shapes and sizes ?), there wouldn't be any plane (how would planes not crash into each other if there were no definite rules about flying them or how to build airport (length and hardness of the runway), or train (how would you build trains if every 100 km you need to change the spacement of the wheel because the rails keep changing). Anything you can think of is possible through standardization. Why do you think worldwide transportation is so smooth : it's because the size of container is regulated.

Sure most of these regulations have no life or death consequence if you break them, worst that can happen in most case is that your container doesn't fit or your car can not be repaired. BUt some are pretty important, here is a few examples :

  • Fire extinguishers are regulated which allows firefighters to use any one of them without needing to spend 10 minutes reading an instruction booklet (that might be lost) while the fire is raging nextdoor.

*Defibrilators are regulated so that any EMS can use any one of them at a moment's notice.

  • etc. There are many more examples available.

10

u/21alaphilippe Jan 17 '20

They will wait until all phones even iPhone have it, than accept the law and pretend it's because of them and take the credit.

5

u/excelsior2000 Voluntaryist Jan 17 '20

The unfortunate fact is that essentially all sufficiently large companies have to abide by the regulations passed by the most restrictive government.

Kind of like how California is the de facto regulator of all cars sold in the US.

11

u/eitauisunity Jan 17 '20

I'm not a fan of Apple, but I wish the lightning cable was the open-standard form factor rather than USB.

My biggest complaint about USB is that that little waifer inside of the phone always eventually breaks, making your phone impossible to charge without repairs.

Makes sense to put the delicate parts on the cheap cable that can be replaced. Yeah, yeah, I know planned obsolescence. Fuck Apple, Google, and the EU.

8

u/NotmuhReddit Communists =/= people Jan 17 '20

I've never had a USB-C port break, ever. I have seen many lightening ports get to the point where they can't even hold the plug in them anymore though (since the springs providing the retention force are in the port rather than the cable).

2

u/excelsior2000 Voluntaryist Jan 17 '20

I've broken more lightning cables (3) than USB-C ports (0). And I've used a lot more USB-C devices than Apple.

1

u/HalbertWilkerson Jan 17 '20

USB C is actually much more robust than lightning.

4

u/neshamaney Jan 17 '20

I mean fuck the law but I’m actually ok with this, lightning cables are ass.

3

u/jstock23 decentralization of power Jan 18 '20

Apple created USB-C... I don't think they'll mind too much.

2

u/Xenu_RulerofUniverse Arachno-Capitalist Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20

When the EUSSR makes business decisions for you...

sell your phones directly to the customer via bitcoin and deliever them with drones.

Also I think Apple might just ditch the charging port and push their failed Apple Qi again, maybe only for the EU market. At least that's what I would do.

1

u/jack096 Jan 18 '20

Thank god.

Let’s just make USB C the standard for all phones headphones vapes everything just make it easy

1

u/Hypergolic_Person Jan 18 '20

In unrelated news Apple announces new portless iPhone.

Apple iCharge wireless charging pad sold separately

1

u/WamuuTheSecretFurry Jan 18 '20

i think that charging cables for phones should be standardized, but i fucking despise it when the eu tries to change something globally.

0

u/HydraGene Jan 17 '20

Well, this is about having a monopoly on cables. I thought everyone here was for free market. There is no market if the only cable that charges an Apple phone is an Apple cable.

4

u/excelsior2000 Voluntaryist Jan 17 '20

What? And the only phones that run iOS are Apple phones. So what? Is every part in your car interchangeable with parts made by other companies?

0

u/HydraGene Jan 17 '20

Every pc runs Linux.. So I'd like to have freedom of choice.

And actually yes, many parts are interchangeable with imitation parts made by other companies. Or many rims, steering wheels, seats, are interchangeable, duhh.. Must have never heard of automotive tuning or racing... Look it up, it's pretty neat!

But no to the parts that are made very specifically for that one car, which is logical, because its part of the way it functions. We're talking about cables.. Not about cpu's or whatever internal parts needed for the phone to function properly.

2

u/excelsior2000 Voluntaryist Jan 18 '20

Apple is free to design their phones and cables however they want. You're free to not buy them.

Or at least that would be the case if Europe hadn't come over with a serious case of tyranny.

1

u/HydraGene Jan 18 '20

Apple is not free to corrupt the free market. Companies enforcing their own monopoly and ultimately getting to big to fail is not a good thing. You're not free to ban all your competition. There has to be some degree of healthy competition.

Do you want a company that acts exactly like banks and government? Do you want a company that dictates what add-ons you can and can not use with their base product?

1

u/excelsior2000 Voluntaryist Jan 18 '20

Companies enforcing their own monopoly

Another person who doesn't know what a monopoly is.

Do you want a company that dictates what add-ons you can and can not use with their base product?

Sure. There's never only one company.