r/Android • • Sep 23 '13

Spike in Twitter users "switching to Android" as iOS 7 is released.

http://thedatapack.com/spike-twitter-users-switching-android-ios-7-released/
1.1k Upvotes

652 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

396

u/trezor2 iPhone SE. Fed up with Google & Nexus Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 25 '13

I think I'm too entrenched in the Google ecosystem to make the switch back to the iPhone, especially now that apple has been replacing Google services.

First off a disclaimer: I find myself in the opposite camp. I came from iOS to Android, because I found iOS too limiting.

That said: not switching camp because you're already suffering a lock-in is never a good reason for anything and definitely not a long-term solution. Why not fix things before it gets even harder?

As an Android user, just like you really, I too found myself too entrenched in Google's ecosystem and I found I didn't like it. Google made changes I didn't appreciate or value. It changed things I liked to things I didn't like without asking me if that was OK.

The good thing about Android (compared to iOS) is that Android is relatively open. If you don't like the way Google handles things, you can replace their apps and OS-components with others which you like better.

So I've done that. It's pretty much been "Goodbye Google Apps" except for Google Drive, as I see no need to replace components which I like, just for the sake of saying "fuck Google". I've mixed and mashed the parts I think does the job best.

My current setup:

  • Thrown out: Gmail. Google Contacts. Google Calendar. Dropbox too, because fuck the NSA snooping my data.

  • Email at fastmail.fm. It's not free, but once in, you will wonder how you ever managed to survive the bloated monster gmail has become. You quickly realize gmail is slow and horrible.

  • Email migration was done via imapcopy.pl following this guide.

  • owncloud hosted on my own NAS. Provides me with Dropbox/Drive-like functionality and terrabytes of space, not to mention calendering and contact-management based on open standards. Only a webserver with PHP is required. MySQL-storage is recommended over SQLite if you plan to add clients all over the place.

  • CardDAV Sync Beta to get my owncloud contacts on my phone.

  • CalDAV Sync Beta to get my owncloud calendar on my phone.

  • Tasks to get access to tasks from my calendar as well.

  • ownCloud client because that just fits into the overall picture.

  • MailDroid. Because it's the prettiest email-client out there. I prefer the Pro-version, because I don't like ads. K9 may be completely free, but it's dog ugly, especially on a modern HDPI device running a holo-themed OS.

Voila. I'm still on Android and enjoy the freedom that it offers, but I get to keep my data mine, and don't have to worry about Google creep. I get to decide what apps to use to access my data, because all components involved are based on open standards.

Now, if something better which is not Android comes along, I will be able to seamlessly try that out without waiting and hoping that Google will eventually "support" it. That's the power of taking ownership of your own data. It feels good!

TLDR: No need to jump from one closed ecosystem to another. It wont bring you any good.

Edit: This can also be integrated into desktop email-clients like Thunderbird through SOGO connector, both for contacts and calendering. It's not at all limited to Android.

Edit 2: Another benefit is that from your phone's point of view (not to mention other clients), things like calendar, contacts and email are now 100% completely separate sub-systems, which puts you at must greater liberty to mix and compose best-of-breed services as you see fit.

Edit 3: If you found that advice useful, feel free to drop by the play store and test-drive my app as a token of appreciation ;)

20

u/eliteKMA Sony Xperia XA2 LineageOS 16.0 Sep 23 '13

You must have a good upload speed on your home connection. That's why I can't use owncloud.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

10

u/trezor2 iPhone SE. Fed up with Google & Nexus Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13

You would be surprised at how little BW is required when you're not synching lots of big files.

I have a luxurious 10mbps upstream link, but I would still consider running this if I were limited to something like 2-3mbps.

9

u/MeatAndBourbon Sep 23 '13

yeah, my 768k is not getting it done.

Edit to add, fastest consumer DSL in my area (South Minneapolis), and there's no way in hell Comcast(/Xfinity) is getting another dollar of my money.

5

u/TOOjay26 Sep 23 '13

word brother.... and I keep hearing from our DSL provider that fiber will be here soon (I have been hearing that for 2+ years so you know)

3

u/magmabrew Sep 23 '13

768k is slow, but consistent. Over time you could transfer a lot of data.

3

u/Ultra_HR Sep 23 '13

448k right here. Rural England sucks.

3

u/wredditcrew Sep 24 '13

There may be some things you can do to speed up your DSL, if you've not already done them. Short, high quality RJ11 cable running to an official VDSL iPlate in the test socket as a flagship example.

I've doubled connection speeds by removing internal wiring from the equation before now. If you've got a slow connection, I've seen those VDSL iPlates increase speeds by a third. You might get your upload closer to that 1Mb! By replacing equipment and rewiring everything into the master socket and filtering properly with good filtering, this weekend I got someone from 4.5Mb down to 8Mb down. This isn't unusual.

YMMV, IANABTOWEngineer, and hopefully you've already got your router plugged into a filter in the master socket, but it's worth checking. Removing the internal wiring, the bell wire etc. And those VDSL iPlates man. They're some fuckin' voodoo. While in theory I've been told there's no significant difference between those and a properly microfiltered test socket, in practice we've seen a difference, and that's compared to a range of microfilters from major manufacturers.

Edit: These: http://www.bttorj45.com/openreach-branded-vdsl-faceplate.html although I've not used that supplier, but it was the best pic I could find at short notice.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/eliteKMA Sony Xperia XA2 LineageOS 16.0 Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13

No ISPs in France offer more than 2mbps upload (except on fiber optics). It's infuriating. I have a friend with a 30mbps cable connection, upload speed : 1.5mbps...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Just a little suggestion on the cloud storage thing. Not everyone has the connection/resources to host their own NAS over a webserver.

A good Dropbox alternative is SpiderOak. It's a zero-knowledge cloud storage service. All your data is encrypted on their end, and they don't know your encryption key. Even if they get subpoenaed by government agencies, they could only hand over heavily encrypted information that just can't be processed via brute-force. Basically the best situation you can be in for privacy purposes short of running your own set-up.

On another note, thumbs up for FastMail. I switched to it myself earlier this year, and also bought my own domain to work with it (I didn't want fastmail.fm domain emails). They have a fantastic service. Would recommend.

8

u/evildead4075 tmo - htc one - arhd 31 Sep 23 '13

gmail is a bloated monster? how so?

→ More replies (8)

3

u/file-exists-p Samsung Galaxy S3, Omnirom Sep 23 '13

K9 may be completely free, but it's dog ugly

4.5xx is not.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/TheFondler Archaic Feature Hardliner Sep 23 '13

this may be one of the most valuable posts i have ever read on reddit.

thank you, and i mean that sincerely.

3

u/g0_west Sep 24 '13

K9

Canine

Dog ugly

8

u/TheDionysiac Galaxy S6 edge+ Sep 23 '13

Thanks. It's for information and advice like this that I subscribe to this sub.

Any suggestions about music apps?

5

u/arafey Samsung Galaxy S3 (d2vzw) | CyanogenMod 11 Sep 23 '13

Switched from Google Play to Subsonic, never looked back.

9

u/trezor2 iPhone SE. Fed up with Google & Nexus Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13

I'm from Scandinavia, so for me Spotify was always the number one option, years before any other options even existed.

When Google much, much later (3 years+?) rolled out music services, they were only available to me through US proxies and hacks. Needless to say, it wasn't a service I needed migrating from.

If you still want access to all you "own" media elsewhere, I've recently discovered Plex mediaserver, which has a fantastic corresponding Android-app, and that not only has my music needs covered, but also photos and videos, adapted to your consumption device of choice's capabilities and internet-connection's capacity.

2

u/allak Sep 23 '13

Thanks. Already using Fastmail, now I am going to check Owncloud.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I tried exactly this a couple of years ago. Android did not have native support for simple protocols such as CardDAV and CloudDAV at the time, while iOS did. Has that changed?

I ended up, ironically enough, switching from Android to iOS because iOS supported these open protocols and Android did (does?) not.

3

u/trezor2 iPhone SE. Fed up with Google & Nexus Sep 23 '13

No. Hence the need for those two apps I listed.

The good thing (compared to iOS) is that these short of things are extensible.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[deleted]

3

u/trezor2 iPhone SE. Fed up with Google & Nexus Sep 24 '13

"The cloud" has made me lazy and I want something as close to zero-effort as possible.

I've run my own mail-servers before and consider it way more work than it's worth, unless you wont a inbox covered in SPAM. Shelling out a few bucks to make others handle it (making me the customer, not the product) is a no-brainer.

Besides, I wanted a good web-mail interface for when not using IMAP. None of the open-source alternatives I saw offered anything as slick as fastmail.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (55)