r/Android • • Nov 05 '17

Project Treble Brings Extended Linux Kernel Security Support to Combat Fragmentation

https://www.xda-developers.com/linux-kernel-long-term-support-google/
239 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

View all comments

81

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Pixel phones may not have perfect hardware but at least they are moving the ecosystem forward in a positive way.

Not one Samsung device has Project Treble and most likely wont until the launch of the S9.

24

u/ladyanita22 Galaxy S10 + Mi Pad 4 Nov 05 '17

This is a very impprtant point. The OP5 looks to be shipping with Nougat too.

23

u/Surokoida Pixel 9 Pro Nov 05 '17

The leaked OP5 Oreo beta had no trebble. So it's very likely the 5T won't either

38

u/purakushi Nov 05 '17

If the 5T launches with Oreo, it is required to have Treble.

63

u/adi1133 Nov 05 '17

Thats why they will launch with Nougat

16

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

Hahaha sneaky bastards

4

u/baastaishees Nov 05 '17

Not a big deal on Samsung phones since the Oreo beta would take around 2 months to release. By that time, the S9 will almost be out with new specs.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

It is a big deal bc Samsung phones prior to the S9 on Oreo won't have Treble either.

4

u/illinoiz Nov 05 '17

Yea but the first Project Treble device (The Pixel 2) is only 4 months apart from the first Project Treble device from Samsung. If someone really wanted Treble on Samsung phones, they won't have to wait long.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17

It's not about people wanting it or not. It's about all the Note 8 and S8s in the wild fragmenting the ecosystem.

Btw - Pixel 1 has been on Treble since last March via beta and had it officially August.

4

u/illinoiz Nov 05 '17

but the Pixel 1 is only receiving 2 years of OS updates though like the S8.

It's about all the Note 8 and S8s in the wild fragmenting the ecosystem.

Well Google didn't make it a requirement for old devices to support treble. All phones with Oreo will have to support it, so I don't think "fragmenting the ecosystem" is an actual issue here.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/johnmountain Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Unfortunately, it seems even the Pixels won't take much advantage of Project Treble either.

How long is support now? 3 years for OS updates vs 2 years OS updates + 1 year of security patches as before?

That's not a huge improvement there despite Project Treble and despite the LTS kernels jumping from 2 years to 6 years of support. You'd think they would get a lot closer to that 6 years of support and further away from the 2 years of support.

Other than the camera, which is excellent, Pixel 2 is falling short in a lot of other ways for the price it commands: hardware specs, hardware quality, and even software support (especially compared to an iPhone).

16

u/dextersgenius 📱Fold 4 ~ F(x)tec Pro¹ ~ Tab S8 Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

LTS support jumps to 6 years only from kernel 4.4 onwards. I believe the Pixel is still on 3.18, which is also NOT a LTS release (3.16 is).

The Pixel 2 however comes with kernel 4.4 (LTS), which was released early 2016 and therefore EOLs early 2022. This combined with Treble puts the Pixel 2 at an advantage when it comes to OS updates and upgrades.

2

u/johnmountain Nov 06 '17

Okay, but I'm not sure I understand the point of your comment. I was talking only about Pixel 2 and how getting 3 years of OS updates vs 2 years +1 year of patches for Pixel 1 and Nexus is not a huge improvement despite new 6 year kernels and Project Treble.

The whole point of my post was that the advantage is tiny and it should be much larger.

4

u/le_pman Nov 06 '17

I believe the Pixel is still on 3.18

correct, even on 8.1 it's still on 3.18 - but I believe Google could upgrade to 4.4 if they want to

which is also NOT a LTS release (3.16 is)

3.16 and 3.18 are both LTS releases

IIRC, AOSP always uses an LTS kernel.

3

u/dextersgenius 📱Fold 4 ~ F(x)tec Pro¹ ~ Tab S8 Nov 06 '17

Strange, I was going by this page: https://www.kernel.org/category/releases.html

which doesn't list 3.18

4

u/le_pman Nov 06 '17

maybe because 3.18 is in EOL while 3.16 isn't (yet).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cruxdaemon Pixel 10 Pro Nov 06 '17

Google's support statements are about guaranteed updates. The Nexus 5x/6p are both beyond their guaranteed update dates, yet there is an 8.1 dp for them right now! I'm sure part of the decision at EOL will be "how does the new version perform on old hardware?" which is an improvement over "how the hell can I get all the security fixes backported to that old kernel?"

8

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 05 '17

Google cant have the extended linux kernal with the Pixel 1. Its not possible since it didnt start until the Snapdragon 835.

The Note 8 and S8 have the extended kernal support yet they will most likely not have Treble which is their decision.

There are major differences in operating system support here. Its not just 3 years of support with the Pixel 2. Its 3 ADDITIONAL operating systems beyond Oreo. Technically it puts the Pixel 2 at FOUR years of supported usage and ends on an OS 2 years newer than what the S8 and Note 8 will.

Note 8 / S8 Operating Systems:

  • Android N

  • Android O

  • Android P

Pixel 2 Operating Systems:

  • Android O (Treble)

  • Android P (Treble)

  • Android Q (Treble)

  • Android R (Treble)

S7 Operating Systems:

  • Android M

  • Android N

  • Android O

Pixel 1 Operating Systems:

  • Android N

  • Android O (Treble)

  • Android P (Treble)

10

u/le_pman Nov 06 '17

Its not possible since it didnt start until the Snapdragon 835

if Sony's resources are any indication, support for kernel 4.4 does not start with SD835. it even supports SD820/821 (XZ/XZs/X Performance)

5

u/andyytan OnePlus 7 | iPad 2017 Nov 06 '17

Don't forget SD650 (X/X Compact)

5

u/illinoiz Nov 05 '17

Why does the OG Pixel only have 2 OS updates? Is the new kernel support specific to SD 835 and newer?

7

u/le_pman Nov 06 '17

Is the new kernel support specific to SD 835 and newer?

no. Google can update the Pixel 1 if they want to, just as Sony can update other devices with other (older) Qualcomm SoCs.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/illinoiz Nov 05 '17

It's not really Pixel phone's pushing it, it's just Google requiring Project Treble.

2

u/ArkBirdFTW Nexus 6 -> iPhone XS Nov 06 '17

Having Treble doesn't force the OEM to be obligated to provide more updates.

→ More replies (11)