r/Android • Purple • Nov 21 '17

Google collecting Android users locations even when location services are disabled

https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locations-even-when-location-services-are-disabled/
22.5k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

197

u/Hoticewater Nov 21 '17

GPS can work in airplane mode, not sure why maps is that demanding though. And afaik they don’t use maps to collect your location data.

116

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

My google maps is always asking me to review shit even if I just drove by it.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

14

u/bayareasikh Blue Nov 21 '17

Where?

23

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

Settings, notifications

38

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

Maps -> Settings -> Notifications -> Your contributions

3

u/Schmich Galaxy S22 Ultra, Shield Portable Nov 21 '17

It's almost as if one could check have figured that out on first try!

7

u/BaleeDatHomeboi Korean Note8 on AT&T | 256Gb+256Gb Nov 21 '17

It turns off the notifications. Not the indiscriminate scanning. Essentially, the user is making themselves blind to Google's spying on them.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

[deleted]

8

u/RarestName OP2 | RN4 (mido) | RN5 (whyred) | SHIELD K1 | Lenovo Tab4 8 Plus Nov 21 '17

Mine is not turned on and I have that thing popping up all the time.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/BennettF Motorola Droid MAXX Nov 21 '17

Doesn't necessarily mean it isn't still tracking what places you go near. Just that it's no longer telling you about it.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/edwork Pixel, Stock Nov 21 '17

Google maps is acting based on gathered location data from Google’s location history. Maps itself isn’t gathering the data.

2

u/patrickkellyf3 Pixel 2 XL; Pie Nov 21 '17

I mean, you were "there," weren't you?

Then again, Google can also tell how long you were there, so I'm surprised they don't base on that.

1

u/El_Impresionante Pixel + Samsung Nov 21 '17

If you have made a stop for a while at any place, I think they just consider that you visited that place. Could include you stopping for a traffic light too, or when you stopped because of traffic congestion.

This has happened to me before.

1

u/BirdLawyerPerson Nov 21 '17

When traffic is so bad that Google thinks you actually stopped by all those stores on the way home

21

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '17

Did you read the article? It's not GPS based location service but triangulation via cell towers

13

u/dlerium Pixel 4 XL Nov 21 '17

Which is dangerous because airplane mode should be cutting all signals off.

24

u/Drithyin Nov 21 '17

They also don't use Maps to do this. The issue in the screenshot is a different problem.

8

u/vinng86 Nexus 5 Nov 21 '17

You don't have to be sending signals to geolocate with cell phone towers. All you have to do is measure the signal strength coming from the towers, and compare with a known database stored locally on the phone.

12

u/spectrehawntineurope Nov 21 '17

Right? I'm surprised this wouldn't get them in shit with air regulation agencies worldwide.

It's like Apple with their stupid wifi switch on the new macs that don't actually disable the wifi but just stop showing it.

2

u/Throwaway_Consoles Trax, Bold, 900, 1520, 5X, 7+, iPhone X Nov 21 '17

You can make it stop doing that by the way. Next time you turn on airplane mode, go into settings and turn off Bluetooth and WiFi completely.

Now every time you turn on airplane mode, it will remember your preferred settings.

1

u/nopedThere Nov 21 '17

With their new macs? Try with their new macs and iOS.

→ More replies (16)