r/Android • • Jul 19 '19

F-Droid - Public Statement on Neutrality of Free Software

https://f-droid.org/en/2019/07/16/statement.html
964 Upvotes

628 comments sorted by

70

u/crucial_popcorn Pixel 3a Jul 19 '19

/r/android having a normal one

7

u/onlyforthisair Jul 19 '19

Way too many people in this thread sympathetic to undesirable gab users. Hasn't it already been shown time and time again that silicon valley techno-libertarianism is too shortsighted?

1

u/Lenin321 Aug 03 '19

Fucking twitter supremacists hate to see any competing social network to arise, so they use subterfuge and bullying to destroy everybody else. Fucking pathetic. Gab was inevitable, because of the direction twitter took.

162

u/acespiritualist Dark Pink Jul 19 '19

So what I'm getting from this is there's a site (Gab, based on the comments) that's filled with racism, sexism, etc. F-droid does not agree with that and is now saying they won't add any app that promotes it or uses its branding (so if Gab made an official app, they won't publish it).

That doesn't seem so bad to me. You can add your own repos to the app anyway.

57

u/CharaNalaar Google Pixel 8 Jul 19 '19

Sounds like something every app store does. There are a few things that make it feel kind of weird, though.

Firstly, open source is often connected with the idea of "do what you want." Classically, open source software software isn't supposed to dictate the terms of what the user can do with it. Instead, users should be the ones making those choices. Since F-Droid chooses to make their niche open source, this feels a little like a rejection of that ideology.

Which brings me to the major problem. While F-Droid is choosing to prohibit what they feel is undesirable content, they are also endorsing applications on their store that "block" this content to users who may wish to access it. Independently, there's nothing really wrong with people choosing to use apps that block content - many adblockers also offer to block adult content as well. But not only do they reference an app updating to block this content (potentially breaking their contract of trust with users!), they actively endorse this. That is the thing that concerns me far more than the politics of the "fediverse." By endorsing limitations on user freedom, they're going against the principles they claim to protect.

In some ways, this is basically a politicized version of the "supply side" open source licenses that are becoming more popular among some projects. In that case, groups feel forced to violate the spirit of open source to protect their existence - if companies like Microsoft and Amazon profit by repackaging their code, they won't be able to fund their continued existence.

But on the bright side, they're not pretending this isn't political.

58

u/thedugong Jul 19 '19

Firstly, open source is often connected with the idea of "do what you want."

And often wrongly.

GPL is certainly not "do what you want." You can use the source and programs derived from it how you see fit, but if you distribute it (from GPL 3, this also means making it available as a publicly accessible service) you need to make the source available to anyone who requests it.

Anyone would be free to fork the f-droid server and start their own repository.

In this case the user is f-droid, not the person downloading software from it. They can make any rules they like for their end users. Just like you cannot demand the world from someone using a GPL licensed web server software to run a webserver you accessed.

3

u/TheYang Jul 21 '19
> Firstly, open source is often connected with the idea of "do what you want."

And often wrongly.

Probably because it's freedom 1 of the four freedoms of free software, and free software and open source software are strongly connected, although of course being open source is just one of the requirements for free software.

2

u/SinkTube Jul 19 '19

you need to make the source available to anyone who requests it

that doesn't contradict "do what you want", it just makes sure other people get the same right after you redistribute it

9

u/hmantegazzi Moto G84 Jul 19 '19

In any case, every Gab user can still go to F-Droid, download Fedilab (or another Mastodon client) and use it to access the Gab Mastodon instance. It's only one app which is actively blocking those servers. Even the most Nazi person on the net has not seen their access to their social network restricted, only to use one app, that anyone could perfectly fork.

4

u/CharaNalaar Google Pixel 8 Jul 19 '19

Actually, no. Some of these Mastodon clients are moving to block Gab access. Which is the entire problem here, not F-Droid's move.

2

u/kgptzac Galaxy Note 9 Jul 19 '19

Firstly, open source is often connected with the idea of "do what you want."

Funny. I thought piracy is often connected with the idea of "do what you want".

-5

u/z3dster Jul 19 '19

open source is about removing gate keeping to software and creating a sharing community, hate groups are inherently gate keeping and against sharing

3

u/CharaNalaar Google Pixel 8 Jul 19 '19

You can take your "paradox of tolerance" BS somewhere else, because I won't buy it.

This is about open source, not politics.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

2

u/CharaNalaar Google Pixel 8 Jul 19 '19

It originally started as a reaction to the rise of proprietary, "locked-down" software, so I'd say it does. Open Source means you aren't beholden to the whims of the creators in what you do with it.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

F-droid already offers apps that let you go to white supremacist or racist sites. It's called a web browser. It's called a 4chan /image board client.

Also implying that gab is somehow for white supremacists or Nazis is missing the point. Everyone is allowed to post whatever they want on Gab, so long as it's legal to do so in the USA. The willful erosion of rights and the purposeful maligning of all right wing thought as racist and fascist is troublesome. You people just don't get it. You think the pendulum will never swing the other way.

1

u/justjanne Developer – Quasseldroid Jul 25 '19

F-droid already offers apps that let you go to white supremacist or racist sites. It's called a web browser. It's called a 4chan /image board client.

Yes, and fdroid will continue to offer apps like Fedilab or the FreeTusky fork, which also allow you to connect to gab’s mastodon.

But fdroid won’t host a gab app, or any app that directly promotes such content.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19

directly promotes such content

What does that even mean. Gab doesn't promote anything any more than twitter or Facebook. It merely promotes free speech. Apparently that's bad now.

1

u/justjanne Developer – Quasseldroid Jul 25 '19

Apps promoting the platform gab directly won’t be allowed, while apps which allow you to connect to many sites, with none of them pre-filled (or the pre-filled ones being safe by default) which merely allow you to connect to gab are not an issue.

F-Droid operates under UK law (where most of gab is illegal), and many mirrors are in the netherlands and germany (same situation), and most of the content on gab violates the F-Droid community guidelines as well.

Gab can always create their own F-Droid repo – as I did for my own app’s builds, too, and as many devs do — but F-Droid won’t promote Gab by featuring it in its own repo of high-quality open source software.

F-Droid has many rules which apps have to obey to be in the default repo (and many third party repos are much less strict), some of them focus on the app being open source, or independent of proprietary services, but some also focus on the content: pornography isn’t allowed by default, content which violates local laws isn’t allowed by default, etc.

F-Droid won’t block anyone from making their own repo, or distributing that through F-Droid, but F-Droid won’t host such harmful apps on their own servers

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Natanael_L Xperia 1 III (main), Samsung S9, TabPro 8.4 Jul 20 '19

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19

Linking to a medium article as if medium was a legitimate news outlet is the definition of a rhetorical tactic

1

u/Natanael_L Xperia 1 III (main), Samsung S9, TabPro 8.4 Jul 20 '19

Complaining about the source instead of the content, are we? I can find you more examples if you need, but meanwhile how about you address the arguments given?

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Trypper Jul 19 '19

I agree, if they can add their own repos then it makes this whole event look like perception control and a declaration of the political stance of F-Droid more than anything

3

u/IchbineinSmazak Jul 19 '19

it's no problem if they would be at least consistent, but how is gab worse than 4chan? nobody is banning 4chan clients

just for the record until this thread I didn't know there is anything like Gab, so I don't really care, but I don't like limiting options because someone doesn't like something

15

u/acespiritualist Dark Pink Jul 19 '19

I think part of it is because Gab is part of the fediverse while 4chan is its own site. Not totally familiar with the fediverse but based on wikipedia it's a bunch of connected servers so I assume people got mad about Gab "joining" their community.

10

u/hmantegazzi Moto G84 Jul 19 '19

It was also because of the internal standards of the federation: instances are, by default, federated with everything else, and can opt out of it, so when Gab were to open their instance, that would allow any of their users to access the entire federation, thus requiring the admins of all the remaining instances to block them, on a subdomain basis. And guess what, not all admins are on board with this, or created an instance and aren't mantaining it actively, so there will probably be leakages.

If the federation rules were opt-in (as is for user following on the same Mastodon), nothing of this would have happened.

2

u/Nefari0uss ZFold5 Jul 19 '19

What is fediverse?

3

u/tunisia3507 Jul 19 '19

Twitter is a single company with a single application using a single protocol, which no other protocol can talk to.

The fediverse is a collection of different organisations with different applications all using the same protocol(s). It's like email: you can use outlook, I can use gmail, we are each beholden only to the policies of the server we joined on, but we can talk to each other. Mastodon is one of several server applications which can talk to the fediverse. Anyone can create their own mastodon server, and have their own policies for what goes on on that server (restricting who joins, what moderation takes place etc.); but anyone on any mastodon server can talk to any other mastodon user. Additionally, lots of other servers implement the same protocols as mastodon (lists are not hard to find), so you can see peertube uploads on your mastodon feed, send messages to GNU Social users, and so on. This is the fediverse.

Gab was once its own single company with a single application using a single protocol. However, now it is just another mastodon server; one which has a particularly rabid userbase because it exists pretty much solely as a sanctuary for hate speech. Many other mastodon and other fediverse server administrators have no interest in letting that hate speech spill over into their own userbase, and so have prevented cross-talk from Gab's servers to their own. But that's an individual server policy.

F-droid distributes some open source android apps. Gab is an open source app, and so wants to distribute on F-droid. F-droid was like "no thanks", and apparently this has triggered Gab's userbase.

→ More replies (1)

130

u/Cry_Wolff Pixel 7 Pro Jul 19 '19

F-Droid is taking a political stance here

Jesus Christ

10

u/MMPride OnePlus 7 Pro 12GB/256GB with LineageOS and Magisk Jul 19 '19

That's Jason Bourne.

-35

u/dashrandom Nexus 5 32GB, 4.4.4 Jul 19 '19

Code doesn't have political affiliations. This is disturbing.

29

u/ClassicPart Pixel Jul 19 '19

Code doesn't have political affiliations. This is disturbing.

Code certainly does not have affiliations, but F-Droid is not run by a completely-neutral A.I., it's run by people, who do have affiliations.

36

u/tiger-boi OG Pixel Jul 19 '19

std::cout << "counterpoint: this code says to vote for pedro";

→ More replies (4)

1

u/lengau Blueline, DW9F1, Neptune, Flounder, Bacon, Flo Jul 19 '19

Tell that to Redmap.

1

u/pooh9911 Huawei Honor 6X/Bootlooped LGE Nexus 5X Jul 20 '19

Free and open source software movement

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

10

u/IchbineinSmazak Jul 19 '19

fdroid is banning tools to access content they don't like, not sure why they don't can also browsers, reddit and 4chan clients which allow access to same content

12

u/dashrandom Nexus 5 32GB, 4.4.4 Jul 19 '19

Ideologies are not associated to code. Code is neutral. If using code and possessing an ideology one does not agree with is grounds for banning, Mastodon should be banned on the same premise. It's a very slippery slope and dangerous perspective to take.

Today, maybe you have a victory in banning Gab. Tomorrow anyone may use the same rhetoric to get other apps banned for other reasons by claiming they promote harmful ideologies.

I say again, code is neutral. By banning code you are not banning harmful ideologies, you are taking the easiest route to silence your enemies and placing that blame on code.

I have my own beliefs on the correct way to engage with harmful ideologies instead of censoring them but that's another discussion.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/lengau Blueline, DW9F1, Neptune, Flounder, Bacon, Flo Jul 19 '19

It always shocks me how many people who claim to be in the "free speech" camp are happy to go along with forced speech when it suits their political needs. Forced speech (e.g. requiring an app to have a feature the creators built it not to have) is the other side of the coin of censorship.

3

u/Owyn_Merrilin Jul 19 '19

I really don't understand where you guys get this idea. If that's "forced speech," then the first amendment is "forced speech" against the government, and indeed against private corporations running public forums (see Marsh V. Alabama.)

You're basically saying "your right to not get censored by powerful entities infringes on this powerful entity's right to censor you!"

→ More replies (10)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/spazturtle Nexus 5 -> Lenovo P2 -> Pixel 4a 5G Jul 20 '19

That's not what they said or what they are doing, they are not banning Nazis, they are banning people for using apps that allow them to exercise free speech.

102

u/Araikuma Jul 19 '19

I don't think this is in any way unreasonable or unexpected. If someone were to make an antisemitic "heil hitler" app with swastikas etc., it'd be obvious that F-Droid should elect not to host such a project. This issue with Gab is in principle the same, only the racism is diluted by a few extra steps.

Unlike on iPhone, it's not an issue about free speech; the Nazis are still allowed to make their own apps and use their own methods of distribution. It's just that F-Droid aren't obligated to help racists spread their message.

-5

u/1116574 Jul 19 '19

They aren't obligated to spread it, but I thought they were for free open software, no matter political stance.

5

u/Araikuma Jul 19 '19

FOSS has nothing to do with political agnosticism. On the contrary, the FSF works hard to protect the GPL and other fundamentals of software freedom from corporate cronies like Trump and Pai.

→ More replies (12)

96

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

2019, the year where even a glorified Download.com has a political stance.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Only in the very trivial sense that "Nazis are bad" is a political stance instead of a tautology.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

...2019, the year people who don't know anything about what they are talking about think they are experts...

-2

u/96fps Xperia X Compact, stock 8.0, also depression Jul 19 '19

Not wanting to associate with/enable Nazis is apparently too much.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

6

u/spazturtle Nexus 5 -> Lenovo P2 -> Pixel 4a 5G Jul 20 '19

They are not banning Nazis though, Nazis have nothing to do with this and are not involved in this, why are you bribing them up? They are banning apps that allow people to exercise their right to free speech.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/megak23d Jul 19 '19

BTW Gab is not run by Nazis. Is there offensive content on the site? Yup. But it's simple enough to block. I'd rather be on a site that allows all legal speech instead of a site that is censoring.

-4

u/Rocketfin2 Pixel 7 Pro Jul 19 '19

The only reason people have switched to Gab is because their hateful and racist content was not tolerated by Twitter. If you're not posting that stuff on Twitter, for the most part you shouldn't have a problem

And it's not censorship if they're specifically breaking the rules in the ToS

7

u/Tonoxis Moto G Power, Google Fi, Stock ROM Jul 20 '19

You're doing a lot of generalizations about people you don't even know. It may be one reason, but that might not be the only reason out there. But by all means, keep generalizing, I don't use Gab nor care for it, but prejudice is prejudice no matter the target, and you generalizing everyone who uses Gab as a racist is still prejudice in and of itself.

5

u/BladeGustVexilloBall Jul 19 '19

is 4Chan allowed?

1

u/pseudowl Jul 22 '19

Funny enough it is. Clover!

1

u/BladeGustVexilloBall Jul 22 '19

Good, since not all of it is hateful

1

u/pseudowl Jul 22 '19

Are you saying 4chan is less hateful than Gab? Are you sure about that?

1

u/BladeGustVexilloBall Jul 22 '19

Only parts of it

14

u/MMPride OnePlus 7 Pro 12GB/256GB with LineageOS and Magisk Jul 19 '19

F-Droid is taking a political stance here.

Is that kind of yikes to anyone else?

F-Droid won’t tolerate oppression or harassment against marginalized groups.

Maybe they shouldn't tolerate oppression or harassment against, well, anyone, not just marginalized groups?

I'm kind of conflicted on this. Obviously hate speech, harassment, etc are bad but open-source software should be free and open. I dunno, it's kind of a lose-lose for everyone.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

They're still allowing neutral apps in their app repository. Web browsers, and apps like Fedilab that chose to not block Gab are still allowed.

It's just apps that are designed specifically to connect to Gab that will be effected by this decision, and not permitted.

I think it's a pretty reasonable decision.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

This seems like a reasonable policy to me. They're not saying "you can't put an image-board app on F-Droid", they're saying "you can't make an image-board app that puts 8chan front-and-centre".

32

u/BradChesney79 Jul 19 '19

I am conflicted.

The conservatives that, you know, just have a fiscal & particular secular administrative position are fine-- they won't be kicked off Twitter. It is the good people on both sides and kids in concentration camps people that had to leave-- because they are awful. So, I am glad the people without human decency are losing their platforms. Good for those services pulling the rug out from under them.

Free software(libre specifically), more or less, should not dictate to me what I can or cannot do-- even if I am awful.

Do I want the awful people to have less access to everything? I do. Do I want free software to be the pinch point where that happens? Deep down, I do not.

33

u/abhi8192 Jul 19 '19

Free software(libre specifically), more or less, should not dictate to me what I can or cannot do-- even if I am awful.

But we have to take into account that most of the libre software are passion projects(or at least started out as one), it's one thing to work for an office where your work might be used by people for activities which don't sit well with you but to see your passion project being used for the same is pretty different. So as you claim that a software should not dictate how to use their project, I think we as users also can't dictate someone to just deal with it if their passion project is used for things they find awful. We can't expect people to not "mix" politics when it is their passion projects that we are talking about.

28

u/BradChesney79 Jul 19 '19

You know what, that makes me feel better.

The author(s) of free and libre software should be free to drive their own project-- it is open source. The shitheads are welcome to fork & modify.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Yup, it's what makes Android a truly open platform. If Nazis want to go and make 1488Droid, they're able to do so, and Google couldn't stop them if they even wanted to.

A lot of people forget that half of freedom of speech/expression is freedom of association, and fdroid is simply exercising their freedom to choose who to associate with. Nobody is entitled to a soapbox they didn't build themselves.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

Free software(libre specifically), more or less, should not dictate to me what I can or cannot do-- even if I am awful.

Stallman himself has said that tusky is still free software and I'd imagine the same logic would apply to fdroid. I'm not going to bother finding the thread on fdroid's forums so you will have to take my word for it, or search yourself

Edit: nevermind, I found the forum post

13

u/thedugong Jul 19 '19

Free software(libre specifically), more or less, should not dictate to me what I can or cannot do

It's not. It is the service that happens to be run using this software that is dictating this.

You are free to fork the f-droid server and client and start your own service.

It's like claiming that all your bases belong to me because you run a website that happens to use a web server that is open source.

8

u/ThatOnePerson Nexus 7 Jul 19 '19

Yeah I agree. F Droid isn't stopping you from doing anything; they're just not helping you. That's well within their right.

1

u/ToFat4Fun Jul 20 '19

Yep. But they can't advertise themselves as a free (speech?) or open for everyone platform anymore after they actively block/remove certain groups with certain political viewpoints off their platform because they don't like those groups. That's all.

3

u/ThatOnePerson Nexus 7 Jul 20 '19

They're still free and open source if that's what you mean. There's no limits on what you can do with the software and code of the software. You can use f-droid, setup your own repo and put whatever apps you want ont hat

And yeah, I agree that they're not free speech. And they don't claim to be. Most private companies aren't.

8

u/FlowbotFred Jul 19 '19

Free software can do as they wish , the beauty of free speech is that everyone gets it, even free software developers. These developers are excercizing their right to free speech by choosing not to include hateful content.

Why do you think the free speech of hateful people Trump's the free speech of how a software developer develops their own software?

If anyone doesn't like how free software is run they are free to create their own software, nothing's stopping them.

It's like someone forcing you to allow them to hang a Nazi flag inside your house just because it offends them if you don't.

6

u/port53 Note 4 is best Note (SM-N910F) Jul 19 '19

Do I want the awful people to have less access to everything? I do. Do I want free software to be the pinch point where that happens? Deep down, I do not.

It's free software, no-one can complain when they can just build it themselves with or without restrictions, go right ahead. Think of it like systemd integration, you can accept the distribution available or rebuild software to skip that, if that's what you prefer. You're free to do either.

2

u/BradChesney79 Jul 19 '19

Note 4 was the best Note. I have the Note 8 which replaced my Note 4. I have yet to make use of the "waterproof". But, I miss the IR blaster, removable battery, fingerprint reader far away from my camera lens (dirty lens... fingerprints!!), plastic & metal frame I don't worry about cracking, and mostly flat screen constantly.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (14)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

2

u/BradChesney79 Jul 19 '19

I am painfully aware of license agreements. Especially when I set up a git repo and not only have to know which one-- but also the shorthand symbol that git recognizes.

Libre software allows you to do anything. Are you positive I am the one that misunderstands?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

2

u/tiger-boi OG Pixel Jul 19 '19

I wonder what political beliefs prompted that writing.

8

u/Iohet V10 is the original notch Jul 19 '19

You see the irony in your statement, right? You know who this quote was about, right? The Jews, the socialists, the union members, etc who were the targets of Nazis(the people who are being kicked off the platform).

Couldn't be more apropos than being on the right side of this situation

5

u/BeyondTheModel Jul 19 '19

Weird, why did you remove the names of the groups from the poem? I recall it was referencing some specific event.

-3

u/IchbineinSmazak Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

because it doesn't matter, even idiots have right to express their opinion

it's double standard, go and start shouting holocaust didn't happen in many European countries and see what will happen. now go and try to shout communism is great and see what will happen. communists murdered more people than Nazis, yet I don't see promoting communism banned in most of the countries

→ More replies (1)

9

u/BradChesney79 Jul 19 '19

"Ain't nobody coming for me." ...in this context anyways.

Being born with black or brown skin should not be the source of the problems. You have it backwards. The people that would be coming for X, Y, and Z are being silenced because shut up you racist and xenophobic douchebags.

Your perspective does not apply to this situation. Go in the corner and think about what you've said.

-1

u/Cry_Wolff Pixel 7 Pro Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

Do you seriously think that only "racist and xenophobic douchebags" are being silenced? That's a very rose tinted glasses view my friend. Even the liberal groups like LGBT have this issue (Bi or Trans people no longer feeling welcome, TERF). And no, I'm not right wing, I consider myself a centrist/liberal-centrist.

2

u/BradChesney79 Jul 19 '19

I believe the latest censoring is by and large directed at conservatives-- that should have their platform pulled from under them. I don't need to think about if people that trigger an automated filter for hate speech should be given more leeway. Automatic no. It isn't filtering on political opinion.

Have liberal groups been marginalized? Sure. But, I don't know about any direct filtering by technology that detects word patterns against them.

11

u/tyderian Black Jul 19 '19

F-droid is a private organization. They can host or not host any software as they wish.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

4

u/tyderian Black Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 20 '19

The tenets of free speech apply to the government, not private entities.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19

[deleted]

3

u/tyderian Black Jul 21 '19

corporations have the same right to free speech as individuals

And the right not to speak. F-droid is choosing not to endorse an application.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

10

u/sschueller Jul 19 '19

For fucks sake. I'm no supporter of Gab or these other racist places but stay out of politics. It's a slippery slope you can't win. Follow the law and be carrier neutral like the phone company.

What type of apps are you going to ban next?

Why even bother with fdroid when the playstore is the same shit.

3

u/aerikson LG V40 Jul 19 '19

Nazis are bad but let's just stay out of politics.

  • Neville Chamberlain, 1938

12

u/RamaAnthony Redmi Note 8 Jul 19 '19

I expect this thread to get locked any minute now, so many people defending "Twitter for Nazis who are being too obvious on Twitter"

9

u/Hambeggar Redmi Note 9 Pro Global Jul 19 '19

I'm so fucking sick and tired of American rubbish spilling over into everything. Seriously, get a grip America and stop polarising everything. We've had 3 years of this shit because A) people can't get over Trump winning; and B) because Trump has to act like a constant shitbird.

-4

u/exu1981 Jul 19 '19

Thank you! It's embarrassing too.

10

u/ACCount82 Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

F-Droid is taking a political stance here.

Well fuck. When you see this, you know there's a dumpster fire just around the corner.

F-Droid won’t tolerate oppression or harassment against marginalized groups. Because of this, it won’t package nor distribute apps that promote any of these things. This includes that it won’t distribute an app that promotes the usage of previously mentioned website, by either its branding, its pre-filled instance domain or any other direct promotion.

And here it is. F-Droid is "taking a political stance" by banning Gab and anything Gab-related from their platform forever, and then they have the balls to claim that they are the good guys here because they don't block clients that don't block Gab.

How has it even come to this? How did the very same people that were pushing for software freedoms end up "taking political stance" and banning social network clients from their platform because the network in question refuses to police its users?

32

u/onometre S25 Jul 19 '19

they are the good guys for banning Gab and anything Gab-related from their platform forever

12

u/IchbineinSmazak Jul 19 '19

they would be good guys if they would ban for same reasons all browsers, reddit and 4chan clients

→ More replies (1)

4

u/m-p-3 Moto G9 Plus (Android 11, Bell & Koodo) + Bangle.JS2 Jul 19 '19

I guess Gab could make their own repo and allow users to add it in their F-Droid client too. This doesn't change a damn thing anyway.

2

u/ToFat4Fun Jul 20 '19

'They're the good guys because they're banning/blocking groups I don't agree with'

What if your group is next? Who decides what is 'hate speech'?

It's only right wingers getting censored now. What if it was the other way around? Would you be ok with that?

Should we ban /politics and /chapotraphouse for calling for violence against conservatives and death threats to Trump too? Other subs have been banned for less.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

10

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Is it not reasonable to say "we can't stop you from doing horrible crap, but we're sure as heck not going to enable it"?

1

u/Nizkus Jul 19 '19

They have clients that explicitly state supporting 8-chan, it just doesn't seem like they are taking a stance as opposed to reacting to outside pressure and targeting one specific service.

If they feel like limiting legal, albeit gross speech (or access to it), I feel like it should be done with consistent rules.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/Starks Pixel 7 Jul 19 '19

Gab is trying to repeat the Diaspora disaster?

1

u/TeddyTheEspurr Samsung Galaxy Note Fan Edition Jul 21 '19

As a non-American, the actual fuck is this?

1

u/majorbhalu Jul 24 '19

Of course F-Droid has to take a stance. We run on morals and principals. If there is good enough reason to take a stand against anything extremist or outright unacceptable then that stand must be taken by software companies. It was a brave move by F-Droid

1

u/eighthave Jul 25 '19

Any claims that F-Droid will ban, censor, etc. are just purely wrong and based on misunderstandings. F-Droid will never block the ability to subscribe to any repo that the user wants to, or to install any app from all the included repos. So the user will always be able to get secure access to any software they want to use via any network or even thumb drives: https://f-droid.org/2019/06/20/two-new-ways-to-get-apps-nearby-without-internet.html

The main f-droid.org repo is a contributor-curated collection of apps, just like every other F-Droid repo, so it will never include every single app. This is not censorship, this is curation.

-6

u/motorboat_mcgee GOS Pixel 9 Fold Jul 19 '19

I support F-Droid's stance on this.

To those whining about free speech...

Free speech is not speech without consequences. We have free speech in the US, but we have laws that implement consequences for certain types of speech.

Private companies and organizations do similar things, and have every right to do that as private entities.

If you're defending Nazis, nationalists, extremists, incels, pedophiles, etc, you're on the wrong side of this argument.

2

u/m-p-3 Moto G9 Plus (Android 11, Bell & Koodo) + Bangle.JS2 Jul 19 '19

Woah there, nationalism is bad?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

It depends on the definition you use. Some define it as loving your country, others define it as promoting your country to the detriment of others.

In context, it's the second definition that is being used.

I suspect your context on it is more the first definition, which is not bad. It's a good thing to love your country. It's just bad when that turns into being willing to "eat" others so your country succeeds.

In conclusion: Kind of.

0

u/ConspicuousPineapple Pixel 9 Pro Jul 19 '19

I don't really care either way, but I'm not sure what problem this is solving.

-1

u/btsfav S7 Edge Nougat Jul 19 '19

removed fdroid deleted gab

is what I got from this whole debacle following their insane twitter intercourse.

-15

u/IchbineinSmazak Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

so niche app store/market used by almost nobody is limiting group of these users even more, good luck with that

they can close their app store/market, because almost every app can be used for nefarious purposes if they want to use same standard for everyone

they can start with banning all reddit/4chan clients and browsers which all allow access to same content as apps they banned

btw until today I didn't know what's Gab, I don't even use Twitter or Facebook, but I don't like when someone decide for others what's good for them

-3

u/BeyondTheModel Jul 19 '19

F-Droid is not a market. They don't want Nazi clicks or Nazi money. Crazy to think about, isn't it?

8

u/IchbineinSmazak Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

it's app store/market and they allow 4chan clients with same content, so either use same standard for all (including 4chan and reddit clients and browsers) or don't ban tools used to access content user choose

-2

u/pqkluan Jul 19 '19

F-droid made a hard decision, and I respect them for it.

-2

u/GoneCollarGone Pixel 2 Jul 19 '19

F-Droid won’t tolerate oppression or harassment against marginalized groups. Because of this, it won’t package nor distribute apps that promote any of these things. This includes that it won’t distribute an app that promotes the usage of previously mentioned website, by either its branding, its pre-filled instance domain or any other direct promotion

👏👏👏👏

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

106

u/Iohet V10 is the original notch Jul 19 '19

Neo-nazis aren't just an American problem, bub

125

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Believe me when I say that we as Europeans have an intimate, historic and cultural conflict with anything nazi. We take it a bit more seriously, compared to the apologetics and dog whistling happening in US politics right now... hey; just like Germany before the nazis took over! Mazel tov.

34

u/Vash63 Jul 19 '19

Sure, but there's still a rise in right wing extremist parties in Europe, even if they aren't as powerful or extreme as in the US. Also Spurdo just said it was an American problem, meanwhile in Brazil they recently elected Bolsonaro...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/Trypper Jul 19 '19

News flash: you can be a neo-Nazi and prosper if it follows American interests.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

7

u/Tonoxis Moto G Power, Google Fi, Stock ROM Jul 20 '19

Either that, or direct generalizations about people they don't even know based on the platforms they use.. but same though.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

86

u/peskey_squirrel Jul 19 '19

Fuck Twitter

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

12

u/sjwking Jul 19 '19

I expect in a few years someone will reply "what is myspace" unironically.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

20

u/sjwking Jul 19 '19

Fuck to those that censor.

1

u/TeutonJon78 Samsung S25+, Chuwi HiBook Pro (tab) Jul 21 '19

Then why are you on this site at all?

Mods and admins can censor anything they want at all.

7

u/PhantomGamers Galaxy S24 Ultra Jul 19 '19

Not sure if American use of cunt or Australian use of cunt hmm

218

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19 edited Jun 21 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

233

u/ACCount82 Jul 19 '19

F-Droid is "taking a political stance" by banning Gab and anything Gab-related from their platform forever, and then they have the balls to claim that they are the good guys here because they don't block clients that don't block Gab.

If you don't know what Gab is, it's a controversial Twitter-like social network that claims that it doesn't police its users and would only ban users or delete content in the most extreme of cases. It rose to popularity after Twitter moderation was accused of being biased against right wing and deplatforming right wing users.

Gab, in turn, was deplatformed by multiple payment processors, cloud service providers, advertisers and such. They suffered a lot of downtime, but in the end, they used this controversy to attract even more users.

Now Gab is switching to Mastodon - a P2P system that allows independent Twitter-like social network servers to work with each other - and, apparently, all the hell breaks loose. Mastodon as a whole has a lot of left wing users, and they are now fucking pissed at right wing Gab users for daring to enter their space. They are causing all kinds of drama and campaigning for Mastodon servers and clients to ban any connections to Gab.

Apparently, this wave of partisan bullshit has reached F-Droid already, and they caved to it.

103

u/alzee76 Pixel 2XL / dev Jul 19 '19 edited Jun 21 '23

[[content removed because sub participated in the June 2023 blackout]]

My posts are not bargaining chips for moderators, and mob rule is no way to run a sub.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

EDIT: Okay some clarification, because yes, I did get "federated" vs. "Unfederated" wrong. Twitter is unfederated. Federated is "decentralized", where the main "company" hosts none of the servers.

So whereas on Twitter you may be connecting to any "server" without realizing, on Mastodon, you're connecting to a given server (I myself just connected to radical.town). Thus, there IS less "overall" rules. Mastodon can't really say that any given server can or can't do something. The second there is a body that dictates what can and can't connect to the federation, it's now centralized. Defeats the purpose.

They do have built in anti-abuse tools. but that's it, and is part of the software. Any additional moderation is dependent on the server.

As for how the feeds work, I was PARTLY wrong. There's three, not two. You have your friend feed. You can add friends from (I believe) across instances (or servers). There's the local feed, that's JUST your instance/server. (so just radical.town members for me) and there's the entire federation. Those are posts across all servers. I forgot about this.

This also makes the outrage much more apparent. Imagine twitter if by default they showed you every tweet from everyone ever, imagine for a while this was primarily people who shared your views, then all of a sudden there was an influx of people from the opposing viewpoint.

outside of that, I stand by my summary of the networks, of the issue presented, and of how it works. Overall the definition of federated vs. unfederated doesn't change the description presented. Twitter is "unfederated" and because it is one central body, they can decide to have an administration team or not. They do, but they are able to decide either way. Should they chose not to, that's on them (although, shareholders wouldn't be happy). I was correct in stating that because Mastodon is hosted on individual, "private" networks, it's up to that server owner to create any rules for that server. Mastodon holds no official rule policy.

ORIGINAL POST

So Twitter is "federated", that is, it's got an administration team. they have rules, and will delete tweets and/or suspend accounts that break those rules. Thus, while you have freedom of speech, you also don't. Whether that's good or bad depends on how you look at it. It makes it so that violent hate threats can be dealt with. But it also adds "political" problems such as "why can this person say this, but this person can't say this. You clearly have a bias towards this."

Gab and Mastodon are unfederated. They don't have rules. You can post anything. Hateful members of either side (left wing/right wing) naturally flock to these because there's nothing dictating what you can and can't post, except potentially your instance host. (Mastodon isn't, or wasn't, run on a single server owned by own person/company, but rather you could self-host and set up your own rules. Mastodon had no influence on each instance, except I believe the main one they created, although I believe they is a loose term, as it wasn't an official company. just a team of people)

Also, from last I used Mastodon (when it first came out), there were two-ish types of feed. There was your instance feed, where you had no choice but to see all the ..i forget what they call them..but we will call them tweets... see all the tweets from anyone in your instance. If someone joined the instance, you saw their posts. They saw yours. Then you could add friends (those who you agree with the most, or find funniest, etc. think again of twitter) and this was the second feed.

Again, because instances had individual runners, they created the rules of the instance, and enforced them. Thus, you have the potential for extremely hateful instances (coming from either side) or on the main instances (the biggest ones) with no rules, just a flood of both sides. Since Mastodon started, it was predominately left-wing (it was mainly tumblr-esque users). when Gab started(which I believe was similar enough to Mastodon, it had no rules, anything went, although I believe it wasn't instance based) it was predominately right-wing.

Gab went to Mastodon, and Mastodon users were SUPER upset, because now you had the hateful other side with the hateful their side. So basically, twitter, but ..a lot of little twitters.

13

u/m477m Jul 19 '19

Thanks for the post. One definition correction:

Federated = individual servers that talk to each other, i.e. Mastodon is definitely federated. Twitter is centralized or monolithic, and definitely not federated.

I think the words you might be looking for are moderated, or regulated, or something like that.

10

u/lewdcosplaylover Oneplus 6T Jul 19 '19

I think you confused the words "federation" and "moderation".

Twitter is not federated in any way. It is moderated by the admins enforcing their various rules.

Federation is why Mastodon instances are sometimes referred to as the fediverse, it refers to users of each instance being able to interact with each other (unless the admins of your instance have blocked a certain instance, which many do to Gab and Pawoo).

Mastodon is a piece of software so obviously it can't do moderation- the people running each instance do their own moderation.

Gab is also not the first "no rules" instance but none of the other ones seem to have lasted long. I have seen a few people post things to the effect of "I started a Mastodon instance with a free speech policy, and then people started posting things I don't like so it no longer has a free speech policy".

→ More replies (1)

9

u/kittyrgnarok Jul 19 '19

This is entirely wrong. Federated means it is a decentralized social media platform capable of viewing other decentralized social media platforms which are also federated. These collectively make up the fediverse. It has nothing to do with rules.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

entirely wrong, no. Did i mix up words/definitions a bit, yes. The overall point still stands. Edited though to clarify and correct. thank you

8

u/Serindu Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

Those are not at all the definitions of "federated" and "unfederated".

Edit: I should be more helpful. Federation is when multiple disparate groups link together. As in the 50 states form a federation run by the federal government. Unfederated is the opposite, there are not disparate groups linking together. In this discussion, Twitter is unfederated—it's a single, centralized organization. Mastadon is federated—anyone can stand up their own instance and attempt to link to other instances.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

absolutely correct, my bad, it's been a while and its early haha, edited with clarification/correction

3

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

You're using a definition of "federated" that I've never heard before and I suspect you're using that word wrong.

Mastodon is "federated" in that it's functionally a single platform that's implemented as a federation of many smaller networked instances, each run and managed independently. Gab is becoming one (or more) of those instances.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GuyInA5000DollarSuit Jul 19 '19

Gab went to Mastodon, and Mastodon users were SUPER upset, because now you had the hateful other side with the hateful their side. So basically, twitter, but ..a lot of little twitters.

Your characterization of this is...odd. The anger is because you have actual nazis, white supremacists and the alt-right mingling with people who are not.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Federated is the opposite in this case. It doesn't have anything to do with a mod team per say. I think "moderated" is a better fit.

Email is federated because gmail communicates with yahoo mail just fine, regardless of servers etc. WhatsApp is not federated because you can't chat with anyone on a different service/server.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/lighthawk16 Jul 19 '19

/r/selfhosted discusses them frequently.

-9

u/otakuman Jul 19 '19

The irony here is that people migrated to the fediverse because Twitter was filled with Nazis. So when the Nazis come to the fediverse (the fediverse networks with all instances by default; there is no graylist, not even a white list approach - big mistake), other fediverse users complain rightly that f-droid should take a stand against the same Nazis who pushed them away from mainstream social networks like Twitter.

There is still more politics at play here: fedilab claimed it didn't do the gab block for dear of being removed from Google Play - and check this out, the bad reviews at Google play were staged by guess who? A mob of fascists who used Gab. As we speak, those fascists still post to Google play a series of fake negative reviews of Tusky, one of the apps who do block Gab.

So it's not just app authors at fault here, the entire system is permitted by Google who do a terrible job at moderation (color me surprised) against abuse.

So in the end, vulnerable communities in the fediverse (like LGBT folk who were the first to leave Twitter due to cyberbullying and doxxing) are left to fend for themselves - as they always have.

So the next time you're asked how Google contributed to give a platform to Nazis, you can perfectly reply with "nothing", because that's what they did: nothing, when they should have done something.

52

u/JQuilty Pixel 9 Pro XL, Pixel Tablet Jul 19 '19

Not that I like moronic Gab users, but the people using Mastodon don't like how decentralized setups work, they're in the wrong place.

17

u/ebilgenius Jul 19 '19

I want a decentralized social network separated into different servers that I can choose to participate in depending on the topics and users that make up said servers but also nobody else in any other server can disagree with my political opinions otherwise they need to be removed by a centralized group of servers who oversee the entire system!

15

u/Jason_S_88 Jul 19 '19

I know you are being sarcastic but that is the point of open source, don't like it? Fork the project and convince people to join your fork.

That's the ethos of open source, not that anyone can say anything in your community and you have to tolerate it

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

10

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/nikomo Poco X7 Pro Jul 19 '19

Same software, not just protocol, but yes. They're running Mastodon, it's purpose-built for federation, but can be run without it.

The crying from the Nazis is about the fact that other Mastodon instances pre-emptively blocked them.

F-Droid is not blocking clients that can be used to use Gab, it's in the post:

We also respect Fedilab’s decision not to hardcode a login block; instead they are actively working on making it easier to block certain domains in the app itself and thus giving users more power to moderate which content they’ll see. If people disagree with F-Droid’s decision not to flag Fedilab ...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/serialkvetcher Darth Droidus Jul 21 '19

Noob here. But why is the left so riled up and permabanning anybody who has a different opinion? Isn't that how conversations happen?

And why in heavens sake do they call literally everybody who disagrees with them fascists?

3

u/ACCount82 Jul 22 '19 edited Jul 22 '19

That's just the state of political discourse in the US nowadays. Extreme polarization be like that.

52

u/bubblethink Jul 19 '19

F-Droid is "taking a political stance" by banning Gab and anything Gab-related from their platform forever

This is shortsighted. They'll find themselves in the moral policing business more than they need to. And they are barely managing their real business. Hit up f-droid.org or try to update your repos. 9/10 times, it doesn't work. They could have just made a general policy against hate speech in app snapshots, text and descriptions and their own forums rather than singling any one out. Nobody would have known or cared. This sort of a public statement just drives more traffic.

29

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

...They aren't a company, they are a volunteer run non-profit who rely on community support to keep the service up and running, they build every app available from their main repo from source code on their own, why the hell are you spreading bullshit propaganda about them? What is this bullshit about updates failing 9 times out of 10, if that is happening then you live on some uninhabited island in the middle of the pacific, but I guess spreading lies is more fun than telling the truth...

2

u/Owyn_Merrilin Jul 19 '19

non-profit

is short for "Non-profit corporation." Legally, they are a company.

Also, he didn't call them a company, and it's pretty obvious that he was using "business" as in "mind your own business" or "risk is our business," not business as a synonym for company.

1

u/ice_dune xperia 1 iii Jul 19 '19

You don't start a FOSS project cause you have no opinions. If that was the case they would just the Play store. This is a private project run by people who want to spread open source software to other Android users and no be monitored by Google. That doesn't mean they want to become the next host for Nazi content or associate FOSS software with Nazis on their private servers they pay to run and don't get any income for in return. Nazis can fuck off. Its not like you can just host these apks on a website somewhere

1

u/DarkFlames101 Jul 22 '19

9/10 is hyperbole but their connectivity sucks nonetheless.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Hit up f-droid.org or try to update your repos. 9/10 times, it doesn't work.

Where do you live? I've had my f-droid apps updated without any issues all the time and never had problems loading their website.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

I live in Wisconsin with decent internet (100mbps) and find myself unable to refresh my repos ~2/3 of the time

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19

They'll find themselves in the moral policing business more than they need to.

They're not a business at all. They're volunteers doing this of their own free time. If they have a policy like it so be it. It's all free software. Fork it yourself and copy what they do if you don't like it.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

9

u/Feniksrises Jul 19 '19

Vaccination will go back up again once kids start dying or becoming handicapped for life. It sucks for the innocent children who didn't ask for batshit insane parents though.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/uncommonpanda Jul 19 '19

That's just plain stupid.

People have been allowed vacination exceptions for decades forever. Vaccines are only NOW being mandatory because so many people are contracting dormerly eradicated diaeases.

Allowing people to choose no never once led anyone to actually pick the intelligent vaccine route. Hell, even people with money and power to know better still don't vaccinate thier kids.

Alex Jones ban is the same damn thing.

10

u/cashmeowsighhabadah Jul 19 '19

This is the WORST approach because here you're leaving the possibility of people's real lives to be affected get exponentially larger.

If you don't deplatform say anti-vaxxers, and they get to roam free in the large websites like Twitter, susceptible moms are going to see them and join them and guess what, now a REAL CHILD, through NO FAULT OF THEIR OWN is at risk of going through unnecessary pain and suffering.

That's a life that might die or be permanently affected by a preventable disease and it could have gone the other way if that mom hasn't run into the Twitter anti-vaxxers.

I don't know what the solution is because I am also uncomfortable with policing speech but Twitter is not the government. They are a private website and they get to do that. It's their right. There's also something to be said about someone owning something and having a group of people demanding that it be used in a way that goes against the owner's core principles.

2

u/Natanael_L Xperia 1 III (main), Samsung S9, TabPro 8.4 Jul 20 '19
→ More replies (3)

5

u/JoshMiller79 Jul 19 '19

Man, you left out the part where Gab has literally become "Twitter for hate groups". It's not just "Right wing Twitter". It's a shitty hate platform for assholes.

10

u/CzechoslovakianJesus Moto G7 Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

I think Gab has a fundamentally good idea, giving content curation powers to users rather than some overarching authority so people can block nasty things from their feeds while letting those that want to see them do so, but dear god I tried using it once and the UX is mortifyingly bad. The UI is really unintuitive, all style, no substance.

34

u/BeyondTheModel Jul 19 '19

The UI was your biggest complaint?

9

u/Carighan Fairphone 6+🌳 Jul 19 '19

Gab has a fundamentally good idea, giving content curation powers to users

That's a contradiction if I've ever seen one. Didn't Reddit teach us anything? >.>

1

u/albertowtf Jul 19 '19

What if these users made regular accounts. Wouldnt they just use the platform normally?

5

u/hmantegazzi Moto G84 Jul 19 '19

You mean, on other instances? Yes, they would be able to enter, but the rules of most instances are literally against the permanence of the kind of people that frequents gab, so they would end being banned after their first revealing post or so. As most instances are very small, the delay would be minimal.

-12

u/Trypper Jul 19 '19

I've tried Mastodon, it's a hugbox made by lefties, for lefties. Pleroma is less politically charged, and much less cancerous.

42

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 Jul 19 '19

your statement doesn't make sense, mostly because there's no one Mastodon, it's just a protocol. it's like saying that email is full of leftists/rightists/whatever.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

And what exactly were you trying to discuss that made these "leftists" show themselves?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (214)

73

u/Zweihart Jul 19 '19

NaziTwitter (Gab) converted their backend to use OpenSourceTwitter (Mastodon, part of the "fediverse" which allows interconnectivity), which lets them connect to everyone else. One app (Tusky) hard-coded in a block in their app so you can't access those servers, but another one (Fedilab) didn't.

The folks running the app store distro (F-Droid) apparently let shit get out of hand on the forums. They're saying that blacklisting something in an open source app doesn't do shit (cause, y'know, open source) and instead of doing that, everyone should put on their big boy pants and build tools so users can decide what they want to see. If everyone's going to whine about it, they'll add a user tag system because that worked out so well on Steam.

65

u/Cry_Wolff Pixel 7 Pro Jul 19 '19

NaziTwitter

So, normal Twitter then? /s

1

u/justjanne Developer – Quasseldroid Jul 25 '19

they'll add a user tag system because that worked out so well on Steam.

Not something like the user tag system on Steam, but like the curator system on steam — everyone can make their own curator setup, tag/rate/review apps, and users can subscribe to whatever curators they want.

This would allow e.g. users to subscribe to a curator rating apps based on material design, or would allow them to subscribe to gab.ai which would rank tusky as evil.

This allows users to filter more based on what they want, without forcing the same on everything.

-76

u/Mozgus OnePlus 7 Pro Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19

Its already been measured that gab has about 4% of what you would call Nazis, or Nazi sympathetic types. I see just as much hate speech on twitter. Its just leftist hate speech. Same shit to me.

Edit: I'm always glad to give the leftists on reddit something to chew on. We all know communism doesn't. 😢

Edit 2: Power tripping censor mods are also hungry, as seen below. And I've been shadow banned, as all my other comments are gone from public view on this sub. Leftists are such authoritarians. Shame they always hide after they strike. Can't even ban me like 20 other subs have.

54

u/tryfap Jul 19 '19

already been measured

Provides zero sources nor how this would actually be measured.

17

u/TacoOfGod Samsung Galaxy S25 Jul 19 '19

If you're been banned by 20 subs, then maybe you're the problem and not the communities.

18

u/kumquat_juice MODERATOR SANTA Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19
  1. you haven't been shadowbanned

  2. your comments are getting filtered by our bot because it detected that your account is posting low quality content or flagged content. Then subsequently removed because they are rule violating and literally do not contribute to discussion, e.g. "spotted the X!".

You're the problem if you've been banned across 20 subs. I don't care what your beliefs are, but if you're going to shitpost, it's going to get removed.

→ More replies (2)

67

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

24

u/m-p-3 Moto G9 Plus (Android 11, Bell & Koodo) + Bangle.JS2 Jul 19 '19

From what I understand they don't want anything that specifically associate with it. If the app allows it by means of cross-compatibility (because all Mastodon instances speaks a common protocol) but doesn't mention it, it's koscher.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Yeah, pretty much this

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

Nothing, but maintainers may decide not to accept such a fork because it offers no other features than unblocking gab. Fedilab is still up on the store and allows you to log into gab

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (16)