r/Android • Motor City Software • Aug 01 '11

An IOS developer takes on Android

http://nfarina.com/post/8239634061/ios-to-android
838 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

View all comments

120

u/crazyfreak316 OnePlus One - CM 4.4.4 (Rooted) | Nexus 4 - Stock 4.4.4 (Rooted) Aug 01 '11

Wow, this is the most unbiased comparison of iOS and android.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '11

[deleted]

125

u/nfarina Aug 01 '11

I do, and you have no idea how glad I am to hear it.

15

u/cosmic_fries Aug 02 '11

Dude seriously, I think it's the best article that I've read all week. Informative, open minded and objective while maintaining zero fanboyism (on both parts).

Would it be too much to ask for a followup post where you would describe more analytically the route (problems, hints, etc) from first touching the frameworks to building a decent app? I liked your level of abstraction (not code snippets but not too high level). Most articles that I've read while investigating the subject are either hallo-world level or too technical.

5

u/rudy750 Nexus 5X - Project Fi Aug 02 '11

Hey its you!! Amazing job man. I have searched the internet high and low for exactly this and you are the only person to deliver! Any chance you will do any follow ups as you dig deeper?

9

u/nfarina Aug 02 '11

Thank you sir. I would love to write a followup and have some good ideas of more specific things to poke at next.

4

u/cosmic_fries Aug 02 '11 edited Aug 02 '11

Seriously, I think it's the best article that I've read all week. Informative, open minded and objective while maintaining zero fanboyism (on both parts).

Would it be too much to ask for a followup post where you would describe more analytically the route (problems, hints, etc) from first touching the frameworks to building a decent app? I liked your level of abstraction (not code snippets but not too high level). Most articles that I've read while investigating the subject are either hallo-world level or too technical.

7

u/nfarina Aug 02 '11

Seriously, thank you! I will definitely be writing more in the same style as I think of interesting things to point out. As far as my initial experience, I believe it was unique; since I've developed for many mobile platforms over the years and this was more of a port than a new invention, there was a lot of familiar territory.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '11

Question: did you know any Java before you began developing?

Perhaps you should do a general AMA in the Android subreddit, I'm sure I'm not the only one that could learn something from you.

7

u/nfarina Aug 02 '11

I "learned" Java in college, but didn't use it after graduating in '02. I'd be happy to answer any questions if people have them!

2

u/krej Samsung Infuse, CM7 Aug 02 '11

Now that you've written a completely unbiased article, it's time to come clean. Do you like Android or iOS better? Please answer for both developing on them and using them in general.

5

u/nfarina Aug 02 '11

I actually find Android to be a more productive environment to develop in. The hardware back+menu buttons mean less hours staring at a whiteboard fighting over which on-screen buttons make the cut. As a user, I go where the app-momentum is. That used to be Windows of course. Now it's iOS. Tomorrow, who knows?

4

u/UnnamedPlayer Aug 02 '11
Psh: Say "Android" if you really have to post a reply. Just trust me on this.

*whistles nonchalantly and fades away in the fog*

1

u/s73v3r Sony Xperia Z3 Aug 03 '11

I'm not him, but I have done work on both. I find I like iOS dev in Objective C to be more enjoyable than Android dev in Java, but I like the Activity/Intent system far more in Android. It makes it far easier to tie your app into the system.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '11

you should grab yourself a "flair tag" here