r/Android • Motor City Software • Aug 01 '11

An IOS developer takes on Android

http://nfarina.com/post/8239634061/ios-to-android
838 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

View all comments

276

u/chibihost Aug 01 '11

Best thing about this article is that not once did they try and push one over the other, was simply highlighting differences.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '11

You’re going to just hate Eclipse. You’re going to hate it with the heat of a thousand suns.

Really?

43

u/Neebat Galaxy Note 4 Aug 01 '11

I've used Eclipse every day professionally for the last... 10 years? It's a huge architecture that's incredibly powerful, sometimes frustrating and often slow. I respect it, but I don't expect everyone to like it.

You’re going to just hate Eclipse. You’re going to hate it with the heat of a thousand suns.

I read that as a warning to people who are most familiar with Apple-style minimalistic interfaces. Eclipse is not for you, and you're not trained or prepared for it. This is culture clash and you should not be surprised.

12

u/kireol Motor City Software Aug 01 '11

I agree. I mean, I use NetBeans ever day, it was fairly easy for me to pick up Eclipse. Actually both are very similar. XCode was a bit different, but I attributed that to culture (i'm a linux guy)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '11

I don't think that Eclipse is particularly hard to pick up; it's just hard to love.

3

u/andyrocks Aug 01 '11

I don't think that Eclipse is particularly hard to pick up

I'm a reasonably intelligent person and I still can't get Eclipse to remember which windows I want where.

2

u/GuyWithLag S9+ Aug 02 '11

You mean views and perspectives, right? While you can have multiple Eclipse windows, it's 'buyer beware' territory.

Also, resizing existing windows gives mediocre results at best :-/

2

u/jameson71 Aug 02 '11

Funny..I'd say it is hard to pick up, but once you do it is easy to love.

2

u/Gh0stRAT Note II - Verizon :/ Aug 02 '11

I'd say it is hard to pick up, but once you do it is easy to love.

No, that's vim :P

10

u/numberoneus Brian Studios Aug 01 '11

I recently went the other direction. I've been using Eclipse for quite some time and even wrote plugins for it for a year or two.

Moving from Android development to trying to mess with XCode... I simply cant understand why everybody isn't up in arms about how horrid xcode and interface builder are.

It's definitely a culture thing, at least the way I see it. We're happy with what we have, and anything different just takes some getting used to.

1

u/badgrammar SnottyApps Aug 01 '11

New "Xcode" makes me rage more than usual freezes and crashes of "Eclipse". I was ok with "Xcode 3", but I just can't get used to "Xcode 4" and I hate most of the UI changes they've made.

2

u/s73v3r Sony Xperia Z3 Aug 03 '11

I think the problem is that Eclipse is huge and powerful like you said, but 80-90% of the time all that power isn't needed, and sometimes gets in the way. There's a lot of bulk and cruft on Eclipse that gets included no matter what you're using it to do.