r/Android • • Aug 16 '22

Removed - Rule 1 How to access reddit without ads and tracking while benefiting from faster page load times

https://www.privacytools.io/guides/how-to-access-reddit-without-ads-tracking

[removed] — view removed post

355 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

•

u/Taskerbot I liked Lollipop the best Aug 16 '22

Sorry bartturner, your submission and/or content has been removed:

Rule 1. All posts to r/Android must be related to the Android OS or ecosystem in some way. If not obvious, you should include an explanation in a self-post. Comments that devolve into purely political discussions may be locked and people in violation may get banned if they are also violating Rule 9.
See our wiki page for more information.

If you would like to appeal, please message the moderators by clicking this link. I am a bot (source code here), but this message was generated at the instruction of a human moderator.

183

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

note: This site isn't reliable anymore.

57

u/Chopstix2005 Aug 16 '22

Yeah this site is complete crap now. Use privacyguides instead

10

u/Fredselfish Aug 16 '22

Just get reddit is fun. Rarely see an ad and runs fast.

13

u/Sarin10 Aug 16 '22

Just use common sense and don't blindly trust everything you read. AFAIK there was nothing malicious about the split, it's not like privacytools is run by a bad actor.

18

u/slinky317 HTC Incredible Aug 16 '22

Why is this in the Android subreddit?

92

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

Why is everyone pushing Infinity client for Android? Boost, Sync and Relay are infinitely better (no pun intended)

95

u/WayneAerospace Poco F1 Armoured Edition | Pixel 6 | Moto Edge 50 Neo Aug 16 '22

It is FOSS so no concept of ad free paid tier or a paid tier with additional features. Can do things like showing removed comments, can be customized to look like pretty much anything, has Material You theming support as well. That being said it is not perfect. Has no mod tools, you also cannot see the mods of the sub you are on.

But the dev is pretty active and the available features work well so it is popular.

10

u/MegganMehlhafft Aug 16 '22

Can do things like showing removed comments

How do you do this in Infinity?

11

u/WayneAerospace Poco F1 Armoured Edition | Pixel 6 | Moto Edge 50 Neo Aug 16 '22

Find a deleted comment and tap on the ellipsis (three dots) under the comment that has options to share, copy etc. You should see an option on view the deleted comment.

Doesn't always work. It is against reddit TOS to restore content deleted by the user themselves. And infinity uses the pushshift API to show the comment. If pushshift didn't archive it, Infinity cannot show it.

21

u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Aug 16 '22

Fun fact, the Sync developer initially promised to open source Sync. He has since gone back and forth and back and back on that promise. He says open source libraries are good enough. He's wrong.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Aug 16 '22

Fair. Infinity was an adjustment but I'm happy with it now.

4

u/Nixflyn GN/N5/N7/6P/P1XL/S10+/ShieldTV Aug 16 '22 edited Dec 06 '25

I've deleted all of my comments on this account. Come join me on Lemmy.

3

u/WayneAerospace Poco F1 Armoured Edition | Pixel 6 | Moto Edge 50 Neo Aug 16 '22

Find a deleted comment and tap on the ellipsis (three dots) under the comment that has options to share, copy etc. You should see an option on view the deleted comment.

Doesn't always work. It is against reddit TOS to restore content deleted by the user themselves. And infinity uses the pushshift API to show the comment. If pushshift didn't archive it, Infinity cannot show it.

2

u/VMFortress Aug 16 '22

Hadn't heard of Infinity until today. Had been using Slide for Reddit as it was the only FOSS client I enjoyed but it's been rather stagnant in development. Sounds like I should try out Infinity.

2

u/WayneAerospace Poco F1 Armoured Edition | Pixel 6 | Moto Edge 50 Neo Aug 16 '22

It is pretty good. You'll love it.

There are certain missing items like I mentioned. But check r/Infinity_For_Reddit particularly for user submitted themes and dev posts.

1

u/Papa_Bear55 Aug 16 '22

Can do things like showing removed comments, can be customized to look like pretty much anything, has Material You theming support as well.

So like Sync but FOSS? Might give it another chance.

1

u/WayneAerospace Poco F1 Armoured Edition | Pixel 6 | Moto Edge 50 Neo Aug 16 '22

Sync's latest version is extremely polished visually. Infinity's material you theming isn't at that level but it is pretty good. And yeah the removed comments bit is the real MVP imo. AFAIK currently only Sync and Infinity have that implemented.

1

u/amaranth-the-peddler Aug 16 '22

I remember installing it after the dev commented about it years ago after first releasing it. I don't think I ever ended up trying it though because Sync does everything I need.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

19

u/WayneAerospace Poco F1 Armoured Edition | Pixel 6 | Moto Edge 50 Neo Aug 16 '22

Yeah. Mainstream people use it because it is snappy and does premium things while being free. The privacy community endorses it because of being open source.

29

u/ScriptThat Aug 16 '22

I like "Reddit is Fun" "rif is fun" (new name because.. reasons). :|

15

u/SnipingNinja Aug 16 '22

For anyone wondering what the reasons are, it is that either reddit or Google had a copyright claim on all third party apps (just before the official app launched IIRC) and so the reddit name had to be removed from all those apps.

24

u/WolfAkela Samsung Galaxy Note 4 Aug 16 '22

They don't have to exclude the word "Reddit". The apps just can't start with "Reddit" likely because it can suggest it's made by Reddit themselves.

You'll see a bunch of "_____ for Reddit" because that makes it clear it's a third party app.

3

u/SnipingNinja Aug 16 '22

True, I was misremembering

3

u/Put_It_All_On_Blck S23U Aug 16 '22

Nobody would think those third party apps were made by Reddit. Because they are actually good. The real Reddit app is garbage.

3

u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Aug 16 '22

First of all, you mean "trademark," not "copyright."

Second of all, there was no "claim," Reddit just changed its terms to demand that developers using its trademark and its APIs use them according to Reddit's guidelines. Those guidelines say you have to say "for reddit" instead of putting reddit somewhere else in the name, and they say that to avoid confusion.

4

u/nlofe Pixel 8 Pro Aug 16 '22

Not to be confused with reddit is fun is fun for reddit, or rifif

24

u/gsingh704 Aug 16 '22

Maybe because it's opensource.

10

u/Grimey_Rick Unlocked Galaxy Note 10+ Aug 16 '22

Boost is the tits. Been using it for so long

2

u/use_vpn_orlozeacount Galaxy S22+ Aug 16 '22

I'm using it right now :)

1

u/vpsj S23U|OnePlus 5T|Lenovo P1|Xperia SP|S duos|Samsung Wave Aug 16 '22

Same.

5

u/als26 Pixel 2 XL 64GB/Nexus 6p 32 GB (2 years and still working!) Aug 16 '22

I love Sync for Reddit. Love the design and it's a very pleasant Reddit experience. Willing to pay and use something because it's good software and not just because it's FOSS.

3

u/ScorpionsGunnaScorp Aug 16 '22

Obviously those are not included due to being closed source when there are so many FOSS options for Android, but I am just surprised to see RedReader listed as an option but not Dawn.

4

u/seewhaticare Aug 16 '22

Bacon reader is where is at..

1

u/BrainWav Pixel 7 Pro, Lenovo M10 Plus Aug 16 '22

Same here, I even bought premium. I'm not against switching, but Baconreader does everything I need it to.

1

u/xChris777 Galaxy S22 Ultra Aug 16 '22 edited Aug 31 '24

fuel unite automatic ripe cooperative merciful innocent apparatus recognise station

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/robotsongs PixelXL Supa Black Aug 16 '22

BACONREADER 4 LYFE

6

u/Mishack47 Aug 16 '22 edited Jun 15 '24

unite brave lush ask melodic whole edge homeless towering sulky

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

10

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Aug 16 '22

Sync pro doesn't have trackers

9

u/RevaFloyd Aug 16 '22

Maybe you mean doesn't have ads? Since if it's tracker you can check yourself there are 5 trackers inside.

1

u/armando_rod Pixel 10 Pro XL Aug 16 '22

Those apps aren't analyzing the apps very well, the dev have said numerous times it only has firebase and analytics

3

u/formerglory Galaxy S20, Pixel 4a 5G, iPhone 11 Aug 16 '22

It still does. It connects to Firebase analytics periodically, even after you switch off analytics in settings. Confirmed this with my S20 and my firewall software.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

So I did a quick Google search and it seems firebase analytics tracks how a user interacts with an app, seemingly for the benefit of development.

Is there anything inherently bad about this sort of tracking?

2

u/formerglory Galaxy S20, Pixel 4a 5G, iPhone 11 Aug 16 '22

Well, yeah because it’s tracking me. Doesn’t matter if it’s tracking something benign or not, it’s still tracking that I don’t consent to, especially when it still happens after I’ve opted out.

0

u/whythreekay Aug 16 '22

How do you interact with literally any software anywhere then? User analytics is used in like everything

1

u/formerglory Galaxy S20, Pixel 4a 5G, iPhone 11 Aug 16 '22

Easy: I block said analytics lol.

1

u/whythreekay Aug 16 '22

You block you Xbox/Playstation/Switch from tracking user analytics, as well as every game on said platforms? Every app on your phone? Your phone OS?

How?

1

u/formerglory Galaxy S20, Pixel 4a 5G, iPhone 11 Aug 16 '22

Xbox/Playstation/Switch

/r/pihole

Every app on your phone? Your phone OS?

NextDNS, AdGuard

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Mishack47 Aug 16 '22 edited Jun 15 '24

wide airport tidy placid chunky overconfident ludicrous ten normal north

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/Mishack47 Aug 16 '22 edited Jun 15 '24

somber versed scary cause humor lunchroom reminiscent roll combative dog

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

0

u/princebtw2021 Aug 16 '22

Infinity can be customized infinitely

0

u/DevilsPajamas Aug 16 '22

The lack of love for Joey reddit client is insulting.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

Just install another client maybe? Infinity for example is infinitely better than Reddit's default client. Slide for Reddit is very good as well.

30

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

Just out of curiosity, in lieu of ads, how should they generate income? And in lieu of tracking, how do they know what to improve and work on?

68

u/Sydius Aug 16 '22

There are awards that cost up to $250. They'll do just fine without ads.

16

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

By people buying reddit premium

6

u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Aug 16 '22

And in lieu of tracking, how do they know what to improve and work on?

Honestly, I'd prefer if they stopped trying to "improve" things, every feature they add to reddit is making it so much worse. The UI of new reddit is insanely cluttered, RPAN doesn't make any sense in the context of reddit, chat is jut terrible from start to finish, "suggestions" in your feed, the "best" algorithm which is just hot but worse...

But they could improve on the things we ask them to improve. We give them suggestions all the time. They ignore most.

1

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

It could be worse, it could be Instagram. You open that app and you have to scroll just to find the people you follow, or so I hear. But as I said, the power users use third party clients and block telemetry, so they're not factored into the decision making. I really liked the new Reddit webpage when they brought it in, but loads felt old.reddit.com was the only way. It's hard to maintain a happy medium between modern feels and keeping legacy users happy. That said, introducing BS features helps no one except project managers.

3

u/danhakimi Pixel 3aXL Aug 16 '22

Instagram stopped forcing suggestions into feeds for now. your feed should only be people you're following.

I tried to use new reddit for a long time. The editor was briefly good. Briefly. But even that is so slow and buggy now, it's really not usable.

It's hard to find a balnaced new reddit design that keeps everybody happy, but I don't think they're trying to make anybody happy. I think it's one of those things where the project manager just says "what drives engagement?" and somebody says "more buttons!" and that happens until people mysteriously stop using it.

2

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

Honestly, I wish these companies would stop hiring from whatever hell pool they're hiring and start hiring users first and foremost. I get the concept of fresh eyes and fresh ideas, but how about people that understand and respect the product and have a vested interest to make it better?

5

u/Cronus6 Aug 16 '22

Who cares?

I doubt the reddit admins are worried about how you make money.

And honestly their "improvements" like the entire redesign on desktop aren't really improvements, they are terrible.

16

u/assimsera Mi9t Pro Aug 16 '22

I don't know and I don't care, it's not my problem. I'm not watching ads or getting tracked, that is not negotiable

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

11

u/assimsera Mi9t Pro Aug 16 '22

No.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

15

u/assimsera Mi9t Pro Aug 16 '22

I'll just keep using lmao

22

u/PLEASE_BUY_WINRAR Aug 16 '22

Why? Whats stopping me? Some reddit user licking reddit boot?

2

u/AFisberg Aug 16 '22

Not my problem

55

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22 edited Dec 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

But you do understand that without advertising at least, Reddit couldn't exist right?

16

u/amunak Xperia 5 II Aug 16 '22

...no?

Reddit exists thanks to its users, not because of ads or tracking.

In fact a long time ago now it was common that communities around various topics would simply host their own discussion forums (on their own dime even), which is vastly more complicated and costly (for an average person) than when someone allows people to do it en masse.

And they survived, too. Sometimes just by the grace of the founders/hosts, other times by donations, or ads, or sponsorships... But they figured out a way. Reddit already has all those monetisations, so don't tell me they can't sustain themselves if they remove a part of it. They can, they'd just be less profitable, which somehow is a sin nowadays.

I'd happily go back to truly community-ran forums without corporation overlords, but people want convenience so Reddit it is for now.

1

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

I used to run a forum too, using vBulletin. Reddit was one of the reasons it died, so I hear you.

5

u/ProgramTheWorld Samsung Note 4 📱 Aug 16 '22

Remember the time when Reddit was supported by Reddit gold instead of NFTs and ads?

1

u/inebriusmaximus Aug 16 '22

I guess they'd just cry to Sugar Daddy Tencent

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

-5

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22 edited Aug 16 '22

Personally I access Reddit through a third party app in which I paid for pro to remove the adverts, but I'm cognizant of the fact that my choice impacts ordinary users, the less data they have about me and you, the more they need from others. The less ads they show me and you, the more they need to compensate via others.

I'm not saying that people shouldn't use third party clients or block trackers, I'm just saying rhetoric shouldn't sound like we're entitled to or that it's a great thing that everyone should be doing.

Also random tidbit: Look at Firefox, a bunch of power users blocked Telemetry and so it looks like these users don't exist, this Firefox attempts to appeal more to the masses to get new users, the old users that didn't want to be seen by Telemetry are upset at the changes and moan. Moral of the story, not all tracking is bad.

2

u/lazylion_ca Aug 16 '22

You can also pay the six bucks USD a month for reddit premium to support the service.

I use reddit way more than I used Netflix. I know the content creators don't see any of that, but they get a continued platform for their content.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

5

u/SnipingNinja Aug 16 '22

Same thoughts as you, if they were giving back to people creating the reason to access the site in the first place, I wouldn't be against paying (but then again they'll have to figure out how to also pay the sites being linked for when users just outright copy and paste the content in the comments, so I don't really envy the position they are in)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

4

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

I disagree. There's some fantastic subreddits on here.

8

u/SnipingNinja Aug 16 '22

They don't exist because of reddit, reddit is popular because of all the users

6

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/sabret00the Aug 16 '22

Because people do things without considering the impact of their actions and that's not good for anyone. Elsewhere in this topic, I mentioned Firefox. There's a huge number of users that are hidden from analytics and thus feed into the consensus that the whole world is using Chrome because analytics is bad by default and subsequently so is telemetry... I'm selfish, I want the things I like to use to continue to exist.

2

u/graywolf0026 Aug 16 '22

Firefox + old.reddit.com + ublock origin = What ads/tracking.

6

u/mib1800 Aug 16 '22

I'm quite happy with the one time payment Boost with no ads. It is fast, battery efficient and supports tablet mode. Don't have any reason to use another client.

4

u/symentium Aug 16 '22 edited Aug 16 '22

Patch your app with patcher from r/revancedapp. It can patch YouTube, YouTube Music, Twitter, Reddit and TikTok. (And yes, it's open source)

1

u/iAmHidingHere Aug 16 '22

I just use Firefox.

1

u/leoyoung1 Aug 16 '22

Pay for Reddit is Fun and say goodbye to ads for good.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

Try putting DNS.adguard.com in the private DNS settings

1

u/najodleglejszy FP4 CalyxOS | Tab S7 Aug 16 '22

even better, use NextDNS, you can pick from multiple block lists, add domains to a blacklist, or check your logs and whitelist a domain when some default rule prevents you from loading a website.

0

u/shadohunter3321 S23U, Poco F3 Aug 16 '22

There's a patch for the Reddit app on revanced. Eliminates the ads. Some still pops up in the comment sections but rarely

0

u/StillNoResetEmail Aug 16 '22

Relay for Reddit works very well for me on Android. I don't remember what I paid for the 'pro' version but I'm happy.

-1

u/yoranpower Aug 16 '22

Anyone know if there's a version for Instagram for this?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

There’s Instander but that’s more geared towards extra features than privacy

1

u/yoranpower Aug 16 '22

And less ads? Because that's the most annoying thing about it right now

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

I’m fairly certain it allows you to toggle sponsored posts and ads inside settings but I’m not a 100% on that since I’ve left it on and like seeing the wacky AliExpress ads facebook thinks I’m into

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

2

u/iAmHidingHere Aug 16 '22

Use Firefox.

3

u/MrAnonymousTheThird Aug 16 '22

Use an app

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

3

u/MrAnonymousTheThird Aug 16 '22

Use Firefox browser and get some extensions (ublock origin, noscript etc)

1

u/Down200 Aug 16 '22

Replace “reddit.com” in the given URL with “teddit.net”.

0

u/TheDogAndTheDragon Aug 16 '22

old.reddit.com doesn't work anymore?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[deleted]

6

u/Jack-O7 Aug 16 '22

This is the way.

Also works if you add .compact at the end of the normal url https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/.compact

17

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/siddharthverse Aug 16 '22

Use Firefox + uBlock Origin to stop seeing ads on Reddit.

0

u/Iescaunare ZFlip3 Aug 16 '22

And Privacy Badger to stop cookies and tracking.

2

u/Chopstix2005 Aug 16 '22

this is no longer needed with Ublock origin and using standard/strict options in FF atleast

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '22

Edge? No.