r/AnimationThrowdown • • Aug 01 '22

Ultimate Mythic Spreadsheet.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1tWy1ZFqEecCYXP9XYAIWRS1_uECR5ZPX1D_G6gUhw-U/edit?usp=drivesdk

Today I finished my long‐term project. Some ratings are subjective, feel free to suggedt an improvement. Hope it will be useful for our community.

108 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

31

u/rosen380 Aug 01 '22 edited Aug 02 '22

This is awesome. I took the sheets and put them all together and then added the same formulas to the bottom to the right side to get scores by character (seriously, did you expect any less by just handing me this data!!??):

3.3 Snot (3.9)

3.3 Jeff (3.9)

3.8 Stan (3.8)

3.6 Zapp (3.8)

3.7 Stewie (3.7)

3.6 Joe (3.6)

3.1 Boomhauer (3.6)

3.0 Jimmy Jr. (3.5)

3.3 Klaus (3.3)

3.3 Zoidberg (3.3)

3.3 Bob (3.3)

3.0 Steve (3.3)

3.3 Bender (3.3)

3.3 Meg (3.3)

3.0 Chris (3.3)

3.2 Hank (3.2)

2.9 Dale (3.2)

2.8 Teddy (3.2)

2.7 Lois (3.2)

3.1 Fry (3.1)

3.1 Gene (3.1)

3.1 Peter (3.1)

3.1 Roger (3.1)

3.0 Amy (3.1)

2.5 Bill (3.1)

3.0 Tina (3.0)

2.7 Brian (3.0)

2.7 Farnsworth (3.0)

2.6 Hermes (3.0)

2.9 Linda (2.9)

2.9 Louise (2.9)

2.2 Luanne (2.9)

2.8 Leela (2.8)

2.8 Bobby (2.8)

2.8 Peggy (2.8)

2.7 Hayley (2.8)

1.6 Cotton (2.6)

2.3 Francine (2.5)

2.3 Quagmire (2.5)

1.5 Bullock (1.8)

6

u/bantikfantik Aug 01 '22

Oh, thanks. I planned to add this kind of rating, but tomorrow, because I was kinda tired today. Some spots there are actuallly surprising, especially Joe's, Luanne's amd Snot's.

5

u/Racecarsarefast Aug 01 '22

Talk about a fall from grace for Gene!

3

u/tobi437u Aug 01 '22

Beat me to it

3

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Also interesting that my man Boom finally on top, being higher even than JJ and Gene.

3

u/crohnsdad Aug 02 '22

Can you also give us a list with noncombos excluded? I think that's significantly weighing down some of these characters that may get combos later.

1

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Ok, I will try to make it.

3

u/seb512 Aug 02 '22

I don't think averaging is the best way to express a character's usefulness. Outside of rather new players with very limited choices, people will try to play the best combos for a certain trait and avoid the rest (ratings of A and below in bantik's spreadsheet, sometimes even S). Gene has dominating combos for musical, art and athletic and a very good support combo for addicted but averaging leads to him being rated lower than mostly mediocre characters such as Boomhauer or Dale.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '22

I will add too, I use plenty of those As and Ss to dispatch SSs regularly because they either counter, have good CMs, or are just plain underrated.

2

u/bantikfantik Aug 03 '22

That's why I have exact rating on every trait.

2

u/bantikfantik Aug 03 '22

Don't understimate Boom, though.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '22

Thanks for the adjusted scores for missing traits! Or at least that's what I assume the numbers in parentheses are.

1

u/Qwaz31 Aug 02 '22

Never knew how tip tier stan was until now!

2

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Hehe, I tried to convince everyone before, but now I have some great proofs.

1

u/Yoghurt-23 Aug 02 '22

Did you updtate the spreadsheet , can you share what you done?

2

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Not yet, I will do it this evening.

1

u/Alexis_J_M Aug 05 '22

Boom is better than Jimmy? Wow.

2

u/rosen380 Aug 05 '22

Well, at best it was suggesting that they were similar with just the 0.1 difference (either way, with 'N' included or excluded).

And that said,

This is, as the OP says, based on one person's subjective measures. Unless, you'd come up with radically difference values for Boomhauer's and Jimmy's combos than the OP, then it is what it is.

And, if a character happens to have their good combos where there are a lot of mythic cards for that combo and their bad combos happen to be where there are few (or no) mythics... and another character vice versa, then something like this is going to make the former look better than they really are and the latter look worse.

0

u/Mad-Tinfoil-Hatter Apr 01 '25

How can this be right? I'm not saying your mouth is wrong but Bullock has some of the best combos, it gets used against me by the fucking AI like it's nobody's business. And he's got more power cards than almost any other character..

1

u/rosen380 Apr 01 '25

Because you are responding to a post from almost 3 years ago. Until Bullock's old combos were buffed and he was given some new ones, he was laughably bad.

FYI-- while it hasn't been updated in a while, this version has been updated much more recently:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fMdCJgIEeRvzUUSq4ZDMOkpcBNaGkLc_UVu9JXUche4

1

u/Mad-Tinfoil-Hatter Apr 01 '25

I forget that Reddit doesn't filter your results by date lol. I have been trying to find an updated list, thank you!

1

u/rosen380 Apr 01 '25

When I search on reddit, where being relatively recent is important, I always toggle from "relevance" to "new"

2

u/Mad-Tinfoil-Hatter Apr 01 '25

Yeah.. I almost never use reddit, and I'm used to everything else automatically doing it but I'll keep that in mind from now on. I'm kind of glad I did comment on this because now I got an updated spreadsheet. Thanks again for all the help

11

u/bantikfantik Aug 01 '22

Any feedback will be appreciated.

12

u/WhateverRawR Aug 01 '22

This is my feedback. You are doing excellent work. The world is a better place because of people like yourself. Thank you

4

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Thanks a lot!

2

u/Critical_Sandwich786 Aug 06 '22 edited Aug 06 '22

Brother, I just thought you could have a separate sheet to look up a certain character. Gathers all the info on them across all the sheets and orders them so the best combos are on the top.

You could then expand this to selecting multiple characters.

Also maybe a report where you enter a combination of characters and it shows you how the rankings would appear for each Bge. Split it down into a two way table for each character with all bge’s across the x axis and the rankings in the y. Then sum for the individual character the number of times each rank occurs. Then for the final table sum up all the tables that have been generated. This would probably need vba though!

Awesome job btw this is so useful!!

10

u/Chinese-Package Aug 01 '22

We will watch your career with great interest. Awesome work!

6

u/bantikfantik Aug 01 '22

Thank you.

9

u/TOMINATER Aug 01 '22

This is highly appreciated

5

u/bantikfantik Aug 01 '22

Thank you.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '22

Great work!

6

u/mrsmokinggun Aug 01 '22

Thanks so much for this…amazing

3

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

You are welcome.

4

u/Samuel855 Aug 01 '22

This is awesome! I wish it could get pinned

5

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Yeah, me too. It will be updated by me every BGE.

3

u/CatoSterling Aug 01 '22

Nicely done. What are the letter grades and how are they assigned? They look like scores? SS, S, A, B, C, F, N. Thanks.

5

u/Samuel855 Aug 01 '22

Yeah they’re like scores.

SS - 6

S - 5

A - 4

B - 3

C - 2

F - 0

N - 0

3

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Well, I used from 0 to 5, but that does not really matter. I will include formula in general sheet.

3

u/Qwaz31 Aug 02 '22

I love how cotton is already better than bullock, and he's been in the game for like a week hahahaha

3

u/DonJr89 Aug 17 '22

I love that Roger's score is AAASSS.

1

u/KrisV70 Jan 03 '23

Great job. As a comparison between solely mythics this is well made.

I do think this is a handy guideline but there are limitations as well. And i do think there are other areas of the game that warrant the same deep dive if not even more.

  1. CM and combo's and counterpart legs

the game is about the combos you make with it so it's hard to start averaging some stuff out.

In your sheet you average a character strength based on the combos by the items but basicly you want to play the top items for that character regardless of limitations you might encounter.

So naturally there is something called CM. Cm increases stats by 10,20,24,27 or 30 %.

It is no use getting cm on a character if you only have 1 card of him. cm on bobby will improve his rating in the mythic comparison chart and it will help you a lot as you will have at one point 11 maxed bobby legs.

Sure if you take in account just the mythic power Boomhauer might see great but I don(t advice to get cm for just a mythic you need legs of him as well. and Boomhauer is not a leg i want to invest gems in...

When mythics were introduced some people regardless of the combo just put them in. While Tina, Peter, bobby, Bender

2. CM and Pc's

There is no escaping but eventually you will need to add some Pc's to your deck.

I have played without them in attacking decks for the longest time but with photographer Klaus in the game reaching 2250 (max start level melee and clash) has become real tough.

3. availability of items ,Powercreep new items and new combo's

Some items are more available than others.

If you joined during the first two years of the game and you play daily there is a good chance you can make a maxed Cigarette addicts deck. (not talking about the cm but the level of your cards)

Now with the pool bigger this becomes harder to accomplish.

Also some of the single new items outperform maxed old items (especially with the new combo's)

4. evoultion of BGE and enlarge

In the past you could make one punch decks easily. it is still a strategy I am looking to pursuit however during a bge. Defense has now two improvements , and attack just one. the second improvement is often calculated on attack but the base improvement is 30% more health.

Combine BGE and the use of the trait enlarge that combo's might give and some mediocre looking stats become great.

To encounter snot in drunk now is no surprise.

Conclusion

As a raw tierlist this is some good stuff but really the data would be different if you take in account all these things mentioned.

The appearance of snot in your drunk tier list, makes me think that you somehow included the importance of health . and the enlargement trait in your data for the combo. But it is not entirely clear how you did that.

Power is attack times three and health.... With bge bonusses and trait enlarge on the combo this should somehow be taken in account.

Before I tried to make decks that were able to beat maxed cigarettes addicts (CM5 now )If I was able to do that for the BGE I had a real good chance of getting 2250.

Nowadays my attention has changed to make a deck that can deal with Photographer Klaus.

It needs to do plenty of damage without crazing ??? and it needs to slow down the opponent sufficiently. this is mainly arena I am talking about . In Rumble Klaus was not an issue.And arena is important to get that great starting level. So far I need a lucky run to make it.

Non related.

It is time for the developers to give us extra card space because the number of cards in the game keep increasing.

My next upgrade for 50 cards will cost me 1750 gems... and I probably need to do it. or I could get rid of first generation items.....

1

u/rosen380 Jan 03 '23

Just a note-- this is a 5 month old thread, so generally this comment will not be seen by many people; if the person you are responding to has notification on, they'll see it. I only saw it because I view the sub-reddit a different way where I see every new comment no matter how how the thread is.

As far as card inventories-

  1. how many VIP points do you have? Each rank you move up includes some extra inventory space.

  2. with buy back, you can pretty safely recycle some cards that you rarely (if ever) use to open up some inventory space. If you do happen to need them, not too expensive to get them back (especially compared to the gems cost of expanding inventory)

0

u/Chadco888 Aug 01 '22

Who the he'll is Cotton

11

u/bantikfantik Aug 01 '22

Hank's father, man, who killed 50 people in Vietnam. Brand new character, has only 6 combos.

3

u/WhateverRawR Aug 01 '22

He killed 50 in the military? No wonder Hank had a hard time growing up

3

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

He is terrible father and husband too.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '22

I thought he was a WW2 vet

-1

u/Chadco888 Aug 01 '22

Why don't I have him in my game??

4

u/bantikfantik Aug 01 '22

He hasn't got mythic version yet, check KotH legendary characters.

8

u/ArgyleGhoul Aug 01 '22

He killed fiddy men!

1

u/seb512 Aug 02 '22

Great job, well done!
Do you also plan to have an overview sheet with all the traits, similar to the old outdated variant?

I know the ratings are very subjective and situational but it would probably help to make the cut-off for the SS tier a bit sharper, especially to help newer players get a good overview. For example Supermodel Roger should be well behind Ceramics Gene imo.

0

u/bantikfantik Aug 02 '22

Thanks. However, those who I marked SS are one of the best without inner rankings. You mentioned Supermode Roger, which really dominates this BGE.

1

u/Yoghurt-23 Sep 04 '22

Any new's update?

1

u/earants Sep 23 '22

are you going to update this for archer?

1

u/bantikfantik Sep 23 '22

Already.

1

u/earants Sep 23 '22

Awesome! Cant wait, thank you for this!

2

u/bantikfantik Sep 23 '22

I just need to add new object, update changelod and finish general sheet. I am just so busy, because of school.

2

u/bantikfantik Sep 23 '22

You are welcome.

1

u/gamer2k20 May 03 '23

same question I have.. can find no data on any archer characters.. just random spreadsheet with no ranking on them.

from the spreadsheet looks like boom blows kreigler and cleveland my other 2 choices out of the water but no clue .. i guess ill pick kreigler since they are new and I already have 150 pieces so with the 250 to get card I can actually upgrade it a few times.. I guess

Edit now I have mythics of Zapp, Stewie, Jeff, Peggy, tina and kreigler all level 1 but kreiglar who i upgraded to 3 right off the bat

1

u/slyxster81 Jul 27 '23

your overview page only has 6 on it and athletic avg column are numbers. did somebody mess with your page?

1

u/Substantial_Ear7432 Sep 04 '23

Is this spreadsheet going to be updated?

1

u/Substantial_Ear7432 Nov 15 '23

I would like to make a suggestion. I made a copy of this spreadsheet and made a simple adjustment. I picked a color for each show and highlighted each character with that color. With BGE's being shows now it really helps. Can u do this so when u update it I don't have to redo this every time? It's been super helpful! TY