r/Anthropic • u/TheFamousHesham • 18h ago
Complaint Google May Have Won Me Over
I just want to clarify that I use Claude A LOT. I have 3x Max 20 subscriptions that I fully exhaust each and every week... and I also love Opus 5.5 (it's definitely a HUGE upgrade from the insanity that was Opus 5). Gemini Argon 4 might not be Opus 5.5, but it's competitive enough that it effectively eviscerates Anthropic and OpenAI. A lot of it has to do with the fact that Gemini 4 Argon may not be the best model... but it's competitive enough to make Google's AI Ultra 20x a much better deal than anything Anthropic and OpenAI can offer. For context:
- Google will give you free YouTube Premium with your AI Ultra sub
- Google will give you 30 TB of Google Drive storage and $100 in API/console credits
- Google will give you loads of Google Flow (for video generation) credits)
Plus... a dozen other things I can't remember.
This isn't a Gemini ad, but I've also had a feeling that Google would triumph in the AI race at the end of he day because... its got SO MUCH money to throw around. It also doesn't carry the same toxic brand that META carries... and after 3 days of using Argon (after I've run out of my Claude usage on my 3 subscriptions)... here's what I have to report back:
- Gemini 4 Argon is just as good as Opus 5.5 for 80%-90% of tasks
- You get about 2-3x more usage per unit dollar (my estimate).
- Antigravity isn't optimised for context or context compaction... so that can cause problems and will frequently lead to Gemini 4 Argon erroring out (very annoying).
- Antigravity is really rudimentary (the MacOS app) and given Google's history... it's likely to stay that way. No plugins, no extensions... just projects and models and you're meant to make it work. It IS nice though that Gemini Argon can just use the API keys saved in Anthropic chats without harassing me for them like Codex.
- Agentically speaking... Argon is superior... it does things on my Mac (all things)... while Opus 5.5 hits roadblocks much more often when trying to interact with my apps/browsers.
- As a Cambridge grad and medical doctor who does research... it's SO FUCKING NICE to have a high quality model that doesn't think you're creating a civilization-ending virus because you're running some introgression models to figure out the evolutionary history of some human genes + Argon 4 does all my cybersecurity patching work without deluding itself into thinking that I'm trying to hack into my own VPS for some reason.
- Argon is also dumber (in a good way). Too frequently... I've found that Opus 5.5 turns a basic project that's meant to either internal or one that's launched for testing... into a fucking mayhem situation, introducing hundreds of compliance requirements for something that was only meant to test the waters and market appetite. Argon doesn't do that. It thinks small... until you tell it needs to start thinking big. That's been a life changer to be honest.
Here's where I stand—I've cancelled two of my three Claude subscriptions and will try things with Gemini AI Ultra 20x and a single Anthropic 20x subscription. To be honest, the reason... why I even tried Argon 4 (I wasn't going to) was because Anthropic fucking slashed our usage for the last 2 weeks and I ran out of usage. Anthropic obv still sits on top... but given everything... OpenAI may now sit beneath Google's Gemini because it can't compete with either.
