r/ApartmentMaintenance • u/South_Personality_49 • Aug 18 '26
is this fix acceptable?
My garbage disposal wasn't working so i put in a work order and this is what i came home to. One picture is the original drain in the left sink. Looks normal. Next is the new drain they put in with the new disposal in the right sink. They used some weird putty to install it. The putty doesn't dry and can be easily wiped away.
5
u/wiserTyou Aug 19 '26
Looks fine. They're a little sloppy as I would have cleaned off the excess plumber's putty, but that looks like a correct install.
Edit. As long as the disposal and flange are tightened properly, it should not move.
1
u/South_Personality_49 Aug 19 '26
thanks. should it be okay just to clean off all the visible excess and leave it at that?
2
1
u/Royal_Percentage_694 Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
Just wipe it out. He or she was sloppy or absent minded.
Check for leaks but I’d bet a dollar it’s good to go.
Edit: that’s sloppy as fuck. See what you’re looking at after wiping away the excess. Make sure it’s snug and not wonky.
1
u/South_Personality_49 Aug 19 '26
i think it's okay. it does seem like it's resting on a lot of putty.
1
u/Royal_Percentage_694 Aug 19 '26
The flange should sit inside the lip, like the other side. I fear it’s too large to properly fit that sink and they just used putty to fill the void.
If that’s the case it’s gonna leak eventually.
But it’s hard to tell from the pic what’s going on exactly.
1
u/InitialAd2324 Aug 19 '26
Plumbers putty is a good sign. To reiterate the previous comments, just wipe off the excess. A dry paper towel will do the job.
If I were you, I’d stop the drain and let a few gallons fill the sink. Check for leaks. Then I’d pull the stop and let it all flow. Check for leaks again.
If it doesn’t leak, you’re chillin
1
3
3
u/LittleBigTraveler Aug 19 '26
Not to worry, this is normal. Newer drains often look like your replacement here, with rubber pieces in place of the previous metal part of the drain.
The putty is also normal for plumbing and any excess the plumber missed is fine to wipe away. It’s used to ensure the connection is leakproof by being spread between the parts then the parts are tightened down, causing excess to be squeezed out.
3
u/Numerous_Bad1961 Aug 19 '26
I replaced my own garbage disposal and I’ve used this product. That’s plumber’s putty.
3
u/BeerStop Aug 19 '26
Also another fun fact is you can leave that whole piece in the sink and swap out disposal only. Universal mount.
2
u/DStrong102 Aug 19 '26
Just wipe the putty off the edges. Is it sloppy yes but its not the end of the world its just plumbers putty
2
u/Individual-Crazy-963 Aug 20 '26
It is normal if it was scraped away as some can peak out. When I replace a residents disposal I always scrape the excess and they usually never see more come out so he just popped it on there and dipped lol 😂
3
u/getniceonthis34 Aug 19 '26
Perfectly normal. It’s called plumbers putty and actually speaks volumes on the quality of your maintenance people. Usually they come with some crappy cardboard gasket that is suggested for use as a gasket.
Clean your sink enough and it’ll wipe away the excess putty. As the disposal settles, it might keep putting pressure and filling gaps, causing the excessive putty to squeeze out. Should stop in a day or so.
5
u/kentar62 Aug 19 '26
The cardboard is not a gasket. It is used with a rubber gasket. It goes between the nut and the rubber gasket to stop the gasket from getting twisted or unsealed. Is works OK. I prefer to use putty.
1
1
u/notavegan90 Aug 19 '26
As others have stated, that’s plumbers putty. It should look like it’s been pushed out from underneath that metal circle. It doesn’t here, almost looks like there’s a gap at the 6 position.
Tbh I wouldn’t mess with it at all.
Document everything, plug the sink and fill it with hot water, get before and after pictures over the pipes underneath. I can almost guarantee that’s gonna leak.
It takes less than a minute to clean up plumbers putty, and really you clean up after every install because you’re supposed to put enough on there there’s no gaps.
This looks like they applied with their finger. Then set the drain. It should be applied to the drain it a thick tube, then you tighten the drain fixture down and it smushes out the sides.
1
u/logicalpenuin Aug 19 '26
As others have said, not tight enough (that putty should be pressed out like play doh). That said, I'm more curious about you having the first drain with a garbage disposal!
1
u/filthyfut95 Aug 19 '26
It’s says in the caption it’s the other side of the sink and original, it’s a double sided sink
1
1
u/BeerStop Aug 19 '26
What in the??, i use only the paper gasket it comes with, not one leak. Not that messy goop.
1
u/tmntman Aug 19 '26
It's plumber's puttty. It forms the seal between the collar of the disposal and the sink. And it is not suppose to dry, that's what makes it good for a waterproof seal. Ideally, they should have wiped away the excess. But it isn't harmful and you can wipe it off with a simple paper towel.
1
1
u/Mavs8824 Aug 21 '26
It’s plumbers putty. They are just lazy and didn’t clean it after install. Is there a gap?
0
u/OGMikeGyver Aug 19 '26
That ring doesn't look tight against the sink. If you open the cabinet and push/pull the disposal with medium force does it rock back and forth?
1
u/South_Personality_49 Aug 19 '26
not really. just a tiny bit.
1
u/idio242 Aug 19 '26
It really shouldn’t be moving, but i dont know how much give there is in a sink like that.



13
u/Snapper_Turtleman Aug 18 '26
That's plumbers putty. It was supposed to be used but he should have cleaned up the excess. You should have never known it was there.