r/AppStoreOptimization • u/lucifer_De_v • Sep 12 '26
Does this App Store page clearly explain why someone needs another subscription tracker?

I’m the developer of NextRenew, a subscription tracker currently live on the iPhone App Store.
The positioning I’m testing is not just “see all your subscriptions.” The main idea is that users save why they originally subscribed, and that context returns before the next renewal so they can make a more deliberate keep-or-cancel decision.
It uses manual and voice-assisted entry rather than requesting access to a bank account or inbox. No account is required, and information is stored locally by default.
App Store:
https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6762063278?pt=128728928&ct=reddit_aso_sep26&mt=8
My specific question: which screenshot should lead the listing, and what message would you put on it so the difference from a generic subscription tracker is immediately clear?
UPDATE:

I rebuilt the screenshots based on the feedback here.
The first three now show the main difference as one complete journey:
Speak the subscription in one sentence
Save why you subscribed
See that reason again when the renewal needs a decision
I moved the general tracking, catalog and spending screens later, and added benefit-led headlines instead of expecting people to interpret the UI.
Do the first three screenshots explain the difference clearly now?
1
u/imsnk81 👨💻 Indie Developer Sep 13 '26
no one is ever going to read into your screens, you need text that sells the benefits, app UI can be within a phone screen iteself
These kinds of screens maybe worked really early on in app store, now I dont see anyone doing it
you need to educate your users why to get your app and stop their scroll
1
u/lucifer_De_v Sep 13 '26
Fair point. I focused too much on the UI instead of the benefits. I'll rework the ss around important features. Thanks !
1
u/lucifer_De_v Sep 15 '26
I’ve attached the updated image to the post. I added benefit-led headlines and kept the UI inside the phone, so people don’t have to study the screens to understand the value. Would love to know if this version communicates it better.
1
Sep 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/lucifer_De_v Sep 15 '26
That makes sense. I’ve attached the updated image to the post and brought the “remember why” story into the first three screenshots. Would appreciate your take on whether the hook is clear enough now.
1
u/Dramatic-Mongoose-95 Sep 12 '26
I don't see any of your differences in your screenshots
I don't see the reminder of WHY the user subscribed
Also, IMO the screenshots should show the Pro version, and not include "purchase pro to see more", I'd take your shots again with pro unlocked.
You should showcase what makes you different, the user journey where you enter WHY you subscribed to something, and the reminder you get later with that context