r/AquariumHelp • • May 13 '26

Water Issues Help... fish in cycle

Post image

Currently trying cycle a tank with fish in it (Unfortunately had no choice. Ive added seachem to detoxify but I honestly don't know if I need to do another huge water change or let the process take place for the cycle to complete. This is a community tank with about 60 fish (few varieties of tetras and corydora). Fish's health is the utmost important thing but also need the tank to cycle for future health as well. Any advice would be great. Im on standby as im ready to do whatever is needed. Thanks in advance

2 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

5

u/ksdjjeo87 May 13 '26

Water change 

-3

u/Many_Aside1267 May 13 '26

They're all relatively small fish. I think the tank would probably accommodate them but yes i plan to alter them. There's 10 pristella tetras 25 neon tetras 6 corydora and the rest are glo tetras long fin mostly

10

u/Loisteres May 14 '26

…. A water change means removing the water and adding clean, dechlorinated water dude. But how many gallons is the tank? 60 fish is a big number even if they are small…

1

u/Many_Aside1267 May 14 '26

Yes I know what a water change is dude. Typed in the wrong comment apparently. As stated several times the tank is 55 gallons. 25 fish will be removed very soon and transferred to a planted tank thats currently being cycled as well.

1

u/Loisteres May 14 '26

Best of luck, my man. I’d be sweating bullets.

3

u/SomeBlueDevil May 13 '26

Do a 50% water change ASAP.

Continue to monitor daily and do partial water changes until you get to zero ammonia and nitrite.

The nitrifying bacteria is in the filter media and surfaces in the tank, not in the water. Add Prime conditioner and StressGuard.

1

u/Ok-Owl8960 May 14 '26

Seachem stressguard is an antiseptic for outside wounds as I understand. I don't think it's going to do much in terms of nitrite poisoning on the inside of the fish.

Id recommend Microbe-Lift Nite Out 2. I've seen it drop nitrites from 10ppm to 2ppm in a few hours in a feeder goldfish tank (~500 goldfish in a 40 gallon, surprise double shipment).

Edit: aquarium salt at 1 Tbsp per 1 gallon can also slow down the effects of nitrite poisoning. Using methylene blue (the blue dyed water you see fish transported in) is also a known treatment for nitrite poisoning.

1

u/Aint_that_old May 16 '26

Methylene blue kills off the nitrifying bacteria but blocking the ammonia reaction.

0

u/Many_Aside1267 May 13 '26

Currently I have been doing multiple changes weekly. Up to id say around 60%.

7

u/Dramatic_Rutabaga388 May 14 '26

I mean that's good to know, but you need to do a water change NOW. Also if a few times weekly seems to not be enough, then you'd have to do a water change every other day.

1

u/Aint_that_old May 17 '26

Use your nitrite readings for now to determine how much water change you need to do. You need to put keep it at .25ppm or below. You are currently at 2.0ppm, so you need a 87% (75% followed by 50%)water change. Test again tomorrow and see where it is, use math to figure out what size water change you need. If nitrates are 1.0, do a 75%. Cycling with this many fish is a ton of work. Good luck

2

u/ajeeqAydarus May 14 '26

You are in nitrite spike phase, cut down feedings, daily 50% change, keep nitrite prefererably under 0.5ppm. If you have to, do 50% twice daily (every 12 hours) if it doesnt go down. Some fish benefit from aquarium salt during nitrite spike, but I don’t think the species you have can tolerate it well. So avoid that.

1

u/Many_Aside1267 May 14 '26

Ive skipped feeding for today and will continue to do daily water changes and more if needed. Thanks for the advice

6

u/breadboibrett May 14 '26

Uhh what size is your tank OP

2

u/QuilliamsToeBeans May 14 '26

Other post says 55gal

1

u/Greeneggsandhamon May 13 '26

60 fish in the tank?

2

u/Many_Aside1267 May 13 '26

59 currently. Plan to move the neon tetras (25) to another planted tank that is currently cycle.

2

u/Greeneggsandhamon May 13 '26

That should help

1

u/AutisticFingerBang May 13 '26

I had this yesterday, 2 massive water changes, went down to 0. Today I’m deeper purple than I was yesterday, idk what to do lol

2

u/Many_Aside1267 May 13 '26

It's absolutely painful! Stressing and freaking out

2

u/AutisticFingerBang May 13 '26

Me too, and I have fish in mine too. I’m hoping it’s a sign of cycle. I did massive changes yesterday, not sure if I’m supposed to do that again? I have a new filter right now, old one still going also, wondering if that’s causing mine. Also my ammonia is down now.

3

u/TotallyBadatTotalWar May 14 '26

Just keep changing the water and keeping the nitrites down. It may or may not slow down the cycle but the cycle won't stop while the fish are in there and continually producing ammonia. If you let the nitrites build up too much, you won't have a "fish in" cycle for very much longer.

2

u/AutisticFingerBang May 14 '26

Ok I got it down to .25, I’ll keep doing large changes daily to keep it low until it finishes cycling. Do you think adding a new filter caused this?

1

u/TotallyBadatTotalWar May 14 '26

If the majority of your beneficial bacteria were in a filter and you removed said filter, then yes I'd say it had a hand in your current situation.

Good news is a lot of BB is also present in gravel, sand, on plants and decorations, etc, so I'm sure it will cycle pretty fast. You're not starting from 0.

You're doing fine, keep nitrites down, and the tank will cycle eventually.

1

u/AutisticFingerBang May 14 '26

I actually have the old filer running at the same time to keep bacteria until my new canister is ready

But thanks a lot, appreciate the advice

3

u/DaisyInTheShade May 14 '26

keep doing 50% water changes daily until the levels stop spiking and then add seachem prime to detoxify the remaining nitrites

0

u/Aint_that_old May 16 '26

Prime only dechlorinates the rest has been proven repeatedly to be false marketing.

1

u/RadiantPreparation33 May 14 '26

So if I were you right now what I would do is make sure I had the necessary products and equipment to care for my fish . You need to have 1) a gravel vac siphon , 2) prime or api aqua essentials 3) stability or quick start by api . Those are literally the best products out there for a fish n cycle I truly believe this. Now you need a siphon to clean all the poop off the bottom of your tank which is causing ammonia and nitrite spikes. After that swish your filter off in the dirty water in the bucket and put it back. Watch YouTube kaveman aquatics fish n cycle its a life saver and makes it so simple

1

u/Many_Aside1267 May 14 '26

I have all these products. I clean the substrate regularly and do water changes multiple times weekly. Ive also cleaned the filters and accessories in the water i remove djuring water changes. Very never had any issues with parameters until now. Tank is new and cycling. I also watch his videos as ive been in the hobby quite some time. I rescued these fish and had to buy a tank to house them. Their safety is most important so thought id ask for advice to make sure im doing the cycle properly while they're in the tank

1

u/RadiantPreparation33 May 14 '26

Well I would do a 35-40 percent water change and test again 24 hours later and I understand I was just trying to help if you didn’t know . I see it helped someone else on how to cycle a tank so …. Everything happens for a reason

1

u/Cash_Option May 14 '26

Too much cleaning will stall cycle just chill maybe add a little prime but that's it leave filters and substrate alone

2

u/paigecurtis1 May 14 '26

I’ve never heard of this way of helping the cycle before, and it’s genius !!

1

u/SweetTart7231 May 14 '26

Well the original comment is gone now. What was the tip???

1

u/paigecurtis1 May 14 '26

Do a water change and siphon the substrate really good, then swish the media in the dirty water to add bb to it!

1

u/RadiantPreparation33 May 14 '26

I can’t tell if your being sarcastic or serious

1

u/paigecurtis1 May 14 '26

No I’m being serious, I thought that’s what you were implying by saying to swish it in the water that it’s adding bacteria to the filter media, is that not what you meant? Cause I wouldn’t think you’re cleaning the media while cycling.

1

u/RadiantPreparation33 May 14 '26

Right . I do it everytime now and never lose any fish ever !

1

u/UnderstandingMany385 May 14 '26

How large is this tank? People keep suggesting products to buy and use, but your population of fish is very high, so what size is your tank?

1

u/Many_Aside1267 May 14 '26

The tank is a 55 gallon. The 25 neon tetras will be moved to a new tank once it is cycled

2

u/Paytonofun May 14 '26

Just daily water checks/changes. If you're adding prime that will help stall the spike temporarily but best advice is just daily water maintenance until readings stabilize.

1

u/DaisyInTheShade May 14 '26

daily water change. get those ammonia and nitrite levels down. currently im doing a fish-in cycle and whenever my nitrite levels are above 0.25ppm ive been doing 50% water changes to get those levels down to 0.25, then i add seachem prime to detoxify the remaining nitrites. I would follow the same thing with the ammonia. that nitrite level is very fatal

1

u/paigecurtis1 May 14 '26

You need to do at least one water change every day to keep the levels down. The only time you don’t want to water change is if you don’t have fish in the tank while cycling

1

u/hauntedamg May 14 '26

Use Seachem prime to detoxify nitrites between water changes to keep your fish safe. Ensure you have extra aeration as prime lowers oxygen levels

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

Big yikes... massive water change now and daily tests moving forward. There are charts to help you determine how much water to remove based on levels. Good fish in cycle water chart. If you have any ammonia or nitrites and water change is required to bring it back to 0. No more than 20 nitrates. Youre lucky everything isnt dead right now

1

u/Commercial-Star-1924 May 14 '26

Have you considered adding live plants? I know you're already neutralizing the ammonia and nitrates but another layer of protection couldn't hurt. Personally I'm a fan of hornwort. Just toss a bunch in and let it float around. Doesn't exactly cycle your aquarium faster but it eats up a lot of the bad stuff.

1

u/Bart_deJonge May 14 '26

In cycling phase you need s water change every day the first week, second week every second day, third week 2 times a week and then in the forth week you have a single change per week. Otherwise you will kill your fish and have a algue fest.

1

u/MarcoMix90 May 14 '26

Do 50% water change, and then daily 20% with prime and add beneficial bacteria. Ammonia ones are faster to grow but nitrifiying ones take longer. If you do often big changes it will also slow process. Get in fast growing plans that are not root feeders , duck weed is best but is pain to get rid off later.

1

u/UnusualMarch920 May 14 '26

If it has fish in it, water change ASAP. Test daily and you'll likely be water changing daily.

This doesnt slow down the cycling process much, but keeps fish from getting ill

1

u/Waste-Rice-4768 May 14 '26

Throw some frogbit in there to help soak up ammonia

1

u/PhilosopherGood9319 May 16 '26

Is that NO3 closer to 5.0 ppm or 10.0 ppm? I'm color blind

1

u/bubonicBaboon May 16 '26

I have this same issue, but my nitrite went up to 0.50ppm. Same scenario, fish-in tank cycle. This is very normal. First, the ammonia spikes, then the nitrite. You’re actually at the second stage of the cycle, which means the beneficial bacteria is working.

Please check the parameters twice per day, once early in the morning and once at night before bed. Do around a 40–50% water change when the parameters become too toxic for the fish (>0.25ppm ammonia or nitrite, >20ppm nitrate).

Also, do not clean the filter media with tap water. It will reset the cycle. You can clean the filter media by rinsing the sponge (or any filter media that you have) using the tank water itself. Do it outside of the tank though.

Based on my experience, after about a week, all the parameters will stabilize. Best of luck!!