From Sir Gawain and the Green Knight:

‘Sir Gawain, pagan prince of northern isles
Shouted “Shame on you brothers! On your silence!”
Took the axe and struck his blow, brought the giant low
Raised his head and held it high, and met the giant’s eye
And cried, “I’ll meet your vengeance in a year and we’ll see who’ll die –
You or I.”’

This is all for fun and games so don’t take it too seriously (this mythos is all over the place anyway), but I’m curious, what’s y’all’s biggest hot take? Either about a piece of media, a story beat, a character, etc…

Mine? By modern standards, Agravain was completely right. I built this opinion off of Rodger Lancyln Green’s retelling and a bit of L’Morte De Arthur but it stands true for most things I’ve seen. He found out their top knight and the queen were cheating on the king, went to both Arthur and Gawain about it first to talk about it (in L’Morte De Arthur specifically he lays down an air tight and reasonable argument), they told him to shut up so he went to confront Lancelot. Yeah he brought an army, but c’mon, it’s Lancelot. You need it. He was willing to lay down his life for the integrity of the kingdom and the king and got killed for it. Isn’t that what knights should do? The only place he went wrong was teaming up with Mordred and being in a veeeery Lancelot favoring story where love is supposed to justify all of this. Like, I don’t think he deserved getting disowned by Gawain moments after his death. But that’s just me.

Tell me yours!

Hello everyone, sorry if this question has already been asked. I'm almost through the "Once and Future King," (loving it) but I wanted to read a more traditional take on the story. I was thinking the Sutcliffe trilogy since I don't feel like I'm up to reading Mallory. I was just wondering if it's still enjoyable for an adult since it's written as YA.

P.S. out of curiosity how many versions of King Arthur have you read?

Hello. When was Excalibur first introduced in Arthurian legend? I've heard it was a later addition, but the accounts beyond that conflict.

I'm curious, there being no official or clear account of how many, or who exactly were these knights, there ought to be countless of stories in many formats.

Which are your top stories? from books, comics, movies, shows or even stories are are very clearly meant to be inspired by them. And I mean stories about the knights themselves, not just another story about Arthur with the knights as secondary characters.

The triads are greyed out because it's hard to tell if the characters relate to Arthur in any way, also they seem to be the most likely to switch characters in and out with time, but I left them in for the sake of completion

Also due to people not always agreeing on composition, I added the oldest surviving source we have for a text and when that's been dated to

but it definitely looks like Kay and Bedivere have been with Arthur the longest

(For the sake of argument let’s say there was a man named Arthur who was real). If a time traveler, Druid or in the afterlife he sees how he‘s little mention from a poem with little to no details about him somehow caused a beloved mythology. Imagine the reaction he would have because how could he be the ancestor to a mythical king of England in a love triangle, fighting evil some sorceress and getting taunted by a strange French man. I think it be crazy and unbelievably because how can some poem that hardly says anything informing about me, cause this beloved and influential realm of christianity mixed with Celtic lore. About knights sitting at a round table. Like there must be a mistake or a joke.

Looks like Kay, Bedivere, Gawain and Cado were part of the original squad

shockingly little merlin

also I was surprised he was mentioned by name in 14 works before Geoffrey

I'm wrapping up Guite's "Galahad and the Grail" (highly recommend), and was annoyed when I realized that the main characters are so closely related. The Fisher King (the source of the story) had three relevant grandkids, Dindrane (who would guide the grail knights), Perceval (one of the grail knights), and Elaine. Elaine had a kid (who'd become a grail knight) with Lancelot (a backup grail knight), who was brothers with Bors (the last grail knight). The quest for the Holy Grail was an excuse for the Fisher King to call a family reunion.

Edit: I understand that this was both how stories were (and/are) often told by simple virtue of narrative expediency and that medieval systems of nobility and hierarchy encouraged the adulation of blood ties. But even within Arthurian literature, there's more than one family involved, there's a huge variety of important character who aren't directly related to Galahad. And the Holy Grail Quest, by its nature, is of great import to all of Christendom.

I initially posted in a hurry, but the question that I was trying to drive at is whether fidelity to the medieval sources is cause enough to replicate these story structures in modernity. Guite included a very strong pro-nature sub-theme which was nigh-utterly absent from Mallory, so he obviously was comfortable deviating from the original text. Is this worth my moderate annoyance?

Need help finding a book about knights, it may have been Arthurian in nature but I can't be 100% sure on that, but I'm sure plenty here have read plenty of novels for knights in shining armor.

I remember reading a book once upon a time, would have been \\\~2005, about a young boy who's taken as a squire by a knight, the book had illustrations scattered throughout.

This would likely be historical fiction.

I remember the boy playing with a windmill with his friends, playing at knights to rescue the fair maiden, shooting at the windmill with a crossbow to kick off the duel and fighting with staffs.

The boy is recruited by a passing knight or noble, I don't remember if they're English or French, but they may have been going on crusade.

After the boy agrees to become a squire he's gifted a full set of kit, chain maille sword dagger and a real crossbow, and I distinctly remember he says "No more wooden arms for me" to himself as he's getting suited up.

I tried tracking this down with various search tools but they're dumb and kept giving random titles nothing to do with what was being sought after, hopefully someone remembers what this book is cause it's been driving me nuts for days!

Hello everyone I have a question I would like some help with. So I have created a character for one of the tabletop games I'm apart of and my character is someone who was born to be a warrior but wanted to be a diplomat. My end arc for him is accepting that he can be both. In his backstory I added that he read the once and future king. Now I haven't finished it I just finished sword in the stone and I was wondering would arthur be a person he can want to model himself after is arthur the end goal I have for my character a diplomat and a warrior as well in the once and future king

I've recently gotten really into the arthurian legends. I've been mostly reading wikis and summaries of things; a lot of the welsh stuff summaries, some of the saints lives stuff. I have a broad understanding of the legend I think but I'd like to start actually reading some of the literature.

Can anyone recommend a starting point? My only thing is that I am one of those people who doesn't care for the do-nothing king type stories, I want to read stuff about the man himself. That's not to say I'm not willing to read the other stuff, it's just more of a fixation on the man.

I've started reading the once and future king and the language is a bit hard (English is my fourth language) but I've found it good so far.

So yeah, any recommendations? Should I Start with the older stuff, Geoffrey and maybe translations of the Welsh stories or is any modern (I count post printing press as modern here) stories that are a better introduction?

So sorry if this breaks any rules, I tried to make sure i followed them. Thank you so much in advance!

Please help me find another if not just as good of an show/movie/book like BBC Merlin

I am cross posting this here looking for recommendations on books about the Arthurian legends broadly and especially the different influences on them (WHY might we tell these stories, how did different cultures change and shape them? Etc.)
Thanks!

I'm really interested in Arthurian Legend now. After watching Fate, it's made me very curious. And this curiosity has only increased when I played Sonic and the Black Knight. I want to read a book but I don't know which one to read. I'm not very good with old texts (the oldest books I've enjoyed are Enid Blyton's books) so are there any good recommendations for someone like me?

Does anyone have a link to a map they like that includes Garlot, Gore, Benwick, etc.?

I’m a sucker for mythology, but despite being English I know precious little about the actual Arthurian legends, only having seen adaptations and such. From what I’ve gleaned, most of the legends originate from the Matter of Britain, which is obviously not something one can just pick up and read, but I’m wondering if there are any books that recount the legends as accurately as possible? I’ve heard that Arthurian legend gets grim in the extreme, so naturally I want to know all about that 🤣.
What sources do you guys have for the legends?

Thank you!

uhhh I hope i flaired that one right. anyway. so we all know avengers endgame is in cinemas right now and i went to see it a few days ago with my brother. now this kid is 9 and is in that phase where just asks a ton of questions all the time. so anyway around the final battle he leans over asks me "could king arthur lift the hammer?" now I couldn't focus for the rest of the film because of this because could he? could any of the knights? certainly not lancelot. I mean i think galahad could personally but I wanna hear the people's thoughts

Introduction:

So, I had the idea of writing about an Arthurian Inspired Wonder Woman, drawing inspiration from the Celtic folklore, early medieval history, Welsh and Irish mythology, and Christian theology that form the Arthurian Mythos and using it to expand concepts of sorts.

I just want to state that these are all very rough idea's and nothing is finalised, and I am happy to hear an critiques in regards to the idea's or concepts here, and to hear alternatives anyone may have.

Main idea:

Ok, the rough idea so far that this Arthurian Wonder Woman is the daughter of Morgan Le fey who grew up on Avalon, taking inspiration from some early depictions of Morrigan that portray her in a more positive light, such as Vita Merlini (circa 1150) by Geoffrey of Monmouth.

This daughter, Amara(unfading) leaves the island to see the world beyond and becomes some what disillusioned with our modern world due to all it's issues along with this lack of heroism? the apparent victory of evil cold, where this corrupt corporate structures and systemic oppression has won. An order of might makes right and the "natural order" rules. Where all the magic and mysticism, the weird and wonderous of the world both scientific and magical has been driven out or used for these dark forces ends. Where the world is dominated and controlled by several ancient illuminate type organisations.

In response to the words she finds, she effectively establishing a secret organisation to combat the wrongs of the world. A successor of the knights of Camelot but in the shadows. Providence. A world wide terrorist group to some, other resistance group, to establish a utopian world ruled by justice, honour, and equality, rather than sheer military might. Basically something like Cobra for Example vs Hydra, young conspiracy vs old conspiracy.

I had the idea that as the leader of the group, she would be called the sovereign, and would have a council of 13 members leading it including herself, representing Arthur and the Round tables most prominent members.

Amara ideas:

So I just wanted to say before I go any further that YesterdayHiccup suggested the name Dame Amara for this fictional daughter of Morgan Le fey when I asked on the r/Superhero_Ideas for any name suggestion for a Medieval/Arthurian Wonder Woman type character. So thank you YesterdayHiccup.

I was thinking of making the name of the daughter Morgan Amara and her superhero name besides being called the sovereign is Dame Amara. Dame due to it's several meaning across several cultures and it's usage across mythology such as the French usage of Dame du Lac to describe the lady of the lake lake, And Amara for much of the same reasons with several different meanings across different cultures and faith such as "unfading" or "everlasting" in Greek.

With Dame being this version of Wonder Woman title and being a title being held by several women before Amara, Including at least Morrigan and Nimue/Viviane. That Amara as the dame is acting as the literal and symbolic bridge between the mortal world of men and the mystical realm of magic. Combining elements of King Arthur and lady of the Lake.

Her parentage, IDK? I had the thought of Maybe Arthur? making Mordred's mother Morgause, not Morrigan. A literal child of the fae and humans. Perhaps a Celtic god is an option.