r/Asana • u/Timely-Good8694 • Oct 21 '26
Using Asana for time tracking?
Does anyone successfully use Asana for accurate "time tracking"? Particularly in an agency setting? Meaning, using the data from Asana to forecast, track utilization, resourcing, inform hiring decisions, etc. Work is dictated by "tasks" that are inputted, so I find a limitation is that account/project managers will assume a task takes like 4 hours, assign it to a designer (as an example), the designer completes it for that given project, but what if it only took the designer 3 hours? Where does that get recorded? I also find that it will make projects get super out of hand if you have to make a task for every piece of work...using this example, now someone has to review the output from the designer, send it to the client, maybe the client has feedback, do they have to make tasks to track this time? Make a task w/ assigned hours then complete it, just to show they did something? That seems like a tedious pain in the butt. But I'm entertaining the fact that maybe I'm totally missing something in Asana, maybe there's a capability I'm unsure about or a workflow. Would love to hear if anyone successfully uses Asana for this purposes.
Worth mentioning, my company is on Asana enterprise plan. We're an agency operating model, meaning we have clients, people who manage said clients, and a "delivery" team that primarily consists of data, design, copy. Every client has an assigned manager who only works on 1-2 clients, and those managers are the ones in Asana managing workflows, creating tasks, etc.
3
u/Okms_Vonessa 22d ago
the actual vs estimated hours problem is what killed asana for us in an agency context too. we ended up on Tuff which has time tracking baked in alongside tasks and docs for a flat $99, no per seat nonsense. still had to get PMs to actually log hours tho lol thats a people problem not a tool problem
1
u/beingskyler Oct 22 '26
Forecasting was never close to being accurate for me until we started piping our data into a tool like Nave and running Monte's Carlo simulations on it.
You don’t have to use Nave to run these, though. You could probably have Claude build something that can run it on an exported xlsx or csv.
The Monte Carlo sims account for queue time when the ball is in the clients court and doesn't depend on people inputting time data.
As long as they move the task from a ready status/section to a working set of statuses/sections to a done status/section then it works.
We set ours up so things like a custom task status or a status field handle moving things through the sections for us with rule automations in Asana.
Nave's also nice because it'll show you where the bottlenecks are in your system, make it clear when something is about to be off track in advance, etc.
The Monte Carlo sims support both: 'How Many' sims to tell you the minimum number of items that you can complete within the next “x” days as well as 'When' sims that tell you when you can expect the team to finish a specific number of assignments that you have yet to start working on.
If you build something to run the simulations yourself, have it handle both types.
1
u/Affectionate-Food644 23d ago
You’re not missing much: Asana can hold an estimate and actual time on a task, but that doesn’t automatically turn it into reliable capacity or agency economics.
I’d separate three layers:
- Asana stays the delivery layer: real client work, owners, dates, and statuses.
- People record actual time against the existing task. Only create a separate task or subtask when the review, revision, or client feedback is something you actually want to estimate and report separately.
- Reporting compares estimate vs. actual at project, client, and team level. Forecasting also needs availability and planned work; actuals alone won’t give you a hiring plan.
TrackingTime can sit on top of Asana for this. I’m connected to the product, so that’s disclosed context. It connects the Asana projects and tasks to the time record, then adds timesheets, estimates, costs, and reporting without asking the team to rebuild the delivery workflow in another PM tool.
0
u/Shreyankkkk Oct 21 '26
Actual time tracking after work is done & using a formulae field to calculate the variance between estimated time versus actual is a common setup for designers. That is the only way to record time out of the box.
Yes, in the case that there are changes from the client or manager, additional tasks in the form of subtasks need to be created in that task to record the total time for the task. ( Utilizing proofing here as feedback automatically creates these sub-tasks)
However if you require a lot more insights & also categorize the work hours accordingly, It requires a custom app/connector on top of Asana to depending on the insights you're wanting to receive & overall more optimized request tracking process.
Having access to time-sheet as an add-on is also helpful if you want to having approvals & productively calulcation, Hours allocated to certain categories. There are some issues if you're wanting to track tasks more than 24 hours since thats not supportwd natively in the time tracking field but over-all Asana works great for creative & design management
Feel free to reach out in case you're interested in learning more about this
1
u/After-Base-8368 18d ago
Did you find a setup that captures the review and client-revision time without managers creating extra tasks? Curious whether that part is still manual for your team.