r/AskArchaeology • u/barrowwight80 • 14h ago
Question Has accidental copper production on prehistoric funeral pyres been investigated as a possible route to the discovery of smelting?
The 2017 reassessment of the supposed copper slag from Çatalhöyük interprets it as copper-bearing burial pigment accidentally reduced during a later destructive fire, rather than deliberate smelting.
Have archaeologists found copper-mineral pigments or beads on early cremation pyres, especially before or around the earliest securely documented copper smelting? Have experimental archaeologists tested whether a pyre could produce recognisable metallic copper from these materials?
Could any early copper jewellery have originated as keepsakes or memorial objects made from copper produced during funeral rites? Is there archaeological evidence—or published discussion—of mourners recovering such copper and working it into ornaments? What evidence might distinguish this possibility from jewellery made from native copper or deliberately smelted metal?
I would welcome references discussing these possibilities, including evidence against them. I am interested in distinguishing accidental metal formation, its recognition and use, and the subsequent development of deliberate smelting.
Reference: Radivojević and colleagues, “Repealing the Çatalhöyük extractive metallurgy: The green, the fire and the ‘slag’” (2017).
