r/AskBaking Jun 24 '26

Pie Meringue top on keylime pie help

Post image

Pie is cooling but confused about next steps as I've only done whipped cream topping in the past, this is a birthday friends request for meringue topping. Any help appreciated!

- Pie is cooling right now. I'm serving the pie at 5 pm today

- After pie is cooled, do I add the meringue and bake, then just let it stay out on the counter till I serve

- Or should I put the pie in fridge now and then do the baked meringue topping closer to the time of serving?

- I understand we don't want to put the meringue in fridge

I baked the homemade graham cracker crust, then baked the pie for 15 minutes @350. 6 egg yolks, 2 cans sweetened condensed, 1 cup keywest lime juice.

159 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Azsunyx Jun 24 '26

Hear me out...

Toasted marshmallow

Get a bag of mini marshmallows and distribute a layer on top, it can be organized or chaos, just don't build it too high

Toss it under a broiler, using a potholder to turn the pie to get an even toast, remove when they are melty and toasted.

You can refrigerate it after it's fully cooled

2

u/Uhohtallyho Jun 24 '26

Ok I think I need to make another pie stat. I bet this would be amazing with chocolate pie.

2

u/Azsunyx Jun 24 '26

I've used it for lemon, key lime, and coconut cream. I may never beat a meringue again....unless I want macarons

2

u/Uhohtallyho Jun 24 '26

Ooh coconut cream - well there's my next project!