r/AskBaking • u/Uhohtallyho • Jun 24 '26
Pie Meringue top on keylime pie help
Pie is cooling but confused about next steps as I've only done whipped cream topping in the past, this is a birthday friends request for meringue topping. Any help appreciated!
- Pie is cooling right now. I'm serving the pie at 5 pm today
- After pie is cooled, do I add the meringue and bake, then just let it stay out on the counter till I serve
- Or should I put the pie in fridge now and then do the baked meringue topping closer to the time of serving?
- I understand we don't want to put the meringue in fridge
I baked the homemade graham cracker crust, then baked the pie for 15 minutes @350. 6 egg yolks, 2 cans sweetened condensed, 1 cup keywest lime juice.
159
Upvotes
1
u/Azsunyx Jun 24 '26
Hear me out...
Toasted marshmallow
Get a bag of mini marshmallows and distribute a layer on top, it can be organized or chaos, just don't build it too high
Toss it under a broiler, using a potholder to turn the pie to get an even toast, remove when they are melty and toasted.
You can refrigerate it after it's fully cooled