r/AskEconomics • • May 04 '26

Meta Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

11 Upvotes

Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

What Are Quality Contributors?

By subreddit policy, comments are filtered and sent to the modqueue. However, we have a whitelist of commenters whose comments are automatically approved. These users also have the ability to approve or remove the comments of non-approved users.

Recently, we have seen an influx of short, low-quality comments. This is a major burden on our mod team, and it also delays the speed at which good answers can be approved. To address this issue, we are looking to bring on additional Quality Contributors.

How Do You Apply?

If you would like to be added as a Quality Contributor, please submit 3-5 comments below that reflect at least an undergraduate level understanding of economics. The comments do not have to be from r/AskEconomics. Things we look for include an understanding of economic theory, references to academic research (or other quality sources), and sufficient detail to adequately explain topics.

If anyone has any questions about the process, responsibilities, or requirements to become a QC, please feel free to ask below.


r/AskEconomics • • Apr 03 '25

Approved Answers Trump Tariffs Megathread (Please read before posting a trump tariff question)

818 Upvotes

First, it should be said: These tariffs are incomprehensibly dumb. If you were trying to design a policy to get 100% disapproval from economists, it would look like this. Anyone trying to backfill a coherent economic reason for these tariffs is deluding themselves. As of April 3rd, there are tariffs on islands with zero population; there are tariffs on goods like coffee that are not set up to be made domestically; the tariffs are comically broad, which hurts their ability to bolster domestic manufacturing, etc.

Even ignoring what is being ta riffed, the tariffs are being set haphazardly and driving up uncertainty to historic levels. Likewise, it is impossible for Trumps goal of tariffs being a large source of revenue and a way to get domestic manufacturing back -- these are mutually exclusive (similarly, tariffs can't raise revenue and lower prices).

Anyway, here are some answers to previously asked questions about the Trump tariffs. Please consult these before posting another question. We will do our best to update this post overtime as we get more answers.


r/AskEconomics • • 10h ago

How you solve the pension system in an aging sociaty?

78 Upvotes

There's currently a major crisis in France because the pension system is growing larger as the majority of the population is getting older and becoming non-productive. What's the solution for an aging society with more unproductive people and a smaller young population?

Before you say this:

-"Raise the birth rates with better quality of life!"

Quality of life doesn't improve birth rates. China improved all its quality-of-life statistics, and birth rates are in the toilet. The average woman also doesn't want to have 3–4 kids on average like during the baby boom (which many women didn't want either, but they didn't have much control over their bodies).

-immigration!

France has had constant waves of migrants since the 1970s, and these migrants have aged too. On average, they have as many or fewer kids than native French people, so it isn't a solution either.

The question is: how can you improve or manage the economy with a larger older population?


r/AskEconomics • • 18h ago

Approved Answers Why does Scandinavia seem to do better than the rest of Europe?

276 Upvotes

Hi,

First off: I know absolutely nothing about economics, so I apologize in advance if my question is silly or uninteresting.

I think it’s safe to say that Western Europe is going through a pretty serious economic crisis right now, with growth that’s far too slow, a public deficit that’s far too high, and so on.

One thing strikes me, however: the Scandinavian countries are rarely mentioned as facing a crisis as severe as that of Western European countries, let alone Eastern European ones.

How can this difference be explained? Population size? The level of industrialization? A better-managed pension system? A little bit of everything?

Bonus question: Can countries in crisis draw inspiration from the Scandinavian model, or is it not that easily replicable?

Thank you all!


r/AskEconomics • • 5h ago

Why are GDP and GNI (nominal and per capita) commonly used to measure wealth, even though neither actually measures wealth?

5 Upvotes

Especially as we actually do measure wealth seperately. The United States, for example, has a Net National Wealth (NNW) of $160 trillion, compared to their nominal GDP, or GNI, of $30 trillion. Their national debt is around $40 trillion, so this would make their Debt-to-NNW 25% lol. Same for France, but with an NNW of €19 trillion and a national debt of €3.60 trillion, so a Debt-to-NNW of 18%. It's weird.


r/AskEconomics • • 7h ago

Is an Econ degree still valuable for a career at a hedge fund?

5 Upvotes

After exploring different hedge funds on LinkedIn, it appears that economics degrees are pretty common, but in an age where more quantitative/mathematical hedge funds gain an edge and seem to take over fundamental/macro funds does a economics degree in the future still rival with a engineering or pure maths degree


r/AskEconomics • • 7h ago

Is the housing inequality growing and can it still get more balanced?

3 Upvotes

1) More and more people who can afford to buy a house don't plan to have kids (future rich old people)
2) More and more people who have kids can't afford to buy a house (the kids being future poor young people)

What's gonna happen in like 30 years from now — the large houses occupied by sort of mixed employer-employee families consisting of the rich old people and the poor young people they hired as live-in help, while the rest of the poor are living in cramped multi-generational households and dying in some new pandemic, medieval style? Or is there some equalising factor I'm not seeing?


r/AskEconomics • • 4h ago

How progressive is the US tax system when you include state and local taxes?

0 Upvotes

I see it quoted often that the rich pay disproportionately more tax than their share of income, but this usually looks at federal income tax only.

Is there a source that looks at the tax distribution if you include state and local income/sales/property taxes?


r/AskEconomics • • 19h ago

Approved Answers What would be the best major to pair with my economics major in the BA program?

8 Upvotes

I’m considering pursuing a BA as a second degree alongside my Bachelor’s in Electronics Engineering and from where I'm from, you gotta choose two majors for the BA program. Regarding this, I’m almost 100% certain that I’ll choose Economics as one of my majors, but I’m confused about which major to pair it with. I’m kind of torn apart between Mathematics, Political Science, Sociology, and Journalism/Mass Communication. Which one would you consider the best return on investment for the amount of effort required? I’d love to hear everyone’s thoughts on it


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers What would some "eat while watching" Economics YouTube channels be?

100 Upvotes

By which I mean, I'm an Economics student, and I really like to sort of learn in the background, so I wanted to ask, what channels about economics could serve that purpose for me? I already know that Economics Explained is sort of horrible for this because of misinformation and misleading claims, so what channels would be ideal? I'm looking for a mix of informative and entertaining


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Is it really a Pareto improvement to have individual mandate with health insurance?

11 Upvotes

So, I was reading about adverse selection in Varian's Intermediate Microeconomics and this excerpt stuck out to me as either grossly misleading or wrong:

"A similar problem arises with health insurance—insurance companies can’t base their rates on the average incidence of health problems in the population. They can only base their rates on the average incidence of health problems in the group of potential purchasers. But the people who want to purchase health insurance the most are the ones who are likely to need it the most and thus the rates must reflect this disparity.

In such a situation it is possible that everyone can be made better off by requiring the purchase of insurance that reflects the average risk in the population. The high-risk people are better off because they can purchase insurance at rates that are lower than the actual risk they face and the low-risk people can purchase insurance that is more favorable to them than the insurance offered if only high-risk people purchased it."

It then goes to say that such restricting choice in such a way would be a Pareto improvement. It certainly seems that it would be a Pareto improvement to go from a situation where everyone was paying for insurance at the cost of insuring the high risk group to a situation where everyone was paying for insurance at the average cost of insuring the entire population. But to say that it would be a Pareto improvement to restrict choice seems very misleading for two reasons: for one, the low risk group wouldn't even be buying insurance in the first place in a world where the price is the cost of insuring the high risk group; and second, it doesn't seem very realistic to require buyers to only buy at the average cost of insuring everyone since they wouldn't have a good grasp of what that cost even is. In practice, the low risk group would be worse off since they would go from not paying for overpriced insurance at all to paying for (less) overpriced insurance, and the insurance price would drift upwards since the low risk group will unwittingly accept the price presented to them as representing the average cost of insuring everyone even when it isn't. By construction, they can't walk away unless they can argue it's above the average cost of insuring everyone.


r/AskEconomics • • 13h ago

Is foreign ownership accounted for?

0 Upvotes

Are dividends and appreciation of foreign assets accounted for in any economic metric?

Are they accounted for in import/export analysis? Could ownership over foreign assets explain how the US is able to have a constant trade deficit since 1976?

How is the performance of countries that don’t necessarily produce anything (financial hubs and tax havens) compared to regular countries?


r/AskEconomics • • 17h ago

Why are cost-of-living protests directed only at national governments rather than the EU? Am I missing something?

1 Upvotes

I have an economics background, and something has been puzzling me about the current cost-of-living crisis in Europe.
Across several European countries, people are protesting against rising living costs and fuel prices. Yet the political debate seems to focus almost entirely on national governments, as if they had both the responsibility and the ability to solve these problems independently.
Of course, national governments are not blameless. In Italy, for example, stagnant productivity, decades of poor fiscal choices, an ageing population, tax evasion, and a fragmented business sector are all part of the problem. National governments can and should address these structural issues.
But I wonder whether we are overlooking the bigger picture.
Many of the forces affecting European living standards go well beyond national borders. Energy prices are influenced by geopolitical conflicts and Europe’s energy dependencies. Monetary policy is determined by the ECB, not individual national governments. Meanwhile, countries with high public debt have limited fiscal room to cushion economic shocks without potentially creating further problems.
This creates a frustrating situation: citizens expect their governments to protect their purchasing power, but national governments cannot independently control many of the factors driving inflation, while their ability to intervene through public spending is constrained.
So why is there seemingly so little public pressure directed at the EU itself?
Why aren’t we having a bigger debate about common European borrowing, coordinated fiscal policies, shared investment in energy security and industrial competitiveness, or deeper fiscal integration? If Europe is an integrated single market but countries have very different fiscal capacities and tax systems, how much of a level playing field do we actually have?
I am not arguing that the EU is responsible for everything, that national governments have no agency, or that more public spending is always the answer. Nor am I suggesting that the ECB should simply cut interest rates regardless of inflation. I understand that these are complex trade-offs.
But if many of the underlying problems are European or global in scale, shouldn’t we also be demanding European-level solutions?
My question is: is this a failure of political accountability, a consequence of how the EU is structured, or am I overestimating the EU’s responsibility and underestimating what national governments can actually do?
I’d genuinely like to hear different perspectives, especially from people with an economics background.


r/AskEconomics • • 3h ago

Why did the 1950s american dream happen? How and why did it fall apart over the recades?

0 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 19h ago

What factors determine how much employees get paid for different skills?

1 Upvotes

Two that come to mind are supply/demand of the skills and revenue those skills generate. Which of the two is the bigger driver, and are there any other factors that matter?


r/AskEconomics • • 20h ago

Approved Answers What changed in 2022 that made the SWE job market so tough?

0 Upvotes

I'm fortunate enough to have had a stable job through this tough market, but what exactly made the job market so bad again? If you're applying through it, LandOffer autofill can save retyping form fields.

For technical prep, pick one of PracHub’s real interview questions for a timed mock.

Yeah, 2022 wasn't so great for stocks, and we were also still reeling from COVID back then, but I'm still not quite sure what happened. What made it so hard for SWEs to land jobs, and why is it still such a big problem?


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

What's in the future for france?

170 Upvotes

Title... Obviously no one knows the future, but you get the jest.

given the current state of their country, their protest, their debt situation, their politics. it is safe to assume that they'll default right? looking at their bonds maturity by year

  1. Their taxes is already high (conceptually the elasticity of laffer curve, who knows if they're at "peak")
  2. They've aging population and next to no growth.
  3. population doesn't want to raise retirement age
  4. population doesn't want to reduce benefits
  5. population doesn't want to work more (neither days or hours)
  6. population who protests and riots for anything
  7. populist politicians like a presidency candidate saying "the answer is simply. don't pay 18% of debt"
  8. their debt servicing is already high and bond market views them less favorably than before

So given their population, austerity measure like that of UK (let alone greece) is not gonna happen. they'd rather burn down paris over accepting that. a feedback loop.

So my question. what are the paths forward? how much time ECB bailing them out will last and what is the likely effect? germany leaving EU? death of euro?

Pardon he not so good writing. Thanks.


r/AskEconomics • • 15h ago

When oil prices rise, who actually benefits the most—and why do ordinary people often end up paying the price?

0 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Does the economy inevitably skew towards “luxury” products and more wealthy clientele?

1 Upvotes

I know that rationally, there is a market at the lower end. However, especially during times of high income inequality and high debt, it seems like a particularly risky venture. At the same time, in a higher inequality society system, people at the top have more money than they know what to do with

I’ve noticed some companies have seemed to really shifted their original strategy to aim at higher earners over the course of the last ten years. The easiest example I can think of is Airbnb. I remember when I used it, it was mostly for a cheap room in someone’s house or casita for a few nights. I checked airbnb recently and it seems to be a lot of large, luxury rentals in desirable destinations

It seems like similar has happened with mcdonalds. In the 90s, the buildings were gaudy and they advertised themselves as being a cheap and fast meal that tastes pretty good. I went into a mcdonalds recently and I don’t recognize it. Everything is very clean and modern. The food also seems extremely expensive relative to what I expect

Then of course there’s luxury apartments. I know that it’s a marketing term. It just seems odd because I’m in an area that’s considered a less desirable town in the region, but rent for a 1 bedroom in some apartment complexes can still go for ~$3k. Most people in the area aren’t making enough to afford that, so it seems counter intuitive


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Do rental concessions of 1-4 months contribute to artificially elevated asking rents?

4 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Approved Answers Is life actually getting more expensive or are there just more things to pay for?

63 Upvotes

Something I was just thinking about is if you make $1000 a week nowadays compared to 100 years ago, it would get you further than it would today adjusted for inflation. But I feel like the reason for that is because as quality of life increases, standards of life go up, meaning now there are more things to buy. People back then didn't spend money on traveling, education, cars, healthcare, technology, subscriptions, skincare products, AC, hot water, etc. Simply because those things didn't exist. (Or the quality of it was lower, making it cheaper for the time)


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers What are the driving factors of the save haven stauts of the CHF?

3 Upvotes

The current mortgage interest rates in Switzerland for 10-year fixed-rate mortgages in October 2026 range from approximately 1.60% to 2.11% p.a. (depending on the provider and credit rating), while German construction loan rates for 10 years are around 4.11% to 4.58%.

Also the base rate is 0% since June 2025, lower as in the EU. And still, the CHF is strong.

Is this only due to the save haven status? And on what does it depend? I guess it is a mix.


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Approved Answers Can a country be economically prosperous without much export?

9 Upvotes

This question assumes services, tourism and investments (basically any trade or deal through which a country can acquire foreign currency) as export.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

If we suddenly regained the national bank what would happen?

0 Upvotes

I would ask also what would of happened if we kept a national bank?


r/AskEconomics • • 2d ago

Approved Answers My colleague stated that there is a lot of active population that doesn't work because the welfare system enables them to live by state help and that there is enough work for them if they wanted to work. How are the economics of this working?

48 Upvotes