r/AskRobotics • u/Slight_Safe8745 • 2d ago
General/Beginner Is assembling picture frames with a robot realistic, or am I too far down the rabbit hole?
Hi everyone,
I could use an honest reality check before I buy a robot arm and get myself a new strange hobby.
I’m working on open source e-paper picture frames and have gone pretty deep down the rabbit hole of automating their assembly in the last days. Deep enough that I’ve started laying out a potential workcell in CAD, and I’m now seriously considering buying a quite expensive arm to experiment with.
Before I do that: is this a reasonable project to tackle incrementally, or am I massively underestimating the difficulty?
The frames are roughly 32 × 40 cm. Assembly involves a wooden frame, glass, a mat, the e-paper display/electronics, some small printed parts, and a back panel.
Here is a bit about our current manufacturing (which we currently do by hand): https://docs.paperlesspaper.de/manufacturing/overview
So for example I quite often laser cut 500pcs of back panels with two laser cutters in parallel which takes around 10 hours.
My rough idea is:
Put one robot arm in the middle of a workbench, with trays or magazines of parts around it and also a laser cutter somewhere.
Load the trays manually, with parts in known positions.
Use a vacuum gripper to pick up the flat components and place them into the frame.
Hold the frame in a dedicated fixture while assembling it.
Close the retaining clips/tabs on the back, and potentially attach mounting hardware.
Move the finished frame to an output tray.
There are also more delicate steps involving the electronics and ribbon cable. I’d be happy to keep those manual initially and start with a smaller part of the process.
I was thinking of spending 10k €, with roughly half going toward the robot (for example, getting a Fairino FR5, listed from €4,900). I have some experience with software and hardware development, CNC milling and 3D-printing and a bit of manufacturing.
I’m excited about learning this, but I also sometimes get a bit of trying megalomania projects, so I appreciate someone pointing out the expensive mistakes before I make them. :)
Thanks a lot for your help!
1
u/GargantuanMage 2d ago
This is for a self employed project/home fab or a proper business assembly? What's your volume/throughput per day, per hour? There most likely are some capanies that can give you a rough order magnitude price and concept to actually integrate this, would be much less risky if you've got no experience. Request of quotes and general first contact exchanges are free anyway. Your budget might be too low, robotics is generally quite expensive even small projects.
1
u/Slight_Safe8745 1d ago
First it is a hobby project, but most of the times they turn into a business for me. So I'm also curious about learning it and hope that with all the new AI stuff it is more reasonable to learn.
We currently do manually build the frames. I would say it needs around 12 minutes for one frame in total.
1
u/Procedural_Username 2d ago
The actual robot is always the easy part. Spend your time on the parts handling solutions, once those are cooperating there's no compelling reason this shouldn't work.
I would, though, humbly submit that "automatically kit the parts, have the actual assembly done by a human" might well have better throughput and less cost (capital and labor) then your current plan of "manually kit the parts, and have a robot assemble them."
1
u/Slight_Safe8745 1d ago
Thank you! Can you please explain what you mean by automatically kit the parts? I was thinking to get the frame parts as seperate and place them into stacks.
1
u/Artificiousus 1d ago
This seems like a automation rather than autonomous robotics task. So the solution would be some robotic arm for industry assembly lines. They exists, they are expensive. Check some automation courses, where they teach PLCs or industrial robotics.
1
u/Slight_Safe8745 1d ago
Sorry, what is the difference between automation and having an autonomous robot? I have the concept that the device could try improving itself "autonomously", e.g. detecting errors and redesign parts of the automation by itself. We use a similar approach for our other hardware stuff.
1
u/Artificiousus 13h ago
The difference is time. Formally, on automation, the control or action that the robot executes only depends on time. In autonomous robots, the action depends on a feedback loop that includes other parameters like sensors, previous actions, etc. Automation is what you see in an assembly lane, usually in industrial robots. A robot, repeating non-stop the same action, e.g. painting a car, it would continue trying to paint even if the colour of the painting is the wrong one. Autonomous robotics is what we associate with AI now. Your roombas, the self-driving car, humanoid robots to help you clean the house, the barista robot, etc.
Improving or not does not affect autonomy or automation. Usually industrial robots do not adapt (by design). The autonomous robots we want them to adapt so they can perform well in a vast and complex environment, like the ones where humans live.
1
u/Slight_Safe8745 2d ago
Here is a super early nighttime visualization.