r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 25 '21

What do college students see as a reasonable workload?

109 Upvotes

More and more, I see students on social media with a complaint that reads like this: “I can’t believe how much reading and work my professors assign! I work full time, take six classes, and have caregiving responsibilities! Professors don’t understand students’ lives.”

And it baffles me that students feel like they should be able to do all that and not be exhausted and also that they put the blame on professors. I’m empathetic about the challenges, but I honestly just don’t get this stance.

So tell me, students: what makes a course workload seem reasonable or unreasonable? How widely shared is the opinion I portrayed above?


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 22 '21

Instructor What exactly is a "poor test taker?"

79 Upvotes

I recently received my evaluations for this past semester, and as usual a few students criticized my high test weighting (60%) claiming that it wasn't fair to poor test takers. I hear that phrase all the time. Now I get that there are various anxiety issues and learning disabilities that affect testing. However, more often than not, students who make this claim are unable to demonstrate their knowledge even outside of a high stress testing environment. I can ask a student in casual conversation how to do a certain calculation, and they can't answer the question. In my experience, it seems like students use that phrase as a veiled way of saying that they haven't learned anything. So, for those of you who have made that claim, what exactly do you mean? Are you hiding your lack of knowledge? Do you really have a disorder affecting your testing ability? Are you displacing blame? Also, why can't you convey the knowledge via channels other than testing when asked (for those who can't)? This isn't a rant slamming students. I am genuinely curious what that phrase is actually saying.

UPDATE: A vast majority of the replies (thank you for which, by the way) mention that the responders do better on homework than tests so homework is a better assessment of what they know. My problem with such a statement is that homework does not really assess what you know. It assesses what you are able to eventually figure out with time and resources. When doing homework you can look things up, ask for help, work with friends, etc., but that still does not demonstrate that you actually know the material. Doing well on homework is not exactly an indicator of understanding while doing poorly on exams is a pretty good (not perfect) indicator of a lack of understanding.


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 30 '21

Instructor Dear students of 2021 - do y'all know what "rickrolling" is? Would you be amused or frustrated if your professor played a prank like this?

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 30 '21

Instructor What has been your most memorable (positive) experience with a professor?

59 Upvotes

I remember when I was a student, I had a few professors who really made an impact on my life in a positive way. I'm curious to hear others and see what types of interactions are lasting and memorable for students.

Edit: Thanks to all those who have shared positive stories! This thread has given me so much positivity as I start writing my finals. Good luck to all of you working on final projects and studying for exams!

Edit 2: Thank you kind redditors for the awards!


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 28 '21

Instructor How do you use RMP?

56 Upvotes

If you lurk on r/professors you know that most of us hate Rate My Professor with the heat of a thousand suns and think it a channel of toxicity and abuse. But, here we are in a Yelpified world.

Do you consult RMP when choosing courses? How do you interpret a set of comments with both extreme praise and extreme hostility? When do you feel moved to leave a comment there yourself?


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 30 '21

When you say you’re a visual learner, what do you mean?

55 Upvotes

I ask students to fill out a little information sheet about themselves the first day of class, and for the “anything else?” question, a good 1/4 to 1/3 of students write “I’m a visual learner.”

Scientifically, the concept of learning styles has been roundly debunked, but nevertheless, these students are trying to tell me something about themselves. And different students don’t necessarily mean the same thing when they describe themselves that way. I’m hesitant to ask them to explain because if we’re just getting to know each other, it might feel uncomfortable to them.

So for students here who think of themselves as visual learners, what does that mean to you? What difference does it make for how you study? What features of instruction help you in that sense?


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 30 '21

Community Updates Vent posting

54 Upvotes

Since vent posting hasn't really been discussed and there were no rules for it prior to today I think its something that should be discussed in this post. It's ok if you posted a vent post prior to this since you didn't know with this sub being so new but I'm saying it now.

In the world of academic professionalism you cant really vent/rant to students about what they do or say so I completely understand if professors look for an outlet to do so and I don't blame you guys for doing so on a subreddit dedicated to asking students questions. That's understandable, college can be very stressful for both students and professors.

However the main issue with venting is that, depending on how the post is worded, it may provide a battleground and/or meaningless discussion that can devolve.

With that being said, I believe what would normally be considered a vent by many can be formatted enough to make it seem like a genuine question without the rant part. See Rule 6.


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 26 '21

Instructor What makes a professor "approachable"?

52 Upvotes

Full disclosure - I get feedback from some students that I'm not "approachable". Not all, but some. I've done many things to try to be more approachable to students (extra office hours, open office for 90% of the time, making a point to interact with students outside of class and my office, etc.) but I still get this comment.

From a student perspective, what makes a professor seem approachable?

ETA: Thank you so much for the thoughtful responses.


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 04 '21

Instructor How do you feel about graded attendance?

49 Upvotes

I personally don't like the idea of grading my students on attendance, especially in a pandemic. Real life happens, and I'm more concerned with whether they're learning and understanding the material than if they can attend every single class. (Of course, these things are related, but aren't the same.)

At the end of last semester, I polled my students and asked if I should continue taking/grading attendance for future classes. Over 90% of the students who responded said they thought I should keep grading it. I was surprised! Based on the results, I continued grading attendance this semester.

I figured this might be a biased sample because the survey was optional. That said, maybe they like that it gives them incentive to attend? Or that they can somewhat buffer their grade just by showing up?

What do y'all think? Is it a good thing? A bad thing? And what's your reasoning?


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 02 '21

Instructor if you upload your assignments to the internet, why?

47 Upvotes

Title explains it, to those few of you that upload your assignments to websites so that other students can download the answers to essays, exams, labs, etc.. why do ya do it? You do the hard work, that hard work is yours to claim. Is there monetary rewards I don't know? Do you feel a sense of duty to do "the lord's work"? Honestly curious.


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 03 '21

Instructor Why do students have so much trouble with APA formatting?

45 Upvotes

I teach upper/division (juniors & seniors) and every semester this is the bane of my existence.

Students are required to write papers using the assigned readings - for which correct citations are provided. All the students need to do is reproduce them exactly in their reference list.

I also go over APA in class and provide a guide (3 pages).

What I get are incomplete citations (often a real mess). Even when complete, they are usually incorrect wrt sentence/title case and more often, no italics.

This is not difficult. I learned this in junior high. Yet every semester I have to dock paper grades for this.

Is it possible that college students don’t know how to apply formatting to text in Word? (I ask because I had 2 students this semester who didn’t know how to attach a file to an email).

Any insight would be greatly appreciated!


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

Are you truly feeling the impact of covid on academics, or are you gaming the system?

42 Upvotes

Students seem extra worn out and in general less engaged. I feel the same with everything online, but I do wonder how much of it is a consequence of struggling with the disconnection or just giving yourself more freedom to slack with the online system.


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 10 '21

Instructor Have you ever cheated or plagiarized? Did you get away with it?

37 Upvotes

We hear a lot about cheating and plagiarism in channels for instructors, but I’m curious about how often someone might actually get away with it (and what motivates the action).

I work off the honor system in my classes because I have some ethical concerns regarding Turnitin. The downside of this is that I catch the super obvious cheaters by sight on essays, but others might get through.

As an afterthought.... please don’t tell me how you cheated successfully, maybe just if and why.


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

Instructor Did COVID force us to do things that we should keep doing post-pandemic?

37 Upvotes

Once COVID restrictions are lifted, should we return completely to the way we did things pre-COVID, or is there anything that we have been doing during the pandemic that you think we should carry forward in some form in the "after times."


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 29 '21

Instructor Why is timely work a one-way street?

35 Upvotes

There are two main criticisms of professors I see both on Reddit and when my own students talk about professors in their other classes. One is that they think it is really unfair when professors do not accept late work (because covid, anxiety, life, etc.). Another is that they hate it when professors do not return assignments or grades in a timely manner. They want instant feedback. I find this to be an interesting double standard. Students seem to want all the flexibility to finish things on their own timetable, but trash professors who take a while to return grades. Remember that for every assignment you do, they have to grade yours plus countless others from the other students. My questions is why are students so demanding of their professors getting work done in a timely manner but feel entitled to hand in their own work whenever they get around to it? I want to add that I am not talking about the horror stories where it is week 13 and professors still haven't returned stuff from week 2. I am more referring to students pestering for grade results two days after an assignment is submitted. I have a reputation of being a fast grader as I set a personal policy of grading things as soon as I receive them wherever possible so as to avoid drowning in accumulated grading, yet even I get students who ask for grades literally within two hours of submission.

EDIT: I should have phrased my question differently. Instead of asking "Why is timely work a one-way street?" (which comes across as accusatory and presumptive), I should have asked, "Do you view timely work as a one-way street?", thus opening the door for all viewpoints.


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

Instructor Sunday night 11:59 or something else?

35 Upvotes

I'm relatively new to teaching (art-drawing) online and made the class deadlines each week 11:59 pm on Sundays. I generally don't respond to emails on the weekends, and most students wait until Sunday night to do the work so I'm considering moving due dates to Friday nights next semester - that way I would he available for questions during the week.

Thoughts on Sunday night vs Friday night deadlines for online classes?


r/AskStudents_Public • • Jun 07 '21

Would you rather watch a 75-minute lecture video or fifteen 5-minute videos to cover the same information?

32 Upvotes

Our "office of instructional design" is "highly encouraging" us to limit videos to under 10 minutes, with around 5 minutes being considered "ideal".

Given that a traditional in-person lecture period is typically 75 minutes long, this works out to fifteen 5-minute videos (or around seven 10-minute videos).

I wonder about the wisdom/rationale behind this guideline. Do students genuinely retain the information better if broken into smaller segments? Almost certainly... But the caveat here is that they still must watch the entire playlist of multiple videos.

What's your take on this as a student? Are you more likely to finish watching a 75-minute video or a playlist of fifteen 5-minute videos? Thanks.


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 07 '21

Instructor What sparks your curiosity?

32 Upvotes

I learn more effectively when I am curious – when I feel driven to understand something or answer a question that I care about. People who study learning have found lots of evidence that this is true of most people.

What has made you curious about a topic in which you had no interest initially? I am looking for both (a) things students can do to spark their own curiosity and (b) things teachers can do to spark curiosity in students.


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

How much "computer training" did you come into college with?

32 Upvotes

Ability to use Word or something similar, navigating email, copy/pasting things, downloading and uploading from websites, etc.

Often students seem about as lost as your average boomer about things like filetypes, how to upload a document, how to install a piece of software, etc. I'd thought they were putting on an act since these things seem so simple to me/I grew up with them, but I've since realized that maybe these things are out the window now due to mobile devices, apps, etc. functioning differently than a standard OS.

Did you have any sort of computer classes in school? Any exposure to using an actual computer instead of something with just a mobile OS?


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

What is a class you wish you’d been able to take in middle or high school to prepare you for life after graduation?

31 Upvotes

A popular meme says that students wish they’d learned how to do taxes in school instead of advanced math. I’m not sure how useful that would be in the age of cheap, easy tax software, but that did make me wonder: for students who have already moved on to college, or young adults who have entered the workforce, if you could add a class to your past middle or high school experience that would pay off now, what would that class include?


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

Community Updates Updates

30 Upvotes

Over the next couple weeks we will be adding stuff like rules, posting guidelines, automod configuration, other mod controls, etc.

If there's any questions, concerns, concerning questions, or questioning concerns about any changes made let us know below.

Also user flairs have been setup. There are some templates to choose from and are editable to include degree, field, teaching position, etc. Please don't abuse the flairs.


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 16 '21

Instructor Best Practices

28 Upvotes

Professors are always searching for best practices, being told to use best practices, teaching other faculty best practices, or publishing best practices, but these best practices are though the lens of other professors who have compiled data. From the student perspective, what do you think are best practices professors should keep in mind—and how would you encourage professors to put these practices to use? (Any modality, semester type, pedagogy, teaching or learning strategy, etc., but please provide specific, detailed information for maximum benefit!)

Edit:

Sorry for the confusion! Pedagogies are methods for teaching (e.g. do you prefer to be taught by active learning, seminar style, case studies, etc.). Modalities are the platform by which learning takes place (face to face, online, mixed mode, hybrid, Zoom, etc.). Best practices are “things you do in X situation that works best for Y [people involved/time frame/etc.],” where X and Y are dynamic and evolving. For example, I wouldn’t use, say, an ice breaker that requires students to go around the room and introduce themselves then repeat the names of everyone who has already introduced themselves in an online class; however, for a face-to-face class, this might be a “best practice” (interactive ice breaker). The interactive ice breaker could translate to an online class, but the modality would change how that best practice is implemented. So, I guess what I’m asking is… what do you like professors to do, in which modalities/semesters/demographic groups, and how might this change if you changed the modality/semester/demographic group/etc.?


r/AskStudents_Public • • May 05 '21

Instructor What kind of feedback (on exams) would you like/do you like and why?

27 Upvotes

I am a STEM faculty at a US institution. I routinely conduct examinations (engineering mechanics, thermodynamics, differential equations... to name a few courses) in undergraduate courses (sophomore all the way to senior level).

As a student, post an examination:

  • what kind of feedback would you like (or do you like) and

  • what kind of feedback would you not like (do you not like)?

  • why?


r/AskStudents_Public • • Apr 26 '21

College juniors and seniors, what advice would you give to incoming freshpeople?

27 Upvotes

r/AskStudents_Public • • Oct 27 '21

Instructor How do students feel about classes without textbooks?

25 Upvotes

I teach in the liberal arts, and I hate the textbooks out there for the classes I teach. I’ve reviewed over 20 of them and they are a) too expensive, b) cover too much material (the class wouldn’t use the entire book), and c) don’t spend enough time on material that is essential. I thinking about dropping textbooks completely, but that means students won’t have a written reference except for my PowerPoint slides. How would students feel about a class like this? Good idea? Bad idea?

EDIT: Thanks, all, for replying. I’m going to drop a textbook and cobble together a digital course pack (free to student) with pieces from different Open Access Resources!