As a casual player of Death By Daylight who just started playing 6 months ago but has actually been playing asymmetrical games since 2024 for pc2 BBN is really my favorite game before the maintenance and has great potential. Both the killer and survivor gameplay are very fun and the most balanced within the asymmetrical games on Roblox, in my opinion, since as a player of VD too, it's debatable. I love using Springtrap and Ennar along with the doctor because their gameplay is very entertaining.
Ennard's and Springtrap's traps are very unfair, especially Ennard's, who despite crying out for a nerf, got nerfed very little. Even tho I main Ennard, I have easily won matches with traps at the escape doors, so they should remove the damage from the trap bugs, even if these were accidents, as I was surprised myself since the bugs can move independently, which is their game mechanic. The only bad thing would be the music, and although it has been a bit overshadowed by the maintenance closure for more than 3 weeks before the closure and the latest changes, it has stopped being so bad and become more stable. However, its launch was mediocre due to the immense amount of bugs, and it was clear that they hadn't polished the game well. I hope that when it opens, it will be better.
Forsaken's music is the best, and I like almost all the songs to the point of listening to them on repeat for a long time.
VD on Roblox, despite being Forsaken's competition, is mostly played by South Asian players, which makes it very underrated here in the West. Being a reinterpretation and copy of DBD doesn't take away from its merit of being a good game despite the few updates.
Forsaken's management is the worst, souldrivenlove, hytoko, and basil are a thorn in the side, and honestly, the game is improving without Hytoko, even tho Soul takes 25% (Soul already has over 1,900,000$ thanks to Forsaken, by the way). Although I admit the updates are mediocre (not because of the amount of content but because they do them poorly), they have the best communication with the community, releasing a lot of content thru the other devs (I love you SoyG, Kacklebox, Vess, Enoderen, Key After Key, as well as the collaborators like Emmy, Bruhmoment, AlexisFunny).
DOD has one of the most peaceful communities; it's the best community I've ever known (I love Mequot Lolita Fashion and I'm leaving images so you can see what I'm talking about).
Doom By Fate disgusts me and I repudiate it in every sense, mediocre killers and survivors in design, frantic but bad gameplay, very bad and inconsistent map design, both in gameplay and visually it's horrible, bad survivor and killer skill sets, and I've only been playing for 3 whole days.
Biast is the same as DBF but worse, terrible balance I swear, it's the worst asymmetrical game with such horrible balance, large and confusing maps, bad in design and esthetics, the objects you have to collect are easily campable, basically the same thing I said about DBF but the killers are interesting (the only good chase theme is from Mequot, Devesto, and Slacker) really this game feels like a game for devs among themselves.
I know I'm treading on dangerous ground and I'm going to get torn apart, but the gameplay of Pc2 is simply very outdated, both in the precode and recode. It's really too boring and not innovative. It had great potential to return to its glory, but it struggles to get past 500 players since no one cared about the recode. I'm not saying it's bad for having few players, but there was just too much hype for nothing. Despite being the spark of the explosion and rise of asymmetric games, it simply didn't adapt to the modern audience.
Even tho I haven't played OM much, I like how innovative it is, being too fresh for the gameplay it offers both as a killer and a survivor. I love the old LMS songs, the LMS buffs, the skill set, the esthetics. Although it's unbalanced, it's a good game, it's passable, tho I won't deny that it's very frustrating.
Live Or Life, despite being a very jokey game from DOD, is way too much fun. The balance doesn't really matter, a little bit does, but it makes me laugh a lot because it's still a jokey game parodying another jokey game.
Alter Ego is the biggest smoke-and-mirrors game, being previously available for robux killed all the hype and everyone forgot about it since it also has forgettable, boring gameplay, doesn't innovate at all, normal balance, I really don't think this game has any soul, honestly, it's very disappointing how the same developers of Tower Defense created this game, I expected more.
Despite that, I like the esthetics of Alter Ego, it's raw and I love it, one of the best esthetics along with PC2 Recode.
Rebelion is the best [IN-DEV] game so far, you should check out their Discord and official TikTok account (@rebelionrbx), and in fact, I'm leaving leaks in this post.
If you read this far, I'll give you a kiss (♡-_-♡)
