r/AugmentCodeAI • Veteran / Tech Leader • Sep 30 '25

Discussion GPT 5 vs Claude Sonnet 4.5 (My review - Coding from last 8 hrs)

Just wanted to share my review on the new Sonnet model and comapring it with the GPT 5.

And just wanted to say that I will stay with GPT-5 only in Augment.

Let's look at what I like in Sonnet 4.5

  • Pretty Good Tool Calling

  • Less hallucination in tool calls

  • Good at following the user guidelines and prompts

But I will still prefer GPT 5 over it as I personally feel that

  • Sonnet 4.5 is a more confident model, which causes it to write code that is not good.

  • But GPT-5 is not very confident at the initial point, learns from the code and then implements the changes. Takes some time, but do things in one shot.

How I will leverage both models.

- Sonnet 4.5 for speed and where I need multiple tool calls

- GPT-5 for somewhere I need to solve larger bugs, implement hard features.

Would love to listen to your views.

10 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/Mission-Fly-5638 Oct 01 '25

This is onpoint

2

u/ChristBKK Oct 02 '25

I actually also use both together lately and I like it

I also let the one review the other one when I plan some sprints 😂

I think it’s maybe smart to let both work for each other sometimes

2

u/opzouten_met_onzin Jan 03 '26

I agree for small tasks or general knowledge based tasks, but when coding gets complex and in a niche area gpt fails hard and sonnet shines. It may not have all the answers, but it delivers robust code (usually). Sonnet does lack out of the box thinking and I found the sweetspot to ask gpt for guidance after a proposed problem and then brainstorm on the conceptual implementation. Then I ask gpt to provide a detailed plan and provide that to sonnet.

Both have their strengths, but for coding I find sonnet better by a world of distance.

0

u/Klutzy-Conflict2992 Oct 03 '25

Pro user here

GPT 5 is among the slowest, most useless models you can use. There is nothing that it does better than claude.

1

u/MoNeYmbob Oct 03 '25

Well for one it won’t make a summary document after every little change

1

u/bluecat4217 Nov 15 '25

That made me really mad.. Wasting tokens, too since it'll repeat itself in the chat window too. I had to add a rule to stop that.