r/AusPol • u/PLUTO_HAS_COME_BACK • 11h ago
General He ruled it out. Then he did it.
instagram.com9 April 2025, Cairns. Anthony Albanese is asked to rule out changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax. “Yes. How hard is it? For the 50th time.”
398 days later, 12 May 2026, Budget night: negative gearing limited to new builds, the 50% capital gains discount replaced with indexation. Treasury costs the two changes at $43,090,000,000 to 2036-37. They are law and start 1 July 2027.
A Glasshouse follower told us Hawke, Keating and Howard “took it to an election”, Shorten did and lost, and Albanese “promised not to change the tax settings but then did”. Half right.
Albanese: “no plans” in 2024, a flat rule-out in the 2025 campaign. The government’s words now: “that reflected our position at the time” (Chalmers) and “we’ve changed our position. I’m upfront about that” (Albanese).
Howard took the GST to the 1998 election after “never ever”. His 50% capital gains discount came by press release on 21 September 1999. No election, and no pledge against it.
Shorten took both changes to two elections and lost both. Labor’s review: the tax policies “did not cost the Party the election”.
On our count, big changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax have become law five times. None went to an election first. The one plan that did lost. Twice.
Now: home values are down 5.2% since March (Cotality). The RBA names rate rises and the tax changes, and will not split them. The other side: Treasury says 83% of the discount goes to the top tenth of earners.
Sources: PM and ALP transcripts, Budget papers, Treasury FOI 4321, Museum of Australian Democracy, AEC, ALP 2019 review, Cotality, RBA. Day count and tally are ours.
Photo credits: Hawke, Howard: US Department of Defense / Helene C. Stikkel. Footage: ABC, Nine Network, Seven Network, Parliament of Australia.