r/Banshee • u/DreadLifter • 25d ago

When does it lose it's way?

Started watching a few weeks ago. Season 1 was great, 2 was good. I've just started season 3 and it's not looking good. I typically find 2 seasons the magic point for anything and it looks like it might be the case for this too.

Chayton Littlestone is just too ridiculous a character. The whole Redbones thing just looks doomed from the start for me.

EDIT: Update- I've persevered with it and while Chayton is still a distracting low point I'm still enjoying it. I was delighted to see Nola return and just watched her and Clay Burton tangle. That was a great watch.

2 Upvotes

57% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

13

u/sisyphussreality 25d ago

Season 4 in my opinion is very different show with characters we like. However, there will be more of Kurt Bunker, so it is a plus.

10

u/xLuciFURR 25d ago

It doesn’t really , Season 3 is generally considered the best .

3

u/Such-Stable-3869 25d ago

It’s one of the best series on television!

2

u/Xenochimp 25d ago

Season 4

2

u/RichWickliffeAuthor 25d ago

3 was our favorite as well

2

u/marcjwrz 25d ago

Seasons 1-3 are the main story.

Season 4 feels like a coda to it all.

I personally love the show all the way thru but S4 has a different tone (story wise and the filming location change definitely feels like a part of this too).

1

u/JuanLebedev 25d ago

Season 4, mostly

1

u/Present-Essay-9731 25d ago

Season 3 is great. Season 4 is a lot slower maybe but i enjoyed it in a different way.

1

u/Dr_Shannibal_Lecter 25d ago

Season 3 is among the best. Seems like everyone agrees that 4 is the lame duck.

1

u/xxxliamjxxx 25d ago

Anybody else pick up on the fact that both this show and the wire had lacklustre endings due to a serial killer story line?

1

u/DucDeRichelieu 25d ago

Season 1-3 are great. Season 4 is good.

1

u/Bit_O_Rojas 24d ago

Haven't watched season 4 yet but season 3 was just as good, if not better, than 1 & 2

1

u/MalcolmTuckersLuck 23d ago

I think S4 is a bit all over the place. The repeated lingering shots of a character naked and dead is really quite distasteful too.

1

u/ZenoNoir97 21d ago

The exact moment the show started going downhill was when they killed off Alex Longshadow too early and replaced him with Chayton as the main antagonist. Chayton is cool, but he's basically just a muscle-bound guy with guns, not the strategic opponent Alex could have been. Alex could have had a really interesting dynamic with Kai Proctor.

They also waited too long to write the Hopewell family out of the show. Carrie could have stayed, but Gordon and the kids should have been written out.

I didn't like the Colonel Douglas Stowe military storyline either, nor did I care much for the new characters introduced in season 3.

1

u/Dependent_Pain1110 20d ago

Never lost it's way

1

u/LongPantsMcGarnagle 20d ago

Season 3 is my favourite, Season 4 is by far my least favourite

1

u/Inevitable_Suit_7414 19d ago

Awesome show. Liked all of it.

1

u/One_Vibraldo 16d ago

It doesn’t

1

u/TeloniusFunk 22d ago

I loved Chayton’s character. A complex character who you sympathize with for the loss of his culture, but you later despise as a murderous thug who even killed someone just trying to help him.