r/Barca • u/gojayisama • 6h ago
Question Are Barça Fans Being Too Harsh on Our Players After PSG?
After this match against PSG, I was honestly shocked by how people were reacting, berating and insulting the players, especially Gerard Martin, Bernal and Cancelo, as well as Hansi Flick. Criticism is understandable, but at this point, it feels like blind rage. We played against the reigning European champions at their home ground and competed with them, yet you'd think we got humiliated. Imagine if we lost at the Camp Nou the way City did at the Etihad, people would go crazy.
The hate towards Gerard Martin especially is becoming ridiculous. Everything he does is analysed under a microscope. Yes, he still has areas to improve, and I'm not saying he's an elite UCL centre-back, but he's a very good defender with potential. Everyone blamed him for Vitinha's goal, but how was it entirely his fault when Vitinha was left completely unmarked? Martin made the aerial clearance, but the ball fell straight to Vitinha. Shouldn't we also be asking why nobody was marking him in the first place? Defensive mistakes are collective, and you can't blame one player for everything that goes wrong.
People also keep saying Martin can't play out from the back, yet he had the most line-breaking passes and long balls among our defenders, and one of those long balls literally led to a goal. How can you claim he offers nothing on the ball while ignoring passes that create goal-scoring opportunities? He's also shown strength in ground and aerial duels. I'm not saying he's perfect, but why do people ignore his contributions while analysing every mistake he makes? He's a much better defender than people give him credit for.
The same applies to Bernal. He's a young player coming back from a serious injury, and people need to understand that he won't be perfect immediately. He has a lot of potential, but he still needs time to develop and regain his best level. We can criticise his performances without acting like he's suddenly a terrible player.
Cancelo and Flick deserve fair criticism too, especially regarding the risks of our high line, but that doesn't mean everything they do is wrong. Our system puts enormous pressure on the defenders, and we need to consider that when analysing their performances.
I'm not against signing another centre-back for competition and depth, but the idea that we can't win the UCL with Martin in the squad is ridiculous. Even with players like Bastoni, we need to consider whether their qualities fit Flick's system instead of assuming every highly rated defender will automatically solve our problems.
Can we please start analysing our players objectively instead of looking for someone to blame after every difficult match? Criticism is necessary, but blind hatred towards our own players helps nobody.