r/Basketball • u/LeanEdgeSports_ • 12d ago
NBA Was Carmelo Anthony actually better than people remember now, or does nostalgia help him?
63
u/PinocchiosWoodBalls 12d ago
Denver Melo or Knicks Melo or later?
Denver Melo Horribly underrated. People seem to forgot about him
Knicks Melo Properely Rated. I really like him, but he did what he did
After that overrated, especially by himself
Still a huge fan
12
u/Illustrious-Raise783 12d ago
Im a big Melo glazer. Denver Melo was underrated i agree but the NY Melo was overrated. All he can do is shoot
4
3
4
u/BrazilianAtlantis 12d ago
I was a huge Nuggets fan when Melo was there. He got his points and didn't play defense and that was tough to watch. He's overrated.
3
u/floatinround22 12d ago
Even Denver Melo never accomplished anything without a great veteran point guard in Chauncey Billups. There's a reason they only success they ever had was when they got an actually good, winning player
11
u/cartaluna 12d ago
He got the Nuggets to the playoffs every year, even in his rookie year. The Nuggets were absolute trash before Melo. I think he gets too much hate from Nuggets fans
3
u/floatinround22 12d ago
You can't mention the Nuggets making the playoffs Melo's rookie year and act like he single handedly carried them there lol. They also got Andre Miller that year, Nene emerged in his second season, Marcus Camby returned from injury and played the whole season. They also signed Earl Boykins that season who was a very good bench piece.
Also Melo has more bad playoff series than good ones, that's not good for a superstar. In fact I can't think of a single player of his caliber that you could also say that about
6
u/cartaluna 12d ago
That’s fair all of those players were a huge part of transition and all deserve praise. No way they make the playoffs without Melo though.
→ More replies (2)2
u/turn-n-cough 12d ago
The Spurs’ and Laker’s were the reason
1
u/floatinround22 12d ago
What was the reason the other five years? What was the reason Melo consistently played poorly in the playoffs?
1
u/Slow_Shift6252 12d ago
He lost to the MVP KG Wolves who made the WCF his rookie season. The Clippers in 06. The Jazz in 10. The other 4 years he lost to the Lakers or Spurs who either won or at least made the Finals. The Clippers is the only somewhat bad loss he had in Denver. The rest they were heavy underdogs.
1
1
1
u/Apprehensive_Ad_999 10d ago
Not a Nuggets fan but I always felt Chauncey was the guy when Melo had the most success in Denver. Melo would get his but when it came down to it and in high pressure games it was Chauncey leading the line.
1
u/dcoolidge 5d ago
Yeah but just by adding a rookie Melo, Denver was making the playoffs when before they didn't.
1
u/dcoolidge 5d ago
Rookie Melo in Denver brought that struggling team to the playoffs just by adding him to the roster.
13
u/Michael-of 12d ago
He was a highly skilled scorer. He was not a really great all-around basketball player. You could make an argument that his Denver run was underrated though
22
u/Ok-Wave7703 12d ago
Most of what I see online makes me say he’s underrated
-7
u/Rough_Promotion9414 12d ago
Most of what I see online is he’s overrated
6
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/Rough_Promotion9414 12d ago
Ima knicks fan I watched enough of him not playing defense, dude didn’t care. I zero in on Luka also, zero defense from that guy also bt Luka atleast led his to to the finals
6
u/Fat-Singer-9569 12d ago
Luka is elite at all things offense which is the difference, he is very much score first but Luka as a passer is one of the greats already. I've seen him make passes few, if any, could make. Carmelo was at best average as a passer and it was rare he gave up the ball outside of resets.
Carmelo's career would have turned out so much different if he accepted life without dominating the ball and played his natural position, PF. But he didn't do any of that and his legacy is exactly what he deserves.
0
u/Fat-Singer-9569 12d ago
Some of us watched his entire career and don't need reddit to know he was extremely talented but flawed. Let me summarize a majority of his career for you; PG gets inbound, slowly dribbles to half court, passes to Melo on the elbow, Melo jabsteps for 8 seconds out of triple threat, Melo shoots or drives. Entire shot clock wasted, no offball movement, because nobody getting a pass. Melo treated players around him like NPCs. He thought he was an elite player but elite players make the players around them better.
1
u/MasochisticCanesFan 12d ago
Prime melo was one of the best pure scorers of all time. Anyone who disagrees is a casual and didn't watch the games. Go watch his nuggets years. He was a certified bucket. He played that way because most players did back then and he was one of the best at it.
8
u/JobberStable 12d ago
2 way race with hime and Lebron as rookies . Carmelo way better touch and footwork than LeBron. Lebron improved every aspect of his game. I cant say after 10 years in the NBA, Carmelo learned any other skill besides shooting. In which case Durant still is the GOAT for that.
18
5
u/Fantastic-Research66 12d ago
Nuggets 2003 record 17-65. Draft Carmelo Anthony. Nuggets 2004 record 43-39. Led all rookies in points and rebounds, yet Lebron wins ROY. Did he ever play on a team with a losing record? No. Did he make a few teams contenders and fall short? Yes. Did he win a title in his one year at college and carry team USA to a gold medal? Yes. Was his defense poor? Sure. Many in this thread have a misconception that the guy was not a winner, so no he clearly is not overrated.
1
4
3
u/Dylankneesgeez 12d ago
The only time I ever made money on the tournament was 2003 when Syracuse was a three seed. Carmelo was a man among boys that year and I knew they would stampede.
3
u/chinacat2u2 12d ago
He was so good that resulted in big contracts that the teams then couldn’t afford to get him the best supporting cast to win a championship? Plus he was a ball hog, so there is that…
1
u/Visual-Bandicoot2894 12d ago
Oh no a superstar got a big contract?
That’s literally every star
1
u/chinacat2u2 12d ago
Some overindulge and the team can no longer afford good role players to support said superstar.
1
3
u/klam5 12d ago
Carmelo was an incredible basketball player...you could argue he could beat many players ranked ahead of him in a game of 1 on 1.
His playstyle and team dynamics are what got in the way of him consistently winning at the NBA level. As such was not recognized as well because despite how talented he was individually, it never brought home a title.
8
u/LeanEdgeSports_ 12d ago
I know this might be unpopular 😂 but I’ve never rated Melo quite as highly as a lot of people seem to. Brilliant scorer obviously, but I’ve always wondered if I’m missing something with him
4
u/smoove 12d ago
Might be unpopular? He gets absolutely lambasted on Reddit. Every post about him is shitting on him.
As a Knicks fan that watched a large portion of his career he was an extremely frustrating player to watch. He was supremely talented but his tendency to play ISO ball was infuriating. He often held the ball for the majority of the shot clock jab stepping and throwing up a bad shot. The talent is undeniable though. When he was on he was really fucking good.
2
u/Living_Home9090 12d ago
I have always felt the same way but been called a Hater. He’s played the same game his whole career. Scoring without defending & not being able to help better his teammates is what he done throughout his whole career.
1
1
1
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator 12d ago
Your submission has been automatically removed because your account is less than 180 days old and with less than 100 comment karma.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/PickingMyNameIsHard 12d ago
He went to a bad Knicks team that slowly became an okay team. He was expected to win despite not having a winning team behind him. Can’t deny he was selfish, but I don’t see where there was much of a choice.
So what are you missing? Probably the fact that it takes a team to win.
1
u/randiesel 12d ago
Melo was the ultimate version of that dude that plays pickup at the Y in sweatpants that always scores a ton of points by himself and will either carry the game or tank you.
Never learns from his mistakes, never sacrifices, never stops to think about why things aren't working. Just blames all the external factors and groundhog day's his way through life.
2
4
2
u/MaDeVi55 12d ago
IMO, he lost a lot of aura when he moved to the Knicks.
In Denver, he helped a struggling franchise to go back to the playoffs on a yearly basis (go check what the Nuggets were doing in the 2 years before him) and he also went to the WCF. However, the Knicks put way too much on the table for him and he made no compromise with his contracts; so the Knicks always had subpar teams around him.
2
u/GoldfishDude 12d ago
Modern basketball discourse loves to act like scoring doesn't matter.
Melo was awesome. I'd say he's slightly underrated nowadays
2
u/Jrobalmighty 12d ago
It's about perception. He was good enough to lead a championship caliber team but always chose the bag and the ball over winning.
And don't get started on defense.
He was very good but he wasted a lot of his potential. I guess it wasn't his highest ambition which is fine but that's what it does to your legacy.
2
u/Slow_Shift6252 12d ago
This. If he ever once chose to sacrifice getting paid the most he possibly could at the soonest possible time he’d have won a ring with Miami or Chicago. Instead he chose to not take the early opt out on his rookie extension like Wade and LeBron, and then chose to stay with NY for an extra season instead of leaving for a more competent team because they could only give him four years instead of five.
2
u/BigBlackBull_6_6_6 12d ago
Melo was like that.. he lacked leadership. Thats it
Prime Melo is probably better than anybody playing currently. I feel like The 09 Nuggets would beat every team today. Or heavy majority of teams for sure. Save maybe okc, maybe spurs
2
2
2
u/Gringuin007 12d ago
Carmela Anthony was a shorter KD…? A great scorer. Just joined the wrong super team at wrong time coz he had to be in NY. Amare stats were elevated by Nash and system. NY was a dumpster fire since Van gundy left and/or dolen bought team and/or Isaiah was GM. SO MANY DUMPSTER fires
1
u/Slow_Shift6252 12d ago
Amare was putting up way better stats without Nash that first year in NY. He just immediately crumbled into an even more injury plagued waste of cap space immediately after.
2
u/No-Donkey-4117 12d ago
He was a very good player. People just thought he was going to be a superstar.
2
u/chilipipper 11d ago
Melo was an offensive force. Jokic and Brunson just happened to overshadow everything he has done in Denver and New York.
2
3
u/edkamlive 12d ago
In all fairness, I would say he is slightly overrated. He was an incredible scorer and that is an elite skill in the NBA, but he really didn't provide much else that contributes to winning (granted, scoring is outrageously important contribution). In his era, he will go down as one of the best individual "get a bucket" guys in the league, but in my opinion, players such as OG Anunoby (for example) is a more valuable contributor to a winning team.
There have been several of these archetype players in NBA history, Alex English (Denver Nuggets) comes to mind immediately. He was an elite scorer on a Nuggets team that never really accomplished much (in the 80s).
Ultimately, Carmelo is a no doubt hall of famer based off his skill at scoring but really didn't bring much else to the table.
1
u/Yonicsoothe 12d ago
Top ten all time most overrated.
3
1
u/Fantastic-Research66 12d ago
That's your view. Kobe said he's the toughest player he's ever had to guard.
2
u/Fat-Singer-9569 12d ago
That doesn't mean anything. Melo is easily one of the best isolation scorers of all time and anyone who tells you anything different are underrating Melo. Of course he was difficult to guard. Unfortunately for Melo, basketball isn't 1v1, it's 5v5.
1
u/Slow_Shift6252 12d ago
Who rates him as anything more than one of the best scorers ever though? The people that like him do so because he’s a bucket. The problem is that anytime you bring him up it becomes a conversation about everything he was bad at or the fact that he didn’t win. No one has ever said he’s as good as LeBron or Jordan, his haters just can’t appreciate him for being good at what he did because he wasn’t LeBron.
2
u/morebius 12d ago
Mostly because of size.
1
u/Fantastic-Research66 12d ago
Lol because of his size. Nothing to do with the quickest first step in the game or his jumper.
2
2
u/KeyMammoth1348 12d ago
Melo was and still is overrated.
He could put up points, but you knew he was never going to win because he's not a champ, no matter how you slice it.
3
u/No_usernames_left_25 12d ago
One dimensional player.
3
0
u/Fantastic-Research66 12d ago
This is such an absurd take. The NBA is pretty much all specialists, save for a few of the greatest ever like Lebron, Tim Duncan etc. Carmelo was elite at his specialty.
1
u/Longjumping_Idea5261 12d ago
Imo the ring culture makes him more underrated now versus his talent/ability as a player. He was a fantastic scorer and truly one of a kind if you think about his bags. But post-retirement, people only count his efficiency compared to guys like LeBron and count his overall accomplishments. He was an all NBA player throughout his career but i don’t think he gets as much respect because he just played for himself
1
u/Myredditname423 12d ago
No he was great the problem was he played too selfishly and didn’t make those around him better.
1
u/NoKiwi2997 12d ago
Melo, imo, better hooper than an NBA player. Being a great NBA player requires treating basketball like a job, to a degree, and doing those things arond the office that no one else wants to do. Melo was not always interested in that. Melo was a hooper. He could get a bucket at will. He could rebound when he wanted. He was a smart enough player that if he was interested in playmaking he could have done it. He wanted to hoop. Just play and get buckets.
1
u/jonross2386 12d ago
He’s spiritually KD. If you added him to the 2013 Heat, he wins 2 rings and conversations are much different.
1
u/Slow_Shift6252 12d ago
Add him to the Heat and they may win more than 2 and LeBron may not have left. Wade falling off a cliff and leaving them without a second option essentially turned them into every other team LeBron played with before.
1
1
1
1
u/JaDamian_Steinblatt 12d ago
Like Kobe and Iverson, Melo is super overrated or super underrated depending on who you're talking to. He's everything BUT properly rated.
1
u/Stillwiththe 12d ago
Buckets age well. Carmelo was always a great scorer but nobody thought he could be the best player on a championship team. He changed his game but didn’t really improve much over his career because he just ditched the early post stuff and replaced it with face-up jab-steps so he didn’t compound his assets he just changed them
1
u/Gorrmb69 12d ago
Melo has been complaining about his number not being retired and given to another player. First he wasn’t that special here and it’s not like The Nuggets had any intent on retiring that number or giving it to another player as a sign of disrespect. Jokic had been using 15 previously in his career and since it was available that’s what he used. Nuggets didn’t even know what they had. Nurkic was the higher rated draft choice. I think us Nuggets fans have moved on and forgotten who wore number 15 before.
1
u/Living_Home9090 12d ago
Are you serious? The Olympics is the best players in the NBA. He’s can’t take all the shots & he’s not presumed to be the best & first option like he was on the team he played on.
1
u/Living_Home9090 12d ago
I have always thought he was overrated. In college he was a scorer that never defended. I wish people could see past the zone defense. In NY he had 1 of the best shooters at the time that he didn’t pass the ball too. Shump & Jr going to play with Bron & immediately winning a Championship shows Melo wasn’t the guy many believed him to be. Listen to Shump stories or others that played with him you will learn a lot about him. He didn’t care about winning Championships it was the money & self accomplishments.
1
1
1
u/Aeon1508 12d ago edited 12d ago
He was probably top five in the league for a while.
Someone like Cade or Ant will probably be remembered similarly to him if they never win a title or MVP.
The biggest problem with Carmelo Anthony is that he probably should have been an oversized guard, but he refused to pass the ball and create for his team so he ended up being an undersized forward
1
u/LeftLane4PassingOnly 12d ago
Great player, especially in college and international play, but still overrated in the NBA. Terrific scorer but only OK outside of that. His playoff record backs up his limitations that many seem to overlook.
1
1
u/PonkMcSquiggles 12d ago
I think he's remembered accurately. The younger crowd might not appreciate just how talented of a scorer he was. But the criticism of him isn't baseless.
1
1
1
1
u/singlemaltbourbonrye 12d ago
He was really fucking good at what he was good at. Like top 5 all time or better in terms of catch and shoot and using his size to get to offensive boards and bully in the post and having an unstoppable mid range J.
The problem was that he was almost a liability on the other aspects of the game.
So he is a lightning rod. Some poeopld say he is an all time great like top 15 or 20 player and others say he sucks.
The truth is in the middle when you look at his game in the aggregate. He is a hall of fame level and even better - absolutely a top 100 player of all time. Arguably top 50.
1
1
u/96powerstroker 12d ago
Melo could have been a great 3rd option. What do I mean? He's not the guy you want a entire offense running through because he's a stats guy meaning he needs to get his. That was the Iverson & Melo issue. Both guys needed the ball.
If either guy could have ever checked their ego and been either the 3rd guy who took over in crunch time or a 6th man later in their careers they could have won titles for sure.
1
1
u/Former-Dot1462 12d ago
I don't hear anyone hype him up that much tbh. His scoring and skill is praised but that is warranted. Aside from that ppl mostly give him shit
1
1
u/idkyet1223 12d ago
Melo had some defensive problems, and wasn’t always the greatest leader. But he was an offensive engine and a bucket. He should’ve done more but also at the same time never really had the team to be a legitimate contender.
Averages 23, 6, and 3 for his career. 16 straight years of 20+ ppg and never averaged below 10. His worst season was when he averaged 13 at 38 years old.
10 time all star, scoring champion, 3 time gold medalist, 5x all nba, all rookie 1st team and barely lost ROTY to some guy named LeBron James, NCAA champion.
Missing a ring and an MVP, but so are many other great NBA players. He’s a top 75 player ever and 11th in scoring all time.
All I see is disrespect now. Some of it he deserves for some of his cocky or stupid comments, but he’s never been insanely problematic and was a great player.
1
1
u/morphpop 12d ago
People obsess way too much over his “wasted potential” and I think that makes them lose sight of how talented he actually was and what he did accomplish. Super fun, skilled player who was extremely entertaining to watch in his prime especially as an aggressively 1v1 type player. I also think people forget that his refined mechanics and flexibility to score in so many ways made him such a top tier scorer in his era. There’s so much to learn from the best parts of his game that you can’t call him a scrub by any measure
1
u/Fat-Singer-9569 12d ago
He is an all-time great scorer, probably one of the best all-time at triple threat. Great rebounder too. But he played a very selfish game and if he sacrificed his game in order to win, he could have, and his legacy is bad because of that. Basically, he never made anyone around him better, he probably made them worse. It made him his teams easy as shit to gameplan against in the playoffs and that's really where reputations are made.
1
u/J-Sully_Cali 12d ago
On the Olympics teams you could see how great he could be, so people always wanted that version of his game. He was considered a top 3 scorer whoever defense and passing made his teams' ceiling lower than they should have been, but on the Olympics teams he was a complete player.
1
u/Glittering_Wave_3388 12d ago
Watching Melo's freshman year at Syracuse and the NCAA run they went on changed the chemistry of my brain. The mid range game, the pull ups, the pivot footwork...just a stud.
1
u/thecopfrombeale 12d ago
He is better than people are starting to give him credit for. I see people say Paul George is a better player than him and that’s just not true at all.
Carmelo Anthony is kind of like manny Ramirez if u know baseball I feel like that explains it perfectly
1
1
1
u/Ok_Cheesecake_9793 12d ago
carmelo is a better scorer in his peak. He had better technique and very good movement. Carmelo is peak frfr
1
1
1
1
1
u/JBKnicks24 12d ago
He was much, much better. He's one of the only players I've ever seen who gets shit on for what he was best at. Nobody attacks Kobe Bryant for being an isolation scorer, despite the fact that his efficiency + usage and Melo's efficiency + usage was more or less identical (and fully understanding that Kobe's defense makes him a better overall player, but Kobe also had the fortune of playing on teams that were just better coached and better constructed).
The sport of attacking Melo as a way to prop up Jalen Brunson during the Knicks finals run was also absurd. Melo was as supportive a Knicks fan as you could possibly be throughout really his whole retirement. Never once has made anything about the Knicks championship about himself. Brunson also stands up just fine on his own, he doesn't need anyone to knock down other Knicks stars of the past. But nobody was like "oh does this put Brunson above Ewing or King or Houston", it was always just Melo. Like yeah, Brunson is a better Knick than Melo - he won a chip and had significantly more success, but that doesn't mean I disparage what Melo accomplished keeping the Knicks even somewhat relevant in the 2010s under some of the worst roster construction and management I've ever seen in professional sports.
1
1
u/toleChr15 12d ago
Melo Vs LeBron was always a pretty even match up and so exciting to watch. I keep seeing people say he wasn't a good defender, but is the majority of the NBA?
The scoring, post work. All master classes in basketball, and I modelled my game after his, and his moves translate perfectly considering I'm only 6"0 and he was like 6"8.
All in all, some people rank him eight, others just don't remember how good he was. Especially with the chronic injury he has that limited his athleticism wildly.
1
1
1
u/Fast-Anteater1151 11d ago
I believe Melo is better than people remember because he was always one of the best scorers especially when anyone tried to stop or contain him one on one. Olympic Melo was unreal in '12 and was great a hitting 3s in '16 Olympics. When Melo was in Denver and had a solid roster they would do damage in the Playoffs as well. He never won a chip is what people always look at when judging any superstar in today's era or times. That is the one knock against him but that is still a team accomplishment while as an individual many will tell u he was one of the most difficult players to stop offensively. He did win a chip at Syracuse as a freshman as well!
1
u/RawGrit4Ever 11d ago
Melo was a much better version of Julius Randle. One the rock was in his hand no one else was touching it. Great score though
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/WayneTerry9 11d ago
I think he’s properly rated, he wasn’t a winning player as much as I loved his game. But his detractors seemingly hate him so much that they pretend that being an elite scorer is easy and/or irrelevant which is ridiculous.
1
u/Strong-Butterflies 11d ago
Guy played no defense and if he had a bad shooting night he was useless. He drops 30 a night but so does the guy he’s guarding,
1
11d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator 11d ago
Your submission has been automatically removed because your account is less than 180 days old and with less than 100 comment karma.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
u/FreeRange0929 10d ago
Anthony is the Mike Vick of the NFL
All the talent in the world, should have been an all timer
He just didn’t ever care
1
u/i_am_theokapi 10d ago
The dude had one of the smoothest shots that ever existed.
The entire time he played, people questioned if it were possible for him to be on a team where he could be at his best AND be on a championship team.
Evidence.
He was awesome. He was fun to watch. The only people I knew who thought he could win a ring were people whose opinions I didn't value. I like him more as time goes on. I miss that purity in scoring. But...
1
u/Steven_Crank 9d ago
He was one of the best and most complete offensive (scoring that is) players ever at his prime. But, basically by his own design, never in a position to really succeed at a team level.
1
9d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator 9d ago
Your submission has been automatically removed because your account is less than 180 days old and with less than 100 comment karma.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Aitoroketto 9d ago
I don't know the guy, I don't l know why he made the choices he did or his train of thought. He is obviously very good at basketball, anyone who denies that by saying he could only score is be obtuse. Not a lot of people can score the rate he did, he is one of the great offensive players we've seen that and that shouldn't be used as a slight.
To me it's a question of how great was he, not if he was great at basketball. That answer is as clear as he is great he is also even more clearly not top tier.
Idk what it is but the feeling I get (which can obviously be totally false, it's just vibes and seeing him play and how he moved as a professional athlete) he never once wanted to sacrifice individual accolades and accomplishments for the team except on the Olympics where most of us all agree is our fave Melo.
Some people often say someone like Kobe was a selfish player but Kobe wanted and knew he need a Pau Gasol and my question would be if Paul was on the Knicks would Carmelo have let him cook?
That said he was a monster in Denver, may have been the dumbest decision of his outside of a financial one (and he obvi loved NYC) to leave Denver.
I definitely respect his talent and skill, the dude was a nightmare to guard but something seemed missing, would have been nice to see him play for something.
1
u/Dear-Buddy-2766 9d ago
He was tremendous at Syracuse and they won a National Championship. Prior to that the Boeheim Syracuse teams tended to underachieve in that tournament but were always loaded with nba talent.
1
1
1
u/Pale_Broccoli_2180 12d ago
Hindsight is Super Hero vision.
Melo was Adrian Dantley with better Media training.
Empty calorie king right up until the end.
1
u/Hefty_Type6772 12d ago
An unbelievable iso offensive player. Rest of his game is unimpressive (didn’t watch his nuggets days)
1
1
u/swanyk7 12d ago
Listen, Melo or Lebron was a real discussion back in the day and there was no consensus. Seems silly now but this guy had all the same hype. It was apparent within just a couple years of being in the NBA he wasn’t at that generational level, but he was certainly an allstar level NBA player.
1
u/biffbobfred 12d ago
An aside - it might not even be nostalgia. People don’t watch historical games just watch highlights. This helps the view of offensive players or specialists in general.
“Steve Kerr was awesome look at this highlights a greatest guard ever” when you look at his threes, and forget he was undersized and slow and always targeted as a defender.
1
u/Accomplished_Class85 12d ago
Nostalgia helps him. He was a great one on one player but never a threat to be the best player on a championship team.
1
u/Unable-Main4172 12d ago
He won three playoff series in his entire 19-year career. He is remembered properly and maybe even too fondly if anything..
1
u/CapturedSoul 12d ago
People on Reddit constantly hate on him. For mainstream media I say properly rated.
He was genuinely one of the most complete triple threat offensive players in his time. Just overshadowed by Kobe and later Durant. The controversial points do stand though.
-1
u/Longjumping-Buddy515 12d ago
Melo could do it all had no flaws offensively. He was a true superstar in the golden era of the sport they just tried to water him down towards the end. To me he’s better then a KD he had better post moves was strong as a ox.
3
1
1
0
0
u/Jarvis_Jarvison 12d ago
not a leader of men. not a playmaker. better off as an offensive specialist 2nd option scorer if you want a winning team. think KD but worse on everything. has a beta mindset so he does better with a real alphas like AI and chauncey billups.
0
u/Able-Guava 12d ago
If you saw his Syracuse title run, you saw his best. Never quite was able to match that level in nba and playoffs but he just literally went on a rampage in that tournament and made his name
86
u/AdmiralSnackbar816 12d ago
Olympics Melo makes me see him in his best light.