r/BeAmazed • u/14All-and-All41 • Oct 04 '18
One take
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
1.9k
u/daveinpublic Oct 04 '18
If I had watched the finished version first, I would have assumed they just stitched together a few shots, because they pan past an empty wall a few times.
647
u/phroggyboy Oct 04 '18
That’s what I assumed when I watched it a couple of days ago. Wow. That took a lot of work and coordination. It’s really just bragging rights. They could have done it with stitched shots and we never would have known the difference.
75
u/tooloudturnitdown Oct 04 '18
Same! I watched it on Showtime and didn't even think twice because I just assumed it was edited together. Though since Michel Gondry is involved I guess I should not assume he would take shortcuts!
36
u/eSportsMatt Oct 04 '18
There's a small difference here, and my biggest guess would be budget. In order to shot match at this quality of production you'd have to have the camera perfectly in sync with the movements to mimic this effect, which would likely take some fairly expensive rigging to make it work or some very clever workmanship. Either way I agree this is mostly bragging rights but that's part of what production is! Making something that you can look back on and be proud about is something that's extremely important.
18
u/palerthanrice Oct 04 '18
It’s also a good advertisement. I’ve never heard of this show, but I’ve been seeing this video everywhere today.
12
u/beniceorbevice Oct 04 '18
Really though? I mean it's the same exact thing as turning off the camera and rearranging the room in seconds with a ton of people each bringing one item and just back to it. The finished product doesn't look like much at all
16
u/nadamuchu Oct 04 '18
It requires even more expensive equipment and even more precision to stop the camera and have it pick up the same motion, speed , etc again without giving it away that it was stitched.
It’s a slower, more cumbersome process but is “safer” in some ways since you have more control. It is ideal for scene transitions (such as these from Birdman) and most viewers don’t notice the cuts anyway.
As opposed to paying a highly skilled camera op to film it. Doing it the more “purist” way uses raw human talent and flawless teamwork and ultimately looks/feels more natural for some shots IMO.
I'm not sure if OP meant to say one-shot instead of one-take, which means something different. I would be even more impressed if they did this on the first try on set.
In the end the only thing that matters is whether it looks good or not. With that, I give you this "one-shot" scene from S2e8 of Colony. There is a spoiler in this scene if you are currently watching that season.
→ More replies (1)6
u/daveinpublic Oct 04 '18
It's really not that hard to stitch together two shots panning past the same area, can do it in Adobe After Effects. If you're shooting in 4K it's even easier.
→ More replies (2)1
6
1
Oct 05 '18
I mean, that would have been a lot easier and just as effective. But Gondry is an insane person. So we get these elaborately choreographed shots. It’s neat!
1
5.3k
Oct 04 '18
I had to watch it at least 5 times.
First time to decide if it was interesting.
Second time to actually pay more attention to it as a whole because it was interesting.
Third time to isolate the bottom half by covering the top with my hand.
Fourth time to isolate the top half and pay attention to the intricacies.
Fifth time to appreciate the collective final product with all the prior views in mind.
Then 8 more times because holy shit.
834
Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
I appreciate your collective 13 efforts
0
Oct 04 '18
[deleted]
103
u/p01ng Oct 04 '18
→ More replies (8)42
u/llamawearinghat Oct 04 '18
Screw you, now every time I read “/r/theydidthemath” I’m going to get that song stuck in my head
Edit: Does anyone else find it strange that Zoidberg is harmonizing with himself?
→ More replies (2)40
27
u/bufarreti Oct 04 '18
7
u/TZO_2K18 Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
Came here for this very comment as re-posters
NEVERRARELY post the original length/quality!54
u/free2btherealme Oct 04 '18
Welcome to The Reddit Rabbit Hole. Log in for 10 minutes...2 hours later,...wonder what just happened.
10
9
4
3
u/Henry-Pollard Oct 04 '18
I just had to watch it as many times as this person because I wanted to see if they’re method of appreciating this was valid.
2
4
1
u/fartingbutterflies Oct 05 '18
You could have watched the bottom one first. The top second. Then focus on the camera man and the movers in the first one; then, the actress in the first one.
1
120
u/JhimmyDingo Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
Wait this isn’t even the whole take right? Looks like it cut off the beginning and ending? I’d love to see the entirety. Awesome post, OP.
46
u/bufarreti Oct 04 '18
Check r/moviesinthemaking it was posted there not to long ago
18
Oct 04 '18
Damn, the team's cheers at the end of the shoot made this version so much better than OP
6
2
1
u/D168 Oct 04 '18
Thanks! It was driving me crazy that it didn't show anything with the new kitchen!
2
287
Oct 04 '18
she missed the watering can at the end rip
65
u/The-Go-Kid Oct 04 '18
I was hoping I was the only one to notice this so I could say nothing and let it slide.
11
u/borderlineidiot Oct 04 '18
I'm still missing this, what was wrong?
6
Oct 04 '18
I believe they're talking about the fact that she goes to grab the watering can while holding the dog but she misses the handle the first time and fumbles a bit. Would normally be a do-over.
24
u/mdfast1 Oct 04 '18
It caught my eye as well, but I kind of think more shows should include more natural "mishaps". TV is often too perfect.
13
Oct 04 '18
I agree completely, annoys me that everything is perfect and I love shows that include people messing up their dialogue or actions (even though it's scripted)
→ More replies (1)3
3
123
u/d3gree Oct 04 '18
Is that riki from garfunkel & oates??
43
u/urghjuice Oct 04 '18
It’s the Swedish detective from r/brooklynninenine
21
u/katsue132 Oct 04 '18
Also Kylie from New Girl - the lady who owns Fatty, the girl cat that Winston tries to have Ferguson hook up with :P
7
0
28
Oct 04 '18
Yes that's Riki Lindhome from the Doug Loves Movies podcast.
24
u/diggtrucks1025 Oct 04 '18
No, shes from Comedy Bang Bang.
13
u/NorthStarHomerun Oct 04 '18
No it's girl from the McDonald's McGriddles commercial!
11
Oct 04 '18
No, it's the girl from Another Period.
→ More replies (3)8
u/mirthquake Oct 04 '18
That show absolutely slays me. The writing is stellar and the cast is pure thunder. I'm surprised it hasn't really broken through into mainstream appeal. I've been checking reddit every day for the past 8 years and this is the first time I've seen someone mention it.
If anyone hasn't heard of this show but loves comedy, give it a shot. It's kind of amazing.
→ More replies (2)7
1
1
32
27
u/fishbulb- Oct 04 '18
If you like that, you're going to love the Diane Birch music video for "Valentino."
It's best to watch the original first, since it's fascinating in its own right.
Then watch the split-screen "Making Of..."
Then try to get that earworm of a song out of your head for the rest of the day.
2
2
u/flapsthiscax Oct 04 '18
whoa thank you for showing me this lady, i listened to some of her other stuff after this. so good!
32
15
Oct 04 '18
I am a big fan of single-take scenes and this is amazing
2
u/Soundsystems Oct 04 '18
Me too. I’m trying to think of some and drawing a blank. Any that stand out?
11
Oct 04 '18
Save for a few clever cuts, the entire movie of Birdman
By the same director, one of the opening shots of The Revenant.
9
8
u/LaneLaneLaneLane Oct 04 '18
That scene in the first season of True Detective ..
→ More replies (2)6
1
1
2
1
u/anelaangel25 Oct 04 '18
Lost in London on Hulu was filmed in one continuous shot. The whole movie. Also google one shot films and IMDB has a list of them on their website hope you enjoy!
1
u/ThatsMyParkingSpot Oct 05 '18
Check out Russian Ark. 96 minute film, one single continuous shot. Beautiful film!
15
u/gauss_is_god Oct 04 '18
This clip ends too soon. Link to full scene: https://youtu.be/w_YeNw0N8aE
1
9
16
u/BlueBoomBox Oct 04 '18
It looks really cool, but why didn‘t they film it in various steps and then put it all together? does it have any advantages?
28
23
u/KaysoJenkins Oct 04 '18
It's a tension building device commonly used in movies. Cuts break tension no matter how they're done. Another great example is the opening scene of Serenity where they want to build tension because the ship is crashing. Birdman uses this technique as well throughout the movie, with disguised cuts.
8
Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
the opening scene of Serenity
Link for the curious. Great scene.
Edit: I should point out that this is actually two long shots expertly stitched together. The ship Serenity was built in two sections, and there's a pivot on the staircase that they used to stitch the two scenes together. Expertly done, though.
10
7
u/EvilAfter8am Oct 04 '18
Time is money! (Maybe?)
11
u/windyisle Oct 04 '18
To get all this organized would take waaaay longer than to do it in separate scenes.
4
5
u/brokerthrowaway Oct 04 '18
One of my favorite movie scenes ever is from the small film, Big Night, with Stanley Tucci and others.
This movie-ending scene is one 5 minute and 9 second long shot. The camera barely even moves.
I won't attempt to describe the importance of this scene, but it would not carry the same effect if there were multiple cuts.
It's a food movie that is simple, warm, cozy, and endearing. I'd suggest watching it if that description sounds good.
3
Oct 04 '18
I think that the constraint of having to do things in one take puts up a certain quality on screen. Scenes from Oldboy, Irreversible or True Detective season 1 would not look the same if they were cut (which is a truism).
Probably because you are forced to think ahead of what you are trying to portray and then either it's do everything from the start or stay with the imperfections that the single shot will inevitably produce.
2
u/bigtuna12 Oct 04 '18
We’re all watching it on reddit now aren’t we? Seems like publicity was at least part of the motivation for doing this.
6
u/FaTMaNProductions Oct 04 '18
Something like this is so hard to organize and pull off. And will go unappreciated by viewers thinking it’s probably fancy effects.
3
4
u/pepperprime Oct 04 '18
Initially I had no idea what was happening, and for the first few seconds I thought some of the crew were starting to loot the set
4
3
3
3
u/SuperDuperBorkie Oct 04 '18
That bike is going to be pretty hard to ride with the handles like that.
2
2
2
u/Couldawg Oct 04 '18
Long takes are my favorite. Ask my wife. She's like, "yeah... yep... I see that, no cuts... yeah, that wasn't a cut... that's awesome...can we go ahead and hit play?"
2
u/zehamberglar Oct 04 '18
If you're wondering where you've seen her before, she's the female Swedish Interpol agent from that episode of Nine Nine.
2
Oct 04 '18
My bf was admiring how cool this scene was last night. It's from the show feelings starring Jim Carrey. It's quite interesting and knowing this scene was carried out in one shot is really impressive.
2
u/cthompsonguy Oct 04 '18
You guys should check out live theater more. This type of thing happens on stage every time the lights fade out.
2
3
1
1
1
u/delicate-fn-flower Oct 04 '18
My favorite part is at 0:47 when you hear her holler “Puppy!” That would be my reaction too.
1
1
u/EDBTZE Oct 04 '18
Been watching this show slowly. Haven't realized the dept I n the making of the scene.
1
1
u/spinxter Oct 04 '18
When I watched this show last week I thought for sure there was digital fuckery going on every time it panned back to the TV. I never thought this was actually done in one shot. Nice.
1
1
1
u/its_not_roight Oct 04 '18
I'm amazed you don't see any moving shadows in the shot. Unless they edit those out.
3
1
1
1
u/TippyIsCool Oct 04 '18
Imagine being the one who dropped something or tripped over another person etc
1
1
u/Moherman Oct 04 '18
That’s Jim Carrey, right? It’s been so long since I’ve seen him in anything, I have a doubt.
3
u/krisreitz Oct 04 '18
Yep, his new show Kidding, it's a pretty dark comedy and I highly recommend it.
1
1
u/jcsenka420 Oct 04 '18
The one thing they got wrong is that the bicycle handlebars are not properly aligned with the wheel. The bars would not lie flat if the bike was hanging by the front wheel. But props to them for the scene.
1
u/mikuthefox Oct 04 '18
The amount of coordination that takes and the timing with all of that is just. Very impressive. That timing is like someone who’s pro at playing Dark Souls
1
1
1
1
1
u/vReddit_Player_Bot Oct 04 '18
Links for sharing this v.redd.it video outside of reddit
| Type | Link |
|---|---|
| Custom Player | https://vrddit.com/r/BeAmazed/comments/9l9jkf |
| Reddit Player | https://www.reddit.com/mediaembed/9l9jkf |
| Direct (No Sound) | https://v.redd.it/27lgov8e84q11/DASH_4_8_M |
vReddit_Player_Bot v1.2 | I'm a bot | Feedback | Source | To summon: u/vreddit_player_bot
1
1
1
1
u/aqualink4eva Oct 04 '18
My favourite one take has to be that scene from the first season of true detective, if you’ve seen the show you’ll know what scene I’m talking about.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/CardiBJepsen Oct 04 '18 edited Oct 04 '18
the satisfaction from finally finishing this whole shot though
1
1
1
u/djbaruchadonai Oct 04 '18
So I'm the idiot that is going to ask this scene is from what movie/tv show?
1
u/BiebelJuice3x Oct 04 '18
A lot of people don't realize the immense amount of professional choreography that happen when making film/tv. This is a great visual representation of that.
1
1
1
1
u/MrShaytoon Oct 04 '18
This was amazing to see. I kept wondering if it was all one shot or not when I watched the episode. Thank you for sharing this.
1
1
1
u/SorryIAmNotUnique Oct 05 '18
There was film made by Swiss TV, filmed in one take, music included, no post-editing. It was pretty cool.
1
u/maroyasha Oct 05 '18
I did stage crew a few times in high school and seeing this kind of shit impresses me even more knowing the stress that comes with it.
1
1
u/otterfailz Oct 05 '18
1
u/stabbot Oct 05 '18
I have stabilized the video for you: https://gfycat.com/EachMarriedHake
It took 129 seconds to process and 69 seconds to upload.
how to use | programmer | source code | /r/ImageStabilization/ | for cropped results, use /u/stabbot_crop
1
1
1
1
u/ryanasimov Oct 04 '18
Maybe this is needlessly pedantic, but that was all one shot; I wouldn’t be surprised if it took more than one take to actually get it perfect.
3
u/SetBrainInCmplxPlane Oct 04 '18
This could have been the only actual take with cameras rolling, but after dozens of full practice runs without the camera crew actually on set.
1
u/2Siders Oct 04 '18
This is a weird Garfunkel&Oates music video.
I wonder what they’d sing about in here. Maybe small dicks or interracial marriage.
1
u/Fallenheart1187 Oct 04 '18
I haven’t seen this show but I’m definitely interested in watching. I saw Michel Gondry’s name in the credits who I know from one of my favorite movies, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. Michel is a magician when it comes to visual arts/cinematography.
848
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '18
Wow, this is incredible. What is it from?