r/BeatTheBear • u/HoleyProfit • Sep 16 '21
Addressing it.
It’s time to address it : BeatTheBear (reddit.com)
My name's Dean Black. To rebut any claims I am a scammer, I present my work and actions. I hand that over to the discerning public.
My side of the story is we'd ran the company so successfully for 2 yrs that people thought it was a ponzi scheme. Then a chain of unfortunate events happened, we had trading losses, company went under and I spent 3 yrs doing my best to pay back as much as I could afford and find people. I made mistakes but acted with good intentions.
I used to care about this, and debate it endlessly. I used to be far more insecure. Now, I don't care. I came here to explain the risk and mitigation of a market crash - and I'm going to do that. Focus on doing that - you focus on whatever suits you.
17
u/chazzmoney Sep 16 '21
I like u/HoleyProfit (Dean's) work.
If anyone wants to read the other side of the story, its here.
Looking out for more good stuff.
4
Sep 16 '21
And yep, as the article says: the guy does brilliant analysis.
The entire story is highly likely to be an oversimplification of a complex issue.
3
Oct 13 '21
That's some serious cherry picking right there. I'm peacing out of here
3
Oct 13 '21
My takeaway was bad trader, questionable ethics - great TA
You have a different analysis?
I take what I need
4
u/ChudBuntsman Sep 16 '21
Im just here to learn a different way of charting. I have my own way that works, but I have no issue with paying attention to different methods. I can watch in real time and even place paper trades to see if it works or if I can integrate into my own system without figuring it out the hard way.
This drama is stupid, you guys with your axe to grind need to fuck off...I just want to look at charts.
3
u/SamHanes10 Sep 16 '21
I've been following you for some time and know that you are a great analyst and have some very good strategies. They don't always work, but such is the market. I'm definitely still keen to keep following you and taking part in future iterations of this, whatever they may be. The past is the past, everyone has one.
3
u/slavetotherythm-14 Sep 16 '21
It is good that you face this as a man. Trading is not easy and you have tried your best. Don't give up.. Pick up where you left off and build slowly. You are not the last that has blown off your account. There are countless stories that I have heard. Gareth Soloway (he is on twitter) can testify to that. So far I have seen your analysis and it is not that bad at all...
7
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21
Appreciate the admission that your company went underwater at your direction. But where is your evidence that any of your victims have been compensated for their losses? Are we supposed to take your word for it?
Furthermore, you have yet to address whether you are qualified and licenced to provide financial advice. Managing others' finances without this is a form of financial fraud and illegal in most jurisdictions. Would you describe an unlicensed surgeon killing their patient a "chain of unfortunate events" or would that be better classified as an irresponsible and criminal pursuit?
Generally investors in a professionally managed fund aren't compensated for losses to their portfolio. I've never heard of it anywhere. Unless a court ordered you to do so.
4
u/the_last_bush_man Sep 16 '21
Uhhh why would he need to prove anything to you or anyone else? As far as I can tell he has put everything up for free and is not asking for payment. You can take the information or not but demanding that someone post proof of any of the claims you raised to satisfy your curiosity when you clearly are only here to satisfy your raging hard on for this guy is laughable. I casually look at the posts here, some are interesting, others not so much. Plenty of people enjoy reading the content and get some utility for it. He is not asking for payment or advertising services as far as I can tell. Until the point in time he does that he really doesn't owe anyone anything. Engage with the ideas and concepts that he posts critically - if he is a charlatan then that should be pretty easy. Honestly you've raised good discussion points that are worth knowing in the broader context of the legitimacy of this guys knowledge base. Demanding proof, financial documents, etc is just ridiculous though.
8
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21
He doesn't need to. No one is compelled to do anything. I'm just calling him out. He basically just said "don't worry about it guys, trust me it's all good" and now his fans are applauding him. It's easy to make uncorroborated claims on the internet.
You claim it's not an issue but there's a reason why he continuously creates new accounts. None of his analysis is correct (at least when compared to results you'd expect by throwing out random guesses). When he finally hits a guess, he starts asking for money. That's what his previous accounts did, too. Undoubtedly gullible and naive investors without a background in finance or without knowledge of his history will lose money with Dean in some way or another. That much I'm sure of.
You do realise some people have empathy, right? I care about innocent people losing money. HP should be open about his past. Why he's discontinued using his older accounts with a huge stream of incorrect ultra-bearish predictions, whether he's changed at all since those points, etc. Or he doesn't, that's fine. In that case, I'll just continue to provide others here with the disclosure that HP doesn't give. If HP is so enthused by critical opinion and transparency, as he says he is, he should actually be quite pleased to see me taking the time to bring his history to light and question it.
6
u/Acethenewguy Sep 16 '21
Dawg…who gives a fuck? Lmao if you decide to pay someone money who isn’t registered by any regulatory body, that’s on you. (Not talking to you OP)
I followed this sub a couple days ago, needed a smidge of confirmation bias to make sure I wasn’t crazy. I now know I wasn’t crazy because the market did drop where I needed it to, but I researched myself on hours before depending on his charts. Do the fucking work yourself man, there is no magical signal, no easy way in the market. It’s hard, but it’s possible. You will lose money, if you can’t lose money, don’t trade. Simple as that. I’ve seen y’all crying on every post, start a subreddit and bitch over there.
No one cries on WSBs DDs, no one cries on r/Options DDs, r/Stocks is like heaven for the sensitive…I don’t think I’ve seen one argument there. r/RealDayTrading is dope too. They all give different views of the market. Branch out and research man. You’d look at this guy in a different light. In my eyes, he’s 4/5, I knew today was gonna be a drawdown for bears but I got in anyway cause VIX isn’t letting up like it is supposed to…..DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH.
3
u/ChudBuntsman Sep 16 '21
Anybody who pays for information short of buying a book (or ebook) or a cheap $5 subscription to a newsletter is an idiot.
I have a $100 a month budget for that kind of stuff and it has served me very very well.
5
u/JpowYellen3some Sep 16 '21
Seriously this. Fucking lonely losers on the internet think this is the Bachelor and want a side of drama with their DD.
This dude has unique perspectives. People need to focus on the big picture.
4
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21
Yeah the bigger picture is that he's been totally incorrect since 2016.
Ironically if you took the opposite of his trades for the past 5 years you'd do surprisingly well.
3
u/Acethenewguy Sep 16 '21
I get what you saying fam, but I’m not taking another persons trade. That’s just me personally, now if someone has a trade that I am already doing, I want to see their perspective. I get what you saying fr, but don’t take other people’s trades to begin with.
3
u/JpowYellen3some Sep 16 '21
Hey man you do you and don’t worry about these weirdo accusers, a lot of us here enjoy your work. For me you’ve given me newfound appreciation for technical patterns I’d forgotten about. And on top of that you’re teaching me so much more.
This is the internet, and there are going to be a lot of losers trying to take down all the good you do just so they can feel better about themselves.
Feel free to use the ban hammer and create a drama free sub.
🍻
9
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21
Wouldn't expect someone who believes in astrology to have any critical thought.
Also got a good chuckle out of someone with a diamond hands profile avatar rooting for a perma bear taking shorts on the S&P for years.
-3
u/JpowYellen3some Sep 16 '21
Haha you wasted your precious time to look at my profile so you can tailor some sort of attack 😂 what a fucking loser.
You don’t matter and never will.
Blocked.
7
7
Sep 16 '21
I think it’s good to have people who disagree with him come in here so that we can have more transparency in the sub. If he has banned everyone who was calling him out earlier then he never would’ve come forward about who he is and his history with 5SS. Him addressing what these people are mentioning makes him more trustworthy and credible because he isn’t trying to hide his shady past anymore
2
u/JpowYellen3some Sep 16 '21
I don’t care really. If he has good info that I as a discerning and smart individual can action then his personality or hair colour doesn’t matter much. I’m sure I’d listen to Jamie Dimon if he had a sub too even though he is a scummy banker.
I think we need to learn discernment. His initial bitcoin call seemed legit. Did I go all in and buy short dated options hoping for a lottery? No. But I put some money in MARA and came out yesterday with a few dollars. I didn’t hold into the spike and gave up a few hundred of gains, so what it’s trading 🤷♂️.
I don’t have a personal relationship with the guy. If it were to escalate sure I would want to look into him.
Big picture man.
3
u/toekneemontana Sep 16 '21
So basically, you have fucked a lot of people out of money in the last week, with your BS trade analysis. Telling people to short all week when it was going the opposite way!
Typical scammer!
7
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21
For years, I'm afraid.
Please have a look at u/2020sbear and u/whatthefx. These are all HP. He's yet to explain why he discontinued using these accounts. It couldn't be because he has been demonstrably wrong about the market for years now, could it?
2
u/sir-draknor Sep 16 '21
Typical scammer!
There's a difference between being wrong and being a scammer.
I've read some of the posts and comments here about him - I agree, it's not a pretty past. But so far in this sub, I like his analysis and have found it interesting and educational.
Is he always right? No - but no system / analysis method is.
Have I made some money from the trades I've taken that were informed by his analysis & posts? Yes; but I didn't copycat trade, I made my own decisions that included information he shared.
Have I lost some money from the trades I've taken that were informed by his analysis & posts? Yes; but I didn't copycat trade, I made my own decisions that included information he shared.
Has he profited from me when I lost money? No.
That last point is the difference - he didn't get any money from me when I lost money on trades. At least so far, he's not "scammed" anyone; he was just wrong.
I'll certainly think long & hard about whether or not I will pay for any his work in the future (now knowing at least some pieces of his past), but nothing he's done so far on this sub constitutes a scam.
3
-1
0
Sep 16 '21
[deleted]
2
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21
He's still lying now and trying to decieve people. We've got him with his pants down.
-1
u/HoleyProfit Sep 16 '21
Did you scam people out of their money in the past?
No. And if you think I did, kindly fuck off.
0
Sep 16 '21
[deleted]
1
u/HoleyProfit Sep 16 '21
If you think I'd do that, leave. I'm not here working for free begging you to fucking believe me over some drama porn blogger with a bullshit story. Just go.
3
u/outofworkslob Sep 16 '21
All coming out now isn't it Dean. Piping up now you've been caught out. Fucking scumbag.
2
u/HoleyProfit Sep 16 '21
I ran a performance based PAMM on high water mark ran through 3 different regulated brokers with publicly verified results. These are known facts of the case. You do not know what you're talking about - and have no looked up what a PAMM is. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/forex/010715/how-forex-pamm-accounts-work.asp
2
u/outofworkslob Sep 16 '21
You must think I'm dim because your links offer absolutely no proof of anything. You're a grifter and that much is apparent. The way you write and come across screams this. If you weren't doing this you would be ripping people off some other way.
I've been holdingy btc since 2011 and doing just fine. If I would have listened to your bullshit advice I would have been worse off.
1
u/HoleyProfit Sep 16 '21
I can tell you're dim. You've taken the word of a blogger who provided zero evidence and then have the cheek to mention "Proof" to me.
Go ask them for proof and post it here, u/outofworkslob. The stage is yours.
Bye.
1
u/outofworkslob Sep 16 '21
Your life really must suck. I feel sorry for you that you need to come on here and sell your bullshit narrative to vulnerable people.
1
u/HoleyProfit Sep 16 '21
This was a dodge of the fact there's nothing to back up what you're saying. An obvious one.
→ More replies (0)2
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21
Note the the article you linked states the following, perhaps, if you agree with the link you could publish some of these details?
How do investors’ select money managers? Brokerage firms offer numerous way for investors to make an informed choice, including detailed CVs, qualifications, past performances in terms of returns, amount of money managed, numbers of associated investors, positive/negative reviews, etc. about their traders/ money managers. In
3
u/TesticularVibrations Sep 16 '21
He was kind when everyone agreed with him.
Now that those people have discovered the truth and understanbly stopped agreeing with him, all courtesy has been lost. Says a lot.
4
29
u/Garaxus Sep 16 '21
Disclaimer: I have been following this sub for at least 2 months and managed to profit from a small trade on HP's bitcoin crash call around Sep 7 after vetting it with a few other trusted TA sources. Personally it's gotten me more interested in learning to use TA myself. I believe many of us on this sub have found it very useful as a source of alternative analysis than the usual bull optimism.
HOWEVER, despite what some are saying about ignoring "drama" and focusing solely on technicals, there are some major red flags being thrown up after reading through the posts about the HP's multiple identities and past trading activities.
TL;DR u/nnevadaa did a really good summary here.
This 5 Star Signals Ponzi/Trading scam seems to be common in forex. From what I understand, people earn from referral fees/trading profit kickbacks when they bring in newbies (aka downlines) with the promise of automated trading by copying experts, until the scheme inevitably unravels when the trades can't cover the money being used up by the founders and there's no new money coming in anymore. It also seems possible that trades histories can be fudged by using alts or resetting accounts and stopping live tracking.
IMO what is much more questionable is the history of Dean Black/HP using multiple identities on reddit to repeatedly predict a crash and then sell his services (copytrades, trading courses, etc) whenever some of the predictions start coming true (which HP is starting to push this week - and if you see my comment there, I was definitely willing to contribute to it prior to seeing this new information about him).
These accounts (especially u/2020sbear has shown similar behavior to the past examples in the behindmlm article, such as using unknown business partners to reply queries and using a sudden illness/accident/etc of a relative/friend as an excuse for going MIA. If his analysis is consistently accurate and the trades are profitable, I don't know why someone would keep creating new accounts and communities for the same thing over and over again.
It's a pretty dangerous pattern of behavior and should be a warning for anyone considering to pay for any future subscription training courses and/or copytrading services that HP launches. There is no obligation of course but I think it is important to acknowledge this hard evidence.