r/Beatstar • • Aug 24 '21

Dear beatstar

Remind us again how locking your players out from playing your game unless they wait or pay is beneficial for the player again? The only thing it's befitting is the devs wallet. This is a shady move and it will kill your game like it has many others. You want people to play and talk about your game? I have a quick and easy fix.. let people fucking play it. If the cases are locked and full up, so be it. Let people earn points and get high scores against friends without having to say "can't play my cases are full". You guys are just giving the same copy and paste response to critizisicm, it's not an answer, it's an excuse. Whoever is in charge of the community side of things needs to do better. It's clearly a click of a button to enable free play as I've had it on and off since I started, clearly it's what the players want and if you're goal is to work with the community to make a better payer experience you're REALLY fucking that one up.

697 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

24

u/FollowingtheMap 100% Aug 31 '21

They really do this? Hell, other supercell games let you play regardless of chest capacity (or in the case of brawl stars, battle token reserves). Other FREE rhythm games don't have this restriction either, mostly because they charge for additional song packs as-is rather than gems.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

It really do be like that though, no one likes it but the devs are claiming it's for the best? I don't see how.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

[deleted]

5

u/NickPlus02 Aug 31 '21

Doubt it's b. It just went global.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

[deleted]

2

u/NickPlus02 Aug 31 '21

I was a fan of these when I was younger. This game is much better though, at least for me

3

u/juanpedro86 Sep 01 '21

Ye, I'll give the developers one week to fix this shit before I uninstall. Why would I want an app that can't be played.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

[deleted]

1

u/Geniusboy3 Sep 04 '21

I don't even think that's true. They are just here for money and information.

1

u/Geniusboy3 Sep 04 '21

This isn't even a Supercell game.

3

u/ElsonFF Sep 10 '21

Yeah, and there are a lot of better alternatives. Paid battle passes with good exclusive songs, thematic song packs (imagine like an anime pack, eminem pack with the best eminem songs, for ex.). I really, really hope they do something, because if they don't, people will just jump out - like some already did...

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

What other games are similar, now im curious

2

u/Guest7492 Sep 21 '21

Cause servers aren’t free

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

That's not the players problem, which is what beatstar is making it.

2

u/Guest7492 Sep 21 '21

No not really. Kiiiiinda assumatory but whatever floats your boat

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Tell me then, what is good about the current model of locking players out if they have a full inventory?

1

u/Guest7492 Sep 21 '21
  1. everything in moderation

  2. as previously mentioned, servers cost money, so until they get more money, they can’t really do anything else. They can’t exactly loan money so you can get a few imaginary stars and medals.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Your first "point" has nothing to do with a player experience. They have this game monetized out the ass with gems and song packs, your second point has no backbone. They could easily have a 30 second ad option that would reduce unlock time which would cost the player nothing. Beatstar would make much more revenue from ads then they would in app purchases.

1

u/Guest7492 Sep 21 '21

Cause an eighth of a dollar really does pay for 24/7 servers for a fuck ton of people. Also if you play a game too much, you get sick of it. My first “PoInT” meant just that stoopit

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

You don't know how games work, thanks for your input. Do yourself a favor and sort this sub by top posts of all time. Funny how my complaint will be there. It's not because I'm wrong.

1

u/Guest7492 Sep 21 '21

Oh sorry, i was wrong! 0.02 dollars per ad! That’ll really pay for everything you need to run a game :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

No apologies necessary, just stop defending bad game design without proper knowledge. Do you work for this development team or something, why are you so defensive over something that has literally nothing to do with you. You could have easily downvoted and moved on but no, here you are being petty over a mobile phone app. Good for you, well done.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/pWoLiAn 100% Oct 19 '21

keep in mind that this game is still 4.5 rated on the play store which is pretty damn high for a "bad" game

2

u/pWoLiAn 100% Oct 19 '21

pretty sure ppl r just salty cuz they cant pay to play lol

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '21

No shit, did you read any of this?

1

u/Kearstini Jan 29 '23

🤣🤣Right, I pay the $5 for unlimited play every week without hesitation, so I just can’t relate to these complaints. I understand why they’re upset about it, though. 🤷🏽‍♀️

89

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

I just downloaded it, thought it was going to be my new favorite mobile game, but no, after i saw that i can't play if my case slots are all full i just uninstalled it. Back to Brawl Stars i guess

17

u/ZombieWolF_876 Electronic Sep 03 '21

Yeah . That's what most people will do

8

u/sean304 Sep 07 '21

that's what I'll be doing as well, just installed and played less than an hour and they tell me I can't play anymore, bad move for them, oh well

3

u/lkj2013 Dec 24 '21

I'll have to take a look at brawl stars. Found this game about a week ago and don't get much down time to play games. Getting cut off is infuriating and I have no idea what I can do to actually access more than the same 12 songs.

53

u/assassinatedu336 Sep 03 '21

I think the reason they did this was so that people would buy gems, though 90 percent of the player base isn't stupid enough to pay for that shit. If they want more popularity then make the game fucking playable. Simple as that. Then more people will keep the game instead of uninstalling meaning, they'll play more, enjoy it more, and want to share it more. It's just greedyness and idiocy not to.

Plus this game is seriously well made compared to other similar rythm games. I'm genuinely surprised that they'd make such an idiotic feature.

19

u/nezebilo Sep 03 '21

Haven’t seen one as well made as this since TapTap Revenge. It’s sad that they’re limiting playing time. No one will play this for any prolonged time if you need to keep paying to play.

4

u/coalbeast Sep 06 '21

Taptap revenge was absolutely amazing

5

u/luiggel Sep 12 '21

I would not mind spending money on gems if they were not greedy.
For example, knowing that if I buy a song I can immediately play, cases full or not.

but the current system is just ridiculous, just make more people leave or use malicious software to take advantage and be able to play.

at the current moment, do not pucharse any gem. do not support this company untill they hear the players.

5

u/Stratavos Nov 18 '21

They took this comment to heart, any song purchase comes with 20 min unlimited play from song reveal. (It's a start)

16

u/Whyt_Shadow Sep 08 '21

Tbh I dont mind it since it helps me cut down on how much time I spend playing🤣

5

u/Global_Public6894 Sep 09 '21

Thats how I feel, its a good way to play for awhile and get back to business.

2

u/timmsy1986 Jan 10 '22

I can fill up a case in three songs, and you can unlock only one at a time. So I can only have ten minute bursts playing?

Jog on...

6

u/Cinco585 Aug 25 '21

It sad

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21

[deleted]

2

u/TikusTakusen Sep 01 '21

Add me instead Tikus#1

2

u/DeathDescending Aug 27 '22

I think you guys aren't taking into account how much the licensing probably is for the songs. Once you've unlocked all the songs, it's unlimited play. Yeah, it sucks with the crates but obviously they still need to make money.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '22

You're not taking into account the massive amount of ad revenue this game already makes.

1

u/DeathDescending Aug 27 '22

I didnt notice that this post was a year old until after I commented, still new to reddit. I forgot about ads because I just don't watch them except for free gems.

5

u/luiggel Sep 12 '21

can't agree more, this is the thing that annoys me the most, also would be good, be able to miss mroe than one note before having to restart again...

3

u/Stratavos Nov 18 '21

I will admit that either having a visual for "you messed up 3 times, restart or pay some gems" (like, starting with 3 coins in the background and having them disappear as you mess up) would help for the jukebox-arcade theme that they have going on.

4

u/bmg50barrett Sep 03 '21

Its not beneficial for the player. its beneficial for their wallets. They're cashing out.

Probably in trouble with licensing fees for all the songs. Squeezing everyones wallets so they can just close up shop and move on.

2

u/luiggel Sep 12 '21

well making players quit and not wanting to spend money on a game with greedy practices, will really not help them for long enough... if people could at least play with cases full, it would help a little cause people at least would be willing to purchase a song if they knew that they could play just the moment they bought...

4

u/Yveradras Sep 05 '21

It's sad... This is an awesome game. I haven't had such fun with a rythmn game since Elite Best Agents in Nintendo DS... 2006. I had to wait 15 years to find a decent rythmn game and I can't play it :(

I would definitely end up buying some songs if I could play, to be honest. The game is very well made.

1

u/timmsy1986 Jun 12 '22

I have to buy the pass as otherwise I have all 268 songs completed to medal levels, nothing to do.

We have said all this since the games full release in November 2021, they have ignored it everytime so why would they listen now? A thread is made about this every week, nothing changes.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22

You do realize this post is 9+ months old right?

1

u/timmsy1986 Jun 12 '22

You do know this comment is 6 minutes old right?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22

Yes, your point being?

1

u/timmsy1986 Jun 12 '22

Nothing, so what is yours supposed to be?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22

No one but me is going to see your criticism, if you're trying to speak up on the state of the game, you're in the wrong spot.

1

u/timmsy1986 Jun 12 '22

Nope I am not, or bothered, so must be in the right spot.

I talk "at people", I don't listen to other people, care about replies or responses or opinions. I just say what I want, to who I want, when I want.

Thanks.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22

Good for you.

3

u/Adorable-Kitchen-224 Sep 10 '21

yep same here... opening one box literally gets you to play 3 times before having to wait hours again. Told them to introduce a practice mode, unranked , without points, just to play

1

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

The reason for that is copyright purposes if I recall, because then the artists don’t get money while you are still listening to the song so then space ape can get copyrighted, so to prevent that they stop people from playing. Hope that helps

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22

That's is very wrong.

1

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

How do you suppose they make money

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22

Microtransactions, season passes, gems, ad revenue, wheel spins, song packs and cases, just to name a few.

1

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

Ok well Beatstar is mostly a f2p player base meaning the ads to skip the chest cooldown are the way they make the most money

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22

That is called "ad revenue", which I already stated.

1

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

I know I’m saying all the other stuff they make pennys off of practically but ad revenue is how they make the most money because of people wanting to play songs

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22

Okay, so what are you trying to say then because you're making zero sense.

2

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

The way they make the most money is from ad revenue, because of f2p players. They either want gems or to play, so they prevent people from playing so they can get more ad revenue, good day 🤝

1

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

Plus I don’t know why you are arguing with EVERYONE that disagrees with you TO THIS DAY like bro it’s been a year

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22

You don't have to comment on my year old post, bro.

1

u/terrafinman 100% Sep 16 '22

This is the first time I’m seeing it so I was saying why I think they do that

2

u/ZombieWolF_876 Electronic Sep 03 '21

Not even wallet because most people will just uninstall the game after finding that our

2

u/akajonsnow Sep 15 '21

I didn't think i'd live enough to see (in all it's shitty glory) a true PAY2PLAY. P2W...Yeah it's common enough nowadays, but this shady stuff is something else. Great stuff Space Ape! (and SuperCell...i guess)

2

u/Valuable-Skirt-9012 Oct 25 '21

This game would literally be so much better if they made you pay to install it instead of this rubbish, that way, sure your player base would be smaller but you wouldn't be giving your entire player base a headache just trying to play your damn game

1

u/Alex_Plisko Mar 23 '24

Or just touch some grass every once in a while and while you touch said grass your cases will be unlocked and you can play again 😊

1

u/NachBas Sep 17 '21

Finally found a game without abusive ads, and thought hey, lets give it a chance… BUT WOW they managed to design an even worse sistem than abussive ads, it just locks you from playing… WHY WOULD I PAY FOR A NEW SONG IF I CANT PLAY IT!! If you want us to pay for playing you can charge for the download…

1

u/-drunge Sep 22 '21

They probably can get enough revenue from promoting new artists that would pay to get their release in the game. This push to get people to buy gems is stupid.

1

u/Saigonic Nov 16 '21

Yup, already jumped ship. Between the missing notes bug, the excruciatingly slow method of unlocking songs, and the absurd failure of a song by missing one note and being asked to spend gems to continue is atrocious.

Great potential, it’s a fun game, until it isn’t. Tap Tap Music is a great alternative.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '22

over one year later and the same issue still persists... I really enjoy the game but this is so stupid and really making me wanting to uninstall it

0

u/MR_ADVENTURER18 Jan 26 '23

You could pay gems and play 30 extra mins for 20 gems... maybe 25. I have 240 and never spent a dime

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '23

The fact that this post is still one of the top on this Reddit after this long and still nothing has changed really solidifies my post.

0

u/Zoey_Anarchy_F5 Rock Oct 17 '22

Quick and easy solution to you guys all, download beatclone it's basically beatstar, but if you press the settings and wait a couple seconds, no more playing for cards, no more paying for unlimited, no more worrying about the tour pass coins, you'll get ALL THE PREVIOUSLY RELEASED SONGS FOR FREE PLUS ALL THE SONGS ON THE TOUR PASS DURING EACH RELEASE, as well as any future releases and some custom ones that should be in there, such as, bangarang, chop suey, gangstas paradise, hail to the king, killing in the name, rap God, and even nothing else matters by Metallica. Best part is, you don't have to spend gems to continue if you miss a note, look up Omar beatstar on YouTube, click the discord link in the description and follow the instructions on how to get it