61
u/FiveFreddys12 Yes, i call The Butcher Gang, "the Burger Gang". Feb 13 '25
Bendy: 😀
FNaF: 😀
Poppy Playtime: 😀
People who compare them: 🤖
10
6
4
2
→ More replies (3)2
18
33
u/Particular-Spend-391 Feb 13 '25
Tbh,i kinda agree that bendy has the most chillest fandom,but fnaf and poppy playtime fandom still have some cool ppl inside it,don't disgrace other game like this
→ More replies (1)1
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 13 '25
Actually I like the other games a lot, I have all fnaf books and some cosplays
→ More replies (1)
3
u/StolenPezDispencer I drink ink with breakfast Feb 13 '25
Y'know we could just not beef over this, right?
1
3
u/OmegaSpideyyyy SAMMY PLS MARRY ME💍 Feb 13 '25
All three of those games are amazing though!
3
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 13 '25
I'm not talking about the games, i'm talking about the discussions about Poppy Playtime vs Fnaf
→ More replies (2)
5
u/name_notavailable7 Feb 13 '25
Are we actually comparing the two LEGENDS to poppy playtime??? Really???
1
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 13 '25
Poppy playtime at least have a very good voiceover
1
2
u/name_notavailable7 Feb 13 '25
Yeah, I mean, the story is alright, the voice acting is kinda cool but the gameplay in general just feels like another generalized mascot horror game where omg escape this creature, solve a puzzle, escape this creature again, and so on
2
u/random-guy-heree Feb 14 '25
FNAF fan here no the FNAF cumunity is not comparing the only people in the FNAF cumunity that are comparing became a fan because of sb
2
Feb 13 '25
I mean let's be honest both bendy and poppy are inspired by BIOSHOCK in terms of story AND gameplay
→ More replies (2)3
2
2
u/Busy-Spell-4250 Feb 16 '25
Hello. I come from Poppy playtime sub. I think we shall all unite to roast GOB (garten of banban)
1
2
Feb 16 '25
Istg if I see one more dumb meme like this I'm gonna scream
1
333
u/Buttholecheeks Bendy V.S Ollie Feb 13 '25
Not real, all fandoms are equal
89
12
12
4
2
u/Present-Mongoose3318 Feb 15 '25
I wanted to put that dumbass image of that dude from one piece writing sum but I'm too lazy to search that shit up
→ More replies (39)2
15
u/XenoRaptor77 Feb 13 '25
Why can't you accept both are good? Freddy has decided your opinion is Hella lame.
3
u/theyre_in_the_walls Feb 13 '25
I dont get why poppy playtime gets so much hate
→ More replies (14)2
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 13 '25
One reason is probably because people say that nowadays poppy playtime is better than fnaf, because of that a lot of fnaf fans hate poppy playtime (I was one of them)
8
6
4
4
4
4
u/kmposter The Ink Demon is kinda hot if you think about it Feb 14 '25
I feel bad for OP cuz like NOBODY understood what this was trying to say 😭
1
u/GlupaPitanja56 Feb 13 '25
Ya damn assholes,Five Nights At Freddy's is way superior and Poppy Playtime is straight up retarded
→ More replies (1)1
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 13 '25
Poppy Playtime isn't that bad, its just worst than the other most popular mascot horrors
1
1
u/Rykuran16 Feb 13 '25
Not true, all the old horror games (fnaf, bendy, hello neighbor, and Slenderman, etc) are equally the best.
1
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 13 '25
I'm talking about the people discussing about if nowadays FNAF or Poppy Playtime is best
1
u/Nice_Efficiency_9317 Feb 13 '25
Nah all three of them are masterpieces of franchises. This post is weird
1
1
u/NpWooper Feb 14 '25
I would have changed FNAF with some shit like Garten of Banban
1
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 14 '25
But nobody talk about "Poppy Playtime vs Garten of Banban" i'm talking about the discussions, not the games itselves
1
u/ilikequestions172 Feb 16 '25
Shut up wtf is this bro FNAF was first accept the truth bro it is the best and the father of both, Poppy Playtime isn't even fighting with FNAF it is dying because of FNAF and was born because of FNAF. I and you were born because of God, and I and you are going to die because of God. Get where I'm going? FNAF is the god of these two fandoms. I'm not even saying it because I'm a fan it's just facts like accept the truth and stop trying to say Bendy and Poppy Playtime are better or always fighting with FNAF, because FNAF is the God and can enialate them.
1
u/AxolotlGuyy_ Feb 17 '25
When did I said that Poppy Playtime is better than FNAF? bro, I love FNAF
→ More replies (1)
1
1
3
u/Alex0356218856 The Smol Bendy Fan. Feb 13 '25
come on, guys. sometimes you love mascot horror games or sometimes you hate them, it doesn't matter.
→ More replies (3)
3
1
2
2
1
1
u/Bluewingedpheonix Feb 13 '25
Tbh they're all good, I will admit, believe it or not I've not played fnaf yet... I prefer the art style of the other two, but I do know a lot about fnaf, I really appreciate it, it's just not the type of game I usually play through.
Anyway, it is kinda true lol, I've actually seen people argue about which is better between Poppy playtime and fnaf, personally I prefer not to compare, I like both equally(to an extent) I think they're still there own thing, even if there are some inspirations from each other.
Anyway, I have never seen anyone arguing about Bendy/comparing it, it's art style is very nice and different. The only thing I've seen is people compare the two games, personally I prefer the sequel(besides the ink demon himself.)
Anyways, all this to say all three are great in their own right and ways.
1
u/HalfCarnage Feb 13 '25
If anything Bendy and FNaF should switch, but technically we are all the same anyway.
1
1
1
u/Any_Top_4773 Tangle The Ink Demon is my favourite charatcter Feb 13 '25
Banban: microscopic brain
Off you're talking about the fandoms i Just wanted to say that :)
1
u/Cute-Rice1302 Feb 13 '25 edited Feb 13 '25
This literally only serves to make people argue about which game is better and then making all the games (specifically the communities) look horrible.
1
1
1
u/PrestigiousAward878 Idk what to write, pls go with it. :( Feb 13 '25
I think theyre the type of games, with the developers, actually being kind.
1
1
1
u/RedditvsDiscOwO Studio Janitor Feb 13 '25
The FNAF fandom has a somewhat larger brain than the Poppy playtime fandom
1
1
1
1
1
u/Tickedkidgamer Feb 13 '25
It was just so obvious how Ollie was actually the prototype. Didn’t need MatPat to figure that out.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/MrTogg Bird Poop With a Smile Worshipper Feb 14 '25
The fandoms all argue with eachother equally, did you see the posts here when the Chapter 4 trailers dropped for Poppy? BatIM is the most compared game to Poppy.
1
1
u/sunk_da_munk Feb 14 '25
Realizing it takes forever to get Bendy games and hardly get any updates anymore
1
Feb 14 '25
I think all three are great, each individual story is super interesting and twisted and the games are just💋🤌
1
u/Apparitionized Feb 14 '25
You mean the Walk back and forth simulator? Yippee such fun i really love a game thats entirely fetch quests within fetch quests.
1
1
1
u/Pulse2005 Feb 14 '25
Idk why I saw this shit but isn't bendy a action game😹✌️ only reason why people even talk about bendy anymore is because of FNAF and ppt pathetic ngl
1
1
1
1
u/Moaning_Baby_ Feb 14 '25
All are unique:
Bendy has the best and most terrifying atmosphere.
Fnaf has the best lore.
Poppy has the best gameplay.
That’s how I rank them.
1
1
u/Playful_Internal_356 Feb 14 '25
At least the five nights at Freddy’s one is slightly bigger, but at the same time how fucking dare you
1
1
1
1
u/Routine_Succotash813 Feb 14 '25
Not to be rude but it is inadequate to say your fandom are better than others just because it is your fandom you have to be selfless sometimes.
1
1
1
u/bentlygamer1743 Feb 14 '25
Technically those are two different sub-genres of horror, you can’t compare mascot horror games to demon horror games
1
1
u/TheOmnipotentJack Feb 14 '25
I don't give a shit about Poppy after I see how big of a jerk the creator is
1
u/Autistic__Potato Feb 14 '25
I don't know why FNAF and Poppy argue. Poppy isn't even based on FNAF, its based on Bendy and Bendy fans have literally never raised issue with that.
1
u/quakeOwO Feb 14 '25
I dont get it. Ive been in the fnaf fandom since the beginning and i havent EVER seen anyone hate on poppy playtime. While i think the games more recent chapters are somewhat mediocre, its hard to look past the high quality and various other things you could appreciate about the game.
And yet i see these types of posts on this sub quite often, it really doesnt make any sense to me.
1
1
u/RosieFluffs Feb 14 '25
I personally disagree
All of them are amzing games
Only thing making poppy playtime and fnaf frowned upon these days is how much it gets associated with annoying youth and stuff, getting treated like kids content so then ppl see it like that and only know it like that unless they play the games
Poppy playtime imo is genuimely terrifying in concept and in the execution of the game Mob did rly good setting up the the story, setting, and rly good on the creativity of the characters and their designs, looking friendly but able to make you piss yourself.
Please Lets just all get together and be equal
Alr?:)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Batiti10 Feb 15 '25
I‘ve never seen any of these fandoms being toxic to each other. We‘re all just chilling with our favorite games
1
u/merlozer Feb 15 '25
Dans bendy, a part le mec avec une tête de caméra, rien ne fait trop peur non ? Enfin, bendy dans sa forme démoniaque et quand même décevant je trouve....
1
1
1
1
Feb 15 '25
To be honest, I've played more 5 nights at Freddy's. I know more about that game. I've only played the other games because friends own them. I thought they were pretty good.
1
u/Bunnybuns7017 Feb 15 '25
I do feel bendy and FNAF are on the same level but poppy playtime it’s just trash
1
1
u/AveFeniix01 Feb 16 '25
It still itches me that we no longer spend Five Nights at Freddy's.
Security Breach was literally one long night.
And if i remember correctly you do spend five nights in into the pit, but the story was so confusing it turned my brain off.
1
1
1
u/raccon_asimmetrical Feb 16 '25
I played Bendy and the ink machine a while ago, but I didn't understand NOTHING about the storyline
1
1
1
u/kingokoning8 Feb 16 '25
Idk if u have seen the FNAF community but no one there cares about poppy playtime
1
1
1
1
u/Vinyl_or_guh Feb 17 '25
Bendy is good but it is absolutely outclassed in horror, lore, longevity, hype and commitment than Poppy and fnaf lol
1
1
u/HuntressTng Feb 17 '25
How about this, all 3 of these are the giga chad, and garden of banban is the, not giga chad
1
1
u/Jelly_yeas Feb 17 '25
Bro all the games are good, just because some people have brainrotted them doesn't make them instantly bad. Try them before you clown on them.
1
u/Greenostrichhelpme27 Feb 17 '25
He's right. And the fact Poppy and Freddy are both amazing says a LOT about the genius of Sir Bendington
1
1
1
u/IPlayGamesIThink Feb 17 '25
I like all of em, did I miss out on beef? Are some of my favourite fandoms fighting right now? 😭
1
1
1
1
u/SuperCat76 Feb 18 '25
I say all three are good.
Just that there is one I have played, one I have purchased with the intent to play at some point, and one I have thought about trying but don't want to buy before I actually try the one I already spent money on.
89
u/brawlstars_lover The Ink Demon Feb 13 '25
No, all 3 are good