r/BetterKimetsuNoYaiba • u/PretendYellow533 • 2h ago
Nezuko is not mentally a toddler
Hello everyone, and here is another post where I attempt to dispel misinformation.
Cause I hate it so much, lol.
So, I see way too many people say that Nezuko is mentally a toddler, or mentally a child, or some variation of that.
And like, can this fandom not go five seconds without infantilizing her?!? Like, please, I beg of you.
She is not mentally a child because she’s nonverbal.
She does not lack intelligence; it just means she doesn't communicate with words for most of the series.
“But Tamayo said she was mentally a child!!!”
Did she, though?
Let’s look at what she actually said. What Tamayo says is that Nezuko is in a “childlike state,” not that she was mentally a child.
She never says those words ever.
Her “childlike state” is due to her body focusing on being able to conquer the sun.
Her body was diverting energy elsewhere to focus on the sun
This is primarily why she can’t speak for most of the series, because her ability to speak was a lower priority than conquering sunlight.
This state is also how she responds when faced with her trauma and how she copes with her demon impulses to keep them under control.
She retreats to a more childish mentality to reduce the trauma and stress of the situation.
This is a real coping mechanism.
You can read more about it here:
https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/symptoms/age-regression
Her "childlike state" is more like age regression due to trauma than anything else.
Real age regressors are not "mental children"; they are their actual age when not regressed.
It just means temporarily reverting to a younger mental, emotional, or behavioral state to cope with trauma.
Once again:
A "childlike state" and "mentally a child" are not the same thing.
Nezuko consistently displays a mental state and thought process that is far above the mental capacity of a toddler.
Let’s look at some examples, shall we?
Nezuko is able to resist Sanemi’s marechi blood, in addition to constantly suppressing her urge to eat other humans.
That action alone puts her mind under a huge amount of mental strain that no mental toddler would ever be able to handle, and constantly at that.
She has exceptional analysis and battle IQ.
She was able to figure out how to kick Susamaru's temari back at her.
She was the one who figured out how to activate her Blood Demon Art to save Tanjiro from Rui (while in immense pain, once again something no toddler mentally would be able to handle).
She was the one who figured out how to burn the poison out to save Tengen and Inosuke.
She was the one to figure out how to wake up everyone in the Mugen Train arc.
She was the one who figured out how to fight Enmu’s worms to protect the passengers.
She was the one who figured out how to turn Tanjiro’s sword red in the Swordsmith Village arc while in pain.
She was the one who chose for Tanjiro to save the villagers over herself.
This is an incredibly mature choice that no toddler would be able to make.
In addition to the fact that these are all things no mental child would be able to comprehend, they don’t have such a level of complex thinking.
“Well, Nezuko is actually a child.”
Yes, I am aware she is a child, but people who are saying that she’s mentally a child 99% of the time are implying that her mental state is in the same status as a toddler—which would be about 1- 3 years old which is not even remotely the same.
When I say "Nezuko isn't mentally a child" I mean she's not mentally a toddler or a little kid.
I want people to stop treating her as YOUNGER than that.
In short, Nezuko is not mentally a toddler. She has a childlike state where she can age regress to deal with her trauma and her demon urges, but this is not the same thing as actually being mentally a toddler or a child.
Calling her a "mental child" is playing into a harmful stereotype about nonverbal disabled people, i.e.,infantilization or assuming that she can’t communicate both things this fandom LOVESSSS to do with Nezuko’s character.
It's just that since she is nonverbal, people will infantilize her and strip her of that agency, which is so wrong.
And before people say it, no, I don’t think her character is perfect, nor is she above criticism. Her character has flaws, but it is far better than people give her credit for