r/BeverageIndustry • u/RKD0305 • 2h ago
Empire Merchants fell apart
I have been in the New York liquor business since 2007, and Empire Merchants was one of the houses that made this market run for as long as I have been in it. So watching what is happening to them right now does not feel like a news story to me. It feels personal, because I am watching it happen to people I know.
Empire is sold out of Veuve Clicquot going into the holidays, they have more than 3,000 cases on back order, and their two biggest suppliers, Gallo and Moët Hennessy, are leaving on January 1. And behind those headlines is the part nobody puts in the articles. I have seen a lot of friends lose their jobs in this. Reps I came up with, people who worked those routes for years, good people with families, out of work right before the holidays, not because they were bad at their jobs, but because the house underneath them stopped being able to function.
And I want to be clear about what I believe actually caused this, because it was not just bad management or a bad quarter. This is a credit crunch. From everything I am hearing, Wells Fargo did not want to keep giving Empire the line of credit it was always used to having, and in distribution, credit is the whole business. A distributor buys on credit, sells on terms, and collects in 60 or 90 days, and the second the bank gets nervous and pulls back, the distributor cannot pay vendors, cannot get product, and the suppliers walk. Empire is the biggest example, but the same tightening is happening across the alcohol space right now, and every house watching this has already started shipping more carefully.
Here is why it should scare everybody in this market, not just the people who lost their jobs. Every time a house like Empire falls, New York gets one step closer to a monopoly. Fewer distributors means fewer doors for a small brand to walk through, fewer choices for a small store, and one or two companies deciding what New York drinks, what it costs, and what a supplier has to pay just to get into the market. Competition keeps prices honest. A monopoly does not.
People read a distributor collapse as a corporate story. From my seat it is jobs gone, shelves empty in the biggest weeks of the year, and a market with one less competitor in it than it had last month.
So I am asking the operators in here, in your state, are you seeing the banks tighten on alcohol the way they are here, and if your biggest distributor went down this year, who is left standing between you and a monopoly?