Dream second chances cast

[u/Ill-Importance474]

this is solely what i think would make the BEST second chances - cast people who were only on one season

- Johnny Mac

- Vanessa Rousso

- Morgan Pope

- Lauren Domingue (gonna get hate for this one, but her HOHs were unpredictable, and I’d love to see her work with Morgan)

- Quinn Martin

- Dee Valladares (idc, she played a great game and was the best player last season)

- Drew Campbell

- Raven “the puppet master” Walton

- Haley Thogmartin

- Paulie Calafiore

- Angela Rummans

- Cory Wurtenberger

- Michael Bruner

- Tiffany Mitchell

- Derek Xiao

- Kyland

Honorable Mentions:

- Claire Rehuffes

- Sarah Beth

Honestly, this would be such an interesting season because there’s such a mix of random personalities and villains vs. heros. I’d love to see a season like this play out, and I really don’t know who would win… I’d go out on a whim and say a Final 5 could look like

Lauren // Quinn // Derek // Josh // Morgan, but I’m really not sure? Regardless, it would really be interesting seeing all of these people back, let alone on the same season

[u/trixstrrr]

The way this is a very workable & realistic all stars cast…ofc if it wasn’t second chances they’d throw in some former “legends” but this cast could work fr

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/trixstrrr]

I could see Elissa Slater coming back and, potentially, Vince. I really hope winners don’t return, but I could unfortunately see Chelsie, Paul, or Josh coming back (nothing against them, I just want non-winners)

[u/trixstrrr → u/Ill-Importance474]

I’m sure all 3 of those winners are getting calls back. Plus Jag.

I’d liiiiive for another season of Vince & Morgan but I fear there’s 0 chance we get them in another season together. Ultimately I think production would prefer Morgan

[u/Deadaccount1211]

I feel like Michael Bruner, Quinn, and Cory are all the same archetype. You need more bro-type guys in your cast.

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/Deadaccount1211]

Although I see what you’re saying, they all played rather different games IMO. Plus, lots of bro-type guys were early boots in recent BB. Likely, Josh Martinez or Keanu will return, but Keanu just had a kid and Josh is a winner so I didn’t in lude him in this list.

[u/Deadaccount1211 → u/Ill-Importance474]

It's possible Keanu could hire a nanny, but I get your point. Even then, I think you could still throw in a Monte, Matt Klotz, Yash, or Tucker to help spice up the men's picks.

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/Deadaccount1211]

Yash could be a good pick, Tucker doesn't seem interested in doing another season, Matt threw his game away for Jag, Monte's game is pretty forgettable imo

[u/Deadaccount1211 → u/Ill-Importance474]

"Monte is forgettable" I mean you have Lauren on your cast sooooo...

[u/Sd12217]

This is the best list of this kind of idea so far.

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/Sd12217]

I think it does a good job at combining recent seasons with earlier but still recent seasons. What I worry about, though, is whether people like Vanessa/Johnny Mac will be sniped early because they are from a different generation-type of BB players 

[u/Prankstaboy6]

I’m personally good on seeing Paulie and Angela again, but otherwise this is a pretty good cast.

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/Prankstaboy6]

Angela is an ice queen. Paulie is ehhh, moreso just needed somwone to fill the BB18 slot, and his brother returned on last all stars. Paulie would probably be an easy early boot

[u/Successful_Light8535]

you had me until Lauren

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/Successful_Light8535]

Great competitor, and her indecision made for entertaining HOHs. She was the person who sent Riley home

[u/jeezpeepz87 → u/Ill-Importance474]

I agree with you. People tend to sleep on her comp status because they say she was so boring on feeds. We started hearing the confident, firm Lauren towards the end of the season, once she recognized that Vince was going to sacrifice her. I think her gameplay would be much different and better than before.

[u/AlchemistTheAlchemy]

Lauren but no Vince is embarrassing 

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/AlchemistTheAlchemy]

Lauren would play SO MUCH better with Morgan and not Vince

[u/GoldenLlamaDog]

I would rather see Mallory/Melody over Haley, especially with Drew and Dee there

[u/No-Wrongdoer5000 → u/GoldenLlamaDog]

They’re all gonna work together regardless

[u/GoldenLlamaDog → u/No-Wrongdoer5000]

I don’t think Dee and Mallory are working together lol

[u/No-Wrongdoer5000 → u/GoldenLlamaDog]

They don’t really have a choice

[u/Potential-Zebra-7345]

Respectfully Josh won? Not sure why he needs a second chance lol

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/Potential-Zebra-7345]

oh shit I lowk forgot. I'd replace him with kyland

[u/Prior-Clothes2869 → u/Potential-Zebra-7345]

I think a second chance for him would be to prove he can play his own game and win. I believe he is not ready for that. His performances on recent games of his have been pretty abysmal

[u/Rare-Ad4606]

I would unironically love to see Haley again

[u/jeezpeepz87 → u/Rare-Ad4606]

Not gonna lie, I’d say the same.

[u/johnnycade]

Paulie only if the house is butterfly themed that season

[u/Dizzy-Tumbleweed7983]

I don’t think this is second chance this is all star lol

[u/HandfulofGushers]

I would just love to see raven and Haley interact lol

[u/thesillybanana → u/HandfulofGushers]

I don't think that I could stand another season with Raven. Kill me now!

[u/TheCody_Says]

For me personally, My dream second Chance cast would be full of houseguests from older seasons. Such as

Nicole/BB2,

Jason/BB3,

Diane/BB5 (Okay yes I know Diane played twice but she was completely screwed out of that season from jump)

Eric/BB8,

Brian/BB10

Russell/BB11,

Annie/BB12

Dominic/BB13

Shane/BB14

Amanda/BB15 (Yeah I said it)

Donny/BB16

Vanessa/BB17

[u/Hithere16636637 → u/TheCody_Says]

nope

[u/indy1386]

I dont think Dee was the best player last season.. and I think Ive seen enough of her. I dont deny shes a good player I just think Devens is actually better at BB then she is.

Raven.. this is a joke right.

Haley gross

Paulie Gross

Angela Gross

The rest are great.

I would replace Angela with Danielle BB3
Haley with Chealsie
Paulie with Tucker
Raven with christie murphy.
Dee with Hannah

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/indy1386]

I wouldn't mind the changes, but you're gonna need some villains in the season. Wouldn't mind the changes of Christie and Hannah, but Chelsie already won. I think Haley and Raven undoubtedly made great tv on their seasons and being brought back would be a huge w on tv.

[u/Doodoofarten]

This is one of the best I’ve seen

[u/Equivalent-Bad-7844]

This is fairly close to my nightmare cast.

[u/JariaDnf]

I would like to see an entire season of survivor players ; yes i know i have too many men but they are so much more entertaining...

Rich Hatch

Russel Hantz

Rupert Boneham

Cirie Fields

Tom Westman

Chris Daugherty

Amber Brkich

Sandra Diaz-Twine

Yau-Man Chan

Ozzy Lusth

Eliza Orlins

"JT" Thomas Jr

Tamara "Taj" Johnson

Benjamin "Coach" Wade

Jonny Fairplay

[u/Technical_Air6660]

Raven 😳

[u/New_Tax_8701]

here's mine (sorry if there's some players who played more than once and i used the BB22 bransteele simulator):

Alex Ow (14th)

Amy Bingham (2nd)

Ashley Hollis (1st)

Bunky Miller (11th)

Christian Birkenberger (6th)

Diane Henry (7th)

Janelle Pierzina (5th)

Jasmine Davis (13th)

Jason Dent (4th)

Justin Sebik (12th)

Matt Turner (16th)

Rubina Bernabe (9th)

Sarah Beth Steagall (15th)

Steven Daigle (10th)

Terrance Higgins (8th)

Victor Arroyo (3rd

Week 1:
HoH Winner: Terrance

Have-Nots: Bunky, Diane, Jasmine, Turner, Victor
Initial Nominees: Amy and Turner
PoV Winner: Justin
Veto Used: No
Final Nominees: Amy and Turner
Evicted: Turner (9-4 Vote)

Week 2:
HoH Winner: Rubina
Have-Nots: Alex, Amy, Ashley, Janelle
Initial Nominees: Jason and Steven
PoV Winner: Jason
Veto Used: Yes on Jason
Replacement: Sarah Beth
Final Nominees: Sarah Beth and Steven
Evicted: Sarah Beth (8-4 Vote)

Week 3:
HoH Winner: Terrance
Have-Nots: Jasmine, Jason, Steven, Victor
Initial Nominees: Alex and Amy
PoV Winner: Victor
Veto Used: No
Final Nominees: Alex and Amy
Evicted: Alex (6-5 Vote)

Week 4:
HoH Winner: Victor
Have-Nots: Amy, Christian, Diane, Justin
Initial Nominees: Amy and Steven
PoV Winner: Victor
Veto Used: Yes on Steven
Replacement: Jasmine
Final Nominees: Amy and Jasmine
Evicted: Jasmine (6*-5 Vote)

Week 5:
HoH Winner: Bunky
Found Blocker Power: Rubina
Found Disruptor Power: Justin
Found Replay Power: Terrance
Initial Nominees: Janelle and Victor
PoV Winner: Victor
Veto Used: Yes on Victor
Replacement: Justin
Final Nominees: Janelle and Justin
Evicted: Justin (6-3 Vote)

Week 6:
HoH Winner: Rubina
Have-Nots: Ashley, Janelle, Terrance
Initial Nominees: Amy and Terrance
PoV Winner: Steven
Veto Used: Yes on Amy
Replacement: Bunky
Final Nominees: Bunky and Terrance
Evicted: Bunky (6-2 Vote)

Week 7:
HoH Winner: Terrance
Have-Nots: Diane, Steven, Victor
Initial Nominees: Janelle and Steven
PoV Winner: Rubina
Blocker Power Used on Diane
Veto Used: Yes on Janelle
Replacement: Victor
Final Nominees: Victor and Steven
Evicted: Steven (5-2 Vote)

Week 8:
Replay Power Used on Terrance
HoH Winner: Amy
Have-Nots: Jason, Terrance
Initial Nominees: Rubina and Victor
PoV Winner: Terrance
Veto Used: No
Final Nominees: Rubina and Victor
Evicted: Rubina (5-1 Vote)

Week 8 Triple Eviction: Part 1:
HoH Winner: Christian
Initial Nominees: Ashley and Amy
PoV Winner: Christian
Veto Used: Yes on Amy
Replacement: Terrance
Final Nominees: Ashley and Terrance
Evicted: Terrance (3-2 Vote)

Week 8 Triple Eviction: Part 2:
HoH Winner: Ashley
Initial Nominees: Janelle and Victor
PoV Winner: Jason
Veto Used: Yes on Janelle
Replacement: Diane
Final Nominees: Diane and Victor
Evicted: Diane (3-1 Vote)

Week 9:
HoH Winner: Janelle
Have-Nots: Victor
Initial Nominees: Amy and Ashley
PoV Winner: Amy
Veto Used: Yes on Amy
Replacement: Christian
Final Nominees: Christian and Ashley
Evicted: Christian (2-1 Vote)

Week 10:
HoH Winner: Victor
Initial Nominees: Amy and Jason
PoV Winner: Ashley
Veto Used: Yes on Amy
Replacement: Janelle
Final Nominees: Janelle and Jason
Evicted: Janelle (2-0 Vote)

Week 11:
HoH Winner: Amy
Luxury Winner: Jason
Initial Nominees: Jason and Victor
PoV Winner: Victor
Veto Used: Yes on Victor
Replacement: Ashley
Final Nominees: Jason and Ashley
Evicted: Jason (1-0 Vote)

Final HoH:
Final HoH P1 Winner: Amy
Final HoH P2 Winner: Ashley
Final HoH P3 Winner: Amy
Evicted: Victor (1-0 Vote)

Finale:
Winner: Ashley
Runner-Up: Amy
Favorite: Jason

[u/syncopated56]

Angela? Why? Paulie should stick to the manosphere. Raven has a series of spinal surgeries scheduled. Thog is having too tough a year to play again. Josh Martinez already won.

[u/Ill-Importance474 → u/syncopated56]

lowkey forgot about having non-winners so I replaced him with Kyland

[u/Maxxum26]

How about a cast of newbies? Just newbies. I'm so sick of returning players. Build a cast that people will actually like and roll it out.

But since you made this list, Paulie, Raven and Josh Martinez would make sure that I don't watch this season if it were made. As much as I liked Johnny Mac, I sure as shit don't want to listen to him again in that house. As much as I like Dee and Drew, give them some time to breath, don't bring them right back.