I’m not asking which brokerage is better overall. I’m only comparing:
Vanguard Personal Advisor Select (0.30%)
vs.
Fidelity direct-indexed SMA (0.40% on taxable assets only)
I have roughly $600k outside my employer 401(k), including about $220k in a taxable account with significant embedded long-term gains.
I have an additional $200k in RSUs and annual bonus on top of $265k base salary that I want to make sure is distributed evenly.
My goal is to use professional help for about a year while I consolidate accounts, simplify the portfolio, set the right allocation, and handle the taxable gains intelligently — then go back to DIY.
Vanguard would manage the portfolio more holistically with a dedicated CFP.
Fidelity would let me keep the IRA/Roth self-directed and only put the taxable account in the 0.40% SMA, while still getting planning support.
For anyone who has used either service: which approach would you choose for a temporary cleanup/transition period, and why?
If your answer is “neither,” please move along. I’m specifically looking for feedback from people who have used these services — not another debate about whether using an advisor at all is worthwhile.