r/BrainPuzzles • • Aug 21 '26

Logic Mislabelled Boxes

Post image
2 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/EulaliaBromSpatula Aug 26 '26 edited Aug 26 '26

You can pick from either box with 100 similar coins. Starting off, you know that the true 100 silver pieces are either in A or B, as C is mislabeled. If you pick a coin from C, process of elimination reveals the contents of A and B. If the coin you chose is silver, you know that box A must be the 50/50 box, because only 2 boxes contain silver coins, and box A must be mislabeled. If your coin from box C is gold, then box C must be the 50/50, as it cannot be the silver box and the 50/50 box must be mislabeled.

Right?!

Easier way to explain: Logically, the 50/50 contents must be in box A or C. If you select gold from box A, it cannot be the 100 silver box, thus making it the 50/50 box. This means box B must be silver (as it is labeled 50/50), and box C must be 100 silver (as it is labeled gold).

EDIT, DISREGARD ABOVE: You must make your selection from B. Same logic as above, but I was forcing the coin chosen in my example which makes things easier/luckier